Usefulness of Holter monitoring in predicting efficacy of amiodarone therapy for sustained ventricular tachycardia associated with coronary artery disease

Can antiarrhythmic agents be selected based on mechanism of action?

When selecting an antiarrhythmic agent the clinician needs to be able to accurately predict the probability that a particular drug will serve its intended purpose in a given patient. This is difficult because of the complexity of variables which govern the relationship between drug administration and clinical outcome. The efficacy of a drug may potentially be predicted from its mechanism of action. At least two classifications of antiarrhythmic agents based on mechanism of action have been proposed. The Vaughan Williams classification is based on the predominant electrophysiological effects of a drug on the action potential. In the Sicilian Gambit approach, a number of potential targets ('vulnerable parameters') for drug action are identified and antiarrhythmic drugs or substances that affect cardiac electrophysiology are characterised by their actions on each of these. The usefulness of these classification systems in predicting antiarrhythmic drug efficacy are limited. Furthermore, in the Vaughan Williams classification not all drugs in the same class have identical effects, whereas some drugs in different classes have overlapping actions. The Sicilian Gambit requires in-depth knowledge regarding cellular and molecular targets of antiarrhythmic agents which may make it intimidating or simply impractical for regular clinical use. Surrogate measures such as 24-hour Holter monitoring and programmed electrical stimulation have been used to predict anti-arrhythmic drug efficacy. However, studies such the Cardiac Arrhythmia Suppression Trial (CAST) have shown that suppression of ventricular ectopy on Holter monitoring does not necessarily correlate with improved survival and may in fact be dangerous. Conversely, studies using programmed electrical stimulation to assess drug effect on variables such as tachycardia inducibility, refractory period and ventricular tachycardia cycle length show that suppression of tachycardia inducibility, prolongation of refractory period and prolongation of ventricular tachycardia cycle length, are all associated with reduced recurrence of tachycardia and possibly improved survival. The most practical use of the current classification systems applied to antiarrhythmic agents may be in their ability to predict with reasonable accuracy, the risk and type of proarrhythmia based on the mechanism of action of an agent.

Therapy of Sustained Ventricular Arrhythmias With Amiodarone: Prediction of Efficacy With Serial Electrophysiologic Studies

BACKGROUND: Programmed electrical stimulation early during amiodarone therapy has poor prognostic capabilities; and persistent inducibility has been associated with a favorable outcome in a majority of patients. These observations result from studies that differed significantly in methodology. METHODS AND RESULTS: The authors prospectively enrolled 121 patients in a standardized amiodarone dosing protocol in which amiodarone was the only antiarrhythmic agent. Electrophysiologic testing was done after 2 and 6 weeks to determine noninducibility, predictive value, and the significance of drug-induced prolongation of tachycardia cycle length. The mean age of the patients in the study was 63.2 +/- 11.5 years, and their ejection fraction was 32.8 +/- 11.9%. Coronary artery disease was present in 103 (85%). At 2 weeks 17 patients (14%) were no longer inducible, whereas 104 patients (86%) remained inducible. Patients in these groups were similar in age and ejection fraction. During follow-up evaluation, recurrences (35% vs 24%; P =.44) and sudden death (12% vs 13.5%) were similar in the two groups. Thirty-five of 95 patients (32%) with sustained monomorphic ventricular tachycardia had more than 100 ms prolongation of their cycle length, which was hemodynamically well tolerated (partial response), but 60 did not (nonresponse). Patients with a partial response were older (66.5 vs 61.1 years; P =.02) and had longer QRS durations (143.2 vs 129.4 ms; P =.03). They also had increased recurrences (37% vs 17%; P =.01) and more sudden deaths (23% vs 8%; P =.02). At 6 weeks 11 of 76 patients studied were noninducible. They had a lower recurrence rate than those who remained inducible (8% vs 27%; P =.02) but a similar number of sudden deaths (8% vs 16%; P =.27). Thirty-two patients partially responded, and 31 patients did not respond. During follow-up examination these two groups had a similar number of recurrences (25% vs 29%; P =.76) and sudden deaths (16% vs 16%). CONCLUSIONS: Noninducibility at 2 or 6 weeks of amiodarone therapy did not identify patients at low risk of sudden death. In inducible patients, tachycardia cycle length prolongation, even when well tolerated, was not a marker for favorable outcome. Electrophysiologically guided therapy, therefore, offers little benefit over empiric amiodarone.