Postdural disc herniation at L5/S1 level mimicking an extradural spinal tumor

Posterior epidural migration of thoracic and lumbar disc material: a comprehensive 63-year systematic review with anatomical perspectives

This study aims to thoroughly investigate the clinical presentation, duration of symptoms, radiological aspects of posterior epidural migration of disc fragments (PEMDF), and assess various treatment options and their impacts on patient functionality. A systematic review was conducted in accordance with the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses (PRISMA) statement. We conducted a comprehensive search in PubMed, Web of Science, and Scopus from inception to March 2024. Patient demographic and clinical outcomes data were extracted from articles that met the inclusion criteria. The extracted data included patients' age, sex, duration of symptoms (months), clinical presentation, diagnostic imaging, PEMDF spinal level, surgical technique used, and functional outcome and clinical improvement with follow-up (months). The primary outcomes of interest were total recovery (complete resolution of neurological deficits), partial recovery (clinical improvement with residual neurologic deficits), stable status (no change from the patient's baseline), and worst outcome (new symptoms or neurological deficits appearing post-surgical treatment). This review examined 105 studies on the pathology of posterior epidural migration of disc fragments, including 29 case series and the remainder as case reports, involving a total of 175 patients. The median age of the cohort was 54 years (range, 19-95), with 75.61% male and 24.39% female. Symptoms lasted a median of 0.5 months (range, 0.1-120 months), with cauda equina syndrome (45.7%) as the most common presenting symptom, followed by radiculopathy (34.3%) and lower back pain (21.1%). A history of heavy lifting was reported in 10.7% of patients. In terms of treatment, 5 patients (2.9%) were managed conservatively, while 162 (92.6%) underwent laminectomy. Additional interventions included minimally invasive interlaminar surgery (3 patients, 1.7%), transforaminal lumbar interbody fusion (2 patients, 1.1%), interlaminar lumbar interbody fusion (1 patient, 0.6%), and endoscopic spine surgery (2 patients, 1.1%). Functional outcomes showed symptomatic improvement in 173 patients (98.9%), with one patient remaining stable and one experiencing worsening symptoms. Partial recovery occurred in 42 patients (24%), while 131 patients (74.9%) achieved total recovery. Our study highlights the rarity and diagnostic complexity of posterior epidural migration of disc fragments. Prompt and precise diagnosis is crucial to prevent further neurological decline. Surgical intervention to remove sequestered disc fragments has demonstrated excellent functional and clinical outcomes.

Risk of Misdiagnosis in Spinal Hypertrophic Pachymeningitis: A Report of Two Cases

Hypertrophic pachymeningitis (HP) is a rare inflammatory disease of the central nervous system. It typically manifests in the cranium; cases involving the spinal cord are rare (8.6%). This report includes two cases of spinal HP encountered among 666 spinal operative cases. The purpose of this study is to present the initial imaging findings, final diagnosis, and course of treatment in these two cases of spinal HP and to present the possible risk of misdiagnosis with a literature review. In case 1, a 69-year-old female presented with back pain. The initial radiological diagnosis with magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) was a meningioma. However, her blood test showed a mild elevation of C-reactive protein level (3.16 mg/dL), with positive IgG4 and myeloperoxidase anti-neutrophil cytoplasmic antibody results, suggesting an autoimmune disease. We performed a biopsy of the thickened dura and an expansive duraplasty. Serological and pathological diagnosis suggested IgG4-related HP. In case 2, a 67-year-old male presented with bilateral thigh pain. MRI revealed a mass resembling a disc hernia at the L2/3 intervertebral level. The mass was surgically removed. Pathological examination and cerebrospinal fluid analysis confirmed the diagnosis of HP associated with IgG4-related disease. In both cases, immunosuppressive therapy was administered, and follow-up MRI scans revealed the disappearance of the mass. The study concludes that a spinal HP can potentially be misdiagnosed when its images resemble those of tumors or disc hernias owing to its rarity.

[Imaging of Sequestered Lumbar Discs]

Intervertebral disc herniation is frequently encountered in radiological practice. Sequestered disc herniation occurs when the disc material undergoes degeneration and completely loses continuity with the parent nucleus pulposus. Sequestered discs can reside within and outside the spinal canal, exerting a mass effect on adjacent structures, compressing nerve pathways, and eliciting a range of clinical symptoms. In particular, sequestered discs within the dura cannot be identified without durotomy. Therefore, precise preoperative localization is crucial for surgical planning. On MRI, the signal intensity of the sequestered disc may vary due to independent degeneration processes. Additionally, most sequestered disc fragments show varying degrees of peripheral enhancement depending on the degree of angiogenesis and granulation around the isolated tissue. In this article, we review various imaging findings and the location of the sequestered disc to provide patients with an accurate diagnosis and appropriate treatment direction.

A Severe Disc Herniation Mimics Spinal Tumor

Lumbar disc herniation (LDH) is prevalent among adults aged 25-55 years who spend a considerable proportion of their time sitting or standing with heavy workloads. We report the case of a 33-year-old male waiter with severe LDH, causing compression of the nerve roots and spinal cord with neurological dysfunction, who presented to a chiropractic clinic. Magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) revealed a radiological differential diagnosis comprising LDH and an epidural mass lesion. To rule out serious pathology, a second MRI with contrast was ordered, which confirmed the diagnosis of severe LDH. Diagnosing large LDH may be challenging, and severe disc herniation often mimics spinal tumors. This study offers insights into the differential diagnosis of LDH and spinal tumors, as well as the design of a treatment strategy for severe LDH in the chiropractic clinic.

Direct epidural metastasis of breast cancer mimicking a large lumbar disc sequestrum: A case report and review of literature

We report a case of cauda equina syndrome (CES) caused by an epidural metastasis of breast cancer, which oddly mimicked a large disc sequestrum leading to misdiagnosis. To our knowledge, it is the first report of a metastatic epidural breast cancer lesion mimicking a disc sequestrum.

Differential Diagnosis of Mimicking Tumor Discs Using Coronal Magnetic Resonance Imaging of Three-Dimensional Fast-Field Echo with Water-Selective Excitation: A Single Center Retrospective Study

OBJECTIVE

As disc fragment completely loses contact with the parent disc and can migrate in all directions of the epidural space, making it appear similar to schwannoma, it is fairly difficult to make a definitive diagnosis for mimicking tumor discs. The aim of this research is to differentially diagnose mimicking tumor discs and schwannomas using coronal magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) of three-dimensional fast-field echo with water-selective excitation (CMRI).

METHODS

Among 76 patients (38 men and 38 women; mean age, 52.88 ± 15.80 [range, 18-78 years]) who were retrospectively examined in this study, 38 were primarily diagnosed with schwannomas and pathologically diagnosed with mimicking tumor discs after surgery, and 38 were primarily diagnosed with neurogenic tumors and pathologically diagnosed with schwannomas after surgery. Open surgery was performed in all the patients between March 2016 and April 2020. The preliminary diagnosis of all patients was considered an intraspinal tumor based on conventional two-dimensional MRI sequences. After open surgery, the final diagnosis was confirmed to mimic a tumor disc or schwannoma based on postoperative pathology reports. The sensitivity, specificity, and reliability of CMRI and conventional MRI for identifying mimicking tumor discs and schwannomas were compared. Chi-square and McNemar tests were used for statistical analyses.

RESULTS

Symptoms were considerably relieved in all the patients after surgery. Seven patients had grade 1 extensor digitorum longus, triceps surae, or quadriceps femoris muscle strength prior to surgery. No nerve root injury was observed in any of the patients. CMRI showed significantly higher sensitivity (94.74%) and specificity (94.74%) than conventional MRI (71.05% and 92.11%, respectively; p = 0.012 < 0.05, and p = 1 > 0.05, respectively) for differential identification between mimicking tumor discs and schwannomas. Moreover, CMRI showed a higher reliability (kappa value = 0.787) than conventional MRI (kappa value = 0.374).

CONCLUSIONS

CMRI is a better non-invasive technology for the identification of intraspinal lesions, especially for differentiating between mimicking tumor discs and schwannomas.

Multispecialty perspective on intradural disc herniation: diagnosis and management - A case report -

Background

Intradural disc herniation (IDH) is a very rare and challenging diagnosis, with an estimated incidence of less than 1.5%. The pathogenesis of IDH remains uncertain. Definitive management remains surgical; however, some cases may initially be managed non-surgically.

Case

A middle-aged male with presented with acute right-sided lumbar radiculopathy following heavy lifting. History was significant for prior lumbar disc herniation managed non-surgically. Lumbar MRI demonstrated a large disc herniation. The patient was initially treated non-surgically with epidural steroid injections. At 4-months, he re-injured and follow-up images demonstrated the herniated disc penetrating the dura and the diagnosis of intradural disc herniation.

Conclusions

The present case is rare because the IDH occurred at the L3-4 level and resulted in unilateral radiculopathy without cauda-equina symptoms and occurred in the absence of prior surgery. This patient was initially treated non-surgically with satisfactory relief, however, reinjury led to progression of IDH with new neurological deficits necessitating surgery.

Lumbar disc sequestration mimicking a tumor: Report of four cases and a literature review

BACKGROUND

Disc herniation refers to the displacement of disc material beyond its anatomical space. Disc sequestration is defined as migration of the herniated disc fragment into the epidural space, completely separating it from the parent disc. The fragment can move in upward, inferior, and lateral directions, which often causes low back pain and discomfort, abnormal sensation, and movement of lower limbs. The free disc fragments detached from the parent disc often mimic spinal tumors. Tumor like lumbar disc herniation can cause clinical symptoms similar to spinal tumors, such as lumbar soreness, pain, numbness and weakness of lower limbs, radiation pain of lower limbs, etc. It is usually necessary to diagnose the disease according to the doctor's clinical experience, and make preliminary diagnosis and differential diagnosis with the help of magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) and contrast-enhanced MRI. However, pathological examination is the gold standard that distinguishes tumoral from non-tumoral status. We report four cases of disc herniation mimicking a tumor, and all the pathological results were intervertebral disc tissue.

CASE SUMMARY

The first case was a 71-year-old man with low back pain accompanied by left lower extremity radiating pain for 1 year, with exacerbation over the last 2 wk. After admission, MRI revealed a circular T2-hypointense lesion in the spinal canal of the L4 vertebral segment, with enhancement on contrast-enhanced MRI suggesting neurilemmoma. The second case was a 74-year-old man with pain in both knees associated with movement limitation for 3 years, with exacerbation over the last 3 mo. MRI revealed an oval T2-hyperintense lesion in the spinal canal at the L4–5 level, with obvious peripheral enhancement on contrast-enhanced MRI. Thus, neurilemmoma was suspected. The third case was a 53-year-old man who presented with numbness and weakness of the lumbar spine and right lower extremity for 2 wk. MRI revealed a round T2-hyperintense lesion in the spinal canal at the L4–5 level, with obvious rim enhancement on contrast-enhanced MRI. Thus, a spinal tumor was suspected. The fourth case was a 75-year-old man with right lower extremity pain for 2 wk, with exacerbation over the last week. MRI revealed a round T1-isointense lesion in the spinal canal of the L3 vertebral segment and a T2-hyperintense signal from the lesion. There was no obvious enhancement on contrast-enhanced MRI, so a spinal tumor was suspected. All four patients underwent surgery and recovered to ASIA grade E on postoperative days 5, 8, 8, and 6, respectively. All patients had an uneventful postoperative course and fully recovered within 3 mo.

CONCLUSION

Disc herniation mimicking a tumor is a relatively rare clinical entity and can be easily misdiagnosed as a spinal tumor. Examinations and tests should be improved preoperatively. Patients should undergo comprehensive preoperative evaluations, and the lesions should be removed surgically and confirmed by pathological diagnosis.

Sequestrated Lumbar Disc Herniation Mimicking Spinal Neoplasm

Sequestered disc fragments do not have indistinctive features and often share the clinical and radiological presentation as spinal neoplasms making their diagnosis and treatment a clinical challenge.

We report a rare case of sequestered lumbar disc fragment at the level of L2-L3 in a 70-year-old male who presented to the ER complaining of six years' history of low back pain with acute onset lower extremities weakness for six days, associated with right foot drop. He was admitted for tumor workup as the MRI showed diffuse bone high signal intensity throughout the spine with a soft tissue epidural mass at L2/3, causing severe compression on the cauda equina nerve roots. The patient underwent L2-L3 decompression and fixation, mass excision, multiple open biopsies. Soft tissue biopsy of the mass revealed fibrocartilaginous tissue consistent with the intervertebral disc, while the bone biopsy was diagnostic of acute leukemia. The patient was observed postoperatively with unremarkable complications. He did well with physiotherapy, and there was a remarkable improvement of his right lower extremity power reaching 4/5.

Our case presented a rare phenomenon in which sequestered disc fragments manifested clinically and radiologically as a spinal neoplasm. Vigilant history taking and physical examination are paramount; a physician should be watchful for any red flags that may warrant further investigation such as in our case.

Posterior epidural sequestrated disc presenting with contralateral radiculopathy: a very rare case

INTRODUCTION

Posterior epidural sequestrated disc is a fairly uncommon condition. We report a case of an unusual presentation of posterior epidural migration with contralateral symptoms. We emphasize a high index of suspicion for early recognition and treatment to promote a good neurological recovery.

CASE PRESENTATION

A 58-year-old man with a history of severe back pain for 1 week developed sudden right leg weakness while walking. Neurological examination revealed motor and sensory impairments of the right lower extremities (positive right straight leg raising test, right tibialis anterior grade 2/5, right extensor hallucis longus grade 1/5, decreased pinprick sensation of L4-5 dermatome right side) according to the Standards for Neurological Classification of Spinal Cord Injury as Asia Impairment Scale D. Magnetic resonance images showed an acute disc herniation at L4-5 on the left side, cranially migrated and sequestrated to the posterior epidural area, causing severe compression to the cauda equina in the thecal sac. The patient was successfully treated with surgery (transforaminal lumbar interbody fusion) on an urgent basis. We saw significant neurological recovery on the first day after surgery. Motor power recovery was achieved with a minor deficit at 4 weeks. At the follow-up examination at 3 months, the patient had no residual neurological deficits as Asia Impairment Scale E.

DISCUSSION

Posterior epidural sequestrated disc with contralateral radiculopathy is very rare. This case brings a new presentation of posterior epidural sequestrated disc. To our knowledge, this is the first report of a case with an unusual presentation of contralateral radiculopathy.

Imaging and histopathologic features of reversible nerve root and peripheral nerve edema secondary to disc herniation in a cat

Nerve root enlargement with increased contrast uptake has been reported in dogs and humans secondary to nerve root compression. In cats, nerve root enlargement and contrast uptake only have been reported in association with inflammatory and neoplastic diseases, but not as a sequela to nerve root compression. An 8‐year‐old oriental short hair cat was presented with acute neurologic deficits consistent with left‐sided sciatic nerve deficit and possible L6‐S1 myelopathy. Magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) was performed and identified compression of the cauda equina and L7 nerve root associated with intervertebral disc herniation (IVDH) at L6‐L7 as well as widespread sciatic nerve enlargement with moderate rim enhancement. A hemilaminectomy was performed to evacuate herniated disc material. The nerve root was biopsied and submitted for histological evaluation. Interstitial nerve edema was diagnosed. Follow‐up MRI 3 months postoperatively showed complete remission of the changes. Nerve root thickening together with contrast enhancement may represent nerve edema in cats secondary to IVDH.

Intradural disc herniation at L4/5 level causing Cauda equina syndrome: A case report

RATIONALE

Intradural disc herniation has been documented rarely and the pathogenesis remains unclear. The region most frequently affected by intradural lumbar disc herniations is L4-5 level, and the average age of intradural disc herniations is between 50 and 60 years. Although magnetic resonance imaging is a valuable tool in the diagnosis of this disease, it is still difficult to make a definite diagnosis preoperatively.

PATIENT CONCERNS

In this report, we described a 58-year-old male patient who presented with intermittent pain of low back and radiating pain of the both lower extremities for 2 years as well as decreased muscle strength of the both legs and dysfunction of urinary and defecation for 1 month.

DIAGNOSIS

Lumbar disc herniation was diagnosed during the first clinical examination in the local hospital. Magnetic resonance imaging revealed a mass disc filling almost the entire spinal canal at the L4/5 level and a stalk connecting the mass to the intervertebral disc was detected in the sagittal T2-weighted image. The massive lesion caused cauda equina compression, resulting in dysfunction of urinary and defecation.

INTERVENTIONS

Considering the mass's volume, bilateral hemilaminectomy, and transforaminal lumbar interbody infusion were performed. During the surgery, we found a perforation in the ventral dura and major part of herniated disc was located in the intradural space through it. The disc was carefully dissected from the surrounding nerve roots and the ventral dura and then totally removed. The defect on the ventral dura was sutured to prevent cerebrospinal fluid leakage.

OUTCOMES

The patient presented complete recovery of the radiculopathy and cauda equina syndrome and significant improvement of muscle strength of both legs at 12 months follow-up.

LESSONS

The diagnosis of intradural disc herniations is very difficult and mainly based on intraoperative and histopathological results. Surgical intervention is only effective method to manage this disease and to relieve symptoms and prevent severe neurological deficits.

Misdiagnosis of posterior sequestered lumbar disc herniation: report of three cases and review of the literature

Introduction

Posterior migration of sequestered disc is an extremely rare event that mimics more common spinal lesions as spinal tumors, making difficult its preoperative diagnosis and appropriate management. We retrospectively reviewed all lumbar disc herniations treated by surgery at our institution from 2006 to 2016 to identify cases with posterior sequestered disc fragments and possible misdiagnosis for other spinal lesions. Complementarily, a literature review of misdiagnosed cases of posterior migrated discs was undertaken.

Case report

Three posterior sequestered lumbar disc cases (one intradural), were found among the 1153 reviewed surgeries. Two of them, presenting with progressive neurological deficit, were respectively misdiagnosed as pseudotumoral lesion and meningioma/neurogenic tumor on MRI. After intraoperative diagnosis and emergent resection, histology confirmed intervertebral disc tissue. The remaining case had an accurate preoperative diagnosis and after an initial conservative management finally underwent surgery because of refractory pain. Full recovery was achieved months after surgical treatment in all cases.

Discussion

Non-tumoral lesions are the most frequent misdiagnosis of posterior sequestered lumbar disc described in the literature. Early surgical treatment is the standard management due to high incidence of cauda equine syndrome (CES); however, spontaneous regression of posterior sequestered lumbar disc herniations has been recently reported. In conclusion low incidence and similar clinical and radiological features with other more common posterior spinal lesions like hematomas, synovial cyst or abscess turns posterior sequestered disc herniations a diagnosis challenge. Despite high incidence of CES, an initial conservative management should be evaluated in selected patients without neurological deficit and well-controlled pain.

Two cases in which 3D MRI was used to differentiate between a disc mass that mimics a tumor and neurinoma

Background

Since disc sequestration that mimics a tumor is rare and sometimes presents with an atypical appearance upon magnetic resonance imaging (MRI), it is often confused with other more common epidural and intradural neoplasms, particularly neurinoma. Open surgery is necessary due to the difficult of achieving a definitive diagnosis using computed tomography, MRI, and gadolinium- enhanced MRI prior to operation. Herein, we describe the use of coronal MR images of 3D fast-field echo with water selective excitation in the diagnosis of disc sequestration mimicking a tumor.

Case presentation

Two patients were admitted to our hospital with back pain, radiating pain, and hypoesthesia in the right lower limb. MRI revealed tumor-like masses in the lateral recess of L3 and posterior to the body of L4. The initial diagnosis indicated disc sequestration mimicking a tumor and neurinoma. The coronal MR images of 3D fast-field echo with water selective excitation showed a clear boundary between the tumor-like mass and the nerve root. Moreover, the mass was also completely separated from the dura. Therefore, neurinoma was excluded as a possible diagnosis prior to operation. Surgical excision to perform removal of the gross mass was performed in one patient. The histopathological diagnosis was consistent with the 3D fast-field echo with water-selective excitation MRI. Another patient was successfully treated by minimally invasive endoscopic surgery.

Conclusions

Disc sequestration that mimics a tumor is difficult to diagnose preoperatively. As a non–invasive strategy, coronal MR images of 3D fast-field echo with water selective excitation is a helpful imaging tool for differentiating between diagnosis of disc sequestration that mimics a tumor and neurinoma prior to operation. If the disc fragment of mimicking tumor can be identified prior to operation, open surgery may not be necessary for all patients. Minimally invasive endoscopic surgery also is an alternative strategy.

Solitary Spinal Epidural Metastasis from Prostatic Small Cell Carcinoma

Solitary, spinal epidural metastasis (SEM) that is not related to vertebral metastasis is very rare. And solitary SEM from prostatic cancer is rarely found in previously published reports. However, it is clinically significant due to the possibility of neurologic dysfunction, and it can be assessed by MRI. In this report, we show a case of solitary SEM arising from prostatic small cell carcinoma detected by MRI.