Surgical outcome in smaller symptomatic vestibular schwannomas. Is there a role for surgery?

Incidence and Risk Factors of Delayed Facial Paralysis After Vestibular Schwannoma Resection: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis

OBJECTIVE

Delayed facial nerve paralysis (DFNP) is a common complication after vestibular schwannoma surgery. Previous studies have focused on immediate facial nerve paralysis, and the risk factors for developing DFNP remain largely unclear. This study aimed to determine the incidence and risk factors of DFNP in patients after vestibular schwannoma resection.

METHODS

Up to 8 October 2024, PubMed, Embase, Cochrane Library, Web of Science, China National Knowledge Infrastructure, Wanfang Data, and China Science and Technology Journal Database were searched to extract the related data of DFNP. The pooled incidence of DFNP was calculated. Possible risk factors of DFNP were conducted to report the odds ratio/weighted mean difference (WMD), and their 95% confidence intervals (CIs).

RESULTS

Twenty-seven studies were included, and 8656 patients underwent vestibular schwannoma resection. The incidence of DFNP in patients with vestibular schwannoma who underwent microsurgical resection was 12.3% (95% CI: 9.4%, 15.1%). The results of the influencing factor analysis showed that age (WMD: -4.28, 95% CI: -5.66, -2.91) and tumor size (WMD: 0.17, 95% CI: 0.01, 0.22) were related to the incidence of DFNP in patients after vestibular schwannoma resection.

CONCLUSIONS

DFNP is a complication after vestibular schwannoma surgery that cannot be ignored. The risk factors (age and tumor size) of DFNP in patients after vestibular schwannoma surgery still need to be considered, and clinical management of high-risk groups should be strengthened in clinical practice.

Cognitive Performance in Patients With Sporadic Vestibular Schwannoma

BACKGROUND

To date, few data are available on the cognitive function of patients with vestibular schwannoma (VS) before treatment.

OBJECTIVE

To provide a cognitive profile of patients with VS.

METHODS

This cross-sectional observational study recruited 75 patients with an untreated VS and 60 age-, sex-, and education-matched healthy control subjects. A set of neuropsychological tests were administered to each participant.

RESULTS

Compared with the matched controls, patients with VS exhibited impaired general cognitive function, memory, psychomotor speed, visuospatial ability, attention and processing speed, and executive function. The subgroup analyses displayed that patients with severe-to-profound unilateral hearing loss were more cognitively impaired than patients with no-to-moderate unilateral hearing loss. In addition, patients with right-sided VS scored worse than those with left-sided VS on tests of memory, attention and processing speed, and executive function. No differences were observed in cognitive performance between patients with or without brainstem compression and those with or without tinnitus. We also found that worse hearing and longer hearing loss duration were associated with poorer cognitive performance in patients with VS.

CONCLUSION

The findings of this study provide evidence for cognitive impairment in patients with untreated VS. It can thus be said that including cognitive assessment in the routine clinical management of patients with VS may facilitate more appropriate clinical decision-making and improve patients' quality of life.

Hypervascularized Large Vestibular Schwannomas: Single-Center Experience in a Series of Forty Cases

Background

Vestibular schwannomas (VS) are usually hypovascularized benign tumors. Large VS (Koos grade IV) with unusual vascular architecture are defined as hypervascular (HVVS); the excessive bleeding during microsurgery has a negative impact on results.

Methods

Forty consecutive patients were operated on for HVVS (group A). A tendency to bleed and adherence of capsule to nervous structures were evaluated by reviewing intraoperative video records. The cisternal facial nerve (FN) position was reported. Microsurgical removal was classified as total, near-total, subtotal, or partial and the MIB-1 index was evaluated in all. FN results were classified according to the House-Brackmann scale.

Results

Results of Group A were compared with those of 45 patients operated on for large low-bleeding VS (group B). Mean tumor diameter was 3.81 cm in group A and 3.58 cm in group B; the mean age was 42.4 and 56.3 years, respectively. The mean American Society of Anesthesiologists Physical Status Scale class of group A was 1.67 versus 2.31 of group B (P < 0.01). Total or near-total resection was accomplished in 76.5% of group A versus 73.3% of group B. Tight capsule adhesion was observed in 67.5% of group A versus 57.8% of group B. Mean MIB-1 was 1.25% and 1.08%, respectively.

FN anatomic preservation was possible in 84.6% of group A versus 95.5% of group B; 67.5% of group A had HB grade I or II FN outcome versus 93.3% of group B (P < 0.001). In group A, 8 patients (20.0%) experienced transient postoperative complications versus 4.4% of group B. Recurrence/regrowth was observed in 4 patients in group A versus 1 in group B.

Conclusions

Intraoperative video for classification of HVVS was used. Microsurgery of large HVVS was associated with higher (usually transient) complications and recurrence/regrowth rates and poorer FN outcome, especially in patients with tight capsule adhesion.

Microsurgical treatment of symptomatic vestibular schwannomas in patients under 40: different results before and after age of 30

In 10-15% of cases of vestibular schwannoma (VS), age at diagnosis is 40 years or less. Little is known about the differences in natural history, surgical findings, and postoperative outcomes of such younger patients as compared to those of greater age. To analyze clinical and surgical and imaging data of a consecutive series of n = 50 patients with unilateral sporadic VS, aged 40 years or younger - separated in a very young group (15-30 years) and a moderately young group (31-40 years). Retrospective case series. Fifty consecutive patients under 40 years of age underwent microsurgical resection of unilateral sporadic VS via the retrosigmoid approach. The study cohort was subdivided into two groups according to the age range: group A, age range 15-30 years (n = 23 patients), and group B, age range 31-40 years (n = 27 patients). The adherence of VS capsule to surrounding nervous structures and the tendency of the tumors to bleed were evaluated by reviewing video records; the course of the FN in relation to the tumor's surface was assessed in each case. Microsurgical removal of tumor was classified as total (T), near total (residual tumor volume < 5%), subtotal (residual tumor volume 5-10%), or partial (residual tumor volume > 10%). Mean tumor size of entire cohort was 2.53 (range: 0.6-5.8) cm: 2.84 cm in group A and 2.36 cm in group B (p = NS). Facial nerve course and position within the cerebellopontine angle did not differ significantly between the two groups. At 6-month follow-up, FN functional outcome was HBI-II in 69.5% in group A, versus 96.3% in group B (p < .001). Hearing preservation was achieved in 60.0% of patients of group A and in 58.3% of group B (p = NS). Total and near-total resection was feasible in 95.6% of cases of group A and in 88.9% of group B (p = NS). Tumor capsule was tightly adherent to nervous structures in 69.6% patients of group A and in 22.2% of group B (p < .05). Significant bleeding was encountered in 56.5% of group A tumors, and in 29.6% of group B tumors (p < .01). Microsurgery of VS in patients aged 40 or less is associated with good functional results, and with high rates of total and near total tumor removal. Patients < 30 years of age have more adherent tumor capsules. Furthermore, their tumors exhibit a tendency to larger sizes, to hypervascularization, to profuse intraoperative bleeding and they present worse long-term functional FN results when compared to patients in their fourth decade of life. Our limited experience seems to suggest that a near total resection in very young VS patients with large tumors should be preferred in adherent and hypervascularized cases, in order to maximize resection and preserve function.

Intraoperative Auditory Brainstem Response Results Predict Delayed Sensorineural Hearing Loss After Middle Cranial Fossa Resection of Vestibular Schwannoma

OBJECTIVE

To identify intraoperative neurophysiologic measures predictive of delayed progressive sensorineural hearing loss in the operative ear after a middle fossa approach (MCF) for resection of vestibular schwannoma (VS).

STUDY DESIGN

Retrospective review.

SETTING

Academic, tertiary referral center.

PATIENTS

Subjects with vestibular schwannoma who underwent a MCF microsurgical resection of VS were analyzed for individuals whose hearing was initially preserved but subsequently developed progressive sensorineural hearing loss in the operative ear. Thirty-seven patients were identified for whom audiologic and neurophysiologic data was available.

INTERVENTION

Intraoperative neurophysiologic changes will correlate with delayed sensorineural hearing loss in the operative ear.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES

Audiometric evaluations, intraoperative electrocochleography (ECoG), and auditory brainstem response (ABR) measures.

RESULTS

Twenty-five subjects experienced stable hearing or hearing loss in the operative ear comparable to the contralateral ear. Twelve subjects suffered a significant increase in the hearing asymmetry between ears. Deterioration in the amplitude of wave V of the ABR persisting at the close of tumor resection correlated with delayed sensorineural hearing loss in the operative ear (p 0.02, 5% mean improvement in the stable hearing group, versus a 14% decline with progressive asymmetry), but changes in ECoG or other auditory brainstem response parameters (p > 0.05) were not predictive.

CONCLUSIONS

Persisting amplitude reduction of wave V of the intraoperative ABR best correlates with delayed progressive sensorineural hearing loss in the operative ear. Neither persistent changes in ECoG, other ABR parameters, nor transient changes, correlated with delayed progressive sensorineural hearing loss in the operative ear.

The natural history of vestibular schwannoma growth-prospective 40-year data from an unselected national cohort

BACKGROUND

Optimal management of vestibular schwannoma (VS) is still debated and thus international consensus has not been achieved. Treatment options are observation, radiotherapy, and surgery. Knowledge on the natural history of tumor growth is essential for choice of treatment modality. The aim is to present intra-/extrameatal tumor growth and management data from a prospective, unselected national cohort of patients diagnosed with VS during the period 1976-2015.

METHODS

Since 1976, all data from patients diagnosed with sporadic VS in Denmark have been referred to our national treatment center, where they have been entered prospectively into the national database. Data on tumor localization, growth, and treatment were retrieved. Growth definition: >2 mm by linear measurement, in accordance with the Tokyo 2001 consensus-meeting recommendations.

RESULTS

3637 cases of VS were diagnosed, in which 1304 patients had surgery and 21 received radiotherapy post diagnosis. 2312 patients were observed with mean follow-up of 7.33 years. Of these, 434(19%; 102 intra-and 332 extrameatal tumors) changed to active treatment during the observation period due to tumor growth. 5 years after diagnosis, 21% of the intrameatal tumors exhibited growth during observation, whereas 37% of extrameatal tumors had grown, increasing to 25% intrameatal and 42% extrameatal after 10 years. Following growth, the intrameatal tumors were mostly observed further and the extrameatal mostly underwent surgery. Tumor growth occurred mainly within the first 5 years post diagnosis.

CONCLUSION

This natural history study documents the growth occurrence of both intra-and extrameatal VS during the first 12 years after diagnosis and should be used in patient counseling, management, and treatment decision making.

Koos grade IV vestibular schwannomas: considerations on a consecutive series of 60 cases-searching for the balance between preservation of function and maximal tumor removal

Koos grade IV vestibular schwannomas (VS) (maximum diameter > 3 cm) compress the brainstem and displace the fourth ventricle. Microsurgical resection with attention to the right balance between preservation of function and maximal tumor removal is the treatment of choice. Our series consists of 60 consecutive patients with unilateral VS, operated on from December 2010 to July 2019. All patients underwent microsurgical removal via the retrosigmoid approach. The adherence of VS' capsule to the surrounding nervous structures and the excessive tendency of tumor to bleed during debulking, because of a redundant vascular architecture, was evaluated by reviewing video records. Microsurgical removal of tumor was classified as total (T), near-total (NT: residue < 5%), subtotal (ST: residue 5-10%), or partial (P: residue > 10%). Maximal mean tumor diameter was 3,97 cm (SD ± 1,13; range 3,1-5,8 cm). Preoperative severely impaired hearing or deafness (AAO-HNS classes C-D) was present in 52 cases (86,7%). Total or NT resection was accomplished in 46 cases (76,7%), 65,8% in cases with, and 95,4% without tight adhesion of capsule to nervous structures (p < 0,001). Endoscopic-assisted microsurgical removal of VS in the IAC was performed in 23 patients: in these cases, a T resection was obtained in 78,3% versus 45,9% of microsurgery only (p < 0,001). The capsule of VS was tightly adherent to nervous structures in 63,3% of patients, whereas hypervascular high-bleeding tumors represented 56,7%. Hearing preservation was possible in 2 out of 8 patients with preoperative class B hearing. At last follow-up, 34 (56,7%) patients had a normal postoperative FN outcome (HBI), 9 (15,0%) were HBII, 8 (13,3%) HBIII, and 9 (15,0%) HBIV. The total NT resection of solid and low-bleeding VS, without tight capsule adhesion, was associated with better FN outcome. Mortality was zero; permanent complications were observed in 2 cases (diplopia, hydrocephalus), transient in 9. Microsurgery of Koos grade IV VS seems to be associated with more than acceptable functional results, with high rate of T and NT removal of tumor. Long-term FN results seem to be worse in patients with cystic Koos grade IV VS, in cases with tight capsule adherences to nervous structures and in high-bleeding tumors.

Exclusive surgical treatment for vestibular schwannoma regrowth or recurrence: A meta-analysis of the literature

Vestibular schwannomas can be treated in different ways, but for symptomatic or growing tumors, the gold standard is surgical removal of the lesion. In order to preserve neurovascular structures, partial removal is often performed, leaving a residual that may grow in subsequent years. To date, there is no consensus with regard to surgical treatment of vestibular schwannoma residuals, and so this review focuses on this topic. A structured search was performed on PubMed searching for all articles discussing vestibular schwannoma residuals and recurrences. Only articles discussing surgical treatment were included, focusing on studies which also examined facial nerve outcomes. A total of 51 articles were eligible for review and these included 375 patients. Statistical analysis was performed by correlating the following parameters: patients' gender and age at first surgery, surgical approach adopted at first and subsequent surgeries, tumor and residual size, and extent of resection (gross total, near total, subtotal or others) at first and subsequent surgical procedures. Facial nerve function was also analyzed focusing on its performance when correlated with the different surgical approaches. The data were analyzed by linear regression but there were no correlations between any of the parameters chosen. There was a statistically significant difference between the first approach used (mainly the retrosigmoid route) compared with subsequent approaches (mainly the translabyrinthine route). In total, 8.5 % of patients needed further treatment due to residual regrowth. Facial nerve outcome was independent of the parameters chosen. Exclusive surgical treatment for vestibular schwannoma residuals had a very low failure rate in terms of requiring further treatment. The approach usually chosen for second surgery was the translabyrinthine technique, and this may be explained by the location of the residual, rather than its size. The choice of a particular surgical approach rather than another had no influence on facial nerve function. Complications rates are comparable to Gamma Knife Radiosurgery's as reported in the literature.

LINAC-based stereotactic radiosurgery versus hypofractionated stereotactic radiotherapy delivered in 3 or 5 fractions for vestibular schwannomas: comparative assessment from a single institution

PURPOSE

The optimal treatment strategy for vestibular schwannoma (VS) is not known, and different radiation techniques and fractionation regimens are currently being used. This report aimed to assess outcomes after LINAC-based radiosurgery (SRS) and hypofractionated radiotherapy (hypo-FSRT) and identify possible differences in outcomes between hypo-FSRT delivered in 3 or 5 fractions.

METHODS

From 2005 to 2017, 136 patients underwent treatment with radiotherapy for VS. Thirty-seven patients received SRS (12 Gy), and 99 received hypo-FSRT. Hypo-FSRT was delivered in 3 fractions (total 18-21 Gy, n = 39) and 5 fractions (total 25 Gy, n = 60).

RESULTS

The median follow-up was 57 months. Eight patients had progression requiring surgery, corresponding to an overall local control rate of 93.4%, with no significant difference between the fractionation schedules. A correlation with borderline significance (p = 0.052) was detected between cystic tumors and local failure. A tendency toward a higher incidence of local failure was observed after 2015 when SRS treatment increased and included slightly larger tumors. Hearing preservation was observed in 35% of patients and 36% of patients experienced acute side effects, but persistent facial or trigeminal nerve toxicity was rare.

CONCLUSION

SRS and hypo-FSRT with 3 or 5 fractions provided a high rate of local control with no significant differences between treatment schedules. SRS is a well-documented radiation technique for VS and is the recommendation for small- to medium-sized tumors. This report demonstrates excellent long-term outcomes after hypo-FSRT; this regimen can be delivered safely and is an alternative for selected patients.

Systematic Review of Hearing Preservation in Observed Vestibular Schwannoma

Objective  This is a systematic review of the literature on the spontaneous course of hearing in patients observed with a vestibular schwannoma. Included studies are appraised using the Grading of Recommendations Assessment, Development and Evaluation system. Design  PubMed, Embase, Medline, Cochrane library, and CINAHL (Cumulative Index to Nursing and Allied Health Literature) were searched for literature on hearing in patients observed with a vestibular schwannoma. Participants  Of 217 evaluated papers, 15 were included, representing a total of 2,142 patients. Main Outcome Measures  Hearing according to the AAO-HNS (American Academy of Otorhinolaryngology- Head and Neck Surgery) classification system. Weighted average of the proportion of patients preserving good hearing (>70% discrimination score and pure tone audiometry [PTA] < 30dB) and serviceable hearing (>50% discrimination score and PTA < 50dB) was determined. Results  Fifty percent of patients presenting with good hearing at diagnosis had preserved this after a mean of 5 years of observation, whereas serviceable hearing was preserved in 54%. Patients with normal discrimination at diagnosis preserve their hearing very well. Very few studies exist on long-term hearing preservation. Conclusions  After 5 years of observation, around half of patients will have preserved good or serviceable hearing. Patients with normal discrimination at diagnosis are more likely to preserve good hearing.