The Genetic Counselor in the Pediatric Arrhythmia Clinic: Review and Assessment of Services

The Prenatal Diagnosis and Perinatal Management of Congenital Long QT Syndrome: A Comprehensive Literature Review and Recent Updates

Congenital long QT syndrome (LQTS) is a group of heritable conditions that are associated with cardiac repolarization abnormalities characterized by QT prolongation on electrocardiogram and the risk of life-threatening arrhythmias. The prenatal detection of LQTS presents significant challenges for clinicians, and a multidisciplinary approach is required for optimal prenatal and postnatal management. In this comprehensive literature review, we describe strategies for the fetal diagnosis of LQTS with variable initial presentation, genetic testing in suspected fetal LQTS, the utility of fetal magnetocardiography as an additional diagnostic tool, prenatal management, and postnatal treatment. We focus on a multidisciplinary team approach including fetal cardiology, adult and pediatric electrophysiology, neonatology, maternal-fetal medicine, and genetic counselors, all playing vital roles in the comprehensive prenatal management and orchestration of postnatal treatment to optimize neonatal outcomes.

The impact of genetic counselor involvement in genetic and genomic test order review: A scoping review

PURPOSE

The increasing complexity of genetic technologies paired with more genetic tests being ordered by nongenetic health care providers, has resulted in an increase in the number of inappropriately ordered tests. Genetic counselors (GCs) are ideally suited to assess the appropriateness of a genetic test.

METHODS

We performed a scoping review of GC involvement in utilization management initiatives in order to describe the impact of having GCs involved in this process. Five databases (MEDLINE, EMBASE, CINHAL, EBM reviews, and Web of Science Core Collection) and gray literature were searched. We considered literature published in English since 2010.

RESULTS

A total of 51 studies were included. The most commonly evaluated outcomes included cancellation rate, economic efficiencies, impact on medical management, diagnostic rate, and time or triage efficiencies. Several studies also described GC impact on nongenetic health care providers.

CONCLUSION

Employment of GCs in the laboratory has been implemented widely as a solution to test misordering. These studies describe ways in which GCs can be integrated into testing workflows to reduce the number of inappropriate tests and have wider impacts on nongenetic health care providers' ordering practices and the patient experience.

Evaluating family-centred care at BC Children's Hospital: Healthcare providers' perspectives

BACKGROUND

Family-centred care (FCC) emphasizes a partnership approach to care between healthcare providers (HCPs), patients, and families. FCC provides significant benefits to both children and families; however, challenges exist in implementing FCC into practice. This study aimed to explore HCPs' FCC behaviours in multidisciplinary specialty clinics at a tertiary pediatric health care center in Canada.

METHODS

A demographic survey and the Measure of Processes of Care for Service Providers (MPOC-SP) questionnaire was administered to HCPs in five specialty clinics: orthopaedics, neurology, multi-organ transplant, immunology, and nephrology. Survey data were summarized using descriptive statistics. The association between possible predictor variables (ethnicity, gender, years in clinical practice) and MPOC-SP scores were analysed by analysis of variance (ANOVA) followed by post-hoc Tukey's test. Differences in scores across professional disciplines were analysed by multivariate analysis of variance (MANOVA) followed by ANOVA. Items rated lower (1-4 out of 7 by >33% of participants) were identified as potential areas for improvement.

RESULTS

HCPs (N = 77) from all five clinics rated the MPOC-SP domain 'Treating People Respectfully' the highest (mean 6.00 ± 0.59) and 'Providing General Information' the lowest (mean 4.56 ± 1.27). HCPs with 5-10 years of experience had higher scores across all domains compared to HCPs with <5 years and >10 years of experience. There were no significant differences in scores based on ethnicity, gender, and professional discipline. Items rated lower (1-4 out of 7 by >33% of participants) involved providing general information and emotional support to families.

CONCLUSIONS

Providing general information and emotional support to patients and families are areas for improvement for all specialty clinics surveyed. Given genetic counsellors (GCs) expertise in education and counselling, GC integration in these clinics is one way in which FCC can be improved. Our study also shows that years of work experience influences HCPs' capacity to provide FCC.

Mapping the use of cardiovascular genetic services in pediatric clinical care: challenges and opportunities for improvement

Purpose

Clinical genetic testing is increasingly integrated in managing and diagnosing cardiac conditions and disease. It is important to identify ongoing challenges. This study aimed to better understand how genetic testing is integrated into pediatric cardiac care and identify barriers and opportunities for improvement.

Methods

We conducted qualitative interviews with pediatric cardiology clinicians (N = 12). Following a journey mapping approach to data analysis, we described genetic testing workflow phases, participants' thoughts and behaviors within each phase, and barriers and opportunities for improvement.

Results

Participants described several challenges across the genetic testing workflow, from identifying patients for testing to disclosing results to the patients. Testing logistics, decision-making, and collaboration emerged as the most prominent challenges. Variation remains in the utilization of genetic testing, partially driven by case complexity and type of testing and attributable to other factors, like the level of interaction with genetics experts and inconsistent processes within the electronic medical record.

Conclusion

Clinical genetic pediatric cardiology requires more systematic integration of genetic testing and transparent processes. Major opportunities include the interplay between clinicians, genetic experts, and the EMR. Incorporating process mapping results into clinical logistics may eradicate some barriers experienced by pediatric cardiologists and increase clinical efficiency.

Becoming agents for genomic change: genetic counsellors' views of patient care and implementation influences when genomics is mainstreamed

Genetic counsellors (GCs) across the world are increasingly transitioning beyond clinical genetics services to meet the growing demands for genomic healthcare. This presents a unique opportunity for GCs to be 'genomic change agents' as they work in alternative models of care. Through various innovative models of mainstream care funded through a change program, we explored the views of GCs regarding their position as 'genomic change agents' and what may hinder or drive the success of their evolving roles. Guided by the Diffusion of Innovation Theory, we conducted qualitative interviews with all twelve GCs employed by the change program in different models of providing genomics across five specialties in Australia. Audio-recordings of all interviews were transcribed verbatim and analysed using inductive content analysis. Findings show that early in these new roles, participants held varied descriptions of 'genomics mainstreaming': some envisioned it as an end state exclusive to medical specialists practicing genomics while others saw the involvement of GCs as crucial. Participants believed they were uniquely positioned to expedite patient access to genomic testing and counselling and enhance medical specialists' capability to use genomics. Challenges included hesitancy of some medical specialists regarding the value of genomics in healthcare and potential tension arising from distinct perspectives and practice between genetic and non-genetic professionals. Participants anticipated a decline in the standard of care when non-genetic colleagues managed consent discussion and result disclosure. Our study underscores leadership support and peer connection with those in similar roles as essential elements for GCs' success in mainstream settings.

Implementing pharmacogenomic testing in Australian general practice: an exploratory qualitative study

Aim: To explore general practitioners' (GPs) views on implementing pharmacogenomic testing in Australian general practice.Methods: Semi-structured interviews were conducted with nine GPs in Australia, recruited from primary care networks. Interviews were analyzed using thematic analysis. Themes were mapped onto the Consolidated Framework for Implementation Research domains.Results: Barriers to implementation included lack of knowledge, education, standardized pharmacogenomic reports and national clinical guidelines and financial inaccessibility. Facilitators included positive exposure to pharmacogenomics, peer influences, interdisciplinary collaboration and proven clinical utility. Current uptake was minimal; however, GPs shared positive perceptions of clinical use.Conclusion: Recommendations for successful implementation include building and disseminating clinical evidence, developing national guidelines and standardized reports, incorporation into formal education and increasing financial accessibility.

Australian healthcare professionals' perspectives on genetic counseling and genetic diagnosis in vascular anomalies

Genomic technologies are now utilized for the genetic diagnosis of vascular anomalies. This provides the opportunity for genetic counselors to make a significant contribution to patient care for this complex disease. The aim of this study was to explore Australian healthcare professionals' perspectives on the relatively recent integration of molecular diagnostic testing for vascular anomalies, with or without genetic counseling support. Nine semi-structured interviews were conducted with Australian healthcare professionals involved in the provision of care for individuals with vascular anomalies. Thematic analysis identified six themes: (1) Molecular diagnosis is beneficial; (2) psychosocial needs can motivate families to pursue a molecular diagnosis; (3) molecular genetic testing for vascular anomalies is complex; (4) genetic service provision is not a one size fits all; (5) a client-centered approach for genetic service provision can go a long way; and (6) the value of genetic counselors. Based on our findings, implementation of a vascular anomalies genetic diagnostic program inclusive of genetic counseling may be challenging, yet such programs are likely to benefit both patients and their families, as well as healthcare professionals. As this paradigm shift unfolds, genetic counselors have an opportunity to contribute to the vascular anomaly field by educating healthcare professionals and patients, by participating in multidisciplinary clinics to support complex cases and by raising awareness regarding their practice and potential contributions.

The genetic counselor workforce in inherited retinal disease clinics: a descriptive assessment

BACKGROUND

Genetic counselors (GCs) have practiced in Inherited Retinal Disease (IRD) clinics for several decades. In this small subspecialty of genetic counseling, GCs are critical for patient understanding of genetic information, which can have prognostic, systemic, family planning and therapeutic implications. Recently, both access to genetic testing for IRDs and the number of genes associated with IRDs (>350) has increased dramatically. However, the practice models and roles of IRD GCs have not been previously described.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

GCs working in academic IRD clinics were surveyed to assess their experience, clinical practices, and roles performed. The collected data was compared to the broader genetic counseling profession and to other specialties using publicly available data on GC professional practices.

RESULTS

While roles of IRD GCs were overlapping with those of the overall genetic counseling profession, all survey respondents reported diverse roles that included both clinical and non-clinical duties, spending up to half their time on research and educational responsibilities. Most respondents (89%) felt that their clinic's MD to GC ratio was too high, while clinical load varied. IRD GCs report varying degrees of prior genetic counseling and ophthalmology-specific experience but unanimously desire additional subspecialty-specific training.

CONCLUSIONS

This descriptive assessment of a small subspecialty suggests a need for growth in the number of GCs practicing in IRD clinics and could help to inform development of new GC positions in IRD centers. It also highlights the desire for additional GC-specific education and may be relevant to curriculum development within GC programs.

The stepwise process of integrating a genetic counsellor into primary care

Genetic services have historically been housed in tertiary care, requiring referral, which can present access barriers. While integrating genetics into primary care could facilitate access, many primary care physicians lack genomics expertise. Integrating genetic counsellors (GCs) into primary care could theoretically address these issues, but little is known about how to do this effectively. To understand and describe the process of integrating a GC into a multidisciplinary primary care setting, we qualitatively explored the perceptions, attitudes and reactions of existing team members prior to, and after the introduction of a GC. Semi-structured interviews were conducted immediately prior to (T1), and 9 months after (T2), the GC joining the clinic. Interviews were recorded, transcribed verbatim and analyzed concurrently with data collection using interpretive description. Twenty-four interviews were conducted with 17 participants (13 at T1, 11 at T2). Participants described several distinct, progressive stages of interaction with the GC: Disinterest or Resistance, Pre-Collaboration, Initial Collaboration, and Effective Collaboration/Integration of the GC into the team. At each stage, specific needs had to be met in order to advance to the next stage of collaboration. A variety of barriers and facilitators attended movement between different stages of the model. The Stepwise Process of Integration Model describes the process through which primary care staff and clinicians integrate a GC into their practice. The insight provided by this model could be used to facilitate more effective integration of GCs into other primary care settings.

Clinical and genetic spectrum of neonatal arrhythmia in a NICU

BACKGROUND

Neonatal arrhythmia is a common complication that might be life-threatening or serious, but the genetic causes are unclear in most cases. The aim of this study is to investigate the genetic causes of neonatal arrhythmia in a NICU in China.

METHODS

Newborns who were diagnosed with arrhythmia during the neonatal period were enrolled from Children's Hospital of Fudan University between January 1st 2016, and December 31st, 2019. A neonatal gene panel was performed for each infant.

RESULTS

In total, 98 neonatal infants with arrhythmia were enrolled. Fourteen genes and a copy number change were identified and classified as pathogenic/likely pathogenic in 22 patients (22.4%), including 4 genes related to syndrome, 4 related to conduction, 2 related to metabolism, 2 related to structure, 2 related to respiration and immunity, respectively, and trisomy 21. Altogether, 6 genes (6/14, 42.9%) caused original heart structure or conduction abnormalities, leading to arrhythmia. Infants with ventricular tachycardia or fibrillation, atrioventricular block and long-QT syndrome all had positive gene results. The gene positive rate among arrhythmic infants with congenital heart disease or severe heart failure was higher than that of infants without congenital heart disease or severe heart failure.

CONCLUSIONS

The genetic disorders associated with neonatal arrhythmia could be syndrome-, conduction-, metabolism-, and structure-related. Infants with non-benign arrhythmia, especially ventricular tachycardia or fibrillation, long-QT syndrome, or high-grade atrioventricular block, have a higher rate of genetic abnormalities and should undergo genetic sequencing. Neonates with hereditary arrhythmias may have a higher risk of congenital heart disease or heart failure.

U.S. Genetic counselors' perceptions of inpatient genetic counseling: A valuable model for medically complex patients

Some genetic counselors (GCs) provide care in the inpatient setting. However, there is little literature on inpatient genetic counseling. The purpose of our study was to describe GC's experiences with the provision of genetic counseling services within inpatient care settings. Participants were recruited from respondents to a quantitative survey study on inpatient genetic counseling, which recruited GCs via the National Society of Genetic Counselors forum. GCs seeing at least five inpatients per year were invited to participate in semi-structured interviews. The interview guide explored how and why their inpatient genetic counseling service started, workflow, and the perceived impact of the service. Interviews were transcribed, inductive analysis was used to develop a codebook, and thematic analysis was used to identify themes. Twenty-one inpatient genetic counselors participated in the study. Many participants worked primarily in outpatient roles with some inpatient duties (61.9%), while the rest worked primarily in inpatient roles (38.1%). Most participants have provided inpatient care for <2 years (66.7%). Many participants were involved in inpatient care across multiple specialties (66.7%), most frequently, pediatrics, neonatology, and neurology. Three themes were identified: (a) The convenience of inpatient genetic counseling leads to increased access to appropriate genetics care for medically complex patients and their inpatient healthcare providers, (b) the inpatient genetic counseling process and workflow is not standard and has multiple moving parts, and (c) genetic counselors are fulfilled by the diverse and unique opportunities of the inpatient care setting despite the emotional intensity of this environment. Participants described their inpatient care as valuable because it increases access to genetics services and adds genetics expertise to multidisciplinary inpatient teams. Overall, participants perceive inpatient genetic counseling as a way to bring genetics care directly to patients at a critical time point in their care, which benefits medically complex patients and their multidisciplinary inpatient team.

Bridging the Gap between Scientific Advancement and Real-World Application: Pediatric Genetic Counseling for Common Syndromes and Single-Gene Disorders

Screening and diagnostic testing for single-gene disorders and common syndromes in the pediatric setting frequently generate data that are challenging to interpret, and the ability to diagnose genetic conditions has outpaced the development of successful treatments or cures. Genetic testing is now integrated purposefully into a variety of primary and specialty care clinics, creating an increased requirement for genetic literacy among providers and patients, as well as a growing need to incorporate genetic counseling services into mainstream clinical practice. The practice of pediatric genetic counseling encompasses a unique combination of skills and training designed to address the evolving psychological, social, educational, medical, and reproductive concerns of patients and their families, which complements the multidisciplinary services of physicians, nurses, and other allied health professionals caring for patients with pediatric-onset genetic conditions. The potential range of genetic counseling needs in the pediatric setting transcends the diagnostic period. The sustained nature of pediatric care presents opportunities for development of trusting and longstanding professional relationships that permit the evolving genetic counseling needs of patients and families to be met. A discussion of cystic fibrosis, a common autosomal recessive single-gene disorder with an increasingly broad clinical spectrum and genotype-phenotype variability, serves as a useful case study to illustrate the current and emerging genetic counseling practices, goals, and challenges impacting patients and their families.

The composition and capacity of the clinical genetics workforce in high-income countries: a scoping review

As genetics becomes increasingly integrated into all areas of health care and the use of complex genetic tests continues to grow, the clinical genetics workforce will likely face greatly increased demand for its services. To inform strategic planning by health-care systems to prepare to meet this future demand, we performed a scoping review of the genetics workforce in high-income countries, summarizing all available evidence on its composition and capacity published between 2010 and 2019. Five databases (MEDLINE, Embase, PAIS, CINAHL, and Web of Science) and gray literature sources were searched, resulting in 162 unique studies being included in the review. The evidence presented includes the composition and size of the workforce, the scope of practice for genetics and nongenetics specialists, the time required to perform genetics-related tasks, case loads of genetics providers, and opportunities to increase efficiency and capacity. Our results indicate that there is currently a shortage of genetics providers and that there is a lack of consensus about the appropriate boundaries between the scopes of practice for genetics and nongenetics providers. Moreover, the results point to strategies that may be used to increase productivity and efficiency, including alternative service delivery models, streamlining processes, and the automation of tasks.

Changes in genetic variant results over time in pediatric cardiomyopathy and electrophysiology

Genetic testing for cardiac disorders continues to change. Our objective was to assess trends in variant classification in pediatric arrhythmia and cardiomyopathy. We conducted a retrospective review of patients tested for genetic arrhythmia and cardiomyopathy disorders from 2006-2017. Variants were classified by CLIA laboratories. Trends were assessed by the Spearman correlation. There were 914 variants in 583 patients from 337 families. The total number of tests ordered increased over time, accelerating after 2012. There was a strong positive correlation between the average number of genes tested per panel and year of testing (r = .97, p < .001) and a weak correlation between the year and a decrease in the percentage of clinically actionable variants (r = -.20, p = .005). By 2011, VUS represented >50% of variants reported on panels. Over 12 years, 203 genes were interrogated; one or more variants were reported in 91 of 203 genes (45%). 32% of patients had at least one clinically actionable variant; 28% had at least one VUS. Reclassification is an important long-term issue, with 21.5% variants changing clinical interpretation. We observed an increase over time in three areas: total number of tests ordered, average number of genes/panel, and percentage of VUS. Providers may need to interpret results from 90 + genes, and ongoing education is critical. Due to their specific training in test result interpretation, we recommend the inclusion of a genetic counselor in pediatric electrophysiology and cardiomyopathy teams.

Support, information, and integration of genetics for children with congenital lower limb deficiencies in British Columbia, Canada

Objectives

Children and families affected by congenital limb deficiencies (CLD) require a unique level of emotional support from diagnosis through to adolescence. The following study aims to collect data on Canadian paediatric patients affected by a CLD followed at BC Children's Hospital (BCCH), Department of Orthopaedics.

Methods

Parents of children with a CLD were asked to complete a written questionnaire examining their experiences. Qualitative and quantitative data were collected concerning parent satisfaction with patient referrals, emotional support, and knowledge of their child's diagnosis.

Results

Twenty-five completed questionnaires were returned. Fifty per cent of the parents reported they were either very satisfied, or satisfied, with the emotional support provided by health care providers (HCPs). Twenty-five per cent of the parents were unsatisfied with the emotional support received by HCPs. Forty-eight per cent of the parents could not recall the specific name of their child's diagnosis; 20% of the parents reported their child did not have diagnosis. All the patients in our study had received a clinical diagnosis. Twenty-eight per cent of the parents in this study were also seen in medical genetics.

Conclusions

Families require additional resources for emotional support, peer support, and referrals to support organizations. Gaps in parent knowledge regarding their child's CLD suggest the need for formalized communication strategies for HCPs. Furthermore, patients with CLDs and their families may benefit from improved communication between orthopaedic and medical genetic services at the time of diagnosis. Integration of genetic counsellors may improve emotional supports and education for families with regards to testing and reproductive planning.