Systematic review and meta-analysis: does pre-implantation genetic testing for aneuploidy at the blastocyst stage improve live birth rate?

Predicting frequency distributions of blastocyst biopsy genotypes by their discrete cohort size using the binomial theorem

RESEARCH QUESTION

How are blastocyst biopsy genotypes distributed as a function of cohort size, and how well does the binomial theorem predict the specific distribution of euploid genotypes across different cohort sizes?

DESIGN

This retrospective observational study included 1065 autologous blastocyst biopsies from 206 consecutive biopsy cases at a single centre. Cohorts were classified into three mutually exclusive categories: euploid+ (containing at least one euploid), euploid-mosaic/segmental+ and meiotic (containing whole chromosome errors alone), stratified by patient age (<37 years versus ≥37 years) and cohort size (10 discrete groups). 'Observed' distributions of individual euploid blastocysts/cohort were compared with binomially 'expected' distributions using the overall probability for euploidy for each age group.

RESULTS

For patients aged <37 years, cohorts were predominantly euploid+ (85.7%). The odds of being euploid increased for each 1-unit increase in cohort size. For each size group, the observed distribution of euploid blastocysts/cohort was closely concordant with distributions predicted binomially in the largest three cohort size quartiles. In contrast, cohort categories in the smallest quartile showed greater discordance. For patients aged ≥37 years, 48.5% of cohorts were euploid+ cohorts. While the odds of being euploid also increased for each 1-unit increase in cohort size, the observed peak number of euploid blastocysts/cohort was lower than predicted binomially in all size quartiles.

CONCLUSIONS

The binomial theorem can predict the probability distributions of euploid genotypes in cohort sizes exceeding four in patients aged <37 years without a biopsy. However, in smaller cohort sizes for patients aged >37 years and all cohort sizes in patients aged ≥37 years, there were fewer euploid blastocysts/cohort than predicted binomially; thus, untransferred mosaic/segmental genotypes represent a repository of pregnancy potential.

The diagnostic accuracy of preimplantation genetic testing (PGT) in assessing the genetic status of embryos: a systematic review and meta-analysis

BACKGROUND

Preimplantation genetic testing (PGT) is widely used in assisted reproduction to assess the genetic status of embryos. However, increasing evidence suggests that the trophectoderm (TE) may not fully reflect the genetic status of the inner cell mass (ICM), raising controversy about the accuracy of TE biopsy. Research in recent years has focused on cell-free DNA (cfDNA) found in blastocoel fluid (BF) and spent culture medium (SCM), as these may contain genetic information from both the TE and ICM. Therefore, further research and validation are essential to determine the reliability and clinical applicability of these diagnostic methods in PGT.

METHODS

Relevant studies published between January 2000 and August 2024 were identified through PubMed and Web of Science (WOS). Risk assessment and publication bias were evaluated using QUADAS-2 and Deek's test. Diagnostic meta-analysis was performed using a bivariate model to combine sensitivity and specificity, with results visualized through forest plots and summary receiver operating characteristic (SROC) curves.

RESULTS

Out of 6,407 initially screened records, 36 studies involving 4,230 embryos were included. TE biopsy was identified as the best method for diagnosing the genetic status of embryos (sensitivity: 0.839; specificity: 0.791, AUC: 0.878), while SCM had slightly lower accuracy (sensitivity: 0.874; specificity: 0.719, AUC: 0.869). The effectiveness of BF (AUC: 0.656) was significantly lower than that of TE biopsy and SCM. Despite this, TE biopsy has not yet achieved ideal diagnostic performance. However, TE biopsies demonstrate a high level of accuracy in diagnosing PGT-SR (AUC: 0.957). Additionally, multiple TE biopsies (AUC: 0.966) or TE biopsies combined with SCM (AUC: 0.927) can enhance the diagnostic efficiency of PGT.

CONCLUSION

The findings of this study suggest that TE biopsy has yet to achieve optimal diagnostic accuracy, which may result in a significant number of missed embryo diagnoses and misdiagnoses. Our results confirm that SCM has the potential to serve as a supplementary test. Employing multiple biopsies or combining TE with SCM may enhance diagnostic efficiency and yield optimal results.

Value of PGT-A when only one or two blastocysts are obtained: propensity-score matching and cost-effectiveness study

OBJECTIVE

To compare the effectiveness and cost of in-vitro fertilization (IVF) with or without preimplantation genetic testing for aneuploidy (PGT-A) when only one or two blastocysts are obtained.

METHODS

A dataset was gathered from 1829 patients including 368 non-PGT-A and 1461 PGT-A cycles with one or two blastocysts obtained, between April 2013 and July 2022. Patients were matched 1:1 by propensity-score matching for maternal age, number of metaphase-II oocytes inseminated and number of blastocysts obtained, achieving a database of 242 patients per group. The non-PGT-A and PGT-A groups were compared for differences in live birth rate (LBR) per embryo transfer (ET), cumulative LBR per patient, miscarriage rate (MR) per clinical pregnancy, number of days between oocyte retrieval and conclusion of the IVF cycle (primary outcome), mean expenses incurred at the clinic and incremental cost-effectiveness ratio (ICER).

RESULTS

More than twice as many ETs were conducted in the non-PGT-A group compared with the PGT-A group, yet the cumulative LBR per patient was similar between groups (23.6% (95% CI, 18.5-29.5%) vs 27.3% (95% CI, 21.9-33.4%)). This outcome was achieved with a higher LBR per ET (16.2% (95% CI, 12.6-20.5%) vs 41.5% (95% CI, 33.9-49.4%)) and lower MR per clinical pregnancy (30.1% (95% CI, 21.8-42.6%) vs 13.9% (95% CI, 7.5-24.0%)) in the PGT-A group. The MR per patient was also lower in the PGT-A group (9.5% (95% CI, 6.2-14.1%) vs 4.5% (95% CI, 2.4-8.2%)). The mean duration between oocyte retrieval and IVF cycle conclusion was 131 (95% CI, 113-150) days in the non-PGT-A group vs 74 (95% CI, 61-87) days in the PGT-A group (P < 0.001; power = 99.8%). The ICER of PGT-A for the months saved between oocyte retrieval and conclusion of the IVF cycle was €499 overall, ranging between €170 and €2065 according to the number of blastocysts obtained and/or maternal age. The ICER of PGT-A for prevented miscarriages was €18 968, decreasing to €3525 when calculated among patients aged ≥ 35 years with two blastocysts obtained.

CONCLUSIONS

When conducted in expert IVF clinics for patients indicated for the procedure, PGT-A is clinically valuable even when only one or two blastocysts are obtained. PGT-A reduces the number of ETs and miscarriages while the cumulative LBR per patient remains unaffected, and allows these outcomes to be achieved in a shorter timeframe. The ICER of PGT-A vs non PGT-A decreased as maternal age increased. © 2024 International Society of Ultrasound in Obstetrics and Gynecology.

Quality of IVM ovarian tissue oocytes: impact of clinical, demographic, and laboratory factors

PURPOSE

To determine how clinical, demographic, and laboratory characteristics influence ovarian tissue oocyte quality.

METHODS

Immature cumulus-oocyte complexes were isolated from removed ovaries and cultured for 48-52 h in either monophasic standard or biphasic CAPA media for fertility preservation. A total of 355 MII oocytes from 53 patients were described for intracytoplasmic and extracytoplasmic anomalies. Multiple clinical, laboratory, and demographic characteristics were analyzed. Statistically significant differences between independent groups in qualitative variables were identified using Pearson's χ2 and Fisher's exact tests. The diagnostic value of quantitative variables was assessed using the ROC curve analysis. Factors associated with the development of dysmorphism, taking patient age into account, were identified using the binary logistic regression analysis.

RESULTS

Dysmorphisms were observed in 245 oocytes (69.0%), with a median number of dysmorphisms of 2. Oocyte dysmorphisms were found to be 2.211 times more likely to be detected in patients with ovarian cancer, while the presence of dark-colored cytoplasm was associated with gynecologic surgery in the anamnesis (p = 0.002; OR 16.652; 95% CI, 1.977-140.237; Cramer's V 0.187). Small polar bodies developed 2.717 times more often (95% CI, 1.195-6.18) in patients older than 35. In the case of ovarian transportation on ice at 4 ℃, the chances of development of cytoplasmic granularity increased 2.569 times (95% CI, 1.301-5.179). The use of biphasic CAPA IVM media contributed to a decrease in the probability of large polar body formation (p = 0.034) compared to the standard monophasic IVM media.

CONCLUSIONS

Both patients' characteristics and laboratory parameters have an impact on the quality of IVM ovarian tissue oocytes.

Impact of aneuploidy on reproductive success in young infertile women: prospective analysis

RESEARCH QUESTION

What is the clinical outcome of the first attempt at conception between two embryo selection methods, blastocyst morphology and preimplantation genetic testing for aneuploidies (PGT-A), chosen at the initial physician IVF consultation?

DESIGN

In this prospective analysis, a clinical decision regarding embryo selection, blastocyst morphology (group A) or PGT-A (group B) was made during initial physician IVF consultation. Female infertility patients were matched based on maternal age (mean 32.6 ± 3.6 years; range 25-43 years) and a similar time frame of oocyte retrieval. The primary outcome was live birth rate from the initial consultation to the first conception attempt for all female patients and for a subset analysis of patients aged <35 years.

RESULTS

The inclusion of PGT-A (group B) for embryo selection during the initial physician IVF consultation resulted in 23 additional women out of the total 100 achieving a healthy live birth following the first conception attempt in this maternally age-matched infertile population (group B = 72.0% versus group A = 49.0%; P = 0.0014). This same benefit was observed for age-matched, younger infertility patients (<35 years), with live birth rates from the initial consultation being significantly higher when the upfront clinical decision included PGT-A for embryo selection (group B = 76.7% versus group A = 53.4%; P = 0.0052). Interestingly, 17 women from group B would have received an aneuploid embryo transfer if selection had been determined by blastocyst morphology alone, as their best-grade embryo was aneuploid.

CONCLUSIONS

This prospective analysis from the initial physician IVF consultation revealed that euploid embryo selection significantly improved live birth potential with the first conception attempt, even for younger women with infertility.

Effect of sequential cleavage and blastocyst embryo transfer compared to single cleavage stage embryo transfer on assisted reproductive technology outcome: An RCT

Background

Assisted reproductive technology (ART), offers hope for many infertile couples by increasing the chance of successful pregnancy. The success of in vitro fertilization depends on various factors, in which embryo transfer (ET) is one of the critical steps influencing in vitro fertilization success rates. Extended embryo culture and blastocyst-stage ET have been considered in ART due to their potential benefits including improved implantation rates.

Objective

This study aimed to compare the outcomes of sequential ET vs single cleavage-stage ET in women undergoing a fresh ET cycle with a limited number of embryos.

Materials and Methods

This randomized clinical trial was conducted on 140 women undergoing infertility treatments and candidates for fresh ET at the Research and Clinical Center for Infertility, Yazd, Iran from August 2023 to January 2024. Women with a number of embryos from 2-5 ( ≥ 2 and ≤ 5 available embryos) were randomly divided into 2 groups: One group underwent sequential ET (one cleavage-stage ET followed by one blastocyst ET) and the other group underwent single-step 2 cleavage-stage ET. The primary outcome was clinical pregnancy, and the secondary outcome included chemical pregnancy and early abortion rates.

Results

Our findings showed significantly higher rates of clinical (33.5% vs 13.6%, p = 0.003) and chemical (41.3% vs 18.2%, p = 0.004) pregnancies in the sequential ET group compared to the single-step cleavage ET group. The early abortion rate was higher in single-step cleavage ET (13% vs 44.4%, p = 0.053).

Conclusion

Sequential fresh ET is a useful choice in women who have a limited number of embryos and can improve ART outcomes.

Comparing blastocyst euploid rates between the progestin-primed and gonadotrophin-releasing hormone antagonist protocols in aneuploidy genetic testing: a randomised trial protocol

INTRODUCTION

Progestin can inhibit the pituitary luteinising hormone (LH) surge during ovarian stimulation for in vitro fertilisation (IVF) and studies show progestin-primed ovarian stimulation (PPOS) is effective in blocking the LH surge in IVF. More and more centres are using PPOS because this regimen appears simpler and cheaper. This study aims to compare the euploidy rate of blastocysts following the PPOS protocol and the gonadotropin-releasing hormone antagonist protocol in women undergoing preimplantation genetic testing for aneuploidy (PGT-A).

METHODS/ANALYSIS

This is a randomised trial. A total of 400 women undergoing PGT-A will be enrolled and randomised according to a computer-generated randomisation list to either (1) the antagonist group: an antagonist given once daily from day 6 of ovarian stimulation till the day of the ovulation trigger; or (2) the PPOS group: dydrogesterone from the first day of ovarian stimulation till the day of ovulation trigger. The primary outcome is the euploidy rate of blastocysts.

ETHICS/DISSEMINATION

An ethical approval was granted from the ethics committee of assisted reproductive medicine in Shanghai JiAi Genetics and IVF institute (JIAIE2020-03). A written informed consent will be obtained from each woman before any study procedure is performed, according to good clinical practice. The results of this randomised trial will be disseminated in a peer-reviewed journal.

TRIAL REGISTRATION NUMBER

NCT04414748.

The Association between Embryo Development and Chromosomal Results from PGT-A in Women of Advanced Age: A Prospective Cohort Study

Embryo morphology and morphokinetics have been studied for their association with euploid embryos. However, the results are controversial, especially in the advanced-aged women group, when the risk of aneuploidy increases significantly. This prospective cohort study evaluated the association between embryo development between day-3 cleavage and day-5 blastocyst stages and euploidy rates, determined using preimplantation genetic testing for aneuploidy (PGT-A). Embryos from women aged 35 years and above who underwent intracytoplasmic sperm injections and PGT-A were studied. Day-3 cleavage-stage embryos were evaluated for their cell number, and day-5 blastocyst-stage embryos were evaluated for their morphological grade. Embryo development from day 3 to day 5 was categorized as either good or poor development and evaluated for its association with the PGT-A results. We evaluated 325 embryos from 101 infertile couples. It was found that 55.17% of blastocysts with good development and 29.83% with poor development were euploid. A significant association was found between embryo development and euploidy rates in advanced-aged women (p < 0.001). Also, there were significantly higher rates of euploid embryos with good blastocyst morphological grades, especially blastocyst expansion grades and trophectoderm grades. In conclusion, embryo morphokinetics shows promising results in predicting euploidy in advanced female age.

Preimplantation genetic testing: A remarkable history of pioneering, technical challenges, innovations, and ethical considerations

Preimplantation genetic testing (PGT) has emerged as a powerful companion to assisted reproduction technologies. The origins and history of PGT are reviewed here, along with descriptions of advances in molecular assays and sampling methods, their capabilities, and their applications in preventing genetic diseases and enhancing pregnancy outcomes. Additionally, the potential for increasing accuracy and genome coverage is considered, as well as some of the emerging ethical and legislative considerations related to the expanding capabilities of PGT.