Reliability of the Parabola Approximation Method in Heart Rate Variability Analysis Using Low-Sampling-Rate Photoplethysmography

A Hybrid Photoplethysmography (PPG) Sensor System Design for Heart Rate Monitoring

A photoplethysmography (PPG) sensor is a cost-effective and efficacious way of measuring health conditions such as heart rate, oxygen saturation, and respiration rate. In this work, we present a hybrid PPG sensor system working in a reflective mode with an optoelectronic module, i.e., the combination of an inorganic light-emitting diode (LED) and a circular-shaped organic photodetector (OPD) surrounding the LED for efficient light harvest followed by the proper driving circuit for accurate PPG signal acquisition. The performance of the hybrid sensor system was confirmed by the heart rate detection process from the PPG using fast Fourier transform analysis. The PPG signal obtained with a 50% LED duty cycle and 250 Hz sampling rate resulted in accurate heart rate monitoring with an acceptable range of error. The effects of the LED duty cycle and the LED luminous intensity were found to be crucial to the heart rate accuracy and to the power consumption, i.e., indispensable factors for the hybrid sensor.

Effects of using different algorithms and fiducial points for the detection of interbeat intervals, and different sampling rates on the assessment of pulse rate variability from photoplethysmography

OBJECTIVE

Pulse Rate Variability (PRV) has been widely used as a surrogate of Heart Rate Variability (HRV). However, there are several technical aspects that may affect the extraction of PRV information from pulse wave signals such as the photoplethysmogram (PPG). The aim of this study was to evaluate the effects of changing the algorithm and fiducial points used for determining inter-beat intervals (IBIs), as well as the PPG sampling rate, from simulated PPG signals with known PRV content.

METHODS

PPG signals were simulated using a proposed model, in which PRV information can be modelled. Two independent experiments were performed. First, 5 IBIs detection algorithms and 8 fiducial points were used for assessing PRV information from the simulated PPG signals, and time-domain and Poincaré plot indices were extracted and compared to the expected values according to the simulated PRV. The best combination of algorithms and fiducial points were determined for each index, using factorial designs. Then, using one of the best combinations, PPG signals were simulated with varying sampling rates. PRV indices were extracted and compared to the expected values using Student t-tests or Mann-Whitney U-tests.

RESULTS

From the first experiment, it was observed that AVNN and SD2 indices behaved similarly, and there was no significant influence of the fiducial points used. For other indices, there were several combinations that behaved similarly well, mostly based on the detection of the valleys of the PPG signal. There were differences according to the quality of the PPG signal. From the second experiment, it was observed that, for all indices but SDNN, the higher the sampling rate the better. AVNN and SD2 showed no statistical differences even at the lowest evaluated sampling rate (32 Hz), while RMSSD, pNN50, S, SD1 and SD1/SD2 showed good performance at sampling rates as low as 128 Hz.

CONCLUSION

The best combination of IBIs detection algorithms and fiducial points differs according to the application, but those based on the detection of the valleys of the PPG signal tend to show a better performance. The sampling rate of PPG signals for PRV analysis could be lowered to around 128 Hz, although it could be further lowered according to the application.

SIGNIFICANCE

The standardisation of PRV analysis could increase the reliability of this signal and allow for the comparison of results obtained from different studies. The obtained results allow for a first approach to establish guidelines for two important aspects in PRV analysis from PPG signals, i.e. the way the IBIs are segmented from PPG signals, and the sampling rate that should be used for these analyses. Moreover, a model for simulating PPG signals with PRV information has been proposed, which allows for the establishing of these guidelines while controlling for other variables, such as the quality of the PPG signal.

Information Retrieval from Photoplethysmographic Sensors: A Comprehensive Comparison of Practical Interpolation and Breath-Extraction Techniques at Different Sampling Rates

The increasingly widespread diffusion of wearable devices makes possible the continuous monitoring of vital signs, such as heart rate (HR), heart rate variability (HRV), and breath signal. However, these devices usually do not record the “gold-standard” signals, namely the electrocardiography (ECG) and respiratory activity, but a single photoplethysmographic (PPG) signal, which can be exploited to estimate HR and respiratory activity. In addition, these devices employ low sampling rates to limit power consumption. Hence, proper methods should be adopted to compensate for the resulting increased discretization error, while diverse breath-extraction algorithms may be differently sensitive to PPG sampling rate. Here, we assessed the efficacy of parabola interpolation, cubic-spline, and linear regression methods to improve the accuracy of the inter-beat intervals (IBIs) extracted from PPG sampled at decreasing rates from 64 to 8 Hz. PPG-derived IBIs and HRV indices were compared with those extracted from a standard ECG. In addition, breath signals extracted from PPG using three different techniques were compared with the gold-standard signal from a thoracic belt. Signals were recorded from eight healthy volunteers during an experimental protocol comprising sitting and standing postures and a controlled respiration task. Parabola and cubic-spline interpolation significantly increased IBIs accuracy at 32, 16, and 8 Hz sampling rates. Concerning breath signal extraction, the method holding higher accuracy was based on PPG bandpass filtering. Our results support the efficacy of parabola and spline interpolations to improve the accuracy of the IBIs obtained from low-sampling rate PPG signals, and also indicate a robust method for breath signal extraction.

Effectiveness of the heartbeat interval error and compensation method on heart rate variability analysis

The purpose of this study is to evaluate the effectiveness of heartbeat error and compensation methods on heart rate variability (HRV) with mobile and wearable sensor devices. The HRV analysis extracts multiple indices related to the heart and autonomic nervous system from beat-to-beat intervals. These HRV analysis indices are affected by the heartbeat interval mismatch, which is caused by sampling error from measurement hardware and inherent errors from the state of human body. Although the sampling rate reduction is a common method to reduce power consumption on wearable devices, it degrades the accuracy of the heartbeat interval. Furthermore, wearable devices often use photoplethysmography (PPG) instead of electrocardiogram (ECG) to measure heart rate. However, there are inherent errors between PPG and ECG, because the PPG is affected by blood pressure fluctuations, vascular stiffness, and body movements. This paper evaluates the impact of these errors on HRV analysis using dataset including both ECG and PPG from 28 subjects. The evaluation results showed that the error compensation method improved the accuracy of HRV analysis in time domain, frequency domain and non-linear analysis. Furthermore, the error compensation by the algorithm was found to be effective for both PPG and ECG.

Enhancing the Robustness of Smartphone Photoplethysmography: A Signal Quality Index Approach

Heart rate variability (HRV) provides essential health information such as the risks of heart attacks and mental disorders. However, inconvenience related to the accurate detection of HRV limits its potential applications. The ubiquitous use of smartphones makes them an excellent choice for regular and portable health monitoring. Following this trend, smartphone photoplethysmography (PPG) has recently garnered prominence; however, the lack of robustness has prevented both researchers and practitioners from embracing this technology. This study aimed to bridge the gap in the literature by developing a novel smartphone PPG quality index (SPQI) that can filter corrupted data. A total of 226 participants joined the study, and results from 1343 samples were used to validate the proposed sinusoidal function-based model. In both the correlation coefficient and Bland-Altman analyses, the agreement between HRV measurements generated by both the smartphone PPG and the reference electrocardiogram improved when data were filtered through the SPQI. Our results support not only the proposed approach but also the general value of using smartphone PPG in HRV analysis.