Photosystem II antennae are not energetically connected: evidence based on flash-induced O2 evolution and chlorophyll fluorescence in sunflower leaves

Excitation transfer and quenching in photosystem II, enlightened by carotenoid triplet state in leaves

Accumulation of carotenoid (Car) triplet states was investigated by singlet-triplet annihilation, measured as chlorophyll (Chl) fluorescence quenching in sunflower and lettuce leaves. The leaves were illuminated by Xe flashes of 4 μs length at half-height and 525-565 or 410-490 nm spectral band, maximum intensity 2 mol quanta m-2 s-1, flash photon dose up to 10 μmol m-2 or 4-10 PSII excitations. Superimposed upon the non-photochemically unquenched Fmd state, fluorescence was strongly quenched near the flash maximum (minimum yield Fe), but returned to the Fmd level after 30-50 μs. The fraction of PSII containing a 3Car in equilibrium with singlet excitation was calculated as Te = (Fmd-Fe)/Fmd. Light dependence of Te was a rectangular hyperbola, whose initial slope and plateau were determined by the quantum yields of triplet formation and annihilation and by the triplet lifetime. The intrinsic lifetime was 9 μs, but it was strongly shortened by the presence of O2. The triplet yield was 0.66 without nonphotochemical quenching (NPQ) but approached zero when NP-Quenched fluorescence approached 0.2 Fmd. The results show that in the Fmd state a light-adapted charge-separated PSIIL state is formed (Sipka et al., The Plant Cell 33:1286-1302, 2021) in which Pheo-P680+ radical pair formation is hindered, and excitation is terminated in the antenna by 3Car formation. The results confirm that there is no excitonic connectivity between PSII units. In the PSIIL state each PSII is individually turned into the NPQ state, where excess excitation is quenched in the antenna without 3Car formation.

The Fitting of the OJ Phase of Chlorophyll Fluorescence Induction Based on an Analytical Solution and Its Application in Urban Heat Island Research

Chlorophyll (Chl) fluorescence induction (FI) upon a dark-light transition has been widely analyzed to derive information on initial events of energy conversion and electron transfer in photosystem II (PSII). However, currently, there is no analytical solution to the differential equation of QA reduction kinetics, raising a doubt about the fitting of FI by numerical iteration solution. We derived an analytical solution to fit the OJ phase of FI, thereby yielding estimates of three parameters: the functional absorption cross-section of PSII (σPSII), a probability parameter that describes the connectivity among PSII complexes (p), and the rate coefficient for QA- oxidation (kox). We found that σPSII, p, and kox exhibited dynamic changes during the transition from O to J. We postulated that in high excitation light, some other energy dissipation pathways may vastly outcompete against excitation energy transfer from a closed PSII trap to an open PSII, thereby giving the impression that connectivity seemingly does not exist. We also conducted a case study on the urban heat island effect on the heat stability of PSII using our method and showed that higher-temperature-acclimated leaves had a greater σPSII, lower kox, and a tendency of lower p towards more shade-type characteristics.

Prying into the green black-box

Life-long efforts of the Tartu photosynthesis research group have been summarized. The measurements were facilitated by self-designed instruments, distinct in multifunctionality and fastresponse time. The black-box type kinetical analysis on intact leaves has revealed several physiologically significant features of leaf photosynthesis. Rubisco studies reflected competition for the active site between the substrates and products, linearizing in vivo kinetics compared with the low-K_m in vitro responses. Rubisco Activase usually activates only a small part of the Rubisco, making the rest of it a storage protein. Precisely quantifying absorbed photons and the responding transmittance changes, electron flow rates through cytochrome b₆f, plastocyanin and photosystem I were measured, revealing competition between the proton-uncoupled cyclic electron flow from PSI to Cyt b₆f to P700⁺ and the proton-coupled linear flow from PSII to Cyt b₆f to P700⁺. Analyzing responses of O₂ evolution and Chl fluorescence to ms-length light pulses we concluded that explanation of the sigmoidal fluorescence induction by excitonic connectivity between PSII units is a misconception. Each PSII processes excitation from its own antenna, but the sigmoidicity is caused by rise of the fluorescence yield of the Q_A-reduced PSII units after their Q_B site becomes occupied by reduced plastoquinone (or diuron). Unlike respiration, photosynthetic electrons must prepare their acceptor by coupled synthesis of 3ATP/4e^-. Feedback regulation of this ratio leads to oscillations under saturating light and CO₂, when the rate is P_i-limited. The slow oscillations (period 60s) indicate that the magnitudes of the deflections in the 3ATP/4e^- ratio, corrected by regulating cyclic and alternative electron flow (including the Mehler type O₂ reduction), are only a fraction of a per cent. The P_i limitation causes slip in the ATP synthase, slightly increasing the basic 12H⁺/3ATP requirement.

Inhibition of non-photochemical quenching increases functional absorption cross-section of photosystem II as excitation from closed reaction centres is transferred to open centres, facilitating earlier light saturation of photosynthetic electron transport

Induction of non-photochemical quenching (NPQ) of chlorophyll fluorescence in leaves affords photoprotection to the photosynthetic apparatus when, for whatever reason, photon capture in the antennae of photosystems exceeds their capacity to utilise this excitation in photochemistry and ultimately in CO2 assimilation. Here we augment traditional monitoring of NPQ using the fast time resolution, remote and relatively non-intrusive light induced fluorescence transient (LIFT) technique (Kolber et al . 2005 ; Osmond et al . 2017 ) that allows direct measurement of functional (σ'PSII ) and optical cross-sections (a 'PSII ) of PSII in situ , and calculates the half saturation light intensity for ETR (E k ). These parameters are obtained from the saturation and relaxation phases of fluorescence transients elicited by a sequence of 270, high intensity 1 μs flashlets at controlled time intervals over a period of 30 ms in the QA flash at intervals of a few seconds. We report that although σ'PSII undergoes large transient increases after transfer from dark to strong white light (WL) it declines little in steady-state as NPQ is induced in shade- and sun-grown spinach and Arabidopsis genotypes Col , OEpsbs , pgr 5bkg , stn 7 and stn 7/8. In contrast, σ'PSII increases by ~30% when induction of NPQ in spinach is inhibited by dithiothreitol and by inhibition of NPQ in Arabidopsis npq 1, npq 4 and pgr 5. We propose this increase in σ'PSII arises as some excitation from closed PSII reaction centres is transferred to open centres when excitation partitioning to photochemistry (Y II ) and NPQ (Y NP ) declines, and is indicated by an increased excitation dissipation from closed PSII centres (Y NO , including fluorescence emission). Although E k increases following dissipation of excitation as heat when NPQ is engaged, it declines when NPQ is inhibited. Evidently photochemistry becomes more easily light saturated when excitation is transferred from closed RCIIs to open centres with larger σ'PSII . The NPQ mutant pgr 5 is an exception; E k increases markedly in strong light as electron transport QA → PQ and PQ → PSI accelerate and the PQ pool becomes strongly reduced. These novel in situ observations are discussed in the context of contemporary evidence for functional and structural changes in the photosynthetic apparatus during induction of NPQ.

Time- and reduction-dependent rise of photosystem II fluorescence during microseconds-long inductions in leaves

Lettuce (Lactuca sativa) and benth (Nicotiana benthamiana) leaves were illuminated with 720 nm background light to mix S-states and oxidize electron carriers. Green-filtered xenon flashes of different photon dose were applied and O2 evolution induced by a flash was measured. After light intensity gradient across the leaf was mathematically considered, the flash-induced PSII electron transport (= 4·O2 evolution) exponentially increased with the flash photon dose in any differential layer of the leaf optical density. This proved the absence of excitonic connectivity between PSII units. Time courses of flash light intensity and 680 nm chlorophyll fluorescence emission were recorded. While with connected PSII the sigmoidal fluorescence rise has been explained by quenching of excitation in closed PSII by its open neighbors, in the absence of connectivity the sigmoidicity indicates gradual rise of the fluorescence yield of an individual closed PSII during the induction. Two phases were discerned: the specific fluorescence yield immediately increased from Fo to 1.8Fo in a PSII, whose reaction center became closed; fluorescence yield of the closed PSII was keeping time-dependent rise from 1.8Fo to about 3Fo, approaching the flash fluorescence yield Ff = 0.6Fm during 40 μs. The time-dependent fluorescence rise was resolved from the quenching by 3Car triplets and related to protein conformational change. We suggest that QA reduction induces a conformational change, which by energetic or structural means closes the gate for excitation entrance into the central radical pair trap-efficiently when QB cannot accept the electron, but less efficiently when it can.

Phenomic and Physiological Analysis of Salinity Effects on Lettuce

Salinity is a rising concern in many lettuce-growing regions. Lettuce (Lactuca sativa L.) is sensitive to salinity, which reduces plant biomass, and causes leaf burn and early senescence. We sought to identify physiological traits important in salt tolerance that allows lettuce adaptation to high salinity while maintaining its productivity. Based on previous salinity tolerance studies, one sensitive and one tolerant genotype each was selected from crisphead, butterhead, and romaine, as well as leaf types of cultivated lettuce and its wild relative, L. serriola L. Physiological parameters were measured four weeks after transplanting two-day old seedlings into 350 mL volume pots filled with sand, hydrated with Hoagland nutrient solution and grown in a growth chamber. Salinity treatment consisted of gradually increasing concentrations of NaCl and CaCl2 from 0 mM/0 mM at the time of transplanting, to 30 mM/15 mM at the beginning of week three, and maintaining it until harvest. Across the 10 genotypes, leaf area and fresh weight decreased 0-64% and 16-67%, respectively, under salinity compared to the control. Salinity stress increased the chlorophyll index by 4-26% in the cultivated genotypes, while decreasing it by 5-14% in the two wild accessions. Tolerant lines less affected by elevated salinity were characterized by high values of the chlorophyll fluorescence parameters Fv/Fm and instantaneous photosystem II quantum yield (QY), and lower leaf transpiration.

Frequently asked questions about chlorophyll fluorescence, the sequel

Using chlorophyll (Chl) a fluorescence many aspects of the photosynthetic apparatus can be studied, both in vitro and, noninvasively, in vivo. Complementary techniques can help to interpret changes in the Chl a fluorescence kinetics. Kalaji et al. (Photosynth Res 122:121-158, 2014a) addressed several questions about instruments, methods and applications based on Chl a fluorescence. Here, additional Chl a fluorescence-related topics are discussed again in a question and answer format. Examples are the effect of connectivity on photochemical quenching, the correction of F V /F M values for PSI fluorescence, the energy partitioning concept, the interpretation of the complementary area, probing the donor side of PSII, the assignment of bands of 77 K fluorescence emission spectra to fluorescence emitters, the relationship between prompt and delayed fluorescence, potential problems when sampling tree canopies, the use of fluorescence parameters in QTL studies, the use of Chl a fluorescence in biosensor applications and the application of neural network approaches for the analysis of fluorescence measurements. The answers draw on knowledge from different Chl a fluorescence analysis domains, yielding in several cases new insights.

Oxidation of plastohydroquinone by photosystem II and by dioxygen in leaves

In sunflower leaves linear electron flow LEF=4O2 evolution rate was measured at 20 ppm O2 in N2. PSII charge separation rate CSRII=aII∙PAD∙(Fm-F)/Fm, where aII is excitation partitioning to PSII, PAD is photon absorption density, Fm and F are maximum and actual fluorescence yields. Under 630 nm LED+720 nm far-red light (FRL), LEF was equal to CSRII with aII=0.51 to 0.58. After FRL was turned off, plastoquinol (PQH2) accumulated, but LEF decreased more than accountable by F increase, indicating PQH2-oxidizing cyclic electron flow in PSII (CEFII). CEFII was faster under conditions requiring more ATP, consistent with CEFII being coupled with proton translocation. We propose that PQH2 bound to the QC site is oxidized, one e- moving to P680+, the other e- to Cyt b559. From Cyt b559 the e- reduces QB- at the QB site, forming PQH2. About 10-15% electrons may cycle, causing misses in the period-4 flash O2 evolution and lower quantum yield of photosynthesis under stress. We also measured concentration dependence of PQH2 oxidation by dioxygen, as indicated by post-illumination decrease of Chl fluorescence yield. After light was turned off, F rapidly decreased from Fm to 0.2 Fv, but further decrease to F0 was slow and O2 concentration dependent. The rate constant of PQH2 oxidation, determined from this slow phase, was 0.054 s(-1) at 270 μM (21%) O2, decreasing with Km(O2) of 60 μM (4.6%) O2. This eliminates the interference of O2 in the measurements of CEFII.

Linking chlorophyll a fluorescence to photosynthesis for remote sensing applications: mechanisms and challenges

Chlorophyll a fluorescence (ChlF) has been used for decades to study the organization, functioning, and physiology of photosynthesis at the leaf and subcellular levels. ChlF is now measurable from remote sensing platforms. This provides a new optical means to track photosynthesis and gross primary productivity of terrestrial ecosystems. Importantly, the spatiotemporal and methodological context of the new applications is dramatically different compared with most of the available ChlF literature, which raises a number of important considerations. Although we have a good mechanistic understanding of the processes that control the ChlF signal over the short term, the seasonal link between ChlF and photosynthesis remains obscure. Additionally, while the current understanding of in vivo ChlF is based on pulse amplitude-modulated (PAM) measurements, remote sensing applications are based on the measurement of the passive solar-induced chlorophyll fluorescence (SIF), which entails important differences and new challenges that remain to be solved. In this review we introduce and revisit the physical, physiological, and methodological factors that control the leaf-level ChlF signal in the context of the new remote sensing applications. Specifically, we present the basis of photosynthetic acclimation and its optical signals, we introduce the physical and physiological basis of ChlF from the molecular to the leaf level and beyond, and we introduce and compare PAM and SIF methodology. Finally, we evaluate and identify the challenges that still remain to be answered in order to consolidate our mechanistic understanding of the remotely sensed SIF signal.

Photosynthetic responses of sun- and shade-grown barley leaves to high light: is the lower PSII connectivity in shade leaves associated with protection against excess of light?

In this study, we have compared photosynthetic performance of barley leaves (Hordeum vulgare L.) grown under sun and shade light regimes during their entire growth period, under field conditions. Analyses were based on measurements of both slow and fast chlorophyll (Chl) a fluorescence kinetics, gas exchange, pigment composition; and of light incident on leaves during their growth. Both the shade and the sun barley leaves had similar Chl a/b and Chl/carotenoid ratios. The fluorescence induction analyses uncovered major functional differences between the sun and the shade leaves: lower connectivity among Photosystem II (PSII), decreased number of electron carriers, and limitations in electron transport between PSII and PSI in the shade leaves; but only low differences in the size of PSII antenna. We discuss the possible protective role of low connectivity between PSII units in shade leaves in keeping the excitation pressure at a lower, physiologically more acceptable level under high light conditions.

Photosynthesis-related quantities for education and modeling

A quantitative understanding of the photosynthetic machinery depends largely on quantities, such as concentrations, sizes, absorption wavelengths, redox potentials, and rate constants. The present contribution is a collection of numbers and quantities related mainly to photosynthesis in higher plants. All numbers are taken directly from a literature or database source and the corresponding reference is provided. The numerical values, presented in this paper, provide ranges of values, obtained in specific experiments for specific organisms. However, the presented numbers can be useful for understanding the principles of structure and function of photosynthetic machinery and for guidance of future research.

Thermal phase and excitonic connectivity in fluorescence induction

Chl fluorescence induction (FI) was recorded in sunflower leaves pre-adapted to darkness or low preferentially PSI light, or inhibited by DCMU. For analysis the FI curves were plotted against the cumulative number of excitations quenched by PSII, n q, calculated as the cumulative complementary area above the FI curve. In the +DCMU leaves n q was <1 per PSII, suggesting pre-reduction of Q A during the dark pre-exposure. A strongly sigmoidal FI curve was constructed by complementing (shifting) the recorded FI curves to n q = 1 excitation per PSII. The full FI curve in +DCMU leaves was well fitted by a model assuming PSII antennae are excitonically connected in domains of four PSII. This result, obtained by gradually reducing Q A in PSII with pre-blocked Q B (by DCMU or PQH2), differs from that obtained by gradually blocking the Q B site (by increasing DCMU or PQH2 level) in leaves during (quasi)steady-state e(-) transport (Oja and Laisk, Photosynth Res 114, 15-28, 2012). Explanations are discussed. Donor side quenching was characterized by comparison of the total n q in one and the same dark-adapted leaf, which apparently increased with increasing PFD during FI. An explanation for the donor side quenching is proposed, based on electron transfer from excited P680* to oxidized tyrosine Z (TyrZ(ox)). At high PFDs the donor side quenching at the J inflection of FI is due mainly to photochemical quenching by TyrZ(ox). This quenching remains active for subsequent photons while TyrZ remains oxidized, following charge transfer to Q A. During further induction this quenching disappears as soon as PQ and Q A become reduced, charge separation becomes impossible and TyrZ is reduced by the water oxidizing complex.

Excitonic connectivity between photosystem II units: what is it, and how to measure it?

In photosynthetic organisms, light energy is absorbed by a complex network of chromophores embedded in light-harvesting antenna complexes. In photosystem II (PSII), the excitation energy from the antenna is transferred very efficiently to an active reaction center (RC) (i.e., with oxidized primary quinone acceptor Q(A)), where the photochemistry begins, leading to O2 evolution, and reduction of plastoquinones. A very small part of the excitation energy is dissipated as fluorescence and heat. Measurements on chlorophyll (Chl) fluorescence and oxygen have shown that a nonlinear (hyperbolic) relationship exists between the fluorescence yield (Φ(F)) (or the oxygen emission yield, (Φ(O2)) and the fraction of closed PSII RCs (i.e., with reduced Q(A)). This nonlinearity is assumed to be related to the transfer of the excitation energy from a closed PSII RC to an open (active) PSII RC, a process called PSII excitonic connectivity by Joliot and Joliot (CR Acad Sci Paris 258: 4622-4625, 1964). Different theoretical approaches of the PSII excitonic connectivity, and experimental methods used to measure it, are discussed in this review. In addition, we present alternative explanations of the observed sigmoidicity of the fluorescence induction and oxygen evolution curves.