Pseudomalfunction of a Beall mitral valve prosthesis in the presence of paravalvular aortic regurgitation

Noninvasive evaluation of normal and abnormal prosthetic valve function

Noninvasive techniques are helpful in evaluating the function of mechanical prostheses and tissue valves. Combined phonocardiography and M-mode echocardiography together with cinefluoroscopy are the most useful noninvasive techniques in differentiating normal from abnormal metallic prosthetic valve function. The intensity of the opening and closing clicks and associated murmurs will depend on the type of prosthetic valve, the heart rate and rhythm and the underlying hemodynamic status. Arrhythmias or conduction disturbances, or both, may produce motion patterns that mimic some of the echocardiographic signs of malfunctioning prosthetic valves. Differentiation of thrombus formation or tissue ingrowth from paravalvular regurgitation or dehiscence is possible by noninvasive techniques. Disc variance, a potentially serious and lethal problem with the older Beall valves, can be readily detected by cinefluoroscopy and echophonocardiography. With regard to bioprosthetic valves, two-dimensional echocardiography is superior to M-mode echocardiography in detecting primary valve failure. In addition, detection of vegetations, valve alignment and ring and individual leaflet motion can be best accomplished by two-dimensional echocardiography. Of greater importance is the patient serving as his or her own control in the follow-up assessment of prosthetic valve function by noninvasive techniques.

Prosthetic mitral valve motion during cardiac dysrhythmias as determined by echocardiography

To assess the changes and physiologic mechanisms of prosthetic valve motion during cardiac dysrhythmias as well as the role of atrial systole in the closure of the mitral valve, M-mode echocardiography was performed in 36 patients with normally functioning prosthetic mitral valves (Björk-Shiley, Starr-Edwards, and Beall valve). Premature closure of the prosthetic mitral valve in diastole with a "sharp" closing motion was seen during first-degree atrioventricular block, atrial fibrillation with ventricular rates less than 60 beats/min, and atrial flutter. A "rounded" premature valve closure due to atrial systole was seen during atrial tachycardia and complete heart block. Atrial systole initiates a closing motion of the prosthetic mitral valve at end-diastole, and ventricular systole completes this closure during normal sinus rhythm. When first-degree atrioventricular block is present, atrial systole alone completes this closure before ventricular contraction. Atrial contraction alone also can effectively close the prosthetic mitral valve during atrial flutter and atrial tachycardia. Other factors (such as left ventricular diastolic volume) may play a role in the effective closure of the prosthetic mitral valve during atrial fibrillation with slow ventricular rates and complete heart block. These findings must be considered in the echocardiographic evaluation of suspected malfunctioning prosthetic mitral valves. A baseline postoperative echocardiogram after prosthesis insertion is important for future evaluation when clinically indicated.

Premature closure of prosthetic mitral valves as a consequence of gravity

To determine the influence of gravity on premature closure of prosthetic mitral valves, we studied 17 patients in whom this phenomenon had been observed during routine examination. All patients were in atrial fibrillation and none had aortic incompetence. Patients were studied in multiple positions by means of simultaneous echocardiography, phonocardiography, and cinefluoroscopy. In all patients premature closure was observed when the atrial side of the prosthesis was below the ventricular side, resulting in a downward motion of the occluder inside the valve cage. When patients were studied in positions in which the atrial side of the valve was higher that the ventricular side, premature closure never occurred, even during extremely prolonged diastolic periods. Since minor positional changes, which were found to determine whether premature closure occurred or not, are unlikely to produce significant alterations in pressure and flow across the mitral orifice during diastole, we conclude that position-dependent premature closure of prosthetic mitral valves in patients with atrial fibrillation is best explained by the effect of gravity on the prosthetic occluder. Examination of such patients in multiple positions should be helpful in distinguishing premature valve closure caused by aortic regurgitation from gravity-related presystolic closure. Inability to produce premature closure in patients in whom it had previously been demonstrated in the presence of similar R-R intervals may even prove useful in diagnosing new orifice obstruction.

Mitral valve closure in atrial flutter

12 patients who had atrial flutter without clinical, echocardiographic or angiographic evidence of aortic insufficiency were studied with simultaneous echo- and phonocardiograms. In patients with high-grade atrioventricular (AV) block, the mitral valve opened and closed with each flutter wave. Of seven patients, two had persistent and five had intermittent early mitral valve closure before QRS inscription. In five patients (three with 2:1 AV block) the mitral valve closed on time. In one patient with a mitral valve prosthesis, echocardiography and cinefluorography demonstrated closure during mid-diastole, with reopening in late diastole after a flutter wave. Final valve closure occurred before the onset of the QRS, and each closure was associated with a click. Simultaneous phonocardiographic analysis in these patients demonstrated that the first heart sound intensity was inversely related to the degree of mitral valve preclosure. This relationship was independent of the length of the RR interval. Thus, atrial flutter independent of any other cause of abnormal hemodynamics may produce early mitral valve closure. The echocardiographic finding of premature mitral arrhythmias, may not have the same diagnostic or prognostic significance previously described in patients with sinus rhythm and normal AV conduction.