Hounsfield units-a significant predictor of lasering time and energy in the management of upper urinary tract stones using Holmium: Yttrium-Aluminum Garnet lasers

Do Hounsfield Units have any significance in predicting intra- and postoperative outcomes in retrograde intrarenal surgery using Holmium and Thulium fiber laser? Results from the FLEXible ureteroscopy Outcomes Registry (FLEXOR)

PURPOSE

To evaluate outcomes of flexible ureteroscopy for renal stones by comparing hard versus soft stones based on their attenuation on computed tomography (Hounsfield Units-HU).

METHODS

Patients were divided into two groups according to the type of laser employed [Holmium:YAG (HL) or Thulium fiber laser (TFL)]. Residual fragments (RF) were defined as > 2 mm. Multivariable logistic regression analysis was performed to evaluate factors associated with RF and RF needing further intervention.

RESULTS

4208 patients from 20 centers were included. In whole series, age, recurrent stones, stone size, lower pole stones (LPS), and multiple stones were predictors of RF at multivariable analysis and LPS and stone size with RF requiring further treatment. HU and TFL were associated with lesser RF and RF requiring an additional treatment. In HU < 1000 stones, recurrent stones, stone size, and LPS were predictors of RF at multivariable analysis, whereas TFL was less likely associated with RF. Recurrent stones, stone size, and multiple stones were predictors of RF requiring further treatment, while LPS and TFL were associated with lesser RF requiring further treatment. In HU ≥ 1000 stones, age, stone size, multiple stones, and LPS were predictors of RF at multivariable analysis, while TFL was less likely associated with RF. Stone size and LPS were predictors of RF requiring further treatment, whereas TFL was associated with RF requiring further treatment.

CONCLUSION

Stone size, LPS, and use of HL are predictors of RF after RIRS for intrarenal stones regardless of stone density. HU should be considered an important parameter in predicting SFR.

The predictive factors that total laser energy consumed during retrograde intrarenal surgery (RIRS): stone area and density

Holmium: YAG (Ho: YAG) laser lithotripsy with flexible ureterorenoscopy can be used with high stone-free and low complication rates for renal stones. This study aimed to determine the factors affecting the total laser energy in cases with provided stone-free status after a single session of retrograde intrarenal surgery (RIRS). Data of 222 patients who underwent RIRS between October 2017 and March 2020 were evaluated retrospectively. After exclusion criteria, the study was carried out with 184 stone-free cases. All cases were performed without using a ureteral access sheath (UAS), and dusting was preferred as the lithotripsy method. The effects of age, gender, body mass index (BMI), previous RIRS history, previous shock wave lithotripsy (SWL) history, stone localization, number of stones, stone surface area, and stone density on total laser energy were analyzed. There was no significant correlation between total laser energy with gender, BMI, previous RIRS history, previous SWL history, stone localization, and the number of stones (p:0.347, p:0.482, p:0.119, p:0.167, p:0.907, p:0.933 respectively). There was a significant correlation between age and total laser energy (p = 0.032), but it was not observed when the effect of the stone surface area was removed (p = 0.354). There were significant correlations between total laser energy and stone surface area, stone density, and total laser time (p<0.001, p<0.001, and p <0.001, respectively). Stone area and stone density affect the total energy consumed during laser lithotripsy. Urologists should consider the stone area, stone density, and the power of the laser device to determine which surgical technic to prefer.

Retrograde intrarenal surgery: laser showdown (Ho:YAG vs thulium fiber laser)

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

Retrograde intrarenal surgery (RIRS) has always been recommended for large stones > 20 mm, using the Ho:YAG laser. The introduction of a new technology in the urological market, the thulium fiber laser (TFL) has revolutionized the endourology world because of its characteristics and significantly shorter laser-on time (LOT) and operative time, without scarifying the champ vision. The aim of this review is to evaluate the most relevant findings of the last 2 years of each laser technology, confronting Ho:YAG vs TFL, analyzing who is more suitable for performing an efficient RIRS.

RECENT FINDINGS

Five full clinical trials using TFL for RIRS were found. Median LOT was between 2.8 and 34 min. All stones were similar in terms of stone volume, >500 mm3, and stone density, > 800 HU. Low complication rate, mostly Clavien-Dindo grade I and II and not related to the laser itself. One clinical trial only analyzed the efficacy of TFL for > 20 mm renal stones.

SUMMARY

Based on this review, TFL performs a more efficient RIRS than the Ho:YAG laser with similar safety.

Laser lithotripsy using dusting technique (low energy, high frequency) for symptomatic upper urinary tract stones

Background

A prospective study to assess the feasibility of stone dusting technique (low energy and high frequency) during laser lithotripsy in symptomatic upper urinary tract |(UUT) stones.

Methods

Sixty patients with symptomatic single or multiple UUT stones less than 3 cm in diameter were included. Patients with coagulation disorders and active UTIs were excluded. All patients were clinically evaluated and underwent non-contrast spiral CT (NCSCT) to detect stone site, size, number, Hounsfield unit. A rigid or flexible ureteroscope was used with stone dusting using the Ho: YAG laser at low-energy and high-frequency (0.5 J & 20 Hz) set. Operative and fluoroscopy time, total energy delivered, type of stent, hospitalization time, complications and its grade, and stone-free rate using NCSCT after 4 weeks were recorded.

Results

The mean stone size ± SD (range) was 1.55 ± 0.55 (0.5–3) cm; out of sixty patients (50 with single stone and 10 with multiple stones), fifty-five patients were stone-free at 4 weeks. Complications had occurred in 11 patients (eight with grade I, one with grade II, and two with grade IIIa) according to Clavien–Dindo grading of surgical complications. Stone size was the only parameter which correlated significantly with stone-free rate. No significant correlation was found between incidence of complications and other parameters (stone size, site, BMI, age and operative time).

Conclusions

Stone dusting technique is feasible, safe and effective in management of UUT stones.

Prediction models of low-power holmium laser effectiveness in renal stone lithotripsy during retrograde intrarenal surgery

The objectives of this study are to develop prediction models for total laser energy (TLE) in order to infer surgical time and assist operative planning of intrarenal low-power Ho:YAG laser lithotripsy, and to predict the fragmented volume as well as the stone-free status (SFS). A retrospective review was performed, comprising all single surgeon standardized retrograde intrarenal surgery and low-power Ho:YAG laser lithotripsy at a tertiary care centre between October 2014 and September 2019. Automated measurement of stone volume and stone density (MSD), measured in Hounsfield units (HU), was employed in both pre- and post-operative non-contrast-enhanced computed tomography (NCCT), using a standardized technique on Osirix Lite® software. SFS was defined as complete absence of stone fragments, or fragments < 0.1 cm on meticulous inspection at the end of the procedure, and residual stone burden < 0.0005 cm³ on postoperative NCCT at 3 months. Statistical analysis was performed using the STATA® version 13.1 software for regression models. A p value < .05 was considered statistically significant. A total of 100 patients met the inclusion criteria, requiring a median of 22.3 kJ/cm³ (13.4-36.0) and resulting in a SFS of 41% at 3 months. In a multivariate analysis, according to stone composition, predicted TLE is equal: for uric acid (UA), 11.17 × volume(cm³) + 0.17 × MSD(HU) + 7.48 kJ; for mixed stones, 11.17 × volume(cm³) + 0.17 × MSD(HU) + 6.26 kJ; for calcium oxalate monohydrate (CaOM) stones, 11.17 × volume(cm³) + 0.17 × MSD(HU) + 1.14 kJ; and for calcium phosphate (CaPh) stones 11.17 × volume(cm³) + 0.17 × MSD(HU) - 1.94 kJ. Predicted fragmented volume is equal to 0.93 × volume(cm³) cm³. The significant predictors for SFS were UA stones, the presence of multiple stones, and lower TLE. In clinical practice, our models for intrarenal low-power Ho:YAG laser lithotripsy indicate that larger, denser, and UA stones are associated to higher TLE, and that single and UA stones are more commonly associated to SFS. Since higher TLE means longer operative time, when adjusting for laser parameters, our prediction models may help urologists plan surgeries more precisely based on stone characteristics, ultimately optimizing patients' treatment.

Retrospective analysis of the factors affecting intraoperative and immediate postoperative complications of RIRS classified by the Clavien and Satava grading systems

BACKGROUND

To classify intraoperative and postoperative complications using the modified Clavien classification system(MCCS) and modified Satava classification system(SCS) and to evaluate the parameters associated with complications in patients undergoing retrograde intrarenal surgery(RIRS) for renal and proximal ureteral stones.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

We performed a retrospective analysis of 949 patients who underwent RIRS for renal stones and proximal ureteral stones at two institutions between March 2015 and June 2020. Intraoperative complications were assessed using SCS and postoperative complications were graded according to MCCS. Univariate and multivariate analyses were undertaken to determine predictive factors affecting complication rates.

RESULTS

The median stone size was determined as 13 mm (range 10-20 mm). The stone-free rate was 83.6% after the first intervention. Reprocedure was applied to 89 of the patients with residual stones and the final stone-free rate was 94.4% after reprocedure. According to SCS, the number of intraoperative events and complication incidences was 153(16.1%). MCCS revealed postoperative complications in 121(12.8%) patients. Major complications were observed in 18(1.9%) patients. The rate of complications was higher in patients with renal anomalies (9.9% vs 3.4%, p=0.001). Stone location, stone size, stone burden, stone number, stone density and residual fragments were determined to be associated with the development of complications (p<0.001,p<0.001,p<0.001, p<0.001,p=0.002 and p<0.001 respectively). In addition, the multivariate analysis revealed that only presence of residual fragments was a significant predictor of complication development for the patients with Grade≥3 complications according to MCCS (p=0.032). However, significant predictors were stone burden (p<0.001), stone density (p=0.002) and fluoroscopy time (p<0.001) for those with Grade≥2b complications according to SCS.

CONCLUSION

This study showed that abnormal kidney anatomy, operation time, stone burden and residual fragments were reliable predictors of complication development during and after RIRS. Appropriate preoperative management should be planned according to these predictors to prevent intraoperative and postoperative complications.

Radiation exposure to the urology surgeon during retrograde intrarenal surgery

Retrograde intrarenal surgery is a common procedure that carries a risk of radiation exposure for urologists. This study aimed to measure the amount of radiation that urologists are exposed to during surgery, and to estimate how many procedures can be safely performed by one urologist per year. Variables that affect radiation exposure were also identified. Radiation exposure doses were measured for the eye, neck, chest, arms, and hands of a urologist who performed 226 retrograde intrarenal surgeries. To determine how many procedures could be safely performed per year, the Annual Permissible Occupational Exposure Radiation Dose Guidelines of the National Council on Radiation Protection and Measurements were consulted. Correlations between radiation exposure dose and the patient's age, sex, body mass index, stone number/burden/laterality/location/Hounsfield unit, and their renal calculi were calculated. The mean surgery and fluoroscopy durations were 83.2 and 5.13 min; the mean tube voltage and current were 68.88 kV and 2.48 mA, respectively. Cumulative radiation doses for the eye, neck, chest, right upper arm, left hand, and right hand were 65.53, 69.95, 131.79, 124.43, 165.66, and 126.64 mSv, respectively. Radiation reduction rates for lead collars and aprons were 97% and 98%, respectively. If the urologists wear only radiation shields and lead apron but do not wear safety glasses during RIRS, the recommended by the ICRP publication 103 is taken into consideration, our results showed that 517 RIRS can be performed per year safely. However, if no protective measures are taken, this number decreases to only 85 RIRS per year. At all measurement sites, significant correlations were observed between the radiation exposure dose and stone numbers and Hounsfield unit values. In conclusion, it is imperative that urologists wear protective gear. Greater effort should be made to reduce radiation exposure when renal calculi have a large number of stones or large Hounsfield unit values.