Impact of surgical technique on operative morbidity and its socioeconomic benefit in thyroid surgery

Bilateral benign multinodular goiter: What is the adequate surgical therapy? A review of literature

BACKGROUND

Benign multinodular goiter (BMNG) is the most common endocrine disease requiring surgery. During the last few years a more aggressive approach has become the trend for bilateral BMNG treatment.

METHOD

Randomized clinical trials of any size that compared bilateral subtotal resection, Dunhill procedure and total thyroidectomy for benign multinodular goiter, published between January 2000 and the end of March 2015, were reviewed.

DISCUSSION

Total thyroidectomy can be considered the most reliable approach in preventing recurrence. The Dunhill procedure is related to a higher rate of recurrence, but rarely recurrences after Dunhill procedure lead to reoperation. Total thyroidectomy avoid completion thyroidectomy for incidental carcinoma and its related risks. Recurrent laryngeal nerve (RLN) palsy becomes less common as surgical experience increases. Transient and permanent hypoparathyroidism is strictly related to the extent of neck dissection. In the risk-cost analysis we must consider the type of patient candidated to surgery and the impact of the surgical protocol we apply. When thyroid surgery is taken in consideration, specific complication rates of different procedures in each hospital must be analyzed accordingly to patient-specific risk factors and local expertise.

CONCLUSION

The Dunhill procedure seems to be a good compromise between radicality and prevention of complications, avoiding reoperation for recurrence or completion thyroidectomy for incidental thyroid carcinoma. More follow-up studies and prospective studies are necessary to better evaluate, definitively, whether to prefer total thyroidectomy or Dunhill procedure in case of benign goiter surgery.

The surgical treatment of bilateral benign nodular goiter: balancing invasiveness with complications

BACKGROUND

About 100,000 thyroid operations are performed in Germany each year. There is a current trend toward more radical surgery for bilateral euthyroid nodular goiter. In recent years, thyroid specialists and specialty guidelines have recommended total thyroidectomy, because it ensures that nodules will not recur and already provides an adequately radical excision in case an incidental carcinoma is found postoperatively on histological study of the specimen. An alternative method is unilateral hemithyroidectomy with contralateral subtotal resection (the Dunhill procedure).

METHOD

Selective literature review.

RESULTS

Three randomized controlled trials (RCTs) have compared the longterm outcomes of different surgical methods. In addition, retrospective studies have been published, but their findings must be interpreted with caution because of limitations of method. When all of the data are considered, it appears that radical procedures are often not justified. According to the RCTs, nodules arose during long-term follow-up in 4.7-14% of patients who had undergone subtotal resection; yet, in the two more recent and methodologically more valid RCTs, surgery for recurrent goiter was needed in only 0-0.5% of patients treated with a Dunhill procedure and given adequate hormone supplementation. Most incidental carcinomas are papillary microcarcinomas; this entity is usually adequately treated with hemithyroidectomy. The reported complication rates of total thyroidectomy for permanent hypoparathyroidism in particular range from 0.5% (in specialized centers) to 10% (in a cross-sectional study) and thus seem higher than the corresponding rate for a Dunhill procedure (1-2%).

CONCLUSION

Total thyroidectomy has significant risks and should only be performed if the indication has been critically assessed. Alternative methods such as the Dunhill procedure are often radical enough with a much lower rate of postoperative hypoparathyroidism; they remain an important option in thyroid surgery. Further RCTs with sufficient long-term follow-up are needed so that the different surgical methods can be reliably compared in detail.