Competition for electrons between pyridine and quinoline during their simultaneous biodegradation

Treatment options of nitrogen heterocyclic compounds in industrial wastewater: From fundamental technologies to energy valorization applications and future process design strategies

Nitrogen heterocyclic compounds (NHCs) widely exist in industrial wastewater and presented significant environmental and health risks due to their toxicity and persistence. This review addressed the challenges in treating NHCs in industrial wastewater, focusing on developing sustainable and efficient treatment processes. While various technologies, including adsorption, advanced oxidation/reduction processes (AOPs/ARPs), and microbial treatments, have been studied at the experimental stage of treating synthetic wastewater, scale-up for industrial applications is imperative. After analyzing the characteristics of NHCs and evaluating different treatment methods with the aid of efficiency and cost-benefit analysis, efficient detoxification while maximizing energy recovery constitutes a critical requirement in treating NHC-containing wastewater. Hence, we proposed a comprehensive strategy combining hydrolysis-acidification pretreatment enhanced by electro-assisted micro-aeration with methanogenic anaerobic digestion as core treatment units. The process design for NHC-containing wastewater treatment should consider the dynamic balance between removal efficiency, energy consumption, and ammonia recovery, incorporating environmental and economic impacts through life cycle assessment and technical-economic analysis. The potential of machine learning in optimizing operational parameters, predicting effluent quality, and supporting process design decisions is promising. To develop interpretable and practical solutions, the integration of data-driven approaches with mechanistic understanding and prior knowledge is indispensable. This review provided novel insights into sustainable NHC treatment strategies in the context of energy valorization and artificial intelligence advancement, offering guidance for future research and industrial applications.

Behavior of carbon source type on the construction of aerobic granular sludge system and its removal of quinoline: A tortoise and hare race between starch and phenol

Coal chemical wastewater contains high concentrations of toxic organic pollutants such as quinoline and phenol. Microorganisms in aerobic granular sludge (AGS) are known to efficiently degrade organic matter. This study systematically compared the cultivation characteristics of quinoline-degrading aerobic granular sludge using starch (R1), a common carbon source, and phenol (R2), a toxic carbon source, as co-metabolizing substrates. The results indicated that R2 was more conducive to improving sludge settleability, biomass retention, and the growth of quinoline-degrading bacteria when a low quinoline concentration (30 mg/L) was applied. However, as the quinoline concentration increased, the granular sludge cultured with starch eventually outperformed phenol as a co-metabolizing substrate in terms of settling performance, biomass, and pollutant removal. Analysis of the pollutant degradation characteristics during a typical operation cycle revealed that the time required to degrade quinoline to approximately 5.5 mg/L was 150 min in R1 and 420 min in R2, indicating a higher reaction rate in R1. Acidovorax was identified as the dominant quinoline-degrading bacterium in both reactors. In addition, microbial differential analysis and functional genes indicated more pronounced bacterial differentiation in R1, enriched in Firmicutes and Deinococcaceae. the relative abundance of enzymes associated with quinoline degradation was higher in R1.

New insights into the typical nitrogen-containing heterocyclic compound-quinoline degradation and detoxification by microbial consortium: Integrated pathways, meta-transcriptomic analysis and toxicological evaluation

As the primary source of COD in industrial wastewater, quinoline has aroused increasing attention because of its potential teratogenic, carcinogenic, and mutagenic effects in the environment. The activated sludge isolate quinoline-degrading microbial consortium (QDMC) efficiently metabolizes quinoline. However, the molecular underpinnings of the degradation mechanism of quinoline by QDMC have not been elucidated. High-throughput sequencing revealed that the dominant genera included Diaphorobacter, Bacteroidia, Moheibacter and Comamonas. Furthermore, a positive strong correlation was observed between the key bacterial communities (Diaphorobact and Bacteroidia) and quinoline degradation. According to metatranscriptomics, genes associated with quorum sensing, ABC transporters, component systems, carbohydrate, aromatic compound degradation, energy metabolism and amino metabolism showed high expression, thus improving adaptability of microbial community to quinoline stress. In addition, the mechanism of QDMC in adapting and resisting to extreme environmental conditions in line with the corresponding internal functional properties and promoting biogegradation efficiency was illustrated. Based on the identified products, QDMC effectively mineralized quinoline into low-toxicity metabolites through three major metabolic pathways, including hydroxyquinoline, 1,2,3,4-H-quinoline, 5,6,7,8-tetrahydroquinoline and 1-oxoquinoline pathways. Finally, toxicological, genotoxicity and phytotoxicity studies supported the detoxification of quinoline by the QDMC. This study provided a promising approach for the stable, environmental-friendly and efficient bioremediation applications for quinoline-containing wastewater.

Efficient utilization of photoelectron-hole at semiconductor-microbe interface for pyridine degradation with assistance of external electric field

In this study, enhanced pyridine bio-photodegradation with assistance of electricity was achieved. Meanwhile, photoelectron-hole played a vital role in accelerating pyridine biomineralization. The significant separation of photoelectron-hole was achieved with an external electric field, which provided sufficient electron donors and acceptors for pyridine biodegradation. The enhanced electron transport system activity also revealed the full utilization of photoelectron-hole by microbes at semiconductor-microbe interface with assistance of electricity. Microbial community analysis confirmed the enrichment of functional species related to pyridine biodegradation and electron transfer. Microbial function analysis and microbial co-occurrence networks analysis indicated that upregulated functional genes and positive interactions of different species were the important reasons for enhanced pyridine bio-photodegradation with external electric field. A possible mechanism of enhanced pyridine biodegradation was proposed, i.e., more photoelectrons and holes of semiconductors were utilized by microbes to accelerate reduction and oxidation of pyridine with the assistance of electrical stimulation. The excellent performance of the photoelectrical biodegradation system showed a potential alternative for recalcitrant organic wastewater treatment.

Strategic analysis on development of simultaneous adsorption and catalytic biodegradation over advanced bio-carriers for zero-liquid discharge of industrial wastewater

With rapid industrial development, millions of tons of industrial wastewater are produced that contain highly toxic, carcinogenic, mutagenic compounds. These compounds may consist of high concentration of refractory organics with plentiful carbon and nitrogen. To date, a substantial proportion of industrial wastewater is discharged directly to precious water bodies due to the high operational costs associated with selective treatment methods. For example, many existing treatment processes rely on activated sludge-based treatments that only target readily available carbon using conventional microbes, with limited capacity for nitrogen and other nutrient removal. Therefore, an additional set-up is often required in the treatment chain to address residual nitrogen, but even after treatment, refractory organics persist in the effluents due to their low biodegradability. With the advancements in nanotechnology and biotechnology, novel processes such as adsorption and biodegradation have been developed, and one promising approach is integration of adsorption and biodegradation over porous substrates (bio-carriers). Regardless of recent focus in a few applied researches, the process assessment and critical analysis of this approach is still missing, and it highlights the urgency and importance of this review. This review paper discussed the development of the simultaneous adsorption and catalytic biodegradation (SACB) over a bio-carrier for the sustainable treatment of refractory organics. It provides insights into the physico-chemical characteristics of the bio-carrier, the development mechanism of SACB, stabilization techniques, and process optimization strategies. Furthermore, the most efficient treatment chain is proposed, and its technical aspects are critically analysed based on updated research. It is anticipated that this review will contribute to the knowledge of academia and industrialist for sustainable upgradation of existing industrial wastewater treatment plants.

Study on the removal characteristics and degradation pathways of highly toxic and refractory organic pollutants in real pharmaceutical factory wastewater treated by a pilot-scale integrated process

Introduction

Pharmaceutical wastewater frequently contains high levels of toxic pollutants. If they are discharged untreated, they pose a threat to the environment. The traditional activated sludge process and the advanced oxidation process do not sufficiently remove toxic and conventional pollutants from pharmaceutical wastewater treatment plants (PWWTPs).

Methods

We designed a pilot-scale reaction system to reduce toxic organic pollutants and conventional pollutants from pharmaceutical wastewater during the biochemical reaction stage. This system included a continuous stirred tank reactor (CSTR), microbial electrolysis cells (MECs), an expanded sludge bed reactor (EGSB), and a moving bed biofilm reactor (MBBR). We used this system to further investigate the benzothiazole degradation pathway.

Results and discussion

The system effectively degraded the toxic pollutants (benzothiazole, pyridine, indole, and quinoline) and the conventional chemicals (COD, NH4+-N, TN). During the stable operation of the pilot-scale plant, the total removal rates of benzothiazole, indole, pyridine, and quinoline were 97.66, 94.13, 79.69, and 81.34%, respectively. The CSTR and MECs contributed the most to the removal of toxic pollutants, while the EGSB and MBBR contributed less to the removal of the four toxic pollutants. Benzothiazoles can be degraded via two pathways: the benzene ring-opening reaction and the heterocyclic ring-opening reaction. The heterocyclic ring-opening reaction was more important in degrading the benzothiazoles in this study.

Conclusion

This study provides feasible design alternatives for PWWTPs to remove both toxic and conventional pollutants at the same time.

How Comamonas testosteroni and Rhodococcus ruber enhance nitrification in the presence of quinoline

Because many wastewater-treatment plants receive effluents containing inhibitory compounds from chemical or pharmaceutical facilities, the input of these inhibitors can lead to failure of nitrification and total-N removal. Nitrification de facto is the more important process, as it is the first step of nitrogen removal and involves slow-growing autotrophic bacteria. In this work, quinoline, the target compound severely inhibited nitrification: The biomass-normalized nitrification rate decreased four-fold in the presence of quinoline. The inhibition was relieved by bioaugmenting Comamonas testosteroni or Rhodococcus ruber to the nitrifying biomass. Because the inhibition was derived from a quinoline intermediate, 2‑hydroxyl quinoline (2HQ), not quinoline itself, nitrification was accelerated only after 2HQ disappeared due to the addition of R. ruber or C. testosteroni. R. ruber was superior to C. testosteroni for 2HQ biodegradation and accelerating nitrification. Besides accelerating nitrification, adding C. testosteroni or R. ruber led to the enrichment of Nitrospira, which appeared to be carrying out commamox metabolism, since ammonium-oxidizing bacteria were not enriched.

Selective acceleration of 2-hydroxyl pyridine mono-oxygenation using specially acclimated biomass

Biodegradation of pyridine starts with two mono-oxygenation reactions, and 2-hydroxyl pyridine (2-HP) accumulates as pyridine is mono-oxygenated in the first reaction. The accumulation of 2-HP inhibits both initial reactions. Therefore, selective acceleration of the second mono-oxygenation reaction should significantly enhance pyridine transformation and mineralization. Activated-sludge biomass was separately acclimated with pyridine or 2-HP to produce pyridine- and 2-HP-acclimated biomasses. The pyridine-acclimated biomass was superior for pyridine biodegradation, but the 2-HP-acclimated biomass was superior for 2-HP biodegradation. As a consequence, the pyridine-acclimated biomass by itself achieved faster mono-oxygenation of pyridine to 2-HP, but 2-HP accumulated, which limited mineralization to 60%. In contrast, mineralization reached 90% when one-third of the pyridine-acclimated was replaced with 2-HP-acclimated biomass, because 2-HP did not accumulate during pyridine biodegradation. The lack of 2-HP accumulation relieved its inhibition: e.g., the pyridine removal rates, normalized to the mass of pyridine-acclimated biomass, increased from 0.52 to 0.57 mM^0.5⋅h^-1 when one-third of the pyridine-acclimated biomass was replaced by 2-HP-acclimated biomass. Phylogenetic analysis showed that microbiological communities of pyridine-acclimated biomass and 2-HP-acclimated biomass differed in important ways. On the one hand, the 2-HP-acclimated biomass was richer and dominated by a rare biosphere, or genera having <0.1% of total reads. On the other hand, the most-enriched genus in the pyridine-acclimated community (Methylibium) is associated with the first mono-oxygenation of pyridine, while enriched genera in the 2-HP-acclimated community (Sediminibacterium and Dokdonella) are associated with the second mono-oxygenation of pyridine.

Synergy of strains that accelerate biodegradation of pyridine and quinoline

Three bacterial strains were isolated from activated sludge acclimated to biodegrade pyridine and quinoline simultaneously. The strains were identified as Bacillus tropicus, Bacillus aquimaris, and Rhodococcus ruber. When the isolated bacteria were used for pyridine and quinoline biodegradation in separate or combined modes, R. ruber had much faster kinetics, and combining R. ruber with one or both of the Bacillus strains increased further the biodegradation kinetics. For example, the time needed for complete biodegradation of 1 mM quinoline and pyridine decreased to 20 h and 6 h, respectively, with the three strains combined, compared to 26 h and 7 h with R. ruber alone. Whereas quinoline was completely mineralized by all three strains, 10-14% of the pyridine persisted as a dead-end product, 2-hydroxypyridine (2HP). The acclimated sludge from which the three bacterial species were isolated was able to transform 2HP, and adding the bacterial strains (especially R. ruber) to the acclimated sludge accelerated the rate of 2HP removal and mineralization through a form of synergy.

How bioaugmentation with Comamonas testosteroni accelerates pyridine mono-oxygenation and mineralization

Pyridine is a common heterocycle found in industrial wastewaters. Its biodegradation begins with a mono-oxygenation reaction, and bioaugmentation with bacteria able to carry out this mono-oxygenation is one strategy to improve pyridine removal and mineralization. Although bioaugmentation has been used to enhance the biodegradation of recalcitrant organic compounds, the specific role played by the bioaugmented bacteria usually has not been addressed. We acclimated activated-sludge biomass for pyridine biodegradation and then isolated a strain -- Comamonas testosteroni -- based on its ability to biodegrade and grow on pyridine alone. Pyridine was removed faster by C. testosteroni, compared to pyridine-acclimated biomass, but pyridine mineralization was slower. Pyridine biodegradation and mineralization rates were accelerated when C. testosteroni was bioaugmented into the acclimated biomass, which increased the amount of C. testosteroni, but otherwise had minimal effects on the microbial community. The key role of C. testosteroni was to accelerate the first step of pyridine biodegradation, mono-oxygenation to 2-hydroxylpyridine (2HP), and the acclimated biomass was better able to complete downstream reactions leading to mineralization. Thus, bioaugmentation increased the rates of pyridine mono-oxygenation and subsequent mineralization through the synergistic roles of C. testosteroni and the main community in the acclimated biomass.

BiVO4/FeOOH semiconductor-microbe interface for enhanced visible-light-driven biodegradation of pyridine

Pyridine, a highly toxic nitrogen-containing heterocyclic compound, is recalcitrant in the conventional biodegradation process. In this study, BiVO₄/FeOOH semiconductor-microbe interface was developed for enhanced visible-light-driven biodegradation of pyridine, where the efficiencies of pyridine removal (100%), total organic carbon (TOC) removal (88.06±3.76%) and NH₄⁺-N formation (84.51±8.95%) were remarkably improved, compared to the biodegradation system and photodegradation system. The electron transport system activity and photoelectrochemical analysis implied the significant improvement of photogenerated carriers transfer between microbes and semiconductors. High-throughput sequencing analysis suggested functional species related to pyridine biodegradation (Shewanella, Bacillus and Lysinibacillus) and electron transfer (Shewanella and Tissierella) were enriched at the semiconductor-microbe interface. The light-excited holes played a crucial role in promoting pyridine mineralization. This study demonstrated that this bio-photodegradation system would be a potential alternative for the efficient treatment of wastewater containing recalcitrant pollutant such as pyridine.

A state-of-the-art review of quinoline degradation and technical bottlenecks

Quinoline is a critical raw material for the dye, metallurgy, pharmaceutical, rubber, and agrochemical industries, and its use poses a serious threat to human health and the ecological environment. Quinoline has carcinogenic, teratogenic and mutagenic effects on the human body through food accumulation. However, due to the steric hindrance of its bicyclic fused structure and its long photooxidation half-life, quinoline is too difficult to decompose naturally. To date, numerous technologies have been used to degrade quinoline, whereas only a few have been reviewed. Therefore, this paper is focused on offering a comprehensive overview of the state of quinoline degradation in an effort to improve its degradation efficiency and fully utilize the carbon and nitrogen within quinoline without causing any damage to the environment. Accordingly, the strains, research progress and mechanisms of various methods for degrading quinoline are explored and elucidated in detail, especially quinoline biodegradation and the combination of these technologies for efficient removal. The state-of-the-art processes and new findings of our team on the biofortification of quinoline degradation are also presented. Finally, research bottlenecks and gaps for future research were identified along with the prospects and resource utilization of quinoline. These discussions facilitate the realization of the zero discharge of quinoline.

Bioavailable electron donors leached from leaves accelerate biodegradation of pyridine and quinoline

Fallen leaves of Platanus orientalis and Ginkgo biloba linn were separately immersed in water to obtain leachates that were used as exogenous electron donors for accelerating pyridine and quinoline biodegradations. Leachate addition accelerated the pyridine removal rate by up to 4.4% and 3.6% and the quinoline removal rate by 9.5% and 11%. The rates increased further after the leachates were illuminated by UV light: up to 8.5% for pyridine and 12% for quinoline. Succinate and oxalate were separately added into solutions of pyridine and quinoline (respectively) to gauge the acceleration impact of the leaf leachates. Equations describing the relationships between addition of leachate and pyridine or quinoline removal rates were established based on electron-equivalent balances and comparison to the acceleration effects from succinate and oxalate. From 22% to 98% of the COD leached from leaves was available as an electron donor, with the fraction being greater for pyridine and after UV illumination.