Development of robust, fast and efficient QRS complex detector: a methodological review

Machine learning based hybrid anomaly detection technique for automatic diagnosis of cardiovascular diseases using cardiac sympathetic nerve activity and electrocardiogram

OBJECTIVES

Coronary artery diseases (CADs) are the leading cause of death worldwide and early diagnosis is crucial for timely treatment. To address this, our study presents a novel automated Artificial Intelligence (AI)-based Hybrid Anomaly Detection (AIHAD) technique that combines various signal processing, feature extraction, supervised, and unsupervised machine learning methods. By jointly and simultaneously analyzing 12-lead cardiac sympathetic nerve activity (CSNA) and electrocardiogram (ECG) data, the automated AIHAD technique performs fast, early, and accurate diagnosis of CADs.

METHODS

In order to develop and evaluate the proposed automated AIHAD technique, we utilized the fully labeled STAFF III and PTBD databases, which contain the 12-lead wideband raw recordings non-invasively acquired from 260 subjects. Using these wideband raw recordings, we developed a signal processing technique that simultaneously detects the 12-lead CSNA and ECG signals of all subjects. Using the pre-processed 12-lead CSNA and ECG signals, we developed a time-domain feature extraction technique that extracts the statistical CSNA and ECG features critical for the reliable diagnosis of CADs. Using the extracted discriminative features, we developed a supervised classification technique based on Artificial Neural Networks (ANNs) that simultaneously detects anomalies in the 12-lead CSNA and ECG data. Furthermore, we developed an unsupervised clustering technique based on Gaussian mixture models (GMMs) and Neyman-Pearson criterion, which robustly detects outliers corresponding to CADs.

RESULTS

Using the automated AIHAD technique, we have, for the first time, demonstrated a significant association between the increase in CSNA signals and anomalies in ECG signals during CADs. The AIHAD technique achieved highly reliable detection of CADs with a sensitivity of 98.48 %, specificity of 97.73 %, accuracy of 98.11 %, positive predictive value of 97.74 %, negative predictive value of 98.47 %, and F1-score of 98.11 %. Hence, the automated AIHAD technique demonstrates superior performance compared to the gold standard diagnostic test ECG in the diagnosis of CADs. Additionally, it outperforms other techniques developed in this study that separately utilize either only CSNA data or only ECG data. Therefore, it significantly increases the detection performance of CADs by taking advantage of the diversity in different data types and leveraging their strengths. Furthermore, its performance is comparatively better than that of most previously proposed machine and deep learning methods that exclusively used ECG data to diagnose or classify CADs. Additionally, it has a very low implementation time, which is highly desirable for real-time detection of CADs.

CONCLUSIONS

The proposed automated AIHAD technique may serve as an efficient decision-support system to increase physicians' success in fast, early, and accurate diagnosis of CADs. It may be highly beneficial and valuable, particularly for asymptomatic patients, for whom the diagnostic information provided by ECG alone is not sufficient to reliably diagnose the disease. Hence, it may significantly improve patient outcomes by enabling timely treatments and considerably reducing the mortality of cardiovascular diseases (CVDs).

Precise detection and localization of R-peaks from ECG signals

Heart rate variability (HRV) is derived from the R-R interval, which depends on the precise localization of R-peaks within an electrocardiogram (ECG) signal. However, current algorithm assessment methods prioritize the R-peak detection's sensitivity rather than the precision of pinpointing the exact R-peak positions. As a result, it is of great value to develop an R-peak detection algorithm with high-precision R-peak localization. This paper introduces a novel R-peak localization algorithm that involves modifications to the well-established Pan-Tompkins (PT) algorithm. The algorithm was implemented as follows. First, the raw ECG signal $ X\left(i\right) $ was band-pass filtered (5-35 Hz) to obtain a preprocessed signal $ Y\left(i\right) $. Second, $ Y\left(i\right) $ was squared to enhance the QRS complex, followed by a 5 Hz low-pass filter to obtain the QRS envelope, which was transformed into a window signal $ W\left(i\right) $ by dynamic threshold with a minimum width of 200 ms to mark the QRS complex. Third, $ Y\left(i\right) $ was used to generate QRS template $ T\left(n\right) $ automatically, and then the R-peak was identified by a template matching process to find the maximum absolute value of all cross-correlation values between $ T\left(n\right) $ and $ Y\left(i\right) $. The proposed algorithm achieved a sensitivity (SE) of 99.78%, a positive prediction value (PPV) of 99.78% and data error rate (DER) of 0.44% in R-peak localization for the MIT-BIH Arrhythmia database. The annotated-detected error (ADE), which represents the error between the annotated R-peak location and the detected R-peak location, was 8.35 ms for the MIT-BIH Arrhythmia database. These results outperformed the results obtained using the classical Pan-Tompkins algorithm which yielded an SE of 98.87%, a PPV of 99.14%, a DER of 1.98% and an ADE of 21.65 ms for the MIT-BIH Arrhythmia database. It can be concluded that the algorithm can precisely detect the location of R-peaks and may have the potential to enhance clinical applications of HRV analysis.

Cuffless Hypertension Detection using Swarm Support Vector Machine Utilizing Photoplethysmogram and Electrocardiogram

Background

Hypertension is associated with severe complications, and its detection is important to provide early information about a hypertension event, which is essential to prevent further complications.

Objective

This study aimed to investigate a strategy for hypertension detection without a cuff using parameters of bioelectric signals, i.e., Electrocardiogram (ECG), Photoplethysmogram (PPG,) and an algorithm of Swarm-based Support Vector Machine (SSVM).

Material and Methods

This experimental study was conducted to develop a hypertension detection system. ECG and PPG bioelectrical records were collected from the Medical Information Mart for Intensive Care (MIMIC) from normal and hypertension participants and processed to find the parameters, used for the inputs of SSVM and comprised Pulse Arrival Time (PAT) and the characteristics of PPG signal derivatives. The SSVM was n Support Vector Machine (SVM) algorithm optimized using particle swarm optimization with Quantum Delta-potential-well (QDPSO). The SSVMs with different inputs were investigated to find the optimal detection performance.

Results

The proposed strategy was performed at 96% in terms of F1-score, accuracy, sensitivity, and specificity with better performance than the other methods tested and methods and also could develop a cuff-free hypertension monitoring system.

Conclusion

Hypertension using SSVM, ECG, and PPG parameters is acceptably performed. The hypertension detection had lower performance utilizing only PPG than both ECG and PPG.

A Deep Learning Architecture Using 3D Vectorcardiogram to Detect R-Peaks in ECG with Enhanced Precision

Providing reliable detection of QRS complexes is key in automated analyses of electrocardiograms (ECG). Accurate and timely R-peak detections provide a basis for ECG-based diagnoses and to synchronize radiologic, electrophysiologic, or other medical devices. Compared with classical algorithms, deep learning (DL) architectures have demonstrated superior accuracy and high generalization capacity. Furthermore, they can be embedded on edge devices for real-time inference. 3D vectorcardiograms (VCG) provide a unifying framework for detecting R-peaks regardless of the acquisition strategy or number of ECG leads. In this article, a DL architecture was demonstrated to provide enhanced precision when trained and applied on 3D VCG, with no pre-processing nor post-processing steps. Experiments were conducted on four different public databases. Using the proposed approach, high F1-scores of 99.80% and 99.64% were achieved in leave-one-out cross-validation and cross-database validation protocols, respectively. False detections, measured by a precision of 99.88% or more, were significantly reduced compared with recent state-of-the-art methods tested on the same databases, without penalty in the number of missed peaks, measured by a recall of 99.39% or more. This approach can provide new applications for devices where precision, or positive predictive value, is essential, for instance cardiac magnetic resonance imaging.

Algorithm for Mobile Platform-Based Real-Time QRS Detection

Recent advancements in smart, wearable technologies have allowed the detection of various medical conditions. In particular, continuous collection and real-time analysis of electrocardiogram data have enabled the early identification of pathologic cardiac rhythms. Various algorithms to assess cardiac rhythms have been developed, but these utilize excessive computational power. Therefore, adoption to mobile platforms requires more computationally efficient algorithms that do not sacrifice correctness. This study presents a modified QRS detection algorithm, the AccYouRate Modified Pan-Tompkins (AMPT), which is a simplified version of the well-established Pan-Tompkins algorithm. Using archived ECG data from a variety of publicly available datasets, relative to the Pan-Tompkins, the AMPT algorithm demonstrated improved computational efficiency by 5-20×, while also universally enhancing correctness, both of which favor translation to a mobile platform for continuous, real-time QRS detection.

An enhanced T-wave delineation method using phasor transform in the electrocardiogram

Accurate detection of key components plays a vital role in determining cardiovascular diseases in the ECG. In this method, we propose an enhanced T-wave delineation method using the phasor transform. Discrete Wavelet Transform (DWT) and median filters were used to suppress the high-frequency noise and baseline drift during pre-processing. The phasor transform was used to detect and locate the delineation points before and after the T-wave. The proposed method was tested on the QTDB for R-peak, T-peak, and T_offdetection. It achieved both sensitivity (Se%) and positive predictivity (+P%) values of 100 for R-peak detection. In T-peak detection, method shows Se % = 99.46 and +P % = 99.54, respectively. This method has reported Se% = 99.34 and +P% = 99.48 for T_offdetection in the ECG. The achieved results show that the method can be used for cardiac arrhythmia detection related to the morphology of T-wave.

A novel and lightweight P, QRS, and T peaks detector using adaptive thresholding and template waveform

Accurate detection of key components in an electrocardiogram (ECG) plays a vital role in identifying cardiovascular diseases. In this work, we proposed a novel and lightweight P, QRS, and T peaks detector using adaptive thresholding and template waveform. In the first stage, we proposed a QRS complex detector, which utilises a novel adaptive thresholding process followed by threshold initialisation. Moreover, false positive QRS complexes were removed using the kurtosis coefficient computation. In the second stage, the ECG segment from the S wave point to the Q wave point was extracted for clustering. The template waveform was generated from the cluster members using the ensemble average method, interpolation, and resampling. Next, a novel conditional thresholding process was used to calculate the threshold values based on the template waveform morphology for P and T peaks detection. Finally, the min-max functions were used to detect the P and T peaks. The proposed technique was applied to the MIT-BIH arrhythmia database (MIT-AD) and the QT database for QRS detection and validation. Sensitivity (Se%) values of 99.81 and 99.90 and positive predictivity (+P%) values of 99.85 and 99.94 were obtained for the MIT-AD and QT database for QRS complex detection, respectively. Further, we found that Se% = 96.50 and +P% = 96.08 for the P peak detection, Se% = 100 and +P% = 100 for the R peak detection, and Se% = 99.54 and +P% = 99.68 for the T peak detection when using the manually annotated QT database. The proposed technique exhibits low computational complexity and can be implemented on low-cost hardware, since it is based on simple decision rules rather than a heuristic approach.

Exploratory data analysis based efficient QRS-complex detection technique with minimal computational load

Detection of QRS-complex in the electrocardiogram (ECG) plays a decisive role in cardiac disorder detection. We face many challenges in terms of powerline interference, baseline drift, and abnormal varying peaks. In this work, we propose an exploratory data analysis (EDA) based efficient QRS-complex detection technique with minimal computational load. This paper includes median and moving average filter for pre-processing of the ECG. The peak of filtered ECG is enhanced to third power of the signal. The root mean square (rms) of the signal is estimated for the decision making rule. This technique adapted the new concept for isoelectric line identification and EDA based QRS-complex detection. In this paper, total 10,70,981 beats were used for validation from MIT BIH-Arrhythmia Database (MIT-BIH), Fantasia Database (FDB), European ST-T database (ESTD), a self recorded dataset (SDB), and fetal ECG database (FTDB). Overall sensitivity of 99.65 % and positive predictivity rate of 99.84 % have been achieved. The proposed technique doesn't require selection, setting, and training for QRS-complex detection. Thus, this paper presents a QRS-complex detection technique based on simple decision rules.

A novel adaptive window based technique for T wave detection and delineation in the ECG

The electrocardiogram (ECG) morphology determines the overall activity of the heart and is the most widely used tool in the diagnostic processes. T wave is a crucial wave component that reveals very useful information regarding various cardiac disorders. In this paper we have proposed a novel T wave detection technique based on adaptive window and simple decision rule. The proposed technique uses two-stage median filters followed by the Savitzky-Golay filter at the pre-processing stage to remove the noises in the ECG signal. The QRS complex is detected for locating the T wave as a reference in one ECG cycle. An R-R interval based window is considered for detecting the T wave, and decision logic depends on the iso-electric line value. The proposed technique is tested on the QT database and self-recorded dataset for its performance evaluation. In the present work, the results achieved for T wave detection sensitivity (Se), positive predictivity (+P), detection error rate (DER), and accuracy (Acc) on the QT database are Se = 97.57%, +P = 99.63%, DER = 2.78%, and Acc = 97.22% with an average time error of (3.468 ± 5.732) ms. The proposed technique shows Se = 99.94%, +P = 99.94%, DER = 0.01%, and Acc = 99.89% on the self-recorded dataset. The proposed technique is also capable of detecting both the upward and downward T wave efficiently in the ECG signal.