Contact force-sensing catheters: performance in an ex vivo porcine heart model

Characterization of high-power and very-high-power short-duration radiofrequency lesions performed with a new-generation catheter and a temperature-control ablation mode

INTRODUCTION

High-power short-duration (HPSD) has been proposed to shorten procedure times while maintaining efficacy and safety. We evaluated the differences in size and geometry between radiofrequency lesions obtained with this method and conventional ones.

METHODS AND RESULTS

Twenty-eight sets of 10 perpendicular radiofrequency applications were performed with two commercially available catheters: a temperature-controlled HPSD catheter (QDot-Micro) and a conventional power-controlled catheter (Thermocool SmartTouch) on porcine left ventricle. Different power settings (35, 40, 50, and 90 W), contact force (CF; 10 and 20 g), ablation index (AI; 400 and 550), and application times were combined to create conventional (35-40 W), HPSD (50 W) and very-high-power short-duration (VHPSD; 90 W) lesions, that were cross-sectioned and measured. About 4-s VHPSD lesions were smaller, shallower, and thinner than HPSD performed with the QDot-Micro catheter in any scenario of CF or AI (61 ± 7.8 mm³ , 6.1 ± 0.3 mm wide, and 2.9 ± 0.1 mm deep with 10 g; 72.2 ± 0.5 mm³ , 6.8 ± 0.3 mm wide, and 2.9 ± 0.2 mm deep with 20 g). Conventional and HPSD lesions performed with the temperature-controlled catheter were generally bigger, deeper, and wider than the ones obtained with the power-controlled catheter, as well as more consistent in size. This was especially true with the lower CF and AI scenario, while differences were less notable with other setting combinations.

CONCLUSION

VHPSD lesions performed with QDot-Micro catheter were smaller than any other lesions, which is especially attractive for posterior left atrial wall ablation. On the contrary, conventional-powered and HPSD lesions performed with this catheter were equally sized (or even bigger with lower CF and AI objectives), as well as more consistent in size, which would guarantee transmurality in other locations.

Effect of Baseline Impedance in Radiofrequency Delivery on Lesion Characteristics and the Relationship Between Impedance and Steam Pops

Objective

To explore the effects of baseline impedance (R) and power (P) on radiofrequency ablation (RFA) lesion characteristics and their correlation with steam pops using ThermoCool SmartTouch-SF (STSF) catheters in the porcine heart.

Method

A porcine left ventricle was submerged in 37°C saline ex vivo, and the experiment was performed with various P (P = 30, 40, 50, and 60 W) and multiple R loads (R = 80–100, 100–140, 140–180, and 180–220 Ω) to reach the target ablation index (AI; AI = 350, 450, and 500) or reach the target ablation time using a fixed contact force (CF; CF = 10–15 g) and the same saline irrigation (30 W/8 ml/min or 40–60 W/15 ml/min), repeated five times under each condition.

Results

The surface diameter, maximum diameter, depth, and volume of the lesions were strongly correlated with the AI (P = 40 W, R = 100–140 Ω, CF = 10–15 g) (r = 0.5412; r = 0.7889; r = 0.9366; and r = 0.913, respectively; all p < 0.05). As the value of R increased, the maximum diameter, depth, and volume of the lesions significantly increased (AI = 350, P = 30 W). Moreover, the higher the baseline value of R, the greater the absolute value of the R decrease (r = 0.9035, p < 0.05, Y = 0.2759 × X – 18.33). Under high power and high impedance, the occurrence rate of steam pops was high (P = 60 W, R = 180–220 Ω, AI when a steam pop occurred: 480 ± 26.5, ablation time: 11.29 ± 1.04 s).

Conclusion

Radiofrequency catheter ablation (RFCA) in power-controlled mode resulted in various lesion characteristics that were related to diverse baseline Rs. In addition, the incidence of steam pops was strongly correlated with high baseline R and high P.

Impact of power and contact force on index-guided radiofrequency lesions in an ex vivo porcine heart model

PURPOSE

Lesion size index (LSI) and ablation index (AI) are markers of lesion quality that incorporate power, contact force (CF) and time in a weighted formula to estimate lesion size. Although accurate predicting lesion depth in vitro, their precision in lesion size estimation has not been well established for certain power and CF settings. We conducted an experimental ex vivo study to analyse the effect of power and CF in size and morphology of ablation lesions in a porcine heart model.

METHODS

Twenty-four sets of 10 perpendicular epicardial radiofrequency applications were performed with two commercially available catheters (TactiCath, Sensor Enabled; and SmartTouch) on porcine left ventricle submerged in 37 °C saline, combining different power (25, 30, 35, 40, 50 and 60 W) and CF (10 and 20 g) settings, and aiming at a lower (LSI/AI of 5/400) or higher (LSI/AI of 6/550) index. After each application, lesions were cross-sectioned and measured.

RESULTS

Four hundred eighty lesions were performed. For a given target index and CF, significant differences in lesion volume and depth with different power were observed with both catheters, generally with smaller lesions using higher power. Lesions performed with CF of 10 g were particularly smaller with TactiCath compared to SmartTouch; lesions with CF of 20 g aiming a low LSI/AI were, however, bigger; lesions with CF of 20 g aiming a high LSI/AI were similar. In general, high-power lesions were wider and shallower than low-power lesions, especially with SmartTouch.

CONCLUSION

Size and morphology of index-guided radiofrequency lesions varied significantly with different power and CF settings.

Comparison of the lesion formation and safety in ex vivo porcine heart study: Using ThermoCool SmartTouch and ThermoCool SmartTouch-SF catheters

BACKGROUND

The study was performed to compare the efficacy and safety during radiofrequency ablation (RFA) using ThermoCool SmartTouch (ST) and ThermoCool SmartTouch-SF (STSF) catheters in the porcine heart.

METHODS AND RESULTS

RFA was performed on the porcine myocardium by using two irrigated ablation catheters. Three groups were divided based on the different contact forces (CFs): low contact force (LCF) (1-3 g), medium contact force (MCF) (5-10 g), and high contact force (HCF) (15-20 g). In each group, RFA was delivered at four power settings of 30, 40, 50, 60 W. At each power, RFA was applied to reach the target ablation index (AI) of 350, 450, and 500. Altogether, 360 RF lesions were created by using 72 ablation conditions. AI value was positively correlated with lesion size using ST and STSF catheters. At a fixed power, lesion dimensions significantly smaller in the LCF group, whereas did not differ between MCF and HCF groups. Furthermore, at a fixed CF, lesion dimensions increased with power set at 40 W compared with 30 W but decreased with high-power RF energy (50 and 60 W). Although the average lesion surface diameter and the maximum diameter was increased using the STSF catheter, there were no significant differences in LV between the two catheters. The steam pop provoked more frequently using ST catheter and showed a negative correlation with CF and positive correlation with high-power energy.

CONCLUSION

The STSF catheter is safer and equally effective in lesion formation compared with the ST catheter. LV was increased along with the early increase of CF and power, whereas a further increase of CF and power significantly reduces the lesion size.

Relationship of Catheter Contact Angle and Contact Force with Contact Area on the Surface of Heart Muscle Tissue in Cardiac Catheter Ablation

Purpose

The aims of this study were to develop an experimental procedure for setting the catheter angle with respect to the surface of the heart muscle and the catheter contact force and to investigate the catheter contact area on the heart muscle as a function of catheter contact angle and force.

Methods

Visualization tests were performed for 5 contact angles (0°, 30°, 45°, 60°, and 90°) and 8 contact forces (2, 4, 6, 10, 15, 20, 30, and 40 gf). Each experiment was repeated 6 times with 2 different commercially available catheter tips.

Results

The morphology of the contact area was classified into rectangular, circular, ellipsoidal, and semi-ellipsoidal. The correlation between contact force and contact area was a logarithmic function; increasing contact force was associated with increased contact area. At the same contact force, the correlation between contact angle and contact area was inverse; decreasing contact angle was associated with a corresponding increase in contact area.

Conclusion

Both the catheter contact angle and contact force substantially impact the contact area and morphology in catheter ablation procedures.

Computer simulation study on the effect of electrode-tissue contact force on thermal lesion size in cardiac radiofrequency ablation

Purpose: In cardiac radiofrequency (RF) ablation, RF energy is often used to create a series of transmural lesions for blocking accessory conduction pathways. Electrode-tissue contact force (CF) is one of the key determinants of lesion formation during RF ablation. Low electrode-tissue CF is associated with ineffective RF lesion formation, whereas excessive CF may increase the risk of steam pop and perforation. By using finite element analysis, we studied lesion size and features at different values of electrode-tissue CF in cardiac RF ablation.Materials and methods: A computer-model-coupled electrode-tissue CF field, RF electric field, and thermal field were developed to study temperature distribution and lesion dimensions in cardiac tissue subjected to CF of 2, 5, 10, 20, 30, and 40 g with identical RF voltage and duration.Results: Increasing CF was associated with an increase in lesion depth, width, and cross-section area. The lesion cross-section area exhibited a linear increase, and the lesion width was significantly greater than lesion depth under the identical ablation condition. The relationship between CF value and lesion size is a power function: Lesion Size = a × CF^b (Lesion Depth = 3.17 × CF^0.14 and Lesion Width = 5.17 × CF^0.14).Conclusions: This study confirmed that CF is a major determinant of RF lesion size and that electrode-tissue CF affects the amount of power dissipated in tissue. At a constant RF voltage and application time, RF lesion size increases as CF increases.

Impact of catheter-tissue contact force on lesion size during right ventricular outflow tract ablation in a swine model

Background

The catheter-tissue contact force (CF) is one of the significant determinants of lesion size and thus has a considerable impact on the effectiveness of ablation procedures. This study aimed to evaluate the impact of CF on the lesion size during right ventricular outflow tract (RVOT) ablation in a swine model.

Methods

Twelve Guangxi Bama miniature male pigs weighing 40 to 50 kg were studied. After general anesthesia, a ThermoCool SmartTouch contact-sensing ablation catheter was introduced to the RVOT via the femoral vein under the guidance of the CARTO 3 system. The local ventricular voltage amplitude and impedance were measured using different CF levels. We randomly divided the animals into the following four groups according to the different CF levels: group A (3–9 g); group B (10–19 g); group C (20–29 g); and group D (30–39 g). Radiofrequency ablations were performed at three points in the free wall and septum of the RVOT in power control mode at 30 W for 30 s while maintaining the saline irrigation rate at 17 mL/min. At the end of the procedures, the maximum depth, surface diameter, and lesion volume were measured and recorded. A linear regression analysis was performed to determine the relationship between continuous variables.

Results

A total of 72 ablation lesions were created in the RVOT of the 12 Bama pigs. The maximum depth, surface diameter, and volume of the lesions measured were well correlated with the CF (free wall: β = 0.105, β = 0.162, β = 3.355, respectively, P < 0.001; septum: β = 0.093, β = 0.150, β = 3.712, respectively, P < 0.001). The regional ventricular bipolar voltage amplitude, unipolar voltage amplitude, and impedance were weakly positively associated with the CF (β = 0.065, β = 0.125, and β = 1.054, respectively, P < 0.001). There was a significant difference in the incidence of steam pops among groups A, B, C, and D (free wall: F = 7.3, P = 0.032; septum: F = 10.5, P = 0.009); and steam pops occurred only when the CF exceeded 20 g. Trans-mural lesions were observed when the CF exceeded 10 g in the free wall, while the lesions in the septum were non-trans-mural even though the CF reached 30 g.

Conclusions

CF seems to be a leading predictive factor for the size of formed lesions in RVOT ablation. Maintaining the CF value between 3 and 10 g may be reasonable and effective for creating the necessary lesion size and reducing the risk of complications, such as steam pops and perforations.

Bipolar ablation's unique paradigm: Duration and power as respectively distinct primary determinants of transmurality and steam pop formation

Background

Bipolar radiofrequency (RF) ablation strategies are increasingly used, mainly to target deep myocardial reentrant circuits responsible for ventricular tachycardia that cannot be extinguished with traditional unipolar RF ablation. Because this strategy is novel, factors that affect lesion geometry and steam pop formation require further investigation.

Objective

To assess the effect of contact force, power, and time on the resulting lesion geometry and the risk of steam pop formation during bipolar RF ablation of thick myocardial tissue.

Methods

A custom ex vivo bipolar ablation model was used to assess lesion formation. A combination of parallel and perpendicular configurations of ablation catheters was used to create lesions by varying force (20g, 30g, or 40g), power (30 or 40 W), and time (20, 30, 45, or 60 seconds). Lesion dimensions and the incidence of steam pops were recorded and then analyzed with binary logistic regression and multiple linear regression.

Results

In bipolar ablation, lesion transmurality was most affected by the amount of time RF energy was applied. Durations longer than 20 seconds resulted in lesions deeper than half the tissue thickness. Steam pop formation was more frequent in thinner tissue, at longer ablation times, and at higher powers.

Conclusion

The parameters assessed in this ex vivo model could be used as guidelines for future in vivo work and clinical evaluation of interventricular septal bipolar ablation.