In-vivo and in-vitro histological evaluation of two commercially available acellular dermal matrices

Vascularization of Human Acellular Dermal Matrices: A Comparative Study in a Nonhuman Primate Model

Four human acellular dermal matrices (hADMs) were characterized in a nonhuman primate abdominal wall repair model by evaluating host immune response, vascularization, and incorporation into host tissues. AlloDerm™ (electron beam-sterilized hADM [e-hADM]), AlloMax™ (gamma beam-sterilized hADM, freeze-dried [g-hADM-FD]), DermaMatrix™ (hADM, freeze-dried [hADM-FD]), and FlexHD™ (ethanol-treated hADM [EtOH-hADM]) were each implanted in an abdominal wall-bridging defect in nonhuman primates (n = 3 animals/time point, n = 36 animals). Immunohistochemical and histological assessments were conducted on biopsies from each hADM at 1-, 3-, and 6-months postimplantation to assess vascularization (hematoxylin and eosin [H&E], CD31, alpha smooth muscle actin [αSMA], collagen IV), inflammatory/immune response (H&E, CD3, CD20, CD68), and collagen turnover (H&E, matrix metalloproteinase-9 [MMP-9]). MMP-9 immunolabeling was similar among different hADMs at 1 month; however, hADM-FD and EtOH-hADM showed higher total mean MMP-9-immunopositive areas at approximately 16% compared with <1% for e-hADM and g-hADM at 6 months postimplantation. Cells that stained positively for CD68, CD3, and CD20 were generally higher for hADM-FD and EtOH-hADM compared with other hADMs. The mean CD31-immunopositive area, CD31 vessel density, CD31 vessel diameter, and collagen IV-immunopositive area increased over time. Among all the hADM types, e-hADM had the highest mean (±standard deviation [SD]) CD31-immunopositive area at 1.54% ± 1.01%, vessel density at 7.86 × 10-5 ± 3.96 × 10-5 vessels/µm2, and collagen IV-immunopositive area at 2.55% ± 0.73% 1-month postimplantation. The pattern of αSMA immunolabeling varied among the hADMs. Histology showed that overall inflammation was mild at 1 month. Overall fibroblast repopulation and collagen remodeling increased over time from 1 to 6 months postimplantation. Fibroblast infiltration was minimal to mild at 1 month, with e-hADM showing the highest mean (±SD) score at 2.00 ± 0.00 compared with other hADMs. Only hADM-FD was not completely replaced by neotissue formation at 6 months postimplantation. All hADMs promoted vascularization, cell infiltration, and incorporation into host tissue, which were associated with acute inflammation and immune responses, within a 6-month period. A trend toward relatively enhanced early vascularization in e-hADM compared with other hADMs was observed. Immunogenic responses among the hADMs in the present study showed a slight distinction toward more quiescent terminally sterilized hADMs (e-hADM, g-hADM-FD) versus aseptically processed hADMs (EtOH-hADM, hADM-FD).

Comparison of the Characteristics of Three Acellular Dermal Matrices Subjected to Distinct Processing Methods Using Five Types of Histochemical Staining

BACKGROUND

Acellular dermal matrix (ADM) is treated using various devitalization and aseptic processing methods. The processing effects on ADM were evaluated by histochemical tests.

METHODS

From January 2014 to December 2016, 18 patients [average age, 43.0 (range, 30-54) years] who underwent breast reconstruction with an ADM and tissue expander were prospectively enrolled. During the permanent implant replacement, a biopsy of the ADM was performed. We used three different human-derived products, namely, Alloderm®, Allomend®, and Megaderm®. Hematoxylin and eosin, CD68, CD3, CD31, and smooth muscle actin were used to evaluate the collagen structure, inflammation, angiogenesis, and myofibroblast infiltration. Each ADM was semi-quantitatively analyzed.

RESULTS

Significant differences in collagen degradation, acute inflammation, and myofibroblast infiltration were observed among the ADMs. Collagen degeneration (p<0.001) and myofibroblast infiltration (smooth muscle actin-positive, p=0.018; CD31-negative, p=0.765) were the most severe in Megaderm®. Acute inflammation, represented by CD68, was most severe in Alloderm® (p=0.024). Both radiation and freeze-drying treatment physically damaged the collagen structure. Collagen degeneration was most severe in Megaderm®, followed by Allomend® and Alloderm®. Since Alloderm® is treated using chemicals, an assessment of the chemical irritation is warranted.

CONCLUSIONS

The biopsy results were inconclusive. Therefore, to better interpret processing, more large-scale, serial, histochemical studies of each ADM are needed.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE IV

This journal requires that authors 38 assign a level of evidence to each article. For a full 39 description of these Evidence-Based Medicine ratings, 40 please refer to the Table of Contents or the online 41 Instructions to Authors www.springer.com/00266 .

A Feasibility and Safety Study of a Novel Human Decellularized Dermal Matrix to Accelerate Healing of Neuropathic Diabetic Foot Ulcers in People With Type 1 and Type 2 Diabetes

OBJECTIVES

The purpose of this study was to determine the feasibility and safety of a novel decellularized dermal matrix (DDM) for the treatment of chronic diabetic foot ulcers (DFUs).

METHODS

An interventional, single-arm, prospective study of DDM for DFU treatment was conducted in 2 Canadian centres from July 1, 2016, to May 30, 2017. Individuals ≥18 years of age with an active DFU of ≥2 weeks and ulcer area ≥1 cm2 before debridement and who consented to participate were enrolled in this clinical trial.

RESULTS

A total of 11 patients were enrolled, with 9 patients (82%) having achieved 100% closure between 2 and 8 weeks. The mean and median times to wound closure for these patients were 3.3 and 2.5 weeks, respectively. The mean and median reductions in wound area at 4 weeks posttreatment were 87% and 100%, respectively. The proportion of patients having achieved complete healing at 12 weeks was 82%. All patients received only 1 DDM application to achieve these results. There were no adverse events related to use of the product. No cases of recurrence during a 1-year follow-up after completion of the study were reported for patients who achieved wound closure.

CONCLUSIONS

These findings provide evidence that this DDM may be safe and effective for the treatment of chronic, hard-to-heal neuropathic DFUs. Specifically, DDM demonstrated the potential to accelerate healing of DFUs when compared with reported times of 8 to 12 weeks required to achieve closure using the current standard of care.

Semiautomated quantification of the fibrous tissue response to complex three-dimensional filamentous scaffolds using digital image analysis

Fibrosis represents a relevant response to the implantation of biomaterials, which occurs not only at the tissue-material interface (fibrotic encapsulation) but also within the void fraction of complex three-dimensional (3D) biomaterial constructions (fibrotic ingrowth). Usual evaluation of the biocompatibility mostly depicts fibrosis at the interface of the biomaterial using semiquantitative scores. Here, the relations between encapsulation and infiltrating fibrotic growth are poorly represented. Virtual pathology and digital image analysis provide new strategies to assess fibrosis in a more differentiated way. In this study, we adopted a method previously used to quantify fibrosis in visceral organs to the quantification of fibrosis to 3D biomaterials. In a proof-of-concept study, we transferred the "Collagen Proportionate Area" (CPA) analysis from hepatology to the field of biomaterials. As one task of an experimental animal study, we used CPA analysis to quantify the fibrotic ingrowth into a filamentous scaffold after subcutaneous implantation. We were able to demonstrate that the application of the CPA analysis is well suited as an additional fibrosis evaluation strategy for new biomaterial constructions. The CPA method can contribute to a better understanding of the fibrotic interactions between 3D scaffolds and the host tissue responses.

Addition of platelet-rich plasma supports immune modulation and improved mechanical integrity in Alloderm mesh for ventral hernia repair in a rat model

The recurrence of ventral hernias continues to be a problem faced by surgeons, in spite of efforts toward implementing novel repair techniques and utilizing different materials to promote healing. Cadaveric acellular dermal matrices (Alloderm) have shown some promise in numerous surgical subspecialties, but these meshes still suffer from subsequent failure and necessitation of re-intervention. Here, it is demonstrated that the addition of platelet rich plasma to Alloderm meshes temporally modulates both the innate and cytotoxic inflammatory responses to the implanted material. This results in decreased inflammatory cytokine production at early time points, decreased matrix metalloproteinase expression, and decreased CD8+ T cell infiltration. Collectively, these immune effects result in a healing phenotype that is free from mesh thinning and characterized by increased material stiffness.

Precision cell delivery in biphasic polymer systems enhances growth of keratinocytes in culture and promotes their attachment on acellular dermal matrices

Current approaches for precision deposition of cells are not optimized for moist environments or for substrates with complex surface topographic features, for example, the surface of dermal matrices and other biomaterials. To overcome these challenges, an approach is presented that utilizes cell confinement in phase-separating polymer solutions of polyethylene glycol and dextran to precisely deliver keratinocytes in well-defined colonies. Using this approach, keratinocyte colonies are produced with superior viability, proliferative capacity, and barrier formation compared with the same number of cells dispersedly seeded across substrate surfaces. It is further demonstrated that keratinocytes delivered in colonies to the surface of acellular dermal matrices form an intact epidermal basal layer more rapidly and more completely than cells delivered by conventional dispersed seeding. These findings demonstrate that delivery of keratinocytes in phase-separating polymer solutions holds potential for enhancing growth of keratinocytes in culture and production of functional skin equivalents.

Biocompatibility of Intensified Decellularized Equine Carotid Arteries in a Rat Subcutaneous Implantation Model and in a Human In Vitro Model

Limited biocompatibility of decellularized scaffolds is an ongoing challenge in tissue engineering. We recently demonstrated that intensified detergent-based decellularization of equine carotid artery (dEAC_intens) removed residual cellular molecules from the scaffold more efficiently than a conventional decellularization (dEAC_con), although this approach did not eliminate its immunogenicity entirely. CCN1 has been shown to improve biocompatibility of dEAC_con in a sheep model. In this study, we tested the biocompatibility of dEAC_intens and dEAC_con with or without CCN1 coating after subcutaneous implantation in rats for up to 12 weeks. Explants were assessed by conventional histopathology and immunostaining for infiltrating M2 macrophages. Moreover, human macrophages derived from monocytes (MDM) or THP-1 cells (THP-derived macrophages [TDM]) were seeded onto dEAC_con and dEAC_intens, and activation was assessed either by cytokine expression or matrix metalloprotease 2 and 7 staining. dEAC_intens showed a significantly reduced inflammatory infiltration (52%; p < 0.0001), as well as an earlier and denser neovascularization (1.4-fold, p < 0.0001) independent of CCN1 coating, which, however, reduced fibrosis exclusively with dEAC_intens (26-53%; p < 0.05). Human MDM seeded for 48 h onto dEAC_intens showed higher transcript levels for anti-inflammatory IL-10 (2.3-fold), proinflammatory TNFα (2.2-fold), and macrophage/monocyte recruiting MIP1α (3.5-fold; all p < 0.05) and MCP (2.7-fold; p < 0.01), whereas 1.92-fold more TDM on dEAC_intens showed staining for MMP2 (p > 0.001). Thus, although being advantageous in regard to fibrosis, CCN1 coating of dEAC_intens does not appear to be necessary for further improving dEAC_intens excellent biocompatibility in rats. In humans, the unspecific cellular immune response toward dEAC_intens seemed to be more complex, but generally comparable to the mild acute inflammatory tissue reaction with high remodeling activity as observed after rat subcutaneous implantation.

Soft Tissue Augmentation Techniques and Materials Used in the Oral Cavity: An Overview

PURPOSE

Oral soft tissue augmentation or grafting procedures are often necessary to achieve proper wound closure after deficits resulting from tumor excision, clefts, trauma, dental implants, and tooth recessions.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Autologous soft tissue grafts still remain the gold standard to acquire a functionally adequate zone of keratinized attached gingiva. However, soft tissue substitutes are more commonly used because they minimize morbidity and shorten surgical time.

RESULTS

This review aimed to assess soft tissue grafting techniques and materials used in the oral cavity from existing literature. There are a large variety of materials and techniques, including grafts, local flaps, allogenic derived matrices such as acellular dermal allograft, xenogenic tissue matrices from animal origin, and synthetic materials.

CONCLUSIONS

Tissue engineering of oral mucosa represents an interesting alternative to obtain sufficient autologous tissue for reconstructing oral wounds using biodegradable scaffolds, and may improve vascularization and epithelialization, which are critical for successful outcomes.

Complication prevalence following use of tutoplast-derived human acellular dermal matrix in prosthetic breast reconstruction: a retrospective review of 203 patients

Use of human acellular dermal matrix (ADM) during prosthetic breast reconstruction has increased. Several ADM products are available produced by differing manufacturing techniques. It is not known if outcomes vary with different products. This study reports the complication prevalence following use of a tutoplast-derived ADM (T-ADM) in prosthetic breast reconstruction. We performed a retrospective chart review of 203 patients (mean follow-up times 12.2 months) who underwent mastectomy and immediate prosthetic breast reconstruction utilizing T-ADM, recording demographic data, surgical indications and complication (infection, seroma, hematoma, wound healing exceeding three weeks and reconstruction failure). During a four-year period, 348 breast reconstructions were performed Complications occurred in 16.4% of reconstructed breasts. Infection occurred in 6.6% of breast reconstructions (3.7% - major infection, requiring intravenous antibiotics and 2.9% minor infection, requiring oral antibiotics only). Seromas occurred in 3.4% and reconstruction failure occurred in 0.6% of breast reconstructions. Analysis suggested that complication prevalence was significantly higher in patients with a BMI >30 (p = 0.03). The complication profile following T-ADM use is this series is comparable to that reported for with other ADM products. T-ADM appears to be a safe and acceptable option for use in ADM-assisted breast reconstruction.

Effects of biologic scaffolds on human stem cells and implications for CNS tissue engineering

Biologic scaffolds composed of mammalian extracellular matrix (ECM) promote constructive remodeling of tissues via mechanisms that include the recruitment of endogenous stem/progenitor cells, modulation of the host innate immune response, and influence of cell fate differentiation. Such scaffold materials are typically prepared by decellularization of source tissues and are prepared as sheets, powder, or hydrogels. It is plausible that ECM derived from an anatomically distinct tissue would have unique or specific effects on cells that naturally reside in this same tissue. The present study investigated the in vitro effect of a soluble form of ECM derived from central nervous system (CNS) tissue, specifically the spinal cord or brain, versus ECM derived from a non-CNS tissue; specifically, the urinary bladder on the behavior of neural stem cells (NSCs) and perivascular stem cells. All forms of ECM induce positive, mitogenic, and chemotactic effects at concentrations of approximately 100 μg/mL without affecting stem cell viability. CNS-derived ECMs also showed the ability to differentiate NSCs into neurons as indicted by βIII-tubulin expression in two-dimensional culture and neurite extension on the millimeter scale after 24 days of three-dimensional cultures in an ECM hydrogel. These results suggest that solubilized forms of ECM scaffold materials may facilitate the postinjury healing response in CNS tissues.

Mechanical and biocompatible characterization of a cross-linked collagen-hyaluronic acid wound dressing

Collagen scaffolds have been widely employed as a dermal equivalent to induce fibroblast infiltrations and dermal regeneration in the treatment of chronic wounds and diabetic foot ulcers. Cross-linking methods have been developed to address the disadvantages of the rapid degradation associated with collagen-based scaffolds. To eliminate the potential drawbacks associated with glutaraldehyde cross-linking, methods using a water soluble carbodiimide have been developed. In the present study, the glycosaminoglycan (GAG) hyaluronic acid (HA), was covalently attached to an equine tendon derived collagen scaffold using 1-ethyl-3-(3-dimethyl aminopropyl) carbodiimide (EDC) to create ntSPONGE™. The HA was shown to be homogeneously distributed throughout the collagen matrix. In vitro analyses of the scaffold indicated that the cross-linking enhanced the biological stability by decreasing the enzymatic degradation and increasing the thermal denaturation temperature. The material was shown to support the attachment and proliferation of mouse L929 fibroblast cells. In addition, the cross-linking decreased the resorption rate of the collagen as measured in an intramuscular implant model in rabbits. The material was also shown to be biocompatible in a variety of in vitro and in vivo assays. These results indicate that this cross-linked collagen-HA scaffold, ntSPONGE™, has the potential for use in chronic wound healing.

Comparison of different ADM materials in breast surgery

This is a brief review of the history of the role of acellular dermal matrices in breast reconstruction surgery, with a summary of several currently available products, including a table of comparisons. Key features, including biologic tissue source, surgical preparation, sterility, polarity, contraindications, shelf life, and cost, are examined. A paucity of data exists to directly compare AlloDerm®, DermaMatrix®, Strattice™, Permacol™, DermACELL, FlexHD®, SurgiMend®, and ALLOMAX™ for breast reconstruction; most studies relate to hernia repair. An ideal acellular dermal matrix product is still unavailable but the information provided in this review should facilitate a breast surgeons decision-making process.