Integrated In Silico-In Vitro Identification and Optimization of Bone Morphogenic Protein-2 Armpit Epitope as Its Antagonist Binding Site

Structural Mapping of BMP Conformational Epitopes and Bioengineering Design of Osteogenic Peptides to Specifically Target the Epitope-Binding Sites

Introduction

Human bone morphogenetic proteins (BMPs) constitute a large family of cytokines related to members of the transforming growth factor-β superfamily, which fulfill biological functions by specificity binding to their cognate type I (BRI) and type II (BRII) receptors through conformational wrist and linear knuckle epitopes, respectively.

Methods and Results

We systematically examined the intermolecular recognition and interaction between the BMP proteins and BRI receptor at structural, energetic and dynamic levels. The BRI-binding site consists of three hotspot regions on BMP surface, which totally contribute ~70% potency to the BMP-BRI binding events and represent the core sections of BMP conformational wrist epitope; the contribution increases in the order: hotspot 2 (~ 8%) < hotspot 3 (~ 20%) < hotspot 1 (~ 40%). Multiple sequence alignment and structural superposition revealed a consensus sequence pattern and a similar binding mode of the three hotspots shared by most BMP members, indicating a high conservation of wrist epitope in BMP family. The three hotspots are natively folded into wellstructured U-shaped,, loop and double-stranded conformations in BMP proteins, which, however, would become largely disordered when splitting from the protein context to derive osteogenic peptides in free state, thus largely impairing their rebinding capability to BRI receptor. In this respect, cyclization strategy was employed to constrain hotspot 1/3-derived peptides into a native-like conformation, which was conducted by adding a disulfide bond across the ending arms of linear peptides based on their native conformations. Fluorescence-based assays substantiated that the cyclization can effectively improve the binding affinities of osteogenic peptides to BRI receptor by 3-6-fold. The cyclic peptides also exhibit a good selectivity for BRI over BRII (> 5-fold), confirming that they can specifically target the wrist epitope-binding site of BRI receptor.

Conclusion

The rationally designed cyclic peptides can be regarded as the promising lead entities that should be further chemically modified to enhance their in vivo biological stability for further bioengineering therapeutic osteogenic peptides against chondrocyte senescence and bone disorder.

Structural definition of the discrete hotspot sites of BMP-2 conformational wrist epitope and rational design of the hotspot-derived osteogenic peptides against chondrocyte senescence

The bone morphogenetic protein-2 (BMP-2) is an essential regulator of bone formation and remodeling, which has also been implicated in the pathogenesis of osteoarthritis and its closely related chondrocyte senescence. The BMP-2 uses a conformational wrist epitope and a linear knuckle epitope to interact with type-I (BMPR-I) and type-II (BMPR-II) receptors, respectively. Previously, the knuckle epitope has been intensely studied, but the wrist epitope still remains largely unexplored due to its discontinuous nature. In the present work, the intermolecular interaction of BMP-2 with BMPR-I was investigated systematically at structural, energetic and dynamic levels. Three discrete hotspots that represent the key BMPR-I recognition sites of BMP-2 were identified; they are spatially dispersed over the two monomers of BMP-2 dimer and totally account for 83.5 % binding potency of BMP-2 to BMPR-I (hotspot 1: residues 49-70 in monomer 1; hotspot 2: residues 24-31 in monomer 2; hotspot 3: residues 88-107 in monomer 2). Therefore, we defined the three discrete hotspot sites as the core region of wrist epitope; their contribution to the binding increases in the order: hotspot 2 < hotspot 3 < hotspot 1. We demonstrated that the primary hotspot 1 site has a native U-shaped conformation in the full-length BMP-2 protein context, but it cannot maintain in the native conformation when split from the context to obtain a free hotspot-1 peptide, thus largely impairing its binding potency to BMPR-I. We further employed disulfide-bonded cyclization and head-to-tail cyclization to constrain the peptide conformation, and found that only the former can effectively constrain the peptide into native conformation, thus considerably improving its binding affinity to BMPR-I, whereas the latter totally disorders the native conformation, thus rendering the peptide as a full nonbinder of BMPR-I.

Revisiting bone morphogenetic protein-2 knuckle epitope and redesigning the epitope-derived peptides

The bone morphogenetic protein-2 (BMP2) plays a crucial role in bone formation, growth and regeneration, which adopts a conformational wrist epitope and a linear knuckle epitope to interact with its type-I (BRI) and type-II (BRII) receptors, respectively. In this study, we systematically examine the BRII-recognition site of BMP2 at structural, energetic and dynamic levels and accurately locate hotspots of the recognition at BMP2-BRII complex interface. It is revealed that the traditional knuckle epitope (BMP2 residue range 73-92) do fully match the identified hotspots; the BMP2-recognition site includes the C-terminal region of traditional knuckle epitope as well as its flanked β-strands. In addition, the protein context of full-length BMP2 is also responsible for the recognition by addressing conformational constraint on the native epitope segment. Therefore, we herein redefine the knuckle epitope to BMP2 residue range 84-102, which has a similar sequence length but is slid along the protein sequence by ~10 residues as compared to traditional knuckle epitope. The redefined one is also a linear epitope that is natively a double-stranded β-sheet with two asymmetric arms as compared to the natively single β-strand of the traditional version, although their sequences are partially overlapped to each other. It is revealed that the redefined epitope-derived peptide LN^84-102 exhibits an improved affinity by >3-fold relative to the traditional epitope-derived peptide KL^73-92 . Even so, the LN^84-102 peptide still cannot fully represent the BMP2 recognition event by BRII that has been reported to have a nanomolar affinity. We further introduce a disulfide bond across the two arms of double-stranded β-sheet to constrain the free LN^84-102 peptide conformation, which mimics the conformational constraint addressed by protein context. Consequently, several cyclic peptides are redesigned, in which the LN^84-102 (cyc89-101) is determined to exhibit a sub-micromolar affinity; this value is ~5-fold higher than its linear counterpart. Structural analysis also reveals that the cyclic peptide can interact with BRII in a similar binding mode with the redefined knuckle epitope region in full-length BMP2 protein.