Sensitivity of the retinal circular dichroism of bacteriorhodopsin to the mutagenetic single substitution of amino acids: tyrosine

CD spectrum of bacteriorhodopsin: Best evidence against exciton model

We summarize the predictions of the exciton model that was originally proposed to explain the observed biphasic band shape of its CD spectrum in the visible region of bacteriorhodopsin (bR). It is shown that to reconcile these predictions with the observed results on the linear dichroism, the retinal isomerization time and, the retinal-retinal distance, the biphasic nature of the observed CD spectrum of bR becomes itself an evidence against the exciton model because of the uncertainty principle.Reduced bR (RbR), which retains its hexagonal structure, shows a monophasic CD spectrum with relatively small rotational strength as compared to bR. This is shown to disagree with predictions made by the exciton model. The results could best be explained in terms of retinal-protein heterogeneity leading to two or more types of bR in which their retinals suffer opposite sense of intramolecular rotational distortion along their retinal long axis. Such a retinal-protein heterogeneity disappears in reduced bR which is known to have a planar (nondistorted) retinal conjugated system, resulting in a monophasic CD with reduced rotational strength, as observed.

Unique biphasic band shape of the visible circular dichroism of bacteriorhodopsin in purple membrane: Excitons, multiple transitions or protein heterogeneity?

OVER A DECADE AND A HALF AGO, WHEN THE FIRST VISIBLE MEMBRANE SUSPENSION CIRCULAR DICHROIC (CD) SPECTRUM OF THE PURPLE MEMBRANE (PM) WAS PRESENTED, TWO MECHANISMS WERE PROPOSED TO ACCOUNT FOR THE OBSERVED BIPHASIC SHAPED CD BAND: (a) excitonic interactions among the retinals of the sole protein bacteriorhodopsin (bR) in the crystalline structure of the PM, and (b) combination of CD bands with opposite rotational strengths due to a retinal-apoprotein heterogeneity of the bR molecules or due to two possible close-lying long-wavelength transitions of the retinal of the bR with opposite rotational strengths. Since that time, an impressive body of experimental and theoretical evidence has been accumulated, mostly consistent with an exciton model but many at serious odds with any heterogeneity or multiple transition model. Recently, a number of articles have appeared reporting analyses of new experimental observations which are proposed to cast serious doubts on the viability of the exciton model, and therefore, may revive the heterogeneity or multiple transition model as an explanation for the unique shape of the CD band of the PM. The intent of this article is to demonstrate that if all observations found in literature baring on this question are considered in toto and in a consistent manner, they can be interpreted without exception by excitons, and furthermore, that there is no plausible evidence available to warrant the revival of the heterogeneity or multiple transition model as an explanation for the unique shape of the biphasic CD band of the PM.

Circular dichroism and cross-linking studies of bacteriorhodopsin mutants

Circular dichroism (CD) spectroscopy was employed for native (wild type, WT) bacteriorhodopsin (bR) and several mutant derivatives: R134K, R134H, R82Q, S35C, L66C, and R134C/E194C. Comparative analysis of the CD spectra in visible range shows that only R134C/E194C exhibits biphasic CD, typical for native bR, the other mutants demonstrate CD spectra with significantly smaller or absent negative band. Since the biphasic CD is a feature of hexagonal lattice structure composed by bR trimers in the purple membrane, these mutants and WT were examined by cross-linking studies, which confirmed the same trend towards trimeric organization. Therefore, a single amino acid substitution may lead to drastically different CD spectra without disruption of bR trimeric organization. Thus, although disruption of bR trimeric crystalline lattice structure (e.g., solubilization with detergents) directly results in the disappearance of characteristic bilobe in visible CD, the lack of the bilobe in the CD alone does not predict the absence of trimers.

Circular dichroism of heterochromophoric and partially regenerated purple membrane: Search for exciton coupling

In order to determine the origin of the bisignate CD spectra of native purple membrane, heterochromophoric analogues containing bacteriorhodopsin regenerated with native all-trans-retinal and retinal analogues were investigated. The data collected for the purple membrane samples containing two different chromophores suggest the additive character of the CD spectra. This conclusion was supported by a series of spectra using 5,6-dihydroretinal and 3-dehydroretinal and by using 33% regenerated PM in buffer and in presence of osmolytes. Our results support the idea of conformational heterogeneity of the chromophores in the bR in the trimer, suggesting that the three bR subunits in the trimer are not conformationally equal, and therefore, the bisignate CD spectrum of bR in the purple membrane occurs rather due to a superposition of the CD spectra from variously distorted bR subunits in the trimer than interchromophoric exciton-coupling interactions.

Comparison of the dynamics of the primary events of bacteriorhodopsin in its trimeric and monomeric states

In this paper, femtosecond pump-probe spectroscopy in the visible region of the spectrum has been used to examine the ultrafast dynamics of the retinal excited state in both the native trimeric state and the monomeric state of bacteriorhodopsin (bR). It is found that the excited state lifetime (probed at 490 nm) increases only slightly upon the monomerization of bR. No significant kinetic difference is observed in the recovery process of the bR ground state probed at 570 nm nor in the fluorescent state observed at 850 nm. However, an increase in the relative amplitude of the slow component of bR excited state decay is observed in the monomer, which is due to the increase in the concentration of the 13-cis retinal isomer in the ground state of the light-adapted bR monomer. Our data indicate that when the protein packing around the retinal is changed upon bR monomerization, there is only a subtle change in the retinal potential surface, which is dependent on the charge distribution and the dipoles within the retinal-binding cavity. In addition, our results show that 40% of the excited state bR molecules return to the ground state on three different time scales: one-half-picosecond component during the relaxation of the excited state and the formation of the J intermediate, a 3-ps component as the J changes to the K intermediate where retinal photoisomerization occurs, and a subnanosecond component during the photocycle.

Trimeric mutant bacteriorhodopsin, D85N, shows a monophasic CD spectrum

The structure of mutant bacteriorhodopsin (bR), D85N, was examined by CD and X-ray diffraction at pH 7. The absorption maximum of D85N at pH 7 is located at 605 nm, which is similar to the acid-blue form of wild-type bR. D85N shows a monophasic CD band, the maximum of which is at 575 nm, although the crystalline arrangement and the trimeric structure is maintained. The acid-blue form of wild-type bR shows a biphasic CD despite the similarity in absorption spectra.

Dramatic in situ conformational dynamics of the transmembrane protein bacteriorhodopsin

The conformational dynamic capabilities of the in situ bacteriorhodopsin (bR) can be studied by determination of the changes of the bR net helical segmental tilt angle (the angle between the polypeptide segments and the membrane normal) induced by various perturbations of the purple membrane (PM). The analysis of the far-UV oriented circular dichroism (CD) of the PM provides one means of achieving this. Previous CD studies have indicated that the tilt angle can change from approximately 10 degrees to 39 degrees depending on the perturbants used with no changes in the secondary structure of the bR. A recent study has indicated that the bleaching-induced tilt angle can be enhanced from approximately 24 degrees to 39 degrees by cross-linkage and papain-digestion perturbations which by themselves do not alter the tilt angle. To add further credence, this study has been repeated using midinfrared (IR) linear dichroic spectral analysis. In contrast to the CD method, analysis by the IR method depends on the orientation of the amide plane of the helix assumed. Excellent consistency is achieved between the two methods only when it is assumed that the structural characteristics of the alpha-helices of the bR are equally alpha I and alpha II in nature. Furthermore, the analysis of the IR data becomes essentially independent of the three amide transitions utilized. The net tilt angle of segments completely randomized relative to the incident light must be 54.736 in view of helix symmetry. A value of 54.735 degrees +/- 0.001 degree was achieved by the IR method for the ethanol-treated PM film, establishing this kind of film as an ideal random state standard and demonstrating the accuracy potential of the IR method.