Metamorphosis of human lumbar vertebrae induced by VEPTR growth modulation and stress shielding

Orthopedic mechanism analysis of growing rod distraction for early-onset scoliosis based on 3D morphological parameters

Traditional growing rod (TGR) provides a corrective moment for deformed segments to straighten the spine, whose clinical efficacy has proven positive and growth-friendly. However, an insufficient understanding of orthopedic mechanisms can affect the development of clinical strategies. This research attempts to analyze the spine that has undergone four distraction operations: exploring the spinal orthopedic mechanism, including alignment, growth, and morphology. In this study, the spinal morphology curves were illustrated in three human planes to exhibit the changes in spinal alignment. The spinal growth characteristics were measured to discuss the unsynchronized and diminishing growth rate. The spinal deformations were evaluated to indicate asymmetric growth. As a result, the spinal alignment changes indicated the orthopedic process improved, but the re-unbalance occurred after multiple distractions. Then, unsynchronized growth existed in the superior and inferior segments, and the growth rate over every distraction diminished. Finally, asymmetric growth was indicated as the axial/circumferential growth ratio getting greater and the cuneate level approaching normal. Accordingly, a TGR is growth-friendly, but combining the osteotomy fusion of lumbar segments for severe early-onset scoliosis may be an excellent choice to solve the insufficient corrective stimulation. Regarding the distraction process, reshaping before the final fusion can fix the balance loss, and a prolonged distraction frequency fits the law of diminishing return. In conclusion, studying orthopedic mechanisms based on morphological measurement can guide clinical strategy optimization.

A biomechanical study on the effect of lengthening magnitude on spine off-loading in magnetically controlled growing rod surgery: Implications on lengthening frequency

Purpose: To assess whether the magnitude of lengthening in magnetically controlled growing rod (MCGR) surgeries has an immediate or delayed effect on spinal off-loading. Methods: 9 whole porcine spines were instrumented using two standard MCGRs from T9 to L5. Static compression testing using a mechanical testing system (MTS) was performed at three MCGR lengthening stages (0 mm, 2 mm, and 6 mm) in each spine. At each stage, five cycles of compression at 175N with 25 min of relaxation was carried out. Off-loading was derived by comparing the load sustained by the spine with force applied by the MTS to the spine. Micro-CT imaging was subsequently performed. Results: The mean load sustained by the vertebral body before lengthening was 39.69N, and immediately after lengthening was 25.12N and 19.91N at 2 mm and 6 mm lengthening, respectively; decreasing to 10.07N, 8.31N, and 8.17N after 25 minutes of relaxation, at 0 mm, 2 mm, and 6 mm lengthening stages, respectively. There was no significant difference in off-loading between 2 mm and 6 mm lengthening stages, either instantaneously (p = 0.395) or after viscoelastic relaxation (p = 0.958). CT images showed fractures/separations at the level of pedicle screws in six spines and in the vertebral body's growth zone in five spines after 6 mm MCGR lengthening. Conclusion: This study demonstrated MCGRs cause significant off-loading of the spine leading to stress shielding. 6 mm of lengthening caused tissue damage and microfractures in some spines. There was no significant difference in spine off-loading between 2 mm and 6 mm MCGR lengthening, either immediately after lengthening or after viscoelastic relaxation.

Vertebral column growth in children with early onset scoliosis treated with magnetically controlled growing rods - Effects of distraction on vertebral and disc morphology

OBJECTIVES

To report changes in vertebral and disc morphology following treatment of early onset scoliosis (EOS) with magnetically controlled growing rods (MCGR).

METHODS

30 Patients, 21 girls and 9 boys, treated with MCGR for EOS were compared to a matched control group of 19 patients (12 girls, 7 boys) treated with bracing or observation. Age at surgery in the MCGR group was 8.75 (range: 4.6-11) years compared to 7.75 (range: 3.5-10.3) years in the control group at the time of onset of treatment. Mean follow-up was 45 (range: 24-65) months in the MCGR group vs 42 (range: 24-65) months in the control group. Calibrated radiographs were used to digitally measure disc height, vertebral body height, depth and width after surgery and at latest follow-up. Height, width and depth of lumbar and thoracic vertebrae and discs under distraction were compared to the control group and to vertebrae below instrumentation. T1-T12, T1-S1 length and Cobb angles were also measured.

RESULTS

(1) There is a significant increase of lumbar vertebral height under distraction. (2) Lumbar disc height as well as lumbar vertebral width within distraction is significantly reduced. (3) Depth of lumbar vertebrae is not significantly affected by distraction. (4) Morphology of thoracic vertebrae and adjacent discs is not significantly changed with distraction. (5) T1-T12 distance did not show any significant changes between surgical and control group, while T1-S1 growth was significantly reduced compared to the control group.

CONCLUSIONS

Significant changes of morphology of lumbar vertebra and discs are observed under distraction with MCGR compared to segments below instrumentation and the control group.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Level III - retrospective comparative series.

Smaller Intervertebral Disc Volume and More Disc Degeneration after Spinal Distraction in Scoliotic Children

In recent decades, magnetically controlled growing rods (MCGR) were established to treat progressive early-onset scoliosis. The aim of this investigation was to assess the effect of long-term MCGR with continuous distraction on intervertebral discs in scoliotic children. Magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) of 33 children with spinal muscular atrophy was analyzed by grading intervertebral disc degeneration (IDD) and measuring intervertebral disc volume. Cohort I (n = 17) were children who had continuous spinal distraction with MCGRs for 5.1 years and MRI before (av. age 8.1) and after (av. age 13.4) MCGR treatment. Cohort II (n = 16, av. age 13.7) were patients without prior surgical treatment. Lumbar intervertebral disc volume of cohort I did not change during 5.1 years of MCGR treatment, whereas disc volumes were significantly larger in age- and disease-matched children without prior treatment (cohort II). Cohort I showed more IDD after MCGR treatment in comparison to early MRI studies of the same patients and children without surgical treatment. MRI data showed a volume reduction and disc degeneration of lower thoracic and lumbar intervertebral discs in scoliotic children after continuous spinal distraction with MCGRs. These effects were confirmed in the same subjects before and after treatment as well as in surgically untreated controls.

Vertebral body changes after continuous spinal distraction in scoliotic children

PURPOSE

Growth-friendly spinal implants (GFSI) were established for scoliotic children as an interim solution until definite spinal fusion could be performed during puberty. While deformity control was clearly proven, the effects on vertebral shape and morphology are still unclear. Our prospective study assesses the effect of GFSI with continuous distraction on vertebral body shape and volume in SMA children in comparison with previously untreated age-matched SMA patients.

METHODS

Cohort I (n = 19, age 13.2 years) were SMA patients without prior surgical scoliosis treatment. Cohort II (n = 24, age 12.4 years) were children, who had continuous spinal distraction with GFSI for 4.5 years. Radiographic measurements and computed tomography (CT) 3D volume rendering were performed before definite spinal fusion. For cohort II, additional radiographs were analyzed before the first surgical implantation of GFSI, after surgery and every year thereafter.

RESULTS

Our analysis revealed decreased depth and volume in scoliotic patients with prior GFSI compared to scoliotic patients without prior implants. This difference was significant for the lower thoracic and entire lumbar spine. Vertebral body height and pedicle size were unchanged between the two cohorts.

CONCLUSION

CT data showed volume reduction in the vertebral body in scoliotic children after GFSI treatment. This effect was more severe in the lumbar and lower thoracic area. While vertebral height was identical in both groups, vertebral depth was reduced in the GFSI-treated group. Reduced vertebral depth and altered vertebral morphology should be considered before instrumenting the spine in previously treated scoliotic SMA children.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE III

Diagnostic: individual cross-sectional studies with consistently applied reference standard and blinding.

Severe persistent coronal imbalance following instrumented posterior spinal fusion for adolescent idiopathic scoliosis

STUDY DESIGN

Retrospective case-control study.

OBJECTIVE

The aim of this study was to identify the risk factors and health-related quality of life (HRQoL) impact of severe (> 4 cm) post-operative coronal imbalance at 2 years following posterior spinal fusion (PSF) for adolescent idiopathic scoliosis (AIS). Coronal imbalance is an unfavorable outcome following PSF for AIS, though the degree of imbalance in such patients is typically mild. We hypothesize that a small number of patients become and remain severely imbalanced post-operatively, though this phenomenon has not been well studied.

METHODS

Prospectively collected data from a large multicenter registry were reviewed. Patients with severe coronal imbalance (SCIB; > 4 cm) 2 years after PSF were included. Matched controls without SCIB at 2 years were included at a 3:1 ratio. Comparisons were made between demographics, pre-operative radiographic measures, surgical factors, residual post-operative radiographic measures, and 2-year SRS-22 scores.

RESULTS

Nine of 954 (0.9%) patients (88.9% females; mean age 14.8 ± 2.3 years) were found to be severely imbalanced at 2 years. These patients had significantly greater pre-operative bending thoracic curve magnitude (45° vs. 33°; p = 0.013), curve flexibility (22.9% vs. 63.3%; p = 0.004), and kyphosis (41° vs. 26.5°; p = 0.034) compared to matched controls. Pre-operative curve flexibility of < 20% was associated with a 23.8 times greater odds of SCIB (95% CI 2.1-250; p = 0.008). With respect to HRQoL, median SRS-22 pain (4.1 vs. 4.8; p = 0.041), self-image (3.9 vs. 4.6; p = 0.013), general function (4.5 vs. 5; p = 0.022), and total (4.1 vs. 4.7; p = 0.012) scores at 2 years were significantly lower in cases compared to controls.

CONCLUSIONS

In the present study, thoracic curve stiffness was a strong risk factor for severe post-operative coronal imbalance, which was associated with poor HRQoL measures. Increased pre-operative thoracic curve stiffness (< 20% flexibility) should raise surgeon awareness for altering surgical approach to minimize the risk of severe post-operative coronal imbalance.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Level III.

Radiographic Outcome and Complication Rate of 34 Graduates After Treatment With Vertical Expandable Prosthetic Titanium Rib (VEPTR): A Single Center Report

BACKGROUND

The final strategy for graduates from growth-sparing surgery is challenging. The purpose of this study was to evaluate the radiographic outcome and complications of patients with early onset scoliosis (EOS) who have graduated from vertical expandable prosthetic titanium rib (VEPTR) treatment, either undergoing final fusion surgery or following a nonfusion approach.

METHODS

Final treatment for VEPTR graduates was divided in "VEPTR in situ without final fusion," "removal of VEPTR without final fusion," and "removal of VEPTR with instrumented final fusion." Radiographic evaluations included main coronal Cobb angle and main kyphosis pre and post VEPTR implantation, at the end of implant lengthening, after final fusion (if applicable), and at latest follow-up. Complications during VEPTR treatment and in case of final fusion were reported.

RESULTS

In total, 34 VEPTR graduates were included; 17 underwent final fusion surgery, and 17 followed a nonfusion strategy. Average coronal Cobb angle before VEPTR implantation was 70±23 degrees (range, 21 to 121 degrees), and 65±22 degrees (range, 17 to 119 degrees) at latest follow-up. Average main kyphosis angle was 53±27 degrees (range, 6 to 137 degrees) before VEPTR, and 69±34 degrees (range, 10 to 150 degrees) at latest follow-up. There was a 41% complication rate with final fusion surgery.

CONCLUSIONS

There is a high complication rate during VEPTR treatment and with final fusion surgery. The stiffness of the spine and thorax allow for only limited correction when performing a final instrumented spondylodesis. Avoiding final fusion may be a viable alternative in case of good coronal and sagittal alignment.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Level IV-therapeutic.

Long term outcome of vertical expandable prosthetic titanium rib treatment in children with early onset scoliosis

The vertical expandable prosthetic titanium rib (VEPTR) device was originally developed for the treatment of thoracic insufficiency syndrome with the aim of improving respiratory function of affected patients. Although clinically obvious, the changes in pulmonary function of VEPTR-treated patients are difficult to assess when using common lung function tests, and newer techniques based on functional magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) are currently being evaluated. The potential of improving lung function and simultaneously controlling the spinal deformity has continuously broadened the spectrum of indications for VEPTR, not least due to the frequent reports of complications with spine-based traditional growing rods (tGR). However, the initial enthusiasm of spine-sparing deformity correction has progressively subsided with the increasing number of reports on complications, including the detection of extraspinal ossifications along the implants and across ribs. The avoidance of repetitive surgical implant lengthening with the availability of motorized distraction-based implants has further diminished the use of VEPTR, especially in the absence of volume-depletion deformities of the thorax. In view of the still scarce reporting on the ultimate strategy of VEPTR treatment and the lack of long-term follow-up of patients receiving growth-sparing surgery, only limited conclusions can be drawn so far. Based on the available reports, however, the intended deformity corrections with final fusion surgeries can be achieved to a rather limited extent, while the complication and reoperation rates are still very high.

Vertebral Growth Around Distal Instrumented Vertebra in Patients With Early-Onset Scoliosis Who Underwent Traditional Dual Growing Rod Treatment

STUDY DESIGN

Retrospective radiographic study.

OBJECTIVE

To investigate the growth of the vertebrae around distal instrumented vertebra (DIV) in patients with early-onset scoliosis (EOS) who underwent dual growing rod (DGR) treatment.

SUMMARY OF BACKGROUND DATA

Previous studies indicated that DGR was likely to preserve or even stimulate the spinal growth. However, report pertaining to the effect of growing rod on the growth of individual vertebral body is rare.

METHODS

The EOS patients treated with DGR who had at least four lengthenings and 5-year follow-up were enrolled. Spine radiographs at index surgery and final follow-up were reviewed. The height, width, and depth of vertebral body from DIV-2 to DIV+2, and the height of the adjacent intervertebral space (IVS) were measured. The percentage of growth was calculated.

RESULTS

Thirty-one patients (mean age, 6.2 ± 2.5 years old) met the inclusion criteria, 74.2% (23/31) of whom were female. The average follow-up was 6.2 years (range, 5.0-10.4 yr). The measured vertebrae were divided into DIV group (n = 65), DIV- group (DIV-1 and DIV-2, n = 60), and DIV+ group (DIV+1 and DIV+2, n = 47). There were 33, 90, and 78 measured IVSs in DIV, DIV-, and DIV+ group, respectively. The total percentage growth of vertebral height was significantly higher in DIV- group than that in DIV and DIV+ groups (56.6 ± 20.3% vs. 45.6 ± 18.0% and 42.7 ± 16.2%, respectively, P ≤ 0.001). The vertebrae in DIV- group also had the highest annual height growth rate (8.7 ± 2.6% vs. 7.0 ± 2.4% and 6.6 ± 2.0%, respectively, P ≤ 0.001). A significant decrease of IVS height was observed in DIV- and DIV groups (P ≤ 0.001).

CONCLUSION

Traditional DGR with periodical distraction stimulated the longitudinal growth of the two segments immediately above DIV in patients with EOS. DGR technique had a negative effect on the development of intervertebral discs within distracted levels.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

3.

Pedicle stress shielding following growing rod implantation: case report

Growing rod surgery for skeletally immature patients helps correct severe scoliosis while allowing continued spinal column growth. Previous reports have studied vertebral body changes following growing rod surgery, but there are currently no published reports on alterations in pedicle morphology. Given the potential need for definitive spinal fusion with pedicle screw instrumentation, an awareness of changes in pedicle morphology is critical. A morphometric analysis of pedicles was performed using 3D reconstructions of 3 CT scans (preoperative and at 3 and 6 years) obtained in a young girl with infantile idiopathic scoliosis (T7 apex) who underwent unilateral rib-to-spine growing rod (2nd-4th ribs to L1) implantation with lengthening every 6 months for 6 years. The pedicle widths on the growing rod side from T5 to T9 (apex ± 2) were all smaller at 6 years postoperatively than preoperatively, while the same-level pedicles opposite the device significantly increased in width. These findings support anecdotal intraoperative reports by surgeons and provide evidence of pedicle stress shielding due to growing rod distraction and force deprivation.

Early-onset Scoliosis: Contemporary Decision-making and Treatment Options

Early-onset scoliosis (EOS) describes a wide array of diagnoses and deformities exposed to growth. This potentially life-threatening condition is still 1 of the biggest challenges in pediatric orthopaedics. The enlightenment of Bob Campbell's thoracic insufficiency syndrome concept and the negative impact of the earlier short and straight spine fusion approach on respiratory function and survival have fueled the evolution of EOS care. Despite all the progress made, growth-friendly spine surgery remains to be a burden to patients and caregivers. Even down-sized implants and remote-controlled noninvasive rod expansions do not omit unexpected returns to the operating room: failures of foundations, rod breakage, difficulties to keep the sagittal balance, progressive transverse plane deformities, stiffening, and the need for final instrumented fusion are still common. However, past experience and the current multitude of surgical strategies and implants have sharpened the decision-making process, patients with thoracic insufficiency syndrome require earliest possible vertical expandable prosthetic titanium ribs application. Flexible deformities below 60 degrees, with normal spinal anatomy and without thoracic involvement, benefit from serial Mehta casting which revived as a long available but not-used strategy. In case of progression, standard double growing rods or-if available, affordable, and applicable-magnetically controlled motorized rods provide deformity control and growth promotion. Shilla growth-guiding technique is a less costly alternative. Its lack of stiff lengthening boxes or actuators may be beneficial in difficult deformities. Anterior convex flexible tethering promises benefits of sparing the trunk muscles and keeping mobility. However, this step towards a true nonfusion concept has yet to stand the test of broad clinical application.

A software program to measure the three-dimensional length of the spine from radiographic images: Validation and reliability assessment for adolescent idiopathic scoliosis

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVE

The aim of this study was to validate a new program which aims at measuring the three-dimensional length of the spine's midline based on two calibrated orthogonal radiographic images. The traditional uniplanar T1-S1 measurement method is not reflecting the actual three dimensional curvature of a scoliotic spine and is therefore not accurate. The Spinal Measurement Software (SMS) is an alternative to conveniently measure the true spine's length.

METHODS

The validity, inter- and intra-observer variability and usability of the program were evaluated. The usability was quantified based on a subjective questionnaire filled by eight participants using the program for the first time. The validity and variability were assessed by comparing the length of five phantom spines measured based on CT-scan data and on radiographic images with the SMS. The lengths were measured independently by each participant using both techniques.

RESULTS

The SMS is easy and intuitive to use, even for non-clinicians. The SMS measured spinal length with an error below 2 millimeters compared to length obtained using CT scan datasets. The inter- and intra-observer variability of the SMS measurements was below 5 millimeters.

CONCLUSIONS

The SMS provides accurate measurement of the spinal length based on orthogonal radiographic images. The software is easy to use and could easily integrate the clinical workflow and replace current approximations of the spinal length based on a single radiographic image such as the traditional T1-S1 measurement.