Competition between ADP and nucleotide analogues to occupy regulatory sites(s) related to hysteretic inhibition of mitochondrial F1-ATPase

ATP synthase and the actions of inhibitors utilized to study its roles in human health, disease, and other scientific areas

ATP synthase, a double-motor enzyme, plays various roles in the cell, participating not only in ATP synthesis but in ATP hydrolysis-dependent processes and in the regulation of a proton gradient across some membrane-dependent systems. Recent studies of ATP synthase as a potential molecular target for the treatment of some human diseases have displayed promising results, and this enzyme is now emerging as an attractive molecular target for the development of new therapies for a variety of diseases. Significantly, ATP synthase, because of its complex structure, is inhibited by a number of different inhibitors and provides diverse possibilities in the development of new ATP synthase-directed agents. In this review, we classify over 250 natural and synthetic inhibitors of ATP synthase reported to date and present their inhibitory sites and their known or proposed modes of action. The rich source of ATP synthase inhibitors and their known or purported sites of action presented in this review should provide valuable insights into their applications as potential scaffolds for new therapeutics for human and animal diseases as well as for the discovery of new pesticides and herbicides to help protect the world's food supply. Finally, as ATP synthase is now known to consist of two unique nanomotors involved in making ATP from ADP and P(i), the information provided in this review may greatly assist those investigators entering the emerging field of nanotechnology.

The binding mechanism of the yeast F1-ATPase inhibitory peptide: role of catalytic intermediates and enzyme turnover

The mechanism of inhibition of yeast mitochondrial F(1)-ATPase by its natural regulatory peptide, IF1, was investigated by correlating the rate of inhibition by IF1 with the nucleotide occupancy of the catalytic sites. Nucleotide occupancy of the catalytic sites was probed by fluorescence quenching of a tryptophan, which was engineered in the catalytic site (beta-Y345W). Fluorescence quenching of a beta-Trp(345) indicates that the binding of MgADP to F(1) can be described as 3 binding sites with dissociation constants of K(d)(1) = 10 +/- 2 nm, K(d2) = 0.22 +/- 0.03 microm, and K(d3) = 16.3 +/- 0.2 microm. In addition, the ATPase activity of the beta-Trp(345) enzyme followed simple Michaelis-Menten kinetics with a corresponding K(m) of 55 microm. Values for the K(d) for MgATP were estimated and indicate that the K(m) (55 microm) for ATP hydrolysis corresponds to filling the third catalytic site on F(1). IF1 binds very slowly to F(1)-ATPase depleted of nucleotides and under unisite conditions. The rate of inhibition by IF1 increased with increasing concentration of MgATP to about 50 mum, but decreased thereafter. The rate of inhibition was half-maximal at 5 microm MgATP, which is 10-fold lower than the K(m) for ATPase. The variations of the rate of IF1 binding are related to changes in the conformation of the IF1 binding site during the catalytic reaction cycle of ATP hydrolysis. A model is proposed that suggests that IF1 binds rapidly, but loosely to F(1) with two or three catalytic sites filled, and is then locked in the enzyme during catalytic hydrolysis of ATP.

Functional transitions of F0F1-ATPase mediated by the inhibitory peptide IF1 in yeast coupled submitochondrial particles

The mechanism of inhibition of yeast F(0)F(1)-ATPase by its naturally occurring protein inhibitor (IF1) was investigated in submitochondrial particles by studying the IF1-mediated ATPase inhibition in the presence and absence of a protonmotive force. In the presence of protonmotive force, IF1 added during net NTP hydrolysis almost completely inhibited NTPase activity. At moderate IF1 concentration, subsequent uncoupler addition unexpectedly caused a burst of NTP hydrolysis. We propose that the protonmotive force induces the conversion of IF1-inhibited F(0)F(1)-ATPase into a new form having a lower affinity for IF1. This form remains inactive for ATP hydrolysis after IF1 release. Uncoupling simultaneously releases ATP hydrolysis and converts the latent form of IF1-free F(0)F(1)-ATPase back to the active form. The relationship between the different steps of the catalytic cycle, the mechanism of inhibition by IF1 and the interconversion process is discussed.

One of the non-exchangeable nucleotides of the mitochondrial F1-ATPase is bound at a beta-subunit: evidence for a non-rotatory two-site catalytic mechanism

In active MF1, one of the two non-exchangeable tightly bound adenine nucleotides is an ATP, while the other is an ADP. The respective sites are called the T-site and the D-site. The activity of the enzyme correlates linearly with the amount of bound ATP, ADP at the T-site being inhibitory. When MF1 is stored at room temperature in 50% glycerol and 100 mM Tris-HCl (pH 7.3) after slow passage through a Sephadex column, the tightly bound ATP is slowly dephosphorylated to ADP which is subsequently released, without effect on activity. When enzyme with about one residual ADP left (at the D-site) was incubated at pH 7.3, after dilution of the glycerol, with 400 &mgr;M [14C]ATP under varying conditions, the amount of tightly bound nucleotide triphosphate again correlated well with activity, the residual ADP being bound at the D-site. Optimal results were obtained when the incubation was performed in the presence of a regenerating system. Binding of 2-azido-ATP instead of ATP to the T-site as a triphosphate, as indicated by the specific activity of the enzyme, appeared to be optimal when the binding was performed at pH 6.4 in the absence of Mg2+ and with high concentrations of the nucleotide. Under such conditions, 3 mol 2-azido-AXP per mol F1 remained tightly bound after ammonium sulfate precipitation and column centrifugation, in addition to about one residual ADP at the D-site. After a 2-min period of turnover with ATP/Mg2+ as substrate two mol 2-azido-AXP were left on the enzyme, of which one was bound at a beta-site. These results show that one of the non-catalytic nucleotide binding sites that contain tightly bound nucleotides, is a beta-site, in conflict with the requirements for a rotatory tri-site mechanism for ATP hydrolysis. This beta-site can further be identified with the T-site. The validity of these conclusions for F1 from other sources and for catalysis by membrane-bound enzyme is discussed.

Differential nucleotide binding to catalytic and noncatalytic sites and related conformational changes involving alpha/beta-subunit interactions as monitored by sensitive intrinsic fluorescence in Schizosaccharomyces pombe mitochondrial F1

Mitochondrial F1 from the yeast Schizosaccharomyces pombe exhibits an intrinsic tryptophan fluorescence sensitive to adenine nucleotides and inorganic phosphate [Divita, G., Di Pietro, A., Deléage, G., Roux, B., & Gautheron, D.C. (1991) Biochemistry 30, 3256-3262]. The present results indicate that the intrinsic fluorescence is differentially modified by nucleotide binding to either catalytic or noncatalytic sites. Guanine or hypoxanthine nucleotides, which selectively bind to the catalytic site, produce a hyperbolic saturation monitored by fluorescence quenching at 332 nm, the maximal emission wavelength. On the contrary, adenine nucleotides, which bind to both catalytic and noncatalytic sites, exhibit a biphasic saturation. High-affinity ATP binding produces a marked quenching as opposed to the lower-affinity one. In contrast, ADP exhibits a sigmoidal saturation, with high-affinity binding producing no quenching but responsible for positive cooperativity of binding to the lower-affinity site. The catalytic-site affinity for GDP is almost 20-fold higher at pH 5.0 as compared to pH 9.0, and the high sensitivity of the method allows detection of the 10-fold lower-affinity GMP binding. In contrast, high-affinity binding of ADP, or AMP, is not pH-dependent. The selective catalytic-site saturation induces a F1 conformational change decreasing the Stern-Volmer constant for acrylamide and the tryptophan fraction accessible to iodide. ATP saturation of both catalytic and noncatalytic sites produces an additional reduction of the accessible fraction to acrylamide.

The ATP synthase (F0-F1) complex in oxidative phosphorylation

The transmembrane electrochemical proton gradient generated by the redox systems of the respiratory chain in mitochondria and aerobic bacteria is utilized by proton translocating ATP synthases to catalyze the synthesis of ATP from ADP and P(i). The bacterial and mitochondrial H(+)-ATP synthases both consist of a membranous sector, F0, which forms a H(+)-channel, and an extramembranous sector, F1, which is responsible for catalysis. When detached from the membrane, the purified F1 sector functions mainly as an ATPase. In chloroplasts, the synthesis of ATP is also driven by a proton motive force, and the enzyme complex responsible for this synthesis is similar to the mitochondrial and bacterial ATP synthases. The synthesis of ATP by H(+)-ATP synthases proceeds without the formation of a phosphorylated enzyme intermediate, and involves co-operative interactions between the catalytic subunits.

Structure-function relationships of mitochondrial ATPase-ATPsynthase using Schizosaccharomyces pombe yeast mutants with altered F1 subunits

Phenotypic revertants have been selected from mutants of the yeast Schizosaccharomyces pombe devoid of either alpha or beta subunits of mitochondrial ATPase-ATPsynthase. In contrast to parental mutants, phenotypic revertants are able to grow on glycerol respiratory medium and show immunodetectable alpha and beta subunits. However, growth and cellular respiration are only partially restored as compared to the wild strain, indicating that the recovered subunits are mutated. ATPase activity of revertant submitochondrial particles shows markedly different parameters: more acidic optimal pH, absence of bicarbonate activation and decreased sensitivity to azide inhibition in the alpha subunit-modified R3.51. Opposite differences are observed in the beta subunit-modified R4.3: more alkaline optimal pH, much higher bicarbonate activation, and increased sensitivity to azide. The ITPase activity of R4.3 submitochondrial particles is also more sensitive to azide as compared to the wild strain. ATPase activity of purified F1 also exhibits marked differences: loss of bicarbonate-sensitive negative cooperativity, decreased sensitivity to both ADP and azide inhibitions in the R3.51 revertant. On the contrary, increased negative cooperativity and increased sensitivity to both ADP and azide inhibitions are observed for the R4.3 revertant enzyme which in addition exhibits a much lower maximal rate. The beta subunit-mutation of R4.3 also increases the sensitivity of ITPase activity to tripolyphosphate inhibition, whereas the alpha subunit-mutation of R3.51 is without any effect. Soluble F1 with beta subunit-mutation is very sensitive to high ammonium sulfate concentrations required for enzyme precipitation and concentration and known to partially deplete the enzyme from its endogenous nucleotides. On the contrary, poly(ethylene)glycol is very efficient for preparing from any strain a pure and very stable enzyme retain-ing high amounts of endogenous nucleotides. The R4.3 revertant F1 retains even more nucleotides than the wild-strain F1 and is much less sensitive to high iodide concentrations which favor enzyme dissociation and precipitation. The tryptophan intrinsic fluorescence of F1 is modified by both mutations that increase the maximal emission intensity. The most important effect is produced by beta subunit-mutation which decreases the quenchable fraction, one-third to one-half tryptophans being no longer accessible to iodide. The overall results suggest that both mutations modify enzyme-nucleotide interactions: the alpha subunit-mutation of R3.51 would favor ADP release by lowering interactions with the adenine moiety, whereas the beta subunit-mutation of R4.3 would lower ADP release by strengthening interactions with the phosphate chain moiety.

Purification from a yeast mutant of mitochondrial F1 with modified beta-subunit. High affinity for nucleotides and high negative cooperativity of ATPase activity

Mitochondrial F1 containing genetically modified beta-subunit was purified for the first time from a mutant of the yeast Schizosaccharomyces pombe. Precipitation by poly(ethylene glycol) allowed us to obtain a very stable and pure enzyme from either mutant or wild-type strain. In the presence of EDTA, purified F1 retained high amounts of endogenous nucleotides: 4.6 mol/mol and 3.7 mol/mol for mutant and wild-type F1, respectively. The additional nucleotide in mutant F1 was ATP; it was lost in the presence of Mg2+, which led to a total of 3.4 mol of nucleotides/mol whereas wild-type F1 retained all its nucleotides. Mutant F1 bound more exogenous ADP than wild-type F1 and the same total nucleotide amount was reached with both enzymes. Kinetics of ATPase activity revealed a much higher negative cooperativity for mutant than for wild-type F1. Bicarbonate abolished this negative cooperativity, but higher concentrations were required for mutant F1. The mutant enzyme was more sensitive than the wild-type one to azide inhibition and ADP competitive inhibition; this indicated stronger interactions between nucleotide and F1 in the mutant enzyme. The latter also showed increased sensitivity to N,N'-dicyclohexylcarbodiimide irreversible inhibition.

Evidence from immunological studies of structure-mechanism relationship of F1 and F1F0

Monoclonal and polyclonal antibodies directed against peptides of F1-ATPase of F1F0-ATPase synthase provide new and efficient tools to study structure-function relationships and mechanisms of such complex membrane enzymes. This review summarizes the main results obtained using this approach. Antibodies have permitted the determination of the nature of subunits involved in the complex, their stoichiometry, their organization, neighboring interactions, and vectorial distribution within or on either face of the membrane. Moreover, in a few cases, amino acid sequences exposed on a face of the membrane or buried inside the complex have been identified. Antibodies are very useful for detecting the role of each subunit, especially for those subunits which appear to have no direct involvement in the catalytic mechanism. Concerning the mechanisms, the availability of monoclonal antibodies which inhibit (or activate) ATP hydrolysis or ATP synthesis, which modify nucleotide binding or regulation of activities, which detect specific conformations, etc. brings many new ways of understanding the precise functions. The specific recognition by monoclonal antibodies on the beta subunit of epitopes in the proximity of, or in the catalytic site, gives information on this site. The use of anti-alpha monoclonal antibodies has shown asymmetry of alpha in the complex as already shown for beta. In addition, the involvement of alpha with respect to nucleotide site cooperativity has been detected. Finally, the formation of F1F0-antibody complexes of various masses, seems to exclude the functional rotation of F1 around F0 during catalysis.

IF1 inhibition of mitochondrial F1-ATPase is correlated to entrapment of four adenine- or guanine-nucleotides including at least one triphosphate

This paper demonstrates that the inhibition of F1 ATPase activity by the natural inhibitor protein IF1 is correlated to triphosphate nucleotide entrapment in F1. The complete balance of nucleotides bound after preincubation with Mg-[alpha-32P]GTP or Mg-[alpha-32P]ATP, used to promote IF1 inhibition, has been established on purified F1 containing 0.7 mol of non-exchangeable endogenous nucleotides. As many as 4 mol of labelled guanine- or adenine- nucleotides are trapped in F1; at least one of these nucleotides is a triphosphate. On the contrary, in the absence of IF1, no triphosphate nucleotide is significantly retained and the diphosphate nucleotides bound are mainly exchangeable.

Role of phosphate on the ADP-induced hysteretic inhibition of mitochondrial adenosine 5'-triphosphatase. Effects of the natural protein inhibitor

Preincubation of F1-ATPase with ADP and Mg2+ leads to ADP binding at regulatory site inducing a hysteretic inhibition of ATP hydrolysis, i.e., an inhibition that slowly develops after Mg-ATP addition (Di Pietro, A., Penin, F., Godinot, C. and Gautheron, D.C. (1980) Biochemistry 19, 5671-5678). It is shown here that inorganic phosphate (Pi) together with ADP during preincubation abolishes the time-dependence of the inhibition after the addition of the substrate Mg-ATP. This preincubation in the presence of both Pi and ADP slowly leads to a conformation of the enzyme immediately inhibited after the addition of the substrate Mg-ATP. The Pi effect is half-maximal at 35 microM and pH 6.6, whereas a limited effect is induced at pH 8.0. The preincubation of F1-ATPase with Pi and ADP must last long enough (t1/2 = 5 min). The effects can be correlated to the amount of Pi bound to the enzyme, 1 mol Pi per mol (apparent KD of 33 microM) at saturation. Pi neither modifies the ADP binding nor the final level of the concomitant inhibition. When Pi is not present in the preincubation, the final stable rate of ADP-induced hysteretic inhibition is always reached when a near-constant amount of Pi has been generated during Mg-ATP hydrolysis. Kinetic experiments indicate that preincubation with ADP and Pi decreases both Vmax and Km which would favor a conformational change of the enzyme. Taking into account the Pi effects, a more precise model of hysteretic inhibition is proposed. The natural protein inhibitor IF1 efficiently prevents the binding of Pi produced by ATP hydrolysis indicating that the hysteretic inhibition and the IF1-dependent inhibition obey different mechanisms.

Structure and function of the ATPase-ATP synthase complex of mitochondria as compared to chloroplasts and bacteria

An overview of the structure and function of the mitochondrial ATPase-ATP synthase complex is presented. Attempts are made to identify the analogies and differences between mitochondrial, chloroplastic and bacterial complexes. The relatively more precise information available on the structure of the E. coli enzyme is used to try and understand the apparently more complex structure of the mitochondrial enzyme. Recent ideas on the mechanism of ATP hydrolysis and ATP synthesis will be summarized.

[Use of chemical probes in the study of F1-ATPases]

The purpose of the present review is to discuss in brief the use of chemical probes for the study of the structure and the function of F1-ATPases. Special focus is brought on probes that bind covalently to the proteins.

Interaction of azide with beef heart mitochondrial ATPase

This study examined the inhibition of azide as a probe of the magnesium regulation of beef heart mitochondrial ATPase (F1) catalysis. Azide elicited a slow hysteretic effect on both ATP and ITP hydrolysis of F1. This hysteretic effect was shown to be due to the consecutive binding of magnesium and azide, and to be independent of catalytic turnover. The azide binding site was also shown to be separate from the anion binding HCO3- site on F1. The results presented indicate that metal binding is important in the inhibition of the hydrolytic activity and regulation of F1. A model is presented which is consistent with the hysteretic inhibition of F1 by azide, in which there is a slow equilibration between free enzyme and the enzyme-magnesium-azide complex.

Circular dichroism and nucleotide and phosphate-induced conformational changes of mitochondrial adenosinetriphosphatase

The conformational changes induced by the binding of different effectors on F1-ATPase are investigated by using circular dichroism and are related to enzyme activity. The hydrophilic part of the terminal enzyme of oxidative phosphorylation, F1-ATPase, solubilized from the pig heart mitochondrial membrane contains both regulatory and catalytic sites which can bind nucleotides and phosphate. The circular dichroic spectra of F1-ATPase in the absence or in the presence of ADP, Mg2+, phosphate, and the substrate analogue guanosine 5'-(beta, gamma-imidotriphosphate) [GMP-P-(NH)P] were recorded and analyzed in terms of secondary structure. The most significant result is a sizable increase from 35% to 42% of the alpha-helix content when the enzyme is incubated with all the effectors. Since the kinetic study showed that GMP-P(NH)P is a competitive inhibitor of MgATP with or without preincubation of the enzyme with ADP and phosphate, it was concluded that the catalytic and regulatory sites can be simultaneously occupied by ADP and GMP-P-(NH)P. The increase of alpha-helix content is then interpreted by a conformational change that occurs only after occupation of both types of sites.

A kinetic study of the interaction between mitochondrial F1 adenosine triphosphatase and adenylyl imidodiphosphate and guanylyl imidodiphosphate

1. The presence of 5'-adenylyl imidodiphosphate, a non-hydrolysable analogue of ATP, in the solution used to assay the soluble bovine heart mitochondrial F1-ATPase produced slow competitive inhibition. If the enzyme was preincubated with the inhibitor before the substrate, MgATP, was added, a partial re-activation was obtained. 2. The slow inhibitory process showed first-order rate kinetics, and therefore it seems likely that a conformational change of the enzyme occurs following a faster binding process. A reaction scheme is suggested. At pH 7.8 the rate constant for the inhibition reaction was calculated to be 6.7 X 10(-2)s-1 and that for the re-activation 3.8 X 10(-3)s-1, with Keq. 17.6, indicating that the inhibited enzyme-inhibitor complex will be favoured over the non-inhibited enzyme-inhibitor complex. 3. The presence of 5'-guanylyl imidodiphosphate in the solution used to assay F1-ATPase produced rapid competitive inhibition, which was then slowly reversed until a steady state was reached. This might be explained by a rapid but reversible shift of the inhibition pathway induced by this non-hydrolysable analogue of ATP. A complex rate constant for the displacement of the inhibitor by the substrate of 7.6 X 10(-3)s-1 was calculated. 4. The results are discussed in the light of other recent observations about binding of 5'-adenylyl imidodiphosphate to F1-ATPase and with reference to the binding-site-change mechanism of hydrolysis of ATP by F1-ATPase.

Use of trypsin to monitor conformational changes of mitochondrial adenosinetriphosphatase induced by nucleotides and phosphate

Upon incubation with trypsin, the adenosine-5'-triphosphatase (ATPase) activity of the nucleotide-depleted F1 is first rapidly and slightly activated and then slowly inactivated. The first phase is simultaneous with the conversion of the alpha subunit into an alpha' fragment which migrates between alpha and beta on sodium dodecyl sulfate-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis. The second phase is related to the proteolysis of the three main subunits, alpha', beta, and gamma. Preincubation of the enzyme with low concentrations of adenosine 5'-diphosphate (ADP) or adenosine 5'-triphosphate (ATP) does not modify the slight increase of activity but efficiently prevents the inactivation induced by trypsin. The alpha leads to alpha' conversion is not affected whereas the further proteolysis of alpha', beta, and gamma does not occur. On the contrary, even high concentrations of GDP only slightly lower the trypsin-induced inactivation. The presence of endogenous tightly bound nucleotides also partially lowers the sensitivity to trypsin since F1 is less rapidly inactivated and proteolyzed than the nucleotide-depleted F1. Phosphate, at high concentrations, both slows down the first phase of activation and simultaneous alpha leads to alpha' conversion and prevents the second phase of inactivation and proteolysis of the main subunits. Pretreatment of the nucleotide-depleted F1 with trypsin under conditions where the ATPase activity is largely inhibited only slightly modifies, however, the hysteretic behavior of the enzyme: the ADP binding and the concomitant hysteretic inhibition of the residual activity are not markedly diminished. The purified ATPase-ATP synthase complex binds very few ADP's and is not hysteretically inhibited. Its ATPase activity is rapidly activated but not further inhibited by trypsin. Preincubation of the complex with ADP does not modify the effects of trypsin.