Autologous testicular tunica vaginalis graft in Peyronie's disease: a prospective evaluation

Outcomes of surgical correction of Peyronie's disease with plaque excision and grafting: Comparison of testicular tunica vaginalis graft versus bovine pericardium graft

Objective

Peyronie's disease (PD) is an abnormal wound healing in the penile tunica albuginea. After fibrotic plaque excision, different graft materials have been used to repair the defects, but the optimal graft remains unknown. This study aimed to compare the functional outcomes of testicular tunica vaginalis grafts and bovine pericardium grafts in patients with severe PD.

Methods

A retrospective comparative study was conducted on 33 PD patients undergoing partial plaque excision and grafting from September 2015 to May 2021. The patients were divided into two groups depending on the type of graft used. For 15 patients in Group B, testicular tunica vaginalis grafts were used to repair the defect, while for 18 patients in Group A, bovine pericardium grafts were used. Data of the patient's age, comorbidities, sexual function, penile curvature, postoperative complications, need for further treatment, change in penile length, and satisfaction were gathered and compared between the groups. Sexual function was evaluated using the 5-item version of the International Index of Erectile Function (IIEF-5), and a functional less than 20-degree penile curvature after surgery was considered a successful intervention.

Results

There was no difference in age, comorbidities, degree of curvature, perioperative IIEF-5, operative time, plaque size, or complication rates. After surgery, a statistically significant improvement in curvature degree (p<0.05) and satisfactory penile appearance (p<0.05) were seen in both groups without any superiority between the two groups (p=0.423 and p=0.840, respectively). With a 30-month follow-up, the IIEF-5 was consistent in both groups, with no statistical significance between the groups (p=0.492). The main change in penile length during the operation was increased and still positive in the last follow-up in both groups without statistical significance (p=0.255 and p=0.101, respectively).

Conclusion

Partial plaque excision and corporoplasty with both testicular tunica vaginalis or bovine pericardium grafts are equally effective in treating males with clinically significant PD.

Grafts in Peyronie's surgery without the use of prostheses: a systematic review and meta-analysis

Peyronie's disease (PD) is characterized by abnormal penile curvature, and various surgical methods have been developed using different graft materials. However, there is currently no universal agreement on which type of graft is the best. The objective of this review was to evaluate the available literature and identify the most effective graft material for penile curvature correction in PD. A literature search was conducted using electronic databases, including PubMed, Scopus, and the Cochrane Library. The patients, intervention, comparison, and outcome (PICO) approach was used to define the eligibility of studies. Two authors independently selected studies, evaluated them, and extracted data. Random-effect models using the DerSimonian-Laird method were used. Most studies were single-arm studies and had a high risk of bias. Buccal mucosa grafts (BMG) were found to result in the highest penile straightening rates and were associated with the least de novo erectile dysfunction. TachoSil grafts demonstrated a high success rate in straightening despite a higher mean preoperative curvature, while Tutoplast grafts had a higher incidence of postoperative erectile dysfunction. BMG had the highest percentage of postoperative penile straightening. Overall, the TachoSil graft showed the best performance when preoperative curvature is taken into account. Based on the available literature, BMG appear to be the most effective for penile curvature correction in PD, but this is offset by the requirement for low preoperative curvature. The TachoSil graft shows the best overall performance when preoperative curvature is considered. Comparative randomized clinical trials are still needed to determine graft superiority.