Comparison between retrosigmoid and translabyrinthine approaches for large vestibular schwannoma: focus on cerebellar injury and morbidities

Translabyrinthine versus Retrosigmoid Approach for Vestibular Schwannoma: A Systematic Review and An Updated Meta-Analysis

OBJECTIVE

Several approaches can be used in the surgical treatment of vestibular schwannoma (VS), and the best approach remains uncertain in the literature. This systematic review and meta-analysis aim to compare the translabyrinthine approach (TLA) with the retrosigmoid approach (RSA) for VS in terms of postoperative complications.

DATA SOURCES

PubMed, Web of Science, Embase, and Cochrane.

REVIEW METHODS

The primary outcome was cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) leak; secondary outcomes were facial nerve dysfunction (FND), length of stay (LOS), and meningitis. Statistical analysis was performed using RStudio 2024.04.1 + 748. Heterogeneity was assessed with I² statistics. We performed sensitivity analysis with subgroup analysis and meta-regression. Risk of bias was assessed using ROBINS-I.

RESULTS

Out of 1140 potential articles, 21 met the inclusion criteria. Among the 4572 patients, 2687 and 1885 patients in the TLA and RSA groups, respectively. No significant differences were found in CSF leak (odds ratio [OR] 1.03; 95% confidence interval [CI] 0.81,1.32; P = .794) or meningitis (OR 1.05; 95% CI 0.45, 2.43; P = .73). Meta-regression showed no association with CSF leak and the number of cases per center or publication year. The TLA is associated with a shorter LOS (MD -1.20; 95% CI -1.39, -1.01; P < .01) and a higher chance of having and HB 4 or lower compared to patients who underwent RSA (OR 0.30; 95% CI 0.10, 0.89; P = .03).

CONCLUSION

There was no difference in the odds of CSF leak or meningitis between the groups. In addition, the TLA has a shorter LOS and a higher chance of a better facial nerve outcome compared to the RSA.

Evaluating the effectiveness and complications of the Retrosigmoid, Translabyrinthine and Middle Fossa approaches in vestibular Schwannoma surgical management: a comprehensive systematic review and meta-analysis of 6,889 patients

Surgical resection stands as one of the potential therapeutic methods for vestibular schwannomas (VS). However, in the management of patients with VS, there is limited literature directly comparing the Retrosigmoid approach (RSA) with the Translabyrinthine Approach (TLA) and Middle Fossa Approach (MFA). This gap arises because the MFA is typically reserved for smaller intracanalicular tumors, while the RSA and TLA are preferred for larger lesions. Our objective was to assess and compare the outcomes and safety profile of these three different surgical approaches. A comprehensive search was performed on PubMed, Embase, and Cochrane Library for studies comparing RSA with TLA and MFA in patients with VS. The main outcomes of interest were hearing preservation, facial nerve function, extent of resection, and postoperative complications. Statistical analyses were performed using Review Manager. The I2 test was employed for heterogeneity assessment, while the risk of bias was evaluated utilizing ROBINS-I. We included 6,889 patients from 32 observational studies. RSA was used to manage VS in 3,352 (48,7%) patients. Our comparative hearing preservation analysis revealed no significant difference in patient improvement between RSA and MFA, with a risk ratio (RR) of 1.18 (95% CI: 0.76-1.85, p = 0.46, I2:0%). Late facial nerve preservation comparing RSA and TLA showed RR = 0.91(95% CI: 0.77-1.07, p = 0.25, I2:32%), while RSA with MFA a RR = 0.98 (95% CI: 0.92-1.04, p = 0.53, I2:87%). The cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) leak showed no significant difference in risk RR = 1.18 (95% CI: 0.92-1.51, p = 0.21; I2:0%) and RR = 1.14 (95% CI: 0.70-1.83; p = 0.60, I2:26%) comparing RSA with TLA and MFA respectively. The evidence synthesized in this meta-analysis suggests equivalent hearing preservation and facial nerve function in managing VS patients across the different RSA and MFA surgical approaches analyzed. However, in comparison to TLA and MFA, RSA stood out exhibiting fewer occurrences of postoperative complications consisting of hydrocephalus, and CSF leaks.

Sheep Head Cadaveric Model for the Transmeatal Extensions of the Retrosigmoid Approach

The transmeatal extension of the retrosigmoid approach is an important procedure used in the treatment of various pathologies affecting the posterior fossa, petroclival region, and jugular foramen. Mastering this technique requires a high level of manual skill, particularly in temporal bone drilling. The objective of this study was to describe an easily accessible and cost-effective model of the transmeatal extension of the retrosigmoid approach using cadaveric sheep heads. Five cadaveric sheep heads, fixed in alcohol and formalin with intravascular-colored silicone injection, were prepared for this study. Two heads (four sides) were designated for illustrative anatomical specimens, while three heads (six sides) were used for surgical simulation. Additionally, one head was used to prepare and dissect a dry skull. All critical steps of the transmeatal approach, including both supra- and inframeatal extensions, were successfully replicated on the model. A comparative anatomical analysis was conducted, focusing on the technical nuances of the model. The cadaveric sheep head serves as an effective model for the retrosigmoid approach with transmeatal extensions, primarily for training manual haptic skills. While the sheep model cannot precisely replicate human anatomy, it still offers valuable training opportunities for neurosurgeons, particularly when human cadaveric specimens are unavailable.

Superior petrosal vein sacrifice in translabyrinthine approach for resection of vestibule schwannoma

PURPOSE

The aim of this study was to evaluate the safety and surgical outcome of superior petrosal vein (SPV, Dandy's vein) sacrifice in translabyrinthine approach (TLA) for resection of vestibule schwannoma (VS) as compared with SPV preservation, with further investigation of preoperational factors associated with the implement of SPV sacrifice.

METHODS

The authors prospectively collected data from patients surgically treated for VS through TLA between June 2021 and April 2022 at the Gruppo Otologico.

RESULTS

There were 30 and 49 patients in SPV sacrifice and preservation groups, respectively. SPV sacrifice group had significantly larger tumor size (2.46 vs. 1.40 cm), less percentage of solid tumor (26.7% vs. 83.7%), higher incidence of brainstem compression (80% vs. 26.5%), and higher percentage of facial numbness (20.0% vs. 4.1%) than SPV preservation group. Gross total resection (GTR) rates were 73.3% after SPV sacrifice and 87.8% after SPV preservation. Facial nerve preservation rates were similar. No complication related with SPV sacrifice was observed. Logistic regression analysis showed tumor size and complete solid consistency as significant risk factors associated with SPV sacrifice. ROC curve further demonstrated tumor size as a fair predictor (AUC = 0.833), with optimum cutoff value of 1.68 cm.

CONCLUSION

SPV sacrifice via TLA as needed is a safe and effective maneuver for removal of relatively large VS. Tumor size and consistency can be used as a guidance in preoperational decision-making, with cutoff value of 1.68 cm and cystic formation as predictive indicators.

Factors Associated with Acute Obstructive Hydrocephalus After Retrosigmoid Approach for Extra-Axial Cerebellopontine Angle Tumors

BACKGROUND

This study aimed to identify the risk factors for acute obstructive hydrocephalus (AOHCP) after extra-axial cerebellopontine angle (CPA) tumor surgery using the retrosigmoid (RS) approach.

METHODS

This retrospective study assessed 154 patients (100 vestibular schwannomas, 34 CPA meningiomas [MNGs], 9 trigeminal schwannomas, and 11 petroclival MNGs) who underwent surgical resection using the RS approach by a single surgeon between August 2010 and September 2019. AOHCP was defined as postoperative ventricular enlargement due to cerebrospinal fluid flow obstruction caused by surgery-related cerebellar injury within 1 week. The radiological characteristics of the tumors were classified, and the surgical outcomes were reviewed. We analyzed the impact of different factors on the development of AOHCP after surgery.

RESULTS

AOHCP developed in 17 (11%) patients, all of whom were treated with external ventricular drain insertion. Multivariate analysis showed that CPA MNGs (odds ratio [OR], 37.98), grade of tumor extension beyond the petroclival junction (grade 1: OR, 16.42; grade 2: OR, 17.47), major fourth ventricle compression (OR, 17.77), and surgery-related hemorrhage (OR, 7.64) were associated with AOHCP. Surgery-related hemorrhage was observed in 17 (11%) patients. 9 (6%) patients underwent ventriculoperitoneal shunt surgery because of persistent HCP.

CONCLUSIONS

An increased risk of AOHCP after the RS approach was observed in patients with extra-axial CPA tumors with clival extension and major fourth ventricle compression. Compulsive and meticulous hemostasis must be achieved because postoperative hemorrhage is associated with AOHCP.

Optimal Volume of the Residual Tumor to Predict Long-term Tumor Control Using Stereotactic Radiosurgery after Facial Nerve-preserving Surgery for Vestibular Schwannomas

BACKGROUND

Intended subtotal resection (STR) followed by adjuvant gamma knife radiosurgery (GKRS) has emerged as an effective treatment option for facial nerve (FN) preservation in vestibular schwannomas (VSs). This study aimed to identify the optimal cut-off volume of residual VS to predict favorable outcomes in terms of both tumor control and FN preservation.

METHODS

This retrospective study assessed the patients who underwent adjuvant GKRS for residual VS after microsurgery. A total of 68 patients who had been followed up for ≥ 24 months after GKRS were included. Tumor progression was defined as an increase in tumor volume (TV) of ≥ 20%. House-Brackmann grades I and II were considered to indicate good FN function.

RESULTS

The median residual TV was 2.5 cm³ (range: 0.3-27.4). The median follow-up period after the first adjuvant GKRS was 64 months (range: 25.7-152.4). Eight (12%) patients showed tumor progression. In multivariate analyses, residual TV was associated with tumor progression (P = 0.003; hazard ratio [HR], 1.229; 95% confidence interval [CI], 1.075-1.405). A residual TV of 6.4 cm³ was identified as the cut-off volume for showing the greatest difference in progression-free survival (PFS). The 5-year PFS rates in the group with residual TVs of < 6.4 cm³ (54 patients) and that with residual TVs of ≥ 6.4 cm³ (14 patients) were 93.3% and 69.3%, respectively (P = 0.014). A good FN outcome was achieved in 57 (84%) patients. Residual TV was not associated with good FN function during the immediate postoperative period (P = 0.695; odds ratio [OR], 1.024; 95% CI, 0.908-1.156) or at the last follow-up (P = 0.755; OR, 0.980; 95% CI, 0.866-1.110).

CONCLUSION

In this study, residual TV was associated with tumor progression in VS after adjuvant GKRS following STR. As preservation of FN function is not correlated with the extent of resection, optimal volume reduction is imperative to achieve long-term tumor control. Our findings will help surgeons predict the prognosis of residual VS after FN-preserving surgery.

ALIF in the correction of spinal sagittal misalignment. A systematic review of literature

PURPOSE

We aim at analysing the impact of anterior lumbar interbody fusion (ALIF) in restoring the main spinopelvic parameters, along with its potentials and limitations in correcting sagittal imbalance.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

The 2009 PRISMA flow chart was used to systematically review the literature; 27 papers were eventually selected. The following spinopelvic parameters were observed: pelvic tilt (PT), sacral slope (SS), lumbar lordosis (LL), segmental lumbar lordosis (LLseg) and sagittal vertical axis (SVA). Papers reporting on hyperlordotic cages (HLC) were analysed separately. The indirect decompression potential of ALIF was also assessed. The clinical outcome was obtained by collecting visual analogue scale (VAS) for back and leg pain and Oswestry Disability Index (ODI) scores. Global fusion rate and main complications were collected.

RESULTS

PT, SS, LL, LLseg and SVA spinopelvic parameters all improved postoperatively by - 4.3 ± 5.2°, 3.9 ± 4.5°, 10.6 ± 12.5°, 6.7 ± 3.5° and 51.1 ± 44.8 mm, respectively. HLC were statistically more effective in restoring LL and LLseg (p < 0.05). Postoperative disc height, anterior disc height, posterior disc height and foraminal height, respectively, increased by 58.5%, 87.2%, 80.9% and 18.1%. Postoperative improvements were observed in VAS back and leg and ODI scores (p < 0.05). The global fusion rate was 94.5 ± 5.5%; the overall complication rate was 13%.

CONCLUSION

When managing sagittal imbalance, ALIF can be considered as a valid technique to achieve the correct spinopelvic parameters based on preoperative planning. This technique permits to obtain an optimal LL distribution and a solid anterior column support, with lower complications and higher fusion rates when compared to posterior osteotomies.

Comparison of translabyrinthine and retrosigmoid approach for treating vestibular schwannoma: A meta-analysis

BACKGROUND

To date, the literature directly comparing the translabyrinthine approach and retrosigmoid approach in the operation of patients with vestibular schwannoma was limited. We aimed to evaluate postoperative complications between translabyrinthine approach and retrosigmoid approach for treating vestibular schwannoma patients.

MATERIAL AND METHOD

Potential publications were selected from PubMed, Web of Science and Cochrane Library. Gray relevant studies were manually searched. We set the searching time spanning from the creation date of electronic engines to February 2020. STATA version 12.0 was exerted to process the pooled data.

RESULTS

A total of 9 literature included in the study, involving 2429 patients, hails from the Germany, USA, Canada, Italy, and France. Of these 2429 patients with vestibular schwannoma, there were 1628 cases from the translabyrinthine approach group versus 801 cases from the retrosigmoid approach group. The results demonstrated that the translabyrinthine approach group was associated with a lower rate of tinnitus (OR = 2.687; 95 %CI, 1.167-6.191; P = 0.02) and cranial nerve deficit (OR = 2.946; 95 %CI, 1.562-5.557; P = 0.001). And the translabyrinthine approach group was associated with a higher total resection rate (OR = 0.246; 95 %CI (0.071-0.848); P = 0.026). However, no statistic differences were found in the incidence of the near total (OR = 0.751; P = 0.351), subtotal resection (OR = 3.664; P = 0.109), postoperative facial nerve dysfunctions (OR, 0.763; P = 0.626), postoperative meningitis (OR = 2.7; P = 0.279), cerebrospinal fluid leak (OR = 1.225; P = 0.777), postoperative headache (OR = 1.412; P = 0.339), ophthalmic complications (OR = 0.87; P = 0.59), and vascular complications (OR = 2.501; P = 0.139).

CONCLUSION

Based on current evidence, the translabyrinthine approach was associated with a higher rate of total resection and a lower rate of the tinnitus and cranial nerve deficit. But the risk of cranial nerve deficit was clearly affected by the preoperative status. And a translabyrintine approach could imply a complete sensorineural hearing loss, which contribute to the lower rate of postoperative tinnitus. Consequently, more evidence-based researches are needed to supplement this opinion.