Fatal falls involving stairs: an anthropological analysis of skeletal trauma

A retrospective study of the injury patterns seen in fatal falls downstairs

INTRODUCTION

Fatal falls involving stairs are often associated with advanced age, intoxication, acute natural pathology and less commonly - the involvement of a third-party. The injury patterns seen in these cases are often complex and from a medico-legal standpoint, determining third-party involvement based on pathology alone can prove a significant challenge. Classifying the manner of death in such cases, can become particularly complex when the injury pattern appears inconsistent with a simple fall downstairs, or there is an absence of eye-witness testimony.

AIM

To explore the circumstances and injury patterns seen in cases of fatal falls downstairs which were classified as accidental vs. undetermined by the coroners.

STUDY DESIGN

This retrospective study explored the injury patterns present in all cases of fatal falls downstairs referred to the Office of the State Pathologist (OSP) over a 10-year-period (2012-2022) (n = 51).

RESULTS

Fatal falls downstairs which were classified as undetermined were found to have a greater number of craniofacial fractures, spinal fractures and intracranial injuries when compared to accidental falls. Undetermined staircase deaths also displayed more significant fracturing involving the facial skeleton.

CONCLUSION

Ultimately, where there is a question of third-party involvement, the Post-Mortem Examination (PME) findings alone cannot determine the manner of death. The pathologist's examination may identify injuries that are inconsistent with a simple fall downstairs, but it is the coroner who must conduct a thorough investigation into the circumstances of the fatal fall and ultimately determine the classification of the death.

Effect of gait types and external weight carrying strategies on the femoral neck strains during stair descent

Gait and weight carrying method may change the femoral neck load during stair descent. Applying specific gait and weight carrying methods may reduce the femoral neck load during stair descent, which may reduce hip pain, hip pain related falls and fall related fractures for the older population. The purpose of this study was to test the effect of different gait types (step-over-step v.s. step-by-step) and external weight carrying strategies (ipsilateral v.s. contralateral side) on the femoral neck load, discover which method could reduce the femoral neck load effectively. Seventeen healthy adults from 50 to 70 yrs old were recruited. The kinematic and kinetic analysis, musculoskeletal modelling method were used to estimate the joint and muscle loads for the lower extremities. Finite element analysis was used with the femur model to calculate the femoral neck strains during stair descent with different gait types and weight carrying strategies. The compressive strains were reduced for step-by-step gait method than step-over-step (p<0.015, 12.3-17.4% decrease of strains), the tensile strains were significantly increased for the trailing leg of step-by-step than the leading leg (p<0.001, 24.7% increase of strains). Contralateral weight carrying increased compressive and tensile strains than ipsilateral (p<0.001, 9.9-24.5% increase of strains) in most conditions. Applying step-by-step method and avoiding contralateral side weight carrying could be effective to reduce femoral neck strains. These outcomes could be helpful for the older population to reduce the risks of hip pain, femoral neck pain or pain related falls and fractures.

Investigation of injuries sustained from falls down stairs

Interpretation of injuries sustained from fatal falls involving stairs is a challenge encountered by death investigation teams regularly. The high incidence of this occurrence is because stairs are a common entity in society. Without a medical evaluation of an individual's injuries, it is difficult to determine whether a fall from stairs contributed to how the individual died. The purpose of this study is to characterize the injuries of individuals that were sustained from a confirmed fatal fall involving stairs within our jurisdiction (Ontario, Canada) during 2014-2020. In a retrospective cross-sectional observation study, we examined 159 cases using both postmortem imaging and routine autopsy approaches. Our findings showed the head was the most common anatomical region injured. The most common injuries observed in the head included skull fracture(s) (most commonly the temporal, parietal and occipital bones), subarachnoid hemorrhages, and brain contusions. Anatomical regions less commonly injured included the extremities, thorax, and pelvis. This study identified an association between the presence of intracranial hemorrhage and those 65-years-old and younger; brain injury in the absence of pre-existing medical conditions; and brain injury for individuals that had a blood alcohol concentration between 0 and 80mg/100 mL. Extracranial skeletal trauma, as defined by skeletal trauma apart from the head region, was observed in 62% of cases. Extracranial skeletal trauma was also found to be strongly associated with individuals over 65-years-old. Overall, our study affirms that traumatic head injury is the primary cause of death from falls down stairs. Also, we provide information on rare injuries from falls down stairs, and indirectly, identify which body locations appear protected from injury during falls. These findings may aid in the interpretation of whether injuries in this setting are compatible with accidental or non-accidental trauma.

A comparative study of the injury pattern between suicidal and accidental falls from height in Northern Tunisia

BACKGROUND

Falls from height are a common cause of marbidity and mortality. The aim of this study is to examine the characteristics of the victims, the circumstances of the fall and distribution of the injuries of accidental and suicidal falls from height.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

It was a retrospective cross-sectional study, based on autopsies performed over 16 years (January 2005 to December 2020). The recorded variables included demographic data of the victim, height of fall, death scene findings, length of hospital stay, autopsy findings, and toxicological results.

RESULTS

Of the 753 victims of fall from height, 607 were fallers and 146 were jumpers. We found that male victims were predominant in the accidental group (86.8% vs. 69.2%). The mean age at death was 43.6 ± 17.9 years. Suicidal falls occurred in a private house in the majority of cases (70.5%), while accidental falls occurred most frequently at workplace (43.8%). Suicidal falls were higher than accidental falls (10.4 ± 7.3 m vs. 7.1 ± 5.7 m). Injuries in the thorax, abdomen, pelvis, upper and lower extremities were more frequentl in the suicidal falls group. Pelvic fractures were 2.1 times more likely to occur in the suicidal falls. Head injuries were more frequent in the accidental falls group. The survival delay was shorter in the suicidal falls group.

CONCLUSIONS

our study highlights the differences in the profile of the victims and in the pattern of injuries caused by falls from height, depending on the victim's intention to fall.

Assessment of Cervical Skeletal Trauma: The Synergistic Contribution of Forensic and Clinical Medicine to a Case of Corpse Concealment

Fatal neck injuries represent a major challenge in forensic pathology because the anatomical complexity and high variability of neck structures make it often extremely difficult to differentiate true pathological findings from artifacts at autopsy. This topic becomes even more relevant when the forensic pathologist is required to make a pathophysiological evaluation of bone fractures in the absence of soft tissue to support the diagnosis. We report a case of unidentified, stone-covered, skeletonized human remains found within a pit below an abandoned building with bony lesions of the cervical spine and ribs, including a full-thickness fracture of the right lateral mass of the atlas (C1). After a careful study of the fractures was carried out by screening forensic literature and anthropological studies, clinical neurosurgical expertise was called upon to provide a reliable explanation. A rapid and violent twisting of the neck in the opposite direction from the fracture site by an attacker who pinned the victim's torso is the scenario that most likely occurred in our case. This case report shows that the diagnosis of cervical spine injuries in skeletal remains should be the result of a multidisciplinary approach that integrates forensic, anthropological, and clinical expertise.

Blows or Falls? Distinction by Random Forest Classification

In this study, we propose a classification method between falls and blows using random forests. In total, 400 anonymized patients presenting with fractures from falls or blows aged between 20 and 49 years old were used. There were 549 types of fractures for 57 bones and 12 anatomical regions observed. We first tested various models according to the sensibility of random forest parameters and their effects on model accuracies. The best model was based on the binary coding of 12 anatomical regions or 28 bones with or without baseline (age and sex). Our method achieved the highest accuracy rate of 83% in the distinction between falls and blows. Our findings pave the way for applications to help forensic experts and archaeologists.

A 13-Year Study of Fatal Falls From Height in Northern Tunisia

INTRODUCTION

Falls from height are a major cause of unintentional injury death, resulting in high disability and mortality. We investigated the characteristics of fatal falls and their relationship with intentionality, injury patterns, and death on impact.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

In this retrospective study, we examined 545 cases of fatal falls from height that underwent autopsy in the forensic department of the Charles Nicolle hospital of Tunis (Tunisia) between January 2008 and December 2020. Cases were reviewed in terms of demographics, fall characteristics, and autopsy findings.

RESULTS

The population was predominately male (86.6%). Four hundred twenty-one (77.3%) originated from accidents, 120 (22%) were found to be suicidal, with 4 homicide cases. A notable decline in cases was noticed following the Jasmine revolution, 2011 (R squared = 0.8). The mean height of falls was 8 m. Higher falls were associated with a set of organ-specific injuries. Organ injury pattern did not differ based on intentionality. Female victims were 2.4 times more likely to sustain pelvic injuries than males. The majority of victims deceased before reaching health care structures. Death on impact was strongly associated with higher falls, cranial impact, and organ-specific injuries, including cardiac, pulmonary, and skull injuries.Falls from height are in many cases preventable. A clearly defined fall safety policy, strict implementation of evidence-based interventions, efficient allocation of resources, and raising safety awareness must to be urgently implemented.

CONCLUSION

Understanding patterns of injury and the factors that influence death on impact may be of further interest in the prevention and management of survivors in the acute period.

Finite element analysis of femoral neck strains during stair ascent and descent

For older population, a better understanding of the hip joint loading environment is needed for the prevention of hip pain, and the reduction of the stress fractures and fall risks. Using the motion analysis and inverse dynamics methods, combined with musculoskeletal modelling, static optimization, and finite element (FE) femur model, the difference of femoral neck strains between stair ascent vs. descent, young vs. older populations was compared. A two-way repeated-measures MANOVA was applied to test the effect of age and stair direction on the femoral neck strains. The strains at the femoral neck cross-section were greater for stair descent than ascent for both age groups (mostly P = 0.001 to 0006) but there was no difference between age groups. In this study, femoral neck strains represented bone loading environment in more direct ways than joint reaction forces/moments or joint contact forces, the risk of hip pain, falls and stress fractures might be greater during stair descent than ascent. Possible preventative methods to reduce these risks should be developed in the future studies.

An evaluation of the differences in paediatric skeletal trauma between fatal simple short falls and physical abuse blunt impact loads: An international multicentre pilot study

In cases where a deceased child exhibits trauma as a result of a physical abuse blunt impact load, a parent/caregiver may provide a simple short fall (SSF) as the justification for that trauma. The skeletal fractures remain difficult to differentiate between a SSF and physical abuse however, as both are the result of a blunt impact load, and are therefore biomechanically alike, and the rare nature of these fatalities means only anecdotal research has been available to validate such claims. The aim of this pilot study was to investigate if there may be differences in the skeletal fracture patterns and types resulting from SSFs compared with those resulting from physical abuse blunt impacts. Paediatric (<10 years) cases of fatal SSFs (≤1.5 m) and physical abuse were collected from the Victorian Institute of Forensic Medicine (Australia), Institut Médico-Légal de Paris (France), University of Pretoria (South Africa) and Great Ormond Street Hospital (England). For each case the intrinsic and extrinsic variables were recorded from medico-legal reports and skeletal trauma was documented using post-mortem computed tomography scans and/or skeletal surveys. Three SSFs and 18 physical abuse cases were identified. Of the SSF cases, two exhibited fractures; both of which were simple linear neurocranial fractures. Comparatively, 12 of the physical abuse cases exhibited fractures and these were distributed across the skeleton; 58% located only in the skull, 17% only in the post-cranial and 25% located in both. Skull fracture types were single linear, multiple linear and comminuted. This pilot study suggests, anecdotally, there may be differences in the fracture patterns and types between blunt impact loads resulting from a SSF and physical abuse. This data will form the foundation of the Registry of Paediatric Fatal Fractures (RPFF) which, with further multicentre contributions, would allow this finding to be validated.

An Anthropological Examination of the Types of Skeletal Fractures Resulting from Fatal High (˃3 m) Free Falls

Fatal falls from heights (˃3 m) often result in blunt force trauma (BFT) to the skeleton. The fracture patterns that result from this BFT mechanism are well understood in forensic anthropology and forensic pathology; however, details of the specific types of fractures that result remain poorly documented. The aim of this study was to provide a detailed examination of the types of fractures that may result from fatal high falls. Fractures were recorded from 95 full-body postmortem computed tomography scans of individuals known to have died from a high fall. Trauma was then analyzed taking into account the extrinsic and intrinsic variables known to influence a fall using multiple logistic regression. A total of 339 types of fractures were classified, of which 16 were significantly associated with this BFT mechanism. Classified fracture types will augment anthropological interpretations of the circumstances of death from BFT in cases of suspected high falls.