Assessing Hyolaryngeal Excursion: Comparing Quantitative Methods to Palpation at the Bedside and Visualization During Videofluoroscopy

Safety-related outcomes for patients with a tracheostomy and the use of flexible endoscopic evaluation of swallowing (FEES) for assessment and management of swallowing: A systematic review

PURPOSE

The purpose of this systematic review was to examine safety-related outcomes for patients with tracheostomy after flexible endoscopic evaluation of swallowing (FEES) to assess and manage their swallow, when compared to other non-instrumental swallow assessments such as clinical swallowing examination (CSE) and/or a modified Evans blue dye test (MEBDT).

METHOD

Three databases were searched for articles referring to safety-related outcome data for adults with a tracheostomy, who underwent FEES and CSE and/or MEBDT. Articles were screened using predefined inclusion/exclusion criteria.

RESULT

The search strategy identified 2097 articles; following abstract and full-text screening, seven were included for review. The summary of evidence found low to very low certainty that FEES was associated with improved outcomes across swallow safety, physiological outcomes, tracheostomy cannulation duration, functional outcomes, and detection of upper airway pathologies.

CONCLUSION

This systematic review demonstrated low to very low certainty evidence from seven heterogeneous studies with low sample sizes that incorporating FEES may be associated with improved safety-related outcomes. There is less evidence supporting the accuracy of other swallow assessments conducted at the point of care (i.e. CSE and MEBDT). Future research requires studies with larger sample sizes and routine reporting of safety-related outcomes with use of FEES.

Preliminary Exploration of Variations in Measures of Pharyngeal Area During Nonswallowing Tasks

PURPOSE

Age- and disease-related changes in oropharyngeal anatomy and physiology may be identified through quantitative videofluoroscopic measures of pharyngeal area and dynamics. Pixel-based measures of nonconstricted pharyngeal area (PhAR) are typically taken during oral bolus hold tasks or on postswallow rest frames. A recent study in 87 healthy adults reported mean postswallow PhAR of 62%(C2-4)2, (range: 25%-135%), and significantly larger PhAR in males. The fact that measures were taken after initial bolus swallows without controlling for the presence of subsequent clearing swallows was identified as a potential source of variation. A subset of study participants had completed a protocol including additional static nonswallowing tasks, enabling us to explore variability across those tasks, taking sex differences into account.

METHOD

Videofluoroscopy still shots were analyzed for 20 healthy adults (10 males, 10 females, Mage = 26 years) in head-neutral position, chin-down and chin-up positions, a sustained /a/ vowel vocalization, and oral bolus hold tasks (1-cc, 5-cc). Trained raters used ImageJ software to measure PhAR in %(C2-4)2 units. Measures were compared to previously reported mean postswallow PhAR for the same participants: (a) explorations of sex differences; (b) pairwise linear mixed-model analyses of variance (ANOVAs) of PhAR for each nonswallowing task versus postswallow measures, controlling for sex; and (c) a combined mixed-model ANOVA to confirm comparability of the subset of tasks showing no significant differences from postswallow measures in Step 2.

RESULTS

Overall, PhAR measures were significantly larger in male participants; however, most pairwise task comparisons did not differ by sex. No significant differences from postswallow measures were seen for 5-cc bolus hold, chin-down and chin-up postures, and the second (but not the first) of two repeated head neutral still shots. PhAR during a 5-cc bolus hold was most similar to postswallow measures: mean ± standard deviation of 51 ± 13%(C2-4)2 in females and 64 ± 16%(C2-4)2 in males.

CONCLUSIONS

PhAR is larger in men than in women. Oral bolus hold tasks with a 5-cc liquid bolus yield similar measures to those obtained from postswallow rest frames.

Clinical signs to predict the severity of dysphagia in Acute Ischemic Stroke patients

OBJECTIVES

In the current era, clinicians working in areas with limited and/or without facilities are only able to manage their patients based on clinical signs to detect dysphagia. This study assesses the performance of 5 simple clinical signs for predicting the severity of dysphagia.

METHODS

We systematically documented 5 targeted bedside clinical signs within 24 h after admission in 737 consecutive patients with acute stroke. We examined the median onset of each sign and calculated their ratios associated with severe dysphagia. The performance and significance of these special clinical signs were evaluated by further computation.

RESULTS

In total, 184 of 737 AIS patients were screened positive dysphagia by the modified V-VST. The 5 targeted bedside clinical signs were differed among the patients with and without dysphagia. Patients with serious dysphagia (n = 61,33.15%) showed higher positive percentages of larynx movement disorders than those classified as moderate (73.77% [60.99%-83.50%] vs 29.27% [21.82%-38.03%], p < 0.001). Logistic regression analyses conducted in the subsets confirmed larynx movement disorders as an independent predictor of dysphagia severity.

CONCLUSIONS

Larynx movement disorders is correlated with a higher probability of severe dysphagia as measured by the modified V-VST in AIS patients.

Diagnostic value of a deep learning-based hyoid bone tracking model for aspiration in patients with post-stroke dysphagia

Objective

Hyoid bone movement is potentially related to aspiration risk in post-stroke dysphagia (PSD) patients but is difficult to assess quantitatively. This study aimed to measure the distance of hyoid bone movement more efficiently and accurately using a deep learning model and determine the clinical usefulness of the model in PSD patients.

Methods

This study included 85 patients with PSD within 6 months from onset. Patients were grouped into an aspiration group (n = 35) and a non-aspiration group (n = 50) according to the results of a videofluoroscopic swallowing study. Hyoid bone movement was tracked using a deep learning model constructed with the BiFPN-U-Net(T) architecture. The maximum distance of hyoid bone movement was measured horizontally (H max), vertically (V max), and diagonally (D max).

Results

Compared with the non-aspiration group, the aspiration group showed significant decreases in hyoid bone movement in all directions. The area under the curve of V max was highest at 0.715 with a sensitivity of 0.680 and specificity of 0.743. The V max cutoff value for predicting aspiration risk was 1.61 cm. The success of oral feeding at the time of discharge was significantly more frequent when hyoid movement was equal to or larger than the cutoff value although no significant relationship was found between hyoid movement and other clinical characteristics.

Conclusion

Hyoid bone movement of PSD patients can be measured quantitatively and efficiently using a deep learning model. Deep learning model-based analysis of hyoid bone movement seems to be useful for predicting aspiration risk and the possibility of resuming oral feeding.

Determining the Relationship Between Hyoid Bone Kinematics and Airway Protection in Swallowing

PURPOSE

Research remains equivocal regarding the links between hyoid movement and penetration-aspiration. The aims of this study were (a) to explore associations between hyoid parameters, laryngeal vestibule closure (LVC) parameters, and penetration-aspiration on thin liquids; and (b) to determine which of these parameters are the strongest predictors of penetration-aspiration.

METHOD

This study involved retrospective analysis of an existing videofluoroscopy data set, collected in 305 participants (152 males) with noncongenital/nonsurgical/non-oncological risk for dysphagia. We extracted data for six thin liquid swallows per participant, and obtained measures of hyoid movement (peak position, speed) and LVC (complete/incomplete, timing, duration). Resulting values were coded as typical/atypical relative to healthy reference data. Relationships were explored using chi-square tests and odds ratios (a) for the entire data set and (b) for the subset of data with complete LVC. Hierarchical logistic regression models determined the strongest predictors of penetration-aspiration.

RESULTS

Significant associations were found between penetration-aspiration and incomplete LVC, prolonged time-to-most-complete-LVC, short LVC duration, reduced anterior hyoid peak position, and reduced hyoid speed. Hyoid measures were also significantly associated with LVC parameters. In the first regression model, incomplete LVC and prolonged time-to-most-complete-LVC were the only significant predictors of penetration-aspiration. For cases with complete LVC, the only significant predictor was prolonged time-to-most-complete-LVC.

CONCLUSIONS

Although reduced anterior hyoid peak position and speed are associated with penetration-aspiration on thin liquids, these measures do not independently account for penetration-aspiration when considered in conjunction with measures of LVC. When identifying mechanisms explaining penetration-aspiration, clinicians should focus on LVC (complete/incomplete) and timeliness of LVC.

Swallowing kinematic analysis might be helpful in predicting aspiration and pyriform sinus stasis

Aspiration due to dysphagia can lead to aspiration, which negatively impacts a patient’s overall prognosis. Clinically, videofluoroscopic swallow study (VFSS) is considered the gold-standard instrument to determine physiological impairments of swallowing. According to previously published literature, kinematic analyses of VFSS might provide further information regarding aspiration detection. In this study, 449 files of VFSS studies from 232 patients were divided into three groups: normal, aspiration, and pyriform sinus stasis. Kinematic analyses and between-group comparison were conducted. Significant between-group differences were noted among parameters of anterior hyoid displacement, maximal hyoid displacement, and average velocity of hyoid movement. No significant difference was detected in superior hyoid displacement. Furthermore, receiver-operating characteristic (ROC) analyses of anterior hyoid displacement, velocity of anterior hyoid displacement, and average velocity of maximal hyoid displacement showed acceptable predictability for detecting aspiration. Using 33.0 mm/s as a cutoff value of average velocity of maximal hyoid displacement, the sensitivity of detecting the presence of aspiration was near 90%. The investigators therefore propose that the average velocity of maximal hyoid displacement may serve as a potential screening tool to detect aspiration.

Diagnostic accuracy of the Dysphagia Trained Nurse Assessment tool in acute stroke

BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE

Comprehensive swallow screening assessments to identify dysphagia and make early eating and drinking recommendations can be used by trained nurses. This study aimed to validate the Dysphagia Trained Nurse Assessment (DTNAx) tool in acute stroke patients.

METHODS

Participants with diagnosed stroke were prospectively and consecutively recruited from an acute stroke unit. Following a baseline DTNAx on admission, participants underwent a speech and language therapist (SLT) bedside assessment of swallowing (speech and language therapist assessment [SLTAx]), videofluoroscopy (VFS) and a further DTNAx by the same or a different nurse.

RESULTS

Forty-seven participants were recruited, of whom 22 had dysphagia. Compared to SLTAx in the identification of dysphagia, DTNAx had a sensitivity of 96.9% (95% confidence interval [CI] 83.8-99.9) and specificity of 89.5% (95% CI 75.2-97.1). Compared to VFS in the identification of aspiration, DTNAx had a sensitivity of 77.8% (95% CI 40.0-97.2) and a specificity of 81.6% (95% CI 65.7-92.3). Over 81% of the diet and fluid recommendations made by the dysphagia trained nurses were in absolute agreement compared to SLTAx. Both DTNAx and SLTAx had low diagnostic accuracy compared to the VFS-based definition of dysphagia.

CONCLUSIONS

Nurses trained in DTNAx showed good diagnostic accuracy in identifying dysphagia compared to SLTAx and in identifying aspiration compared to VFS. They made appropriate diet and fluid recommendations in line with SLTs in the early management of dysphagia.

Variations in Hyoid Kinematics Across Liquid Consistencies in Healthy Swallowing

Purpose Judgments regarding hyoid movement are frequently included in evaluations of swallowing. However, the literature lacks reference values for measures of hyoid kinematics in healthy swallowing. This study explores hyoid movement across the continuum from thin to extremely thick liquids. Method Participants were 39 healthy adults under the age of 60 years (19 men) who underwent videofluoroscopy involving three sips each of 20% w/v thin barium and six sips each of slightly, mildly, moderately, and extremely thick barium. Half of the thickened stimuli were prepared using xanthan gum; and half, with a starch-based thickener. Sip volume was derived from pre- and post-sip cup weights. Hyoid position was tracked frame-by-frame relative to the anterior-inferior corner of C4. Measures of peak hyoid position (along the XY axis) were normalized to a C2-C4 scalar, and measures of time-to-peak position, speed, and time-to-peak speed were derived. As a first step, Spearman's correlations confirmed the influence of sip volume on these hyoid measures. Linear mixed-effects models then explored the effects of stimulus, sip volume, and task repetition on the dependent variables. Results The data set comprised 975 swallows with available hyoid tracking data. Sip volume was correlated with peak hyoid XY position (rs = .15, p < .01), time-to-peak position (rs = -.15, p < .05), and speed (rs = .13, p < .01). No significant differences in hyoid kinematics were found across stimuli. Conclusion Measures of hyoid movement in healthy swallowing remain stable across the range from thin to extremely thick liquids with no systematic alterations in hyoid position or kinematics.

Variations in the amplitude and duration of hyolaryngeal elevation during swallow: Effect of sour and carbonated liquid bolus

BACKGROUND

Altering sensory properties of food is relevant to the management of swallowing disorders. The current investigation aimed to examine the influence of sour and carbonated stimuli on measures of hyolaryngeal elevation.

METHOD

Sixty healthy adults in the age range of 18 to 35 years were assessed using Digital Accelerometry Swallowing Imaging (DASI) while swallowing 5 ml of neutral, sour and carbonated liquid bolus.

RESULTS

Sour stimulus was significantly different with higher amplitude and longer durational measures of hyolaryngeal elevation compared to the two other stimuli.

CONCLUSION

Sour stimulus facilitates better hyolaryngeal elevation, which implicates its usage in dysphagia management.

Tracking Hyoid Bone Displacement During Swallowing Without Videofluoroscopy Using Machine Learning of Vibratory Signals

Identifying physiological impairments of swallowing is essential for determining accurate diagnosis and appropriate treatment for patients with dysphagia. The hyoid bone is an anatomical landmark commonly monitored during analysis of videofluoroscopic swallow studies (VFSSs). Its displacement is predictive of penetration/aspiration and is associated with other swallow kinematic events. However, VFSSs are not always readily available/feasible and expose patients to radiation. High-resolution cervical auscultation (HRCA), which uses acoustic and vibratory signals from a microphone and tri-axial accelerometer, is under investigation as a non-invasive dysphagia screening method and potential adjunct to VFSS when it is unavailable or not feasible. We investigated the ability of HRCA to independently track hyoid bone displacement during swallowing with similar accuracy to VFSS, by analyzing vibratory signals from a tri-axial accelerometer using machine learning techniques. We hypothesized HRCA would track hyoid bone displacement with a high degree of accuracy compared to humans. Trained judges completed frame-by-frame analysis of hyoid bone displacement on 400 swallows from 114 patients and 48 swallows from 16 age-matched healthy adults. Extracted features from vibratory signals were used to train the predictive algorithm to generate a bounding box surrounding the hyoid body on each frame. A metric of relative overlapped percentage (ROP) compared human and machine ratings. The mean ROP for all swallows analyzed was 50.75%, indicating > 50% of the bounding box containing the hyoid bone was accurately predicted in every frame. This provides evidence of the feasibility of accurate, automated hyoid bone displacement tracking using HRCA signals without use of VFSS images.

Variations in Healthy Swallowing Mechanics During Various Bolus Conditions Using Computational Analysis of Swallowing Mechanics (CASM)

Bolus properties such as volume, consistency, and density have been shown to influence swallowing through the analysis of kinematics and timing in both normal and disordered swallowing. However, inherent intra- and inter-person variability of swallowing cloud interpretation of group data. Computational analysis of swallow mechanics (CASM) is an established methodology that uses coordinate tracking to map structural movements during swallowing and yields statistically powerful analyses at both the group and individual levels. In this study, the CASM method was used to determine how different bolus properties (volume, consistency, and density) altered swallow mechanics in healthy young adults at the group and individual levels. Videofluoroscopic swallow studies of 10 (4 females) healthy young adults were analyzed using CASM. Five bolus types were administered in each study (3 × 5 ml 40% w/v nectar, 3 × 5 ml 22% w/v thin, 3 × 5 ml 40% w/v thin, 3 × 10 ml 22% w/v thin, and 3 × 20 ml 22% w/v thin). Canonical variate analyses demonstrated that bolus condition did not affect swallowing mechanics at the group level, but bolus condition did affect pharyngeal swallow mechanics at the individual level. Functional swallow adaptations (e.g., hyoid movement) to bolus conditions were not uniform across participants, consistent with the nonsignificant group finding. These results suggest that individual swallowing systems of healthy young individuals vary in how they respond to bolus different conditions, highlighting the intrinsic variability of the swallow mechanism and the importance of individually tailored evaluation and treatment of swallowing. Findings warrant further investigation with different bolus conditions and aging and disordered populations.