Vertebral morphometry reference data by X-ray absorptiometry (MXA) in Iranian women

Normative vertebral deformity measurements in a clinically relevant population using magnetic resonance imaging

BACKGROUND

Osteoporosis is the leading cause of vertebral fractures. Dual-energy X-ray absorptiometry (DXA) and radiographs are traditionally used to detect osteoporosis and vertebral fractures/deformities. Magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) can be utilized to detect the relative severity of vertebral deformities using three-dimensional information not available in traditional DXA and lateral two-dimensional radiography imaging techniques.

AIM

To generate normative vertebral parameters in women using MRI and DXA scans, determine the correlations between MRI-calculated vertebral deformities and age, DXA T-scores, and DXA Z-scores, and compare MRI vertebral deformity values with radiography values previously published in the literature.

METHODS

This study is a retrospective vertebral morphometric analysis conducted at our institution. The patient sample included MR images from 1638 female patients who underwent both MR and DXA imaging between 2005 and 2014. Biconcavity, wedge, crush, anterior height (Ha)/posterior height (Hp), and middle height (Hm)/posterior height values were calculated from the MR images of the patient's vertebrae. Associations between vertebral deformity values, patient age, and DXA T-scores were analyzed using Spearman correlation. The MRI-derived measurements were compared with radiograph-based calculations from population-based data compiled from multiple studies.

RESULTS

Age was positively correlated with lumbar Hm/Hp (P = 0.04) and thoracic wedge (P = 0.03) and biconcavity (P = 0.001) and negatively correlated with thoracic Ha/Hp (P = 0.002) and Hm/Hp (P = 0.001) values. DXA T-scores correlated positively with lumbar Hm/Hp (P < 0.0001) and negatively with lumbar wedge (P = 0.046), biconcavity (P < 0.0001), and Ha/Hp (P = 0.046) values. Qualitative analysis revealed that Ha/Hp differed between MRI and radiography population-based data by no more than 0.3 and Hm/Hp by a maximum of 1.2.

CONCLUSION

Compared with traditional imaging techniques, MRI detects vertebral deformities with high accuracy and reliability. It may be a sensitive, ionizing, radiation-free tool for use in clinical settings.

Vertebral heights and ratios are not only race-specific, but also gender- and region-specific: establishment of reference values for mainland Chinese

This study established gender-specific reference values in mainland Chinese (MC) and is important for quantitative morphometry for diagnosis and epidemiological study of osteoporotic vertebral compressive fracture. Comparisons of reference values among different racial populations are then performed to demonstrate the MC-specific characteristic.

PURPOSE

Osteoporotic vertebral compressive fracture (OVCF) is a common complication of osteoporosis in the elder population. Clinical diagnosis and epidemiological study of OVCF often employ quantitative morphometry, which relies heavily on the comparison of patients' vertebral parameters to existing reference values derived from the normal population. Thus, reference values are crucial in clinical diagnosis. To our knowledge, this is the first study to establish reference values of the mainland Chinese (MC) for quantitative morphometry.

METHODS

Vertebral heights including anterior (Ha), middle (Hm), posterior (Hp) heights, and predicted posterior height (pp) from T4 to L5 were obtained; and ratios of Ha/Hp, Hm/Hp and Hp/pp. were calculated from 585 MC (both female and male) for establishing reference values and subsequent comparisons with other studies.

RESULTS

Vertebral heights increased progressively from T4 to L3 but then decreased in L4 and L5. Both genders showed similar ratios of vertebral dimensions, but male vertebrae were statistically larger than those of female (P < 0.01). Vertebral size of MC population was smaller than that of US and UK population, but was surprisingly larger than that of Hong Kong Chinese, although these two are commonly considered as one race. Data from different racial populations showed similar dimensional ratios in all vertebrae.

CONCLUSIONS

We established gender-specific reference values for MC. Our results also indicated the necessity of establishing reference values that are not only race- and gender-specific, but also population- or region-specific for accurate quantitative morphometric assessment of OVCF.

Vertebral morphometry by X-ray absorptiometry: which reference data for vertebral heights?

INTRODUCTION

The recent improvement in the resolution of dual-energy X-ray absorptiometry (DXA) images enables most vertebral levels to be seen adequately and thus DXA may be a worthwhile alternative to radiologic morphometry for the identification of vertebral fractures (VF). In this multicenter study, we have derived reference data for vertebral heights and their ratios in Italian women using morphometric X-ray absorptiometry (MXA).

METHODS

DXA scans were acquired in 1254 consecutive pre- and postmenopausal women, (mean age 63.7 ± 11.3, range 26-88 yrs), referred to six osteoporosis centers. MXA analysis of these images was performed by the same operator measuring vertebral heights and height ratios from L4 to T4. We calculated measures of central tendency and dispersion of vertebral heights and vertebral ratios using different approaches (mean and standard deviation as well as median and interquartile range of raw data, mean and standard deviation of trimmed data using an iterative algorithm, and mean and standard deviation of not fractured vertebrae).

RESULTS

Independently of the approach that we used, all the measures of central tendency were similar, while significant differences were found when compared with reference ranges in other populations. The vertebral heights of our sample at every vertebral level were significantly smaller than both Rea population and the Lunar reference values, even after normalization. Splitting data according to age groups, there was a decrease in the vertebral heights and ratios between the younger and older women.

CONCLUSIONS

This study demonstrates that reference data for MXA should be population specific and age matched.

Vertebral morphometry

Visual semiquantitative (SQ) assessment of the radiographs by a trained and experienced observer is the "gold standard" method to detect vertebral fractures. Vertebral morphometry is a quantitative method to identify osteoporotic vertebral fractures based on the measurement of vertebral heights. Vertebral morphometry may be performed on conventional spinal radiographs (MRX: morphometric x-ray radiography) or on images obtained from dual x-ray absorptiometry (DXA) scans (MXA: morphometric x-ray absorptiometry). Vertebral fracture assessment (VFA) indicates the method for identification of the vertebral fractures using lateral spine views acquired by DXA, with low-dose exposition. For epidemiologic studies and clinical drug trials in osteoporosis research but also in clinical practice, the preferred method is radiographic SQ assessment., because an expert eye can better distinguish between true fractures and vertebral anomalies than can quantitative morphometry. However, vertebral morphometry, calculating the deformity of overall thoracic and lumbar spine, may supply useful data about the vertebral fracture risk. VFA performed during routine densitometry allows identification, by visual or morphometric methods, of most osteoporotic vertebral fractures, even those that are asymptomatic.

Reference values for vertebral shape in young Chinese women: implication for assessment of vertebral deformity

The race- and sex-specific reference values for vertebral shape are important to determine the prevalence of osteoporotic vertebral fracture. However, these reference values are absent in Chinese women. In the present study, the anterior, middle and posterior heights and the ratios of these heights were measured from 14 vertebral bodies (T4-L5) in 60 premenopausal Chinese women (aged 19-25 years). Cutoff values were set as standard deviations (3 and 3.5 SD) and percentages (15 and 20%) below the means of vertebral height (VH) ratios to define vertebral deformities. The number of subjects with a VH ratio lower than -15% cutoff were significantly more than those with a VH ratio lower than -3 SD cutoff (p < 0.05), but this difference did not occur when a -20% cutoff was selected. A few VH ratios were distributed below -20% and -3 SD cutoffs, and none was below -3.5 SD. The vertebral shape defined by VH ratios was different between Chinese and European women. We conclude that 3.5 SD below the reference mean is an ideal cutoff value for the definition of prevalent vertebral fractures in Chinese women, and reference data should be obtained from young premenopausal women.