Histopathology of Colectomy Specimens Predicts Endoscopic Pouch Phenotype in Patients with Ulcerative Colitis

Prevalence and predictability of the Chicago Classification of Pouchitis in ulcerative colitis: a multicenter study in Japan

BACKGROUND

Endoscopic phenotypes of pouchitis according to the Chicago Classification have been reported to be associated with poor pouch outcomes in ulcerative colitis (UC). Here, we aimed to assess the prevalence of endoscopic phenotypes and their predictability for pouch outcomes.

METHODS

This retrospective multicenter study included UC patients aged 18 years or older who underwent total colectomy between January 2000 and March 2020. The primary endpoints were frequencies of endoscopic phenotypes of the Chicago Classification and their predictability for chronic pouchitis and pouch failure. Endoscopic findings were evaluated at the initial pouchoscopy and at 3 and 10 years after ileostomy takedown.

RESULTS

A total of 392 eligible patients were identified. The frequencies of chronic pouchitis and pouch failure were 32% and 4.9%, respectively. Focal inflammation and inlet involvement at the initial postoperative pouchoscopy were significantly associated with subsequent risk of chronic pouchitis and pouch failure, respectively. Thirty percent of the patients with focal inflammation progressed to diffuse inflammation when chronic pouchitis developed. Multivariate analysis showed chronic pouchitis was significantly associated with diffuse inflammation and cuffitis observed throughout the clinical course. The proportion of pouch-related fistula was significantly lower in our cohort than in the US cohort (4.8% vs 19%, P < 0.001), and pouch-related fistula was an independent risk factor for pouch failure.

CONCLUSIONS

We demonstrated the predictability of the Chicago Classification for pouch outcomes, and a lower prevalence of pouch-related fistula, resulting in a lower pouch failure risk in our multicenter cohort.

Endoscopic assessment of the J pouch in ulcerative colitis: A narrative review

Patients with ulcerative colitis sometimes need a total colectomy with ileal pouch-anal anastomosis due to medically refractory disease or colitis-associated neoplasia. Up to 50% of patients with ulcerative colitis postoperatively develop pouchitis and the rate of chronic inflammatory pouch conditions requiring pouch excision or diverting ileostomy is reported to be 10%. In order to diagnose and monitor pouchitis, pouchoscopy is essential to assess endoscopic inflammatory findings of the J pouch and to survey neoplasia development, particularly in the remnant distal rectum. However, endoscopic protocols for the evaluation of the pouch may not be standardized worldwide and the reliability of existing disease activity indices for pouchitis has been questioned due to the lack of validation. Recently, reliable endoscopic scoring systems based on an observation of the anatomical location of the J pouch were reported and a significant association between the distribution pattern of endoscopic inflammation (i.e., endoscopic phenotype) and pouch outcomes was also uncovered. In this review, we discuss how to survey the J pouch using pouchoscopy, endoscopic indices for pouchitis disease activity, endoscopic phenotypes and classification, and the pathological mechanisms of pouchitis phenotype in patients with ulcerative colitis.

Endoscopic Normalization and Transition of J-Pouch Phenotypes Over Time in Patients With Inflammatory Bowel Disease

BACKGROUND

Patients with inflammatory bowel disease (IBD) who undergo proctocolectomy with ileal pouch-anal anastomosis may develop pouchitis. We previously proposed a novel endoscopic classification of pouchitis describing 7 phenotypes with differing outcomes. This study assessed phenotype transitions over time.

METHODS

We classified pouch findings into 7 main phenotypes: (1) normal, (2) afferent limb (AL) involvement, (3) inlet (IL) involvement, (4) diffuse, (5) focal inflammation of the pouch body, (6) cuffitis, and (7) pouch-related fistulas noted more than 6 months after ileostomy takedown. Among 2 endoscopic phenotypes, the phenotype that was first identified was defined as the primary phenotype, and the phenotype observed later was defined as the subsequent phenotype.

RESULTS

We retrospectively reviewed 1359 pouchoscopies from 426 patients (90% preoperative diagnosis of ulcerative colitis). The frequency of primary phenotype was 31% for AL involvement, 42% for IL involvement, 28% for diffuse inflammation, 72% for focal inflammation, 45% for cuffitis, 18% for pouch-related fistulas, and 28% for normal pouch. The most common subsequent phenotype was focal inflammation (64.8%), followed by IL involvement (38.6%), cuffitis (37.8%), AL involvement (25.6%), diffuse inflammation (23.8%), normal pouch (22.8%), and pouch-related fistulas (11.9%). Subsequent diffuse inflammation, pouch-related fistulas, and AL or IL stenoses significantly increased the pouch excision risk. Patients who achieved subsequent normal pouch were less likely to have pouch excision than those who did not (8.1% vs 15.7%; P = .15).

CONCLUSIONS

Pouch phenotype and the risk of pouch loss can change over time. In patients with pouch inflammation, subsequent pouch normalization is feasible and associated with favorable outcome.

Clinical and histological impact of diffuse inflammation at pouchoscopy

PURPOSE

The anatomical location of inflammation in and around the ileal pouch affects the pouch survival rate, and diffuse inflammation has poor pouch survival rates. We aimed to clarify the symptoms and histological findings of diffuse inflammation of the pouch.

METHODS

We evaluated the symptoms, treatment, and histological findings according to the endoscopic phenotypes of diffuse inflammation, focal inflammation, and normal as the pouch body phenotype and afferent limb involvement, inlet involvement, cuffitis, and fistula as the peripheral findings.

RESULTS

Of the 318 pouchoscopies, 47 had diffuse inflammation, 201 had focal inflammation, and 70 were normal. Symptomatic patients had diffuse inflammation more frequently (46.8%) than focal inflammation (13.4%) and normal (14.2%), with no difference between focal inflammation and normal. Antibiotics and steroids were higher rate administered in cases of diffuse inflammation, but not in cases of focal inflammation or in normal cases. Histological inflammation, inflammatory bowel disease (IBD)-specific finding, and colonic metaplasia showed severity in the order of diffuse inflammation > focal inflammation > normal. The number of peripheral inflammatory findings overlapped in the following order: diffuse inflammation > focal inflammation > normal. The number of symptomatic patients increased as the number of peripheral inflammatory findings increased.

CONCLUSION

Pouches with diffuse inflammation are more symptomatic, have a higher use of therapeutic agents, and have more severe histological inflammation, IBD-specific finding, and colonic metaplasia accompanying peripheral inflammatory findings than the other groups. The higher the overlap of inflammatory findings in the surrounding tissues, the more symptomatic the patients will appear.

Association of colonic metaplasia of goblet cells and endoscopic phenotypes of the J pouch in patients with ulcerative colitis: a retrospective pilot study

BACKGROUND/AIMS

Mucosal adaptation of the ileum toward colonic epithelium has been reported in pouchitis in ulcerative colitis (UC); however, the clinical characteristics, endoscopic findings, and outcomes in patients with pouchitis with ileal mucosal adaptation are poorly understood.

METHODS

This was a single-center retrospective study comprising UC patients treated by proctocolectomy with ileal pouch-anal anastomosis who had undergone pouchoscopy at the University of Tsukuba Hospital between 2005 and 2022. Endoscopic phenotypes were evaluated according to the Chicago classification. High-iron diamine staining (HID) was performed to identify sulfomucin (colon-type mucin)-producing goblet cells (GCs) in pouch biopsies. We compared clinical data between patients with (high HID group) and without > 10% sulfomucin-producing GCs in at least one biopsy (low HID group).

RESULTS

We reviewed 390 endoscopic examination reports from 50 patients. Focal inflammation was the most common phenotype (78%). Five patients (10%) required diverting ileostomy. Diffuse inflammation and fistula were significant risk factors for diverting ileostomy. The median proportion of sulfomucin-producing GCs on histological analysis of 82 pouch biopsies from 23 patients was 9.9% (range, 0%-93%). The duration of disease was significantly greater in the high HID group compared to the low HID group. The median percentage of sulfomucin-producing GCs was significantly higher in patients with diffuse inflammation or fistula compared to other endoscopic phenotypes (14% vs. 6.0%, P= 0.011).

CONCLUSIONS

Greater proportions of sulfomucin-producing GCs were observed in endoscopic phenotypes associated with poor outcomes in UC, indicating patients with pouchitis showing colonic metaplasia of GCs may benefit from early interventions.

Diagnostic and Management Considerations for the IPAA With Crohn's Disease-Like Features

BACKGROUND

Patients with ulcerative colitis often develop medically refractory colonic inflammation or colorectal neoplasia, and approximately 10% to 15% of patients require surgery. The most common surgical procedure is a restorative proctocolectomy with IPAA. Even if the preoperative diagnosis is ulcerative colitis, approximately 10% of patients can develop inflammatory pouch conditions resembling a Crohn's disease phenotype.

OBJECTIVE

This study aimed to review the diagnostic approach, prognosis, and management of IPAA with Crohn's disease-like features.

DATA SOURCES

The data sources include search in electronic databases.

STUDY SELECTION

This narrative review included studies focusing on pouches with Crohn's disease-like features.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES

The main topics in this review included the pathogenesis, risk factors, diagnosis, phenotypes, prognosis, and medications of pouches with Crohn's disease-like features.

RESULTS

A diagnostic approach for the pouch conditions resembling a Crohn's disease phenotype should be based on history-taking to evaluate its risk factors and endoscopic assessment of the pouch. Prior disease history and pathology, location of pouch complications, and timing of complications offer clues for the differential diagnosis of this phenotype. We advocate for the more descriptive term "pouch with Crohn's disease-like features" and reserve the term "Crohn's disease of the pouch" for patients who undergo IPAA and have a precolectomy diagnosis of Crohn's disease or whose colectomy pathology revealed Crohn's disease. Medications, which are often used for traditional Crohn's disease, show efficacy in pouches with Crohn's disease-like features as well. The poor prognosis associated with pouches with Crohn's disease-like features, particularly the fistulizing phenotype, underscores the importance of proactive monitoring and therapeutic intervention.

LIMITATIONS

The limitations include no explicit criteria for article selection.

CONCLUSIONS

This review suggests future research should seek to understand the natural history and meaningful shorter and longer term therapeutic targets for these types of pouch phenotypes. Long-term follow-up and prospective preoperative and postoperative interventional trials of treatments and prevention strategies are needed.

Diagnosis and Management of Cuffitis: A Systematic Review

BACKGROUND

In patients with ulcerative colitis or familial adenomatous polyposis who develop neoplasia or fail medical therapy and require colectomy, restorative proctocolectomy with IPAA is often indicated. Although often well tolerated, IPAA can be complicated by cuffitis or inflammation of the remaining rectal cuff. Although much has been published on this subject, there is no clear and comprehensive synthesis of the literature regarding cuffitis.

METHODS

Our systematic literature review analyzes 34 articles to assess the frequency, cause, pathogenesis, diagnosis, classification, complications, and treatment of cuffitis.

RESULTS

Cuffitis occurs in an estimated 10.2% to 30.1% of pouch patients. Purported risk factors include rectal cuff length >2 cm, pouch-rectal anastomosis, stapled anastomosis, J-pouch configuration, 2- or 3-stage IPAA, preoperative Clostridium difficile infection, toxic megacolon, fulminant colitis, preoperative biologic use, medically refractory disease, immunomodulator/steroids use within 3 months of surgery, extraintestinal manifestations of IBD, and BMI <18.5 kg/m2 at the time of colectomy. Adverse consequences associated with cuffitis include decreased quality-of-life scores, increased risk for pouchitis, pouch failure, pouch excision, and pouch neoplasia.

CONCLUSIONS

Given the similarities between pouchitis and cuffitis, diagnosis and treatment of cuffitis should proceed according to the International Ileal Pouch Consortium guidelines. This review found that the majority of the current literature fails to distinguish between classic cuffitis (a form of reminant ulcerative proctitis) and nonclassic cuffitis (resulting from other causes). Further work is needed to distinguish the unique risk factors and endoscopic characteristics associated with each subtype, and further randomized clinical trials should be conducted to strengthen the evidence for treatment options.