Topical application of mitomycin C prevents epineural scar formation in rats

Shielding the Nerve: A Systematic Review of Nerve Wrapping to Prevent Adhesions in the Rat Sciatic Nerve Model

BACKGROUND

Peripheral nerve pathology is frequently encountered in clinical practice among peripheral nerve and extremity surgeons. One major factor limiting nerve regeneration and possibly leading to revision surgeries is the development of traumatic or postoperative adhesions and scarring around nerves. In experimental models, different materials have been studied to limit scar tissue formation when wrapped around nerves.

METHODS

A systematic review of studies describing nerve-wrapping materials in a non-transectional rat sciatic nerve model was performed following the PRISMA guidelines. Literature describing nerve-wrapping methods for the prevention of peripheral nerve scarring in rat sciatic nerve models was identified using PubMed and Web of Science, scanned for relevance and analyzed.

RESULTS

A total of 15 original articles describing 23 different materials or material combinations for nerve wrapping were included. The heterogeneity of the methods used did not allow a meta-analysis, thus, a systematic review was performed. Out of 28 intervention groups, 21 demonstrated a preventive effect on scar tissue formation in at least one qualitative or quantitative assessment method.

CONCLUSIONS

The analyzed literature describes a variety of materials from different origins to limit peripheral nerve scarring and adhesions. Thus, a scar-preventive effect by wrapping peripheral nerves as adhesion prophylaxis seems likely. However, a quantitative comparison of the studies to identify the optimal material or technique is not possible with the diversity of used models and study designs. Therefore, further research needs to be performed to identify the optimal nerve wraps to be used routinely in clinical practice.

Experimental Methods to Simulate and Evaluate Postsurgical Peripheral Nerve Scarring

As a consequence of trauma or surgical interventions on peripheral nerves, scar tissue can form, interfering with the capacity of the nerve to regenerate properly. Scar tissue may also lead to traction neuropathies, with functional dysfunction and pain for the patient. The search for effective antiadhesion products to prevent scar tissue formation has, therefore, become an important clinical challenge. In this review, we perform extensive research on the PubMed database, retrieving experimental papers on the prevention of peripheral nerve scarring. Different parameters have been considered and discussed, including the animal and nerve models used and the experimental methods employed to simulate and evaluate scar formation. An overview of the different types of antiadhesion devices and strategies investigated in experimental models is also provided. To successfully evaluate the efficacy of new antiscarring agents, it is necessary to have reliable animal models mimicking the complications of peripheral nerve scarring and also standard and quantitative parameters to evaluate perineural scars. So far, there are no standardized methods used in experimental research, and it is, therefore, difficult to compare the results of the different antiadhesion devices.

A novel experimental rat model of peripheral nerve scarring that reliably mimics post-surgical complications and recurring adhesions

Inflammation, fibrosis and perineural adhesions with the surrounding tissue are common pathological processes following nerve injury and surgical interventions on peripheral nerves in human patients. These features can reoccur following external neurolysis, currently the most common surgical treatment for peripheral nerve scarring, thus leading to renewed nerve function impairment and chronic pain. To enable a successful evaluation of new therapeutic approaches, it is crucial to use a reproducible animal model that mimics the main clinical symptoms occurring in human patients. However, a clinically relevant model combining both histological and functional alterations has not been published to date. We therefore developed a reliable rat model that exhibits the essential pathological processes of peripheral nerve scarring. In our study, we present a novel method for the induction of nerve scarring by applying glutaraldehyde-containing glue that is known to cause nerve injury in humans. After a 3-week contact period with the sciatic nerve in female Sprague Dawley rats, we could demonstrate severe intra- and perineural scarring that resulted in grade 3 adhesions and major impairments in the electrophysiological peak amplitude compared with sham control (P=0.0478). Immunohistochemical analysis of the nerve structure revealed vigorous nerve inflammation and recruitment of T cells and macrophages. Also, distinct nerve degeneration was determined by immunostaining. These pathological alterations were further reflected in significant functional deficiencies, as determined by the analysis of relevant gait parameters as well as the quantification of the sciatic functional index starting at week 1 post-operation (P<0.01). Moreover, with this model we could, for the first time, demonstrate not only the primary formation, but also the recurrence, of severe adhesions 1 week after glue removal, imitating a major clinical challenge. As a comparison, we tested a published model for generating perineural fibrotic adhesions, which did not result in significant pathological changes. Taken together, we established an easily reproducible and reliable rat model for peripheral nerve scarring that allows for the effective testing of new therapeutic strategies.

The neurochemistry of peripheral nerve regeneration

Peripheral nerve injuries (PNIs) can be most disabling, resulting in the loss of sensitivity, motor function and autonomic control in the involved anatomical segment. Although injured peripheral nerves are capable of regeneration, sub-optimal recovery of function is seen even with the best reconstruction. Distal axonal degeneration is an unavoidable consequence of PNI. There are currently few strategies aimed to maintain the distal pathway and/or target fidelity during regeneration across the zone of injury. The current state of the art approaches have been focussed on the site of nerve injury and not on their distal muscular targets or representative proximal cell bodies or central cortical regions. This is a comprehensive literature review of the neurochemistry of peripheral nerve regeneration and a state of the art analysis of experimental compounds (inorganic and organic agents) with demonstrated neurotherapeutic efficacy in improving cell body and neuron survival, reducing scar formation and maximising overall nerve regeneration.

Potential risk of mitomycin C at high concentrations on peripheral nerve structure

Although the local application of mitomycin C may prevent epidural adhesion after laminectomy, mitomycin C can induce neurotoxicity in optic and acoustic nerves at high concentrations. To determine the safe concentration range for mitomycin C, cotton pads soaked with mitomycin C at different concentrations (0.1, 0.3, 0.5, and 0.7 mg/mL) were immediately applied for 5 minutes to the operation area of rats that had undergone laminectomy at L₁. Rat sciatic nerves, instead of dorsal nerves, were used in this study. The results showed that mitomycin C at 0.1-0.5 mg/mL did not damage the structure and function of the sciatic nerve, while at 0.7 mg/mL, mitomycin C significantly reduced the thickness of the sciatic nerve myelin sheath compared with lower concentrations, though no functional change was found. These experimental findings indicate that the local application of mitomycin C at low concentrations is safe to prevent scar adhesion following laminectomy, but that mitomycin C at high concentrations (> 0.7 mg/mL) has potential safety risks to peripheral nerve structures.

Effect of topical application of mitomycin-C on wound healing in a postlaminectomy rat model: an experimental study

The aim of this study was to investigate the effects of topical application mitomycin-C (MMC) on wound healing after laminectomy. 60 adult male SD rats were equally and randomly divided into five groups. Laminectomy was performed at the level of L1 in all rats. After hemostasis was achieved, cotton pads soaked with saline and MMC (0.1mg/ml, 0.3mg/ml, 0.5mg/ml and 0.7mg/ml) were directly subjected to the exposed dura for 5min in each group. Two weeks after laminectomy all the rats were killed. The vertebral column including the back scar tissue and muscles was obtained to make paraffin sections. The hematoxylin-eosin staining and Masson staining were performed with the obtained paraffin sections. The number of the fibroblast and the capillary density were counted by the hematoxylin-eosin staining slice. The extent of epidural fibrosis and the expression of vascular endothelial growth factor (VEGF) were evaluated by the immunohistochemical slice through a computer image analysis system. Our data showed that the number of fibroblast, capillary density and fibrotic tissue in the 0.5 and 0.7mg/ml MMC groups was significantly lower than the control, 0.1 and 0.3mg/ml MMC groups; while the expression of VEGF in control and 0.1mg/ml MMC groups was notably higher than 0.3, 0.5 and 0.7mg/ml MMC groups. Topical application of MMC above the concentration of 0.3mg/ml could affect all steps of the wound healing process via inhibiting the angiogenesis and fibroblast proliferation, thus delayed the wound healing after laminectomy.

Study on the optimal concentration of topical mitomycin-C in preventing postlaminectomy epidural adhesion

There is increasing evidence that topical application of mitomycin-C can be beneficial in reducing epidural scar adhesion. However, the ideal concentration of mitomycin-C is unknown. The purpose of this study was to verify its efficacy for preventing epidural adhesion and the immediate electrophysiological responses caused by it in a laminectomy model. Seventy rats underwent laminectomy at L-1 and L-2. Cotton pads soaked with saline and various concentrations of mitomycin-C (0.1 mg/ml, 0.3 mg/ml, 0.5 mg/ml and 0.7 mg/ml) were applied to the exposed dura for 5 min. Spine somatosensory evoked potentials (SSEP) were monitored in preoperative and the immediate electrophysiological responses of mitomycin-C used. Four weeks postlaminectomy the rats were killed. The area of epidural scar tissue and degree of epidural adhesion were determined by 7.0 T Micro MR imaging. Macroscopic evaluations were performed according to the Rydell standard. The results showed that severe epidural adhesion was formed in the saline group and no dural adherence or incomplete adhesions were found in the mitomycin-C group. The Rydell classification and the degree of epidural adhesion and the area of the scar in 0.5 mg/ml group and 0.7 mg/ml mitomycin-C group revealed a significant decrease compared with the control group and 0.1 mg/ml group and 0.3 mg/ml mitomycin-C group. The spine sensory evoked potentials did not alter obviously in both preoperative and the immediate electrophysiological responses of mitomycin-C used. In conclusion, locally applied mitomycin-C in a concentration of 0.5 mg/ml and 0.7 mg/ml mitomycin-C may be the optimal concentration in preventing postlaminectomy epidural adhesion.

Doxorubicin for prevention of epineurial fibrosis in a rat sciatic nerve model: outcome based on gross postsurgical, histopathological, and ultrastructural findings

Object

Epineural fibrosis may complicate peripheral nerve surgeries and currently is considered as one of the main factors responsible for failed surgeries. The authors investigated the postoperative antiscarring effects of topically applied doxorubicin (DXR) on rat sciatic nerves.

Methods

The sciatic nerves were dissected from the surrounding tissue and exposed bilaterally in 20 Wistar albino adult male rats. Abrasion trauma was produced on the exposed surface of the biceps femoris muscle in the vicinity of the sciatic nerves and their main branches in all animals. In the DXR Group, cottonoid pads soaked with DXR (0.5 mg/ml) were placed around the nerves for 5 minutes, whereas cotton pads soaked with saline (0.9% NaCl) were applied to nerves of animals in the Control Group for the same duration. Twelve weeks after the procedure, all of the rats were killed and the sciatic nerves were examined. Epineural adhesions were evaluated histopathologically and ultrastructurally. Additionally, quantitative histological parameters, the scar tissue formation index and the scar density, were calculated in histological evaluation.

Results

Gross postsurgical evaluation as well as histopathological and electron microscopic examination of involved nerve segments showed significantly less epineurial adhesions in the DXR Group than in the Control Group. Quantitative analysis of the epineurium revealed a statistically significant reduction in the density and amount of epineural scarring in specimens from the DXR Group than in those from the Control Group.

Conlusions

The results of gross postsurgical anatomical evaluation and histopathological and ultrastructural studies suggested that topical application of DXR effectively reduced epineural scar formation on rat sciatic nerves. These promising findings merit further experimental and clinical studies to determine the efficacy and safe applicability of DXR in human subjects.

Significant reduction in neural adhesions after administration of the regenerating agent OTR4120, a synthetic glycosaminoglycan mimetic, after peripheral nerve injury in rats

OBJECT

Extradural and intraneural scar formation after peripheral nerve injury frequently causes tethering and compression of the nerve as well as inhibition of axonal regeneration. Regenerating agents (RGTAs) mimic stabilizing and protective properties of sulphated glycosaminoglycan toward heparin-binding growth factors. The aim of this study was to assess the effect of an RGTA known as OTR4120 on extraneural fibrosis and axonal regeneration after crush injury in a rat sciatic nerve model.

METHODS

Thirty-two female Wistar rats underwent a standardized crush injury of the sciatic nerve. The animals were randomly allocated to RGTA treatment or sham treatment in a blinded design. To score neural adhesions, the force required to break the adhesions between the nerve and its surrounding tissue was measured 6 weeks after nerve crush injury. To assess axonal regeneration, magnetoneurographic measurements were performed after 5 weeks. Static footprint analysis was performed preoperatively and at Days 1, 7, 14, 17, 21, 24, 28, 35, and 42 postoperatively.

RESULTS

The magnetoneurographic data show no significant difference in conduction capacity between the RGTA and the control group. In addition, results of the static footprint analysis demonstrate no improved or accelerated recovery pattern. However, the mean pullout force of the RGTA group (67 +/- 9 g [mean +/- standard error of the mean]) was significantly (p < 0.001) lower than that of the control group (207 +/- 14 g [mean +/- standard error of the mean]).

CONCLUSIONS

The RGTAs strongly reduce nerve adherence to surrounding tissue after nerve crush injury.