Evaluation of GENESIS-BCP™ scaffold composed of hydroxyapatite and β-tricalcium phosphate on bone formation

Beyond hype: unveiling the Real challenges in clinical translation of 3D printed bone scaffolds and the fresh prospects of bioprinted organoids

Bone defects pose significant challenges in healthcare, with over 2 million bone repair surgeries performed globally each year. As a burgeoning force in the field of bone tissue engineering, 3D printing offers novel solutions to traditional bone transplantation procedures. However, current 3D-printed bone scaffolds still face three critical challenges in material selection, printing methods, cellular self-organization and co-culture, significantly impeding their clinical application. In this comprehensive review, we delve into the performance criteria that ideal bone scaffolds should possess, with a particular focus on the three core challenges faced by 3D printing technology during clinical translation. We summarize the latest advancements in non-traditional materials and advanced printing techniques, emphasizing the importance of integrating organ-like technologies with bioprinting. This combined approach enables more precise simulation of natural tissue structure and function. Our aim in writing this review is to propose effective strategies to address these challenges and promote the clinical translation of 3D-printed scaffolds for bone defect treatment.

A biphasic calcium phosphate/acylated methacrylate gelatin composite hydrogel promotes osteogenesis and bone repair

PURPOSE/AIM

Bone defects caused by trauma, tumors, congenital malformation, or inflammation are very common in orthopedics. In recent years, mimicking the composition and structure of natural bone tissue has become a hot topic in biomaterial research, with the aim of developing an ideal biomaterial for bone defect transplantation. Here, the feasibility of a biphasic calcium phosphate (BCP)/acylated methacrylate gelatin (GelMA) composite hydrogel to repair bone defects was evaluated in vitro and in rats.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

The biocompatibility of a biphasic calcium phosphate (BCP)/acylated methacrylate gelatin (GelMA) composite hydrogel was evaluated by cytoskeleton staining, live/dead cell staining and cell proliferation assays. The in vitro osteogenic activities of the composite hydrogel were evaluated by alkaline phosphatase and alizarin red staining, as well as osteogenic gene expression analysis at both transcript and protein levels. The in vivo bone repair activities were evaluated using the rat skull defect model.

RESULTS

The BCP/GelMA composite hydrogel displayed excellent biocompatibility and promoted osteogenesis of bone marrow mesenchymal stem cells in vitro. In addition, the BCP/GelMA composite hydrogel markedly promoted new bone formation in the rat skull-defect model.

CONCLUSIONS

BCP/GelMA composite hydrogel may be an effective artificial material for bone tissue engineering.

Applying extrusion-based 3D printing technique accelerates fabricating complex biphasic calcium phosphate-based scaffolds for bone tissue regeneration

•

Biphasic calcium phosphates offer a chemically similar biomaterial to the natural bone, which can significantly accelerate bone formation and reconstruction.

•

Robocasting is a suitable technique to produce porous scaffolds supporting cell viability, proliferation, and differentiation.

•

This review discusses materials and methods utilized for BCP robocasting, considering recent advancements and existing challenges in using additives for bioink preparation.

•

Commercialization and marketing approach, in-vitro and in-vivo evaluations, biologic responses, and post-processing steps are also investigated.

•

Possible strategies and opportunities for the use of BCP toward injured bone regeneration along with clinical applications are discussed.

•

The study proposes that BCP possesses an acceptable level of bone substituting, considering its challenges and struggles.

Background

Aim of review

Key scientific concepts of review

Dental alloplastic bone substitutes currently available in Korea

As dental implant surgery and bone grafts were widely operated in Korean dentist, many bone substitutes are commercially available, currently. For commercially used in Korea, all bone substitutes are firstly evaluated by the Ministry of Health and Welfare (MOHW) for safety and efficacy of the product. After being priced, classified, and registration by the Health Insurance Review and Assessment Service (HIRA), the post-application management is obligatory for the manufacturer (or representative importer) to receive a certificate of Good Manufacturing Practice by Ministry of Food and Drug Safety. Currently, bone substitutes are broadly classified into C group (bone union and fracture fixation), T group (human tissue), L group (general and dental material) and non-insurance material group in MOHW notification No. 2018-248. Among them, bone substitutes classified as dental materials (L7) are divided as xenograft and alloplastic bone graft. The purpose of this paper is to analyze alloplastic bone substitutes of 37 products in MOHW notification No. 2018-248 and to evaluate the reference level based on the ISI Web of Knowledge, PubMed, EMBASE (1980–2019), Cochrane Database, and Google Scholar using the criteria of registered or trademarked product name.

Migration of alloplastic bone graft material in infected conditions: a case study and animal experiment

PURPOSE

Distant migration associated with sinus lifting procedures has not been investigated. In the present study, a case of distant migration of graft material was observed, and the potential mechanisms of migration were analyzed using material analysis and in vivo experiments.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

The migrated graft material was biphasic calcium phosphate-based alloplastic material (BCP), and its physical properties were compared with those of xenogenic material (Bio-Oss). The comparisons of the physical properties were performed using scanning electronic microscopic, x-ray diffraction, and Fourier-transform infrared absorbance spectra analysis. The comparative graft migration study was performed using the subcutaneous pocket model in rats (n = 10). The clinical case was analyzed by histologic section and energy dispersive x-ray (EDX) microanalysis.

RESULTS

The observed diffraction patterns from the Bio-Oss revealed characteristic diffractions for the hydroxyapatite phase, and those from the BCP revealed additional diffractions that could be assigned to the tricalcium phosphate phase. In the animal model, the graft migration distances observed in the BCP group were significantly greater than those observed in the Bio-Oss group (P = .012). In the clinical case, the lymphatic vessels of the submandibular gland contained foreign materials that were morphologically similar to those of the maxillary sinus. EDX microanalysis revealed that the particles in the lymphatic vessels exhibited calcium concentrations that were approximately 200 times greater than those in the adjacent glandular tissue.

CONCLUSIONS

In the present study, BCP-based sinus grafts had migrated into the submandibular glandular area by way of the lymphatic chain in the presented clinical case.