Usefulness of severity of myocardial ischemia on exercise testing in predicting the severity of myocardial ischemia during daily activities

ST segment depression in hypertensive patients: a comparison of exercise test versus Holter ECG

Introduction:

This study compared ST segment depression (ST depression) during cycle ergometry (ergometry) versus simultaneous 24-hour ambulatory blood pressure measurement and electrocardiogram recording (24-h ABPM/ECG) during everyday life.

Methods:

In a German multicenter study, ergometry and 24-h ABPM/ECG records of 239 hypertensive patients were retrospectively analyzed. ST depression was defined as an ST segment depression (1 mm limb or chest recordings V1 to V6) in an incremental cycle ergometry, or 1 mm in the 24-h ABPM/ECG recording under everyday conditions. Blood pressure parameters at the onset of ST depression in the context of the respective method were compared.

Results:

18 patients had ST depression only in ergometry (group B), 23 had ST depression only during 24-h ABPM/ECG monitoring (group C) and 28 patients had ST depression with both methods (group D). Group A had no ST depression with any method. In group D, at the onset of ST depression with 24-h ABPM/ECG investigation, all parameters except diastolic blood pressure were significantly lower compared with the corresponding parameters at the onset of ST depression with ergometry (systolic blood pressure: 148 ± 19 vers 188 ± 35 mmHg, p × 0.001; heart rate: 93 ± 12 vs 120 ± 21 beat/min, p < 0.0001; double product: 13,714 ± 2315 vs 22,992 ± 3,985 mmHg/min), p < 0.0001).

Conclusion:

ST depressions during everyday life detected by 24-h ABPM/ECG are characterized by a substantially lower triggering threshold for blood pressure level parameters compared with ergometry. The two methods detecting ischemia do not replace but complement each other.

Value and limitations of ambulatory ECG monitoring for assessment of myocardial ischemia

Ambulatory ECG monitoring (AEM) is the only available method to assess the presence and severity of myocardial ischemia during daily life. Several investigators have shown that the recording systems currently used can detect ischemic changes with similar accuracy as treadmill exercise testing. Ischemic changes on AEM are, however, present in only 40%-60% of patients with coronary artery disease (CAD) and positive exercise tests. For this reason, and because of the high day-to-day variability in daily ischemic changes, AEM cannot be used as a screening tool for detecting CAD or for evaluating severity of ischemia in individual patients. In patients with proven CAD, ischemic changes on AEM are associated with an adverse outcome in patients with stable and unstable ischemic syndromes, and in postmyocardial infarction patients. Suppression of daily ischemia seems to be associated with improved outcome. The mechanism of daily ischemia is not identical to exercise-induced ischemia. In addition to increased demand, which is a major contributor to AEM detected-ischemia, increased coronary tone also seems to play a major role. AEM has been shown to be a useful and reliable tool to assess the efficacy of various antiischemic drugs.

Asymptomatic Cardiac Ischemia Pilot (ACIP) Study. Relationship between exercise-induced and ambulatory ischemia in patients with stable coronary disease

BACKGROUND

We investigated whether the presence and frequency of asymptomatic ischemic episodes recorded during ambulatory ECG (AECG) monitoring could be predicted on the basis of clinical characteristics or exercise treadmill test (ETT) performance in patients with stable coronary disease and whether the estimate of ischemia severity was similar between the AECG and ETT.

METHODS AND RESULTS

Patients screened for the Asymptomatic Cardiac Ischemia Pilot (ACIP) study were selected for the current analysis if data were available from 48-hour AECG monitoring as well as from an ETT during which the patient developed > or = 1-mm ST-segment depression. Exercise ECG data were available for 143 of the 910 patients without ischemic episodes and for 659 of the 910 patients with ischemic episodes during AECG monitoring. Angina was more frequent among patients with ambulatory ischemic episodes than among patients without such ischemia (P < .001). Patients with AECG ischemia had a consistently more marked ischemic response on the ETT than patients without AECG ischemia; patients likely to have AECG ischemia could be predicted on the basis of ETT performance characteristics. However, the correlation coefficients between the severity of ischemia estimated by ETT and by AECG were small.

CONCLUSIONS

There are significant relations between ischemia detected by AECG monitoring and by ETT, but the relations are limited, indicating that the two tests are not redundant to characterize coronary patients. A larger study investigating the prognostic significance of the ischemia identified by each modality, with follow-up for clinical events, will be necessary to determine the most appropriate methods to evaluate patients with stable coronary disease.

Association between angina pectoris and ischemic indexes during exercise testing and ambulatory monitoring

We examined the relation between anginal symptoms and ischemic indexes during ischemia on exercise testing and daily activities in 76 patients (59 men and 17 women, mean age 61.5 years) with documented coronary artery disease and exercise-induced ischemia. All patients underwent upright bicycle exercise testing and 48-hour ambulatory electrocardiographic monitoring (AECG). Angina was reported in 28 patients (37%) during exercise-induced ischemia. A total of 287 ischemic episodes were detected from 44 patients (58%) during AECG. There was a mean number of 7.4 episodes and a mean total duration of 75 min/48 hours. There were no differences in the prevalence and the magnitude of ambulatory ischemia between patients with and without angina during exercise testing. Among the 44 patients who had ischemia during both tests, 50% of patients with angina during exercise testing had symptomatic ischemia during AECG compared to 14% in patients with silent ischemia during exercise testing (p = 0.01). Ninety-two percent of ischemic episodes were preceded by an increase in heart rate (HR) of > 10 beats/min. There was a strong positive correlation (r = 0.70, p < 0.01) between HR at onset of 1 mm ST depression (ischemic threshold) during exercise testing and during AECG. We conclude that (1) patients with exercise-induced angina have significantly more symptoms during ambulatory ischemia, (2) ischemic threshold during exercise testing and daily life are positively correlated, and (3) our findings emphasize the role of increased myocardial oxygen demand in the development of ambulatory ischemia.

Optimal lead selection for detection of ST segment shifts

A comparison was made to determine the ability of optimal sets of 2-6 unipolar leads and a normal Holter lead set to estimate ST potential distributions changes induced by balloon inflation during angioplasty. The performance of these lead sets was compared to measurements observed in recorded 32-lead body surface maps. Unipolar lead potentials were estimated using a linear, least mean squared error estimator of the total body surface map. The correlation between maximum ST potential change in the body surface map and that predicted by the unipolar lead sets ranged from 0.84-0.93. The correlation between maximum ST segment change measured from the body surface map and measured from the Holter leads was 0.29. Therefore, shifts in ST segment potentials can accurately be estimated from a small number of unipolar leads. In contrast, current bipolar ambulatory recording techniques may introduce significant bias to such estimates.

Ischemic threshold during two exercise testing protocols and during ambulatory electrocardiographic monitoring

OBJECTIVES

The aim of this study was to examine the dependence of the ischemic threshold during exercise testing on the exercise protocol employed and to determine the relation between the ischemic thresholds observed during exercise and during daily activity.

BACKGROUND

The ischemic threshold (heart rate at 1-mm ST segment depression) during daily activity has been reported to be lower than that observed during exercise testing. Recent reports have hypothesized that this difference is probably dependent on the exercise protocol employed.

METHODS

Twenty-two patients with known coronary artery disease, not receiving antianginal medications, were evaluated by repeated exercise testing according to the Bruce and the modified Davidson protocols and by 48-h ambulatory electrocardiographic monitoring.

RESULTS

Although the heart rate at 1-mm ST segment depression was somewhat lower with the Davidson than with the Bruce protocol (112 +/- 14 vs. 115 +/- 14 beats/min), the rate-pressure product at 1-mm ST segment depression was similar during the two protocols (16,900 +/- 4,000 vs. 17,700 +/- 3,600). The mean heart rate (100 + 12 beats/min) at 1-mm ST segment depression during ambulatory ischemic episodes (n = 137) was significantly lower than that observed during both exercise protocols (p < 0.001 for both comparisons).

CONCLUSIONS

Exercise-induced ischemia occurs at a relatively fixed threshold that is mainly dependent on myocardial oxygen demand and is independent of the exercise protocol employed. Ischemia on ambulatory monitoring, however, occurs at a much more variable threshold that is commonly lower than that observed during exercise and is therefore dependent on other factors in addition to increased demand.

Discordance between effects of anti-ischemic therapy on ambulatory ischemia, exercise performance and anginal symptoms in patients with stable angina pectoris. The Angina and Silent Ischemia Study Group (ASIS)

OBJECTIVES

We sought to define the extent to which the therapeutic efficacy of three single-drug regimens on ambulatory ischemia paralleled efficacy on other clinical manifestations of ischemia, specifically exercise test performance and anginal symptoms.

BACKGROUND

Some studies have shown that the presence and severity of ambulatory ischemia are predictive of anginal symptoms and exercise test performance, whereas other studies have not. Less is known about effects of antianginal treatment and whether response to therapy for one clinical manifestation reflects therapeutic responses for other clinical manifestations.

METHODS

We studied 50 patients in the Angina and Silent Ischemia Study who had documented coronary disease, an exercise test positive for ischemia, the presence of ambulatory and asymptomatic ischemia on ambulatory electrocardiographic (ECG) Holter monitoring and stable anginal symptoms. Patients received maximally tolerated doses of sustained release propranolol (mean 293 mg/day), sustained release diltiazem (mean 350 mg/day), nifedipine (mean 79 mg/day) and placebo, each for 2-week periods in a double-blind, crossover fashion. Patients' responses to treatment were assessed by 48-h ambulatory ECG monitoring, exercise test (standard Bruce protocol) and diaries of angina. Levels of efficacy for each agent and for each clinical measure were compared using Spearman correlation analysis.

RESULTS

With placebo there was no correlation among the frequency of ischemic episodes by ambulatory ECG monitoring, exercise time to 1.0-mm ST segment depression or frequency of anginal episodes. Furthermore, for a given patient the efficacy of each active medication in reducing ambulatory ischemia was not correlated with response in anginal symptoms or exercise test performance (r = -0.21 to 0.24, p = NS). Within each of these clinical measures, efficacy of one drug was more strongly correlated with efficacy of another drug (r = 0.64 to 0.81 for ambulatory ischemia, 0.48 to 0.56 for exercise test performance and 0.16 to 0.54 for anginal symptoms).

CONCLUSIONS

Different measures of ischemia, specifically ambulatory ischemia assessed by ambulatory ECG monitoring, exercise performance on exercise test and anginal symptoms, are independent. Efficacy for each clinical end point must be assessed separately when considering response to drug treatment.

Comparison of ST depression recorded by Holter monitors and 12-lead ECGs during coronary angiography and exercise testing

Data from previous studies are debatable regarding whether Holter monitors are a reliable electrocardiographic indicator of ischemia, for which the 12-lead electrocardiogram (ECG) is the standard. Simultaneous 12-lead and Holter ECGs were performed on 30 patients with typical angina pectoris during coronary angiography or exercise testing. ST depression recorded by both methods was directly compared, using the 12-lead ECG as the reference. The Holter tapes were also scanned by two automated ST analysis programs and the results were compared to 12-lead ECGs. Only 66 of the 178 12-lead ECG ST depression events were also present on the Holter recordings (37.1% Holter sensitivity). ST depression was underestimated by the Holter recordings compared to the 12-lead ECGs (p < 0.0001). The majority (67.0%) of ST depression events identified by one computer program were false positive events. The degree of ST depression was overestimated compared to 12-lead ECGs by the second program (p = 0.0033). Holter-detected ST depression may not be a reliable ECG indicator of myocardial ischemia.