15N NMR assignments and chemical shift analysis of uniformly labeled 15N calbindin D9k in the apo, (Cd2+)1 and (Ca2+)2 states

Intracellular antibody signalling is regulated by phosphorylation of the Fc receptor TRIM21

Cell surface Fc receptors activate inflammation and are tightly controlled to prevent autoimmunity. Antibodies also simulate potent immune signalling from inside the cell via the cytosolic antibody receptor TRIM21, but how this is regulated is unknown. Here we show that TRIM21 signalling is constitutively repressed by its B-Box domain and activated by phosphorylation. The B-Box occupies an E2 binding site on the catalytic RING domain by mimicking E2-E3 interactions, inhibiting TRIM21 ubiquitination and preventing immune activation. TRIM21 is derepressed by IKKβ and TBK1 phosphorylation of an LxxIS motif in the RING domain, at the interface with the B-Box. Incorporation of phosphoserine or a phosphomimetic within this motif relieves B-Box inhibition, promoting E2 binding, RING catalysis, NF-κB activation and cytokine transcription upon infection with DNA or RNA viruses. These data explain how intracellular antibody signalling is regulated and reveal that the B-Box is a critical regulator of RING E3 ligase activity.

Antibodies are molecules made by the immune system that protect us from infections. They were discovered over 100 years ago, and for most of that time scientists thought they only worked in the bloodstream. Yet recent research showed that when a virus infects our cells it also carries antibodies in with it. Once inside the cell, a protein called TRIM21 recognises the antibody-covered virus and – together with other proteins called ubiquitin enzymes – targets it for destruction via the cell’s waste disposal system. At the same time TRIM21 sends a signal to the cell’s nucleus to activate certain genes that protect cells across the body from subsequent infection.

The genes activated by TRIM21 have potent antiviral activity. Yet they can also damage the body’s own tissues if they are switched on at the wrong time, which may lead to autoimmune diseases like rheumatoid arthritis and multiple sclerosis. It is thus critical that TRIM21 is carefully regulated and only activated during an infection, but it was not clear how this is achieved.

Dickson, Fletcher et al. now show that although TRIM21 is made all the time and is always ready to detect an incoming virus it is made in an inactive state. This is because part of TRIM21, called a B-Box, inhibits the protein’s own activity. This was an unexpected discovery because, although the B-Box domain is found in around 100 other human proteins, it was unclear what it did. Dickson, Fletcher et al. then combined structural biology and biochemical approaches to show that the B-Box mimics specific enzymes that work with TRIM21, and blocks them from binding to it. This keeps TRIM21 in an inactive state.

Next, Dickson, Fletcher et al. discovered that TRIM21 becomes active when a chemical tag, specifically a phosphate group, is added to the protein. This modification displaces the B-Box, allowing ubiquitin enzymes to bind to TRIM21 and switch on its activity. Further experiments then showed that this process helps regulate TRIM21 during infections with different viruses, including rhinovirus – the virus behind the common cold – and adenovirus – a common cause of respiratory infection.

Antibodies are now used to treat many medical conditions, but present technologies are based on our understanding of how antibodies work outside cells. By revealing the basis of antibody immunity inside cells, these new findings may lead to new treatments for a range of conditions. Future studies could also explore how failures in the TRIM21 system contribute to autoimmune diseases.

Effects of Calcium Binding on the Side-chain Methyl Dynamics of Calbindin D9k: A 2H NMR Relaxation Study

The effects of Ca(2+) binding on the side-chain methyl dynamics of calbindin D(9k) have been characterized by (2)H NMR relaxation rate measurements. Longitudinal, transverse in-phase, quadrupolar order, transverse anti-phase and double quantum relaxation rates are reported for both the apo and Ca(2+)-loaded states of the protein at two magnetic field strengths. The relatively large size of the data set allows for a detailed analysis of the underlying conformational dynamics by spectral density mapping and model-free fitting procedures. The results reveal a correlation between a methyl group's distance from the Ca(2+) binding sites and its conformational dynamics. Several methyl groups segregate into two limiting classes, one proximal and the other distal to the binding sites. Methyl groups in these two classes respond differently to Ca(2+) binding, both in terms of the timescale and amplitude of their fluctuations. Ca(2+) binding elicits a partial immobilization among methyl groups in the proximal class, which is consistent with previous studies of calbindin's backbone dynamics. The distal class, however, exhibits a trend that could not be inferred from the backbone data in that its mobility actually increases with Ca(2+) binding. We have introduced the term polar dynamics to describe this type of organization across the molecule. The trend may represent an important mechanism by which calbindin D(9k) achieves high affinity binding while minimizing the corresponding loss of conformational entropy.

Calcium-dependent regulation of the voltage-gated sodium channel hH1: intrinsic and extrinsic sensors use a common molecular switch

The function of the human cardiac voltage-gated sodium channel Na(V)1.5 (hH1) is regulated in part by binding of calcium to an EF hand in the C-terminal cytoplasmic domain. hH1 is also regulated via an extrinsic calcium-sensing pathway mediated by calmodulin (CaM) via binding to an IQ motif immediately adjacent to the EF-hand domain. The intrinsic EF-hand domain is shown here to interact with the IQ motif, which controls calcium affinity. Remarkably, mutation of the IQ residues has only a minor effect on CaM affinity but drastically reduces calcium affinity of the EF-hand domain, whereas the Brugada mutation A1924T significantly reduces CaM affinity but has no effect on calcium affinity of the EF-hand domain. Moreover, the differences in the biochemical effects of the mutations directly correlate with contrasting effects on channel electrophysiology. A comprehensive model is proposed in which the hH1 IQ motif serves as a molecular switch, coupling the intrinsic and extrinsic calcium sensors.

Focusing of the electrostatic potential at EF-hands of calbindin D(9k): titration of acidic residues

Biological functions for a large class of calmodulin-related proteins, such as target protein activation and Ca(2+) buffering, are based on fine-tuned binding and release of Ca(2+) ions by pairs of coupled EF-hand metal binding sites. These are abundantly filled with acidic residues of so far unknown ionization characteristics, but assumed to be essential for protein function in their ionized forms. Here we describe the measurement and modeling of pK(a) values for all aspartic and glutamic acid residues in apo calbindin D(9k), a representative of calmodulin-related proteins. We point out that while all the acidic residues are ionized predominantly at neutral pH, the onset of proton uptake by Ca(2+) ligands with high pK(a) under these conditions may have functional implications. We also show that the negative electrostatic potential is focused at the bidental Ca(2+) ligand of each site, and that the potential is significantly more negative at the N-terminal binding site.

Locating the metal ion in calcium-binding proteins by using cerium(III) as a probe

The detection and assignment of NMR spectroscopic signals of carbon atoms from carbonyl and carboxylate groups in the loop hosting the Ce(III) ion was performed for the cerium-substituted calcium-binding protein calbindin D9k. This provided a tool to characterize in solution the first coordination sphere of the metal ion. Due to the well-documented possibility of replacing calcium with metal ions of the Ln(III) series, this approach turns out to be extremely efficient for characterizing in solution the coordination of calcium ions in proteins, independently of the availability of X-ray crystal structures. The present approach completes the structural characterization of lanthanide-substituted calcium-binding proteins, for which the role of long-range constraints arising from hyperfine interaction and self-orientation has already been assessed.

Comparison of the structural and dynamical properties of holo and apo bovine alpha-lactalbumin by NMR spectroscopy

In the presence of 0.5 M NaCl at pH 7.1, the Ca(2+)-free apo form of recombinant bovine alpha-lactalbumin (BLA) is sufficiently stabilised in its native state to give well-resolved NMR spectra at 20 degrees C. The (1)H and (15)N NMR resonances of native apo-BLA have been assigned, and the chemical-shifts compared with those of the native holo protein. Large changes observed between the two forms of BLA are mainly limited to the Ca(2+)-binding region of the protein. These data suggest that Na(+) stabilises the native apo state through the screening of repulsive negative charges, at the Ca(2+)-binding site or elsewhere, rather than by a specific interaction at the vacant Ca(2+)-binding site. The hydrogen exchange protection of residues in the Ca(2+)-binding loop and the C-helix is reduced in the apo form compared to that in the holo form. This indicates that the dynamic behaviour of this region of the protein is substantially increased in the absence of the bound Ca(2+). Real-time NMR experiments show that the rearrangements of the structure associated with the conversion of the holo to apo form of the protein do not involve the detectable population of partially unfolded intermediates. Rather, the conversion appears to involve local reorganisations of the structure in the vicinity of the Ca(2+)-binding site that are coupled to the intrinsic fluctuations in the protein structure.

Secondary structure and calcium-induced folding of the Clostridium thermocellum dockerin domain determined by NMR spectroscopy

Assembly of the cellulosome, a large, extracellular cellulase complex, depends upon docking of a myriad of enzymatic subunits to homologous receptors, or cohesin domains, arranged in tandem along a noncatalytic scaffolding protein. Docking to the cohesin domains is mediated by a highly conserved domain, dockerin (DS), borne by each enzymatic subunit. DS consists of two 22-amino-acid duplicated sequences, each bearing homology to the EF-hand calcium-binding loop. To compare the DS structure with that of the EF-hand helix-loop-helix motif, we analyzed the solution secondary structure of the DS from the cellobiohydrolase CelS subunit of the Clostridium thermocellum cellulosome using multidimensional heteronuclear NMR spectroscopy. The effect of Ca(2+)-binding on the DS structure was first investigated by using 2D (15)N-(1)H HSQC NMR spectroscopy. Changes in the spectra during Ca(2+) titration revealed that Ca(2+) induces folding of DS into its tertiary structure. This Ca(2+)-induced protein folding distinguishes DS from typical EF-hand-containing proteins. Sequential backbone assignments were determined for 63 of 69 residues. Analysis of the NOE connectivities and H(alpha) chemical shifts revealed that each half of the dockerin contains just one alpha-helix, comparable to the F-helix of the EF-hand motif. Thus, the structure of the DS Ca(2+)-binding subdomain deviates from that of the canonical EF-hand motif.

Cooperative cyclic interactions involved in metal binding to pairs of sites in EF-hand proteins

This study focuses on a closed net of electron-pair donor-acceptor interactions, present in the core of all metal-bound EF-hand pairs, that link both metal ions across a short two-stranded beta-sheet. A molecular model based on the above cycle of interactions was studied using semi-empirical molecular orbital quantum mechanical methods. The calculations indicate that the interactions in the model cycle are cooperative, that is, that the interaction energy of the cyclic structure is greater than that of the sum of isolated interactions between its components. The cooperativity in this cycle can be attributed to an increase in the stability of the interactions resulting from a mutual polarisation of the associated groups. The predicted polarisation of the amide groups in the cycle is in agreement with experimental NMR 15N deshielding observed for these amide groups upon metal binding. Experimental observations of strengthening of the beta-sheet hydrogen bonds are also consistent with the model calculations. By this mechanism, the binding of the first metal ion would enhance the binding of the second metal ion, and thus, the intradomain cooperativity in cation binding of calmodulin and related EF-hand proteins can be ascribed, at least partly, to this short-range molecular mechanism.

Identification of the binding site on S100B protein for the actin capping protein CapZ

The calcium-binding protein S100B binds to several potential target proteins, but there is no detailed information showing the location of the binding site for any target protein on S100B. We have made backbone assignments of the calcium-bound form of S100B and used chemical-shift changes in spectra of 15N-labeled protein to locate the site that binds a peptide corresponding to residues 265-276 from CapZ alpha, the actin capping protein. The largest chemical-shift changes are observed for resonances arising from residues around the C terminus of the C-terminal helix of S100B and residues Val-8 to Asp-12 of the N-terminal helix. These residues are close to but not identical to residues that have been identified by mutational analysis to be important in other S100 protein-protein interactions. They make up a patch across the S100B dimer interface and include some residues that are quite buried in the structure of calcium-free S100B. We believe we may have identified a binding site that could be common to many S100 protein-protein interactions.

A calbindin D9k mutant containing a novel structural extension: 1H nuclear magnetic resonance studies

Calbindin D9k is a small, well-studied calcium-binding protein consisting of two helix-loop-helix motifs called EF-hands. The P43MG2 mutant is one of a series of mutants designed to sequentially lengthen the largely unstructured tether region between the two EF-hands (F36-S44). A lower calcium affinity for P43MG was expected on the basis of simple entropic arguments. However, this is not the case and P43MG (-97 kJ.mol-1) has a stronger calcium affinity than P43M (-93 kJ.mol-1), P43G (-95 kJ.mol-1) and even wild-type protein (-96 kJ.mol-1). An NMR study was initiated to probe the structural basis for these calcium-binding results. The 1H NMR assignments and 3JHNH alpha values of the calcium-free and calcium-bound form of P43MG calbindin D9k mutant are compared with those of P43G. These comparisons reveal that little structure is formed in the tether regions of P43MG(apo), P43G(apo) and P43G(Ca) but a helical turn (S38-K41) appears to stabilize this part of the protein structure for P43MG(Ca). Several characteristic NOEs obtained from 2D and 3D NMR experiments support this novel helix. A similar, short helix exists in the crystal structure of calcium-bound wild-type calbindin D9k-but this is the first observation in solution for wild-type calbindin D9k or any of its mutants.

On the pH dependence of amide proton exchange rates in proteins

We have analyzed the pH dependencies of published amide proton exchange rates (kex) in three proteins: bovine pancreatic trypsin inhibitor (BPTI), bull seminal plasma proteinase inhibitor IIA (BUSI IIA), and calbindin D9K. The base-catalyzed exchange rate constants (kOH) of solvent exposed amides in BPTI are lower for residues with low peptide carbonyl exposure, showing that the environment around the carbonyl oxygen influences kOH. We also examined the possible importance of an exchange mechanism that involves formations of imidic acid intermediates along chains of hydrogen-bonded peptides in the three proteins. By invoking this "relayed imidic acid exchange mechanism," which should be essentially acid-catalyzed, we can explain the surprisingly high pHmin (the pH value at which kex reaches a minimum) found for the non-hydrogen-bonded amide protons in the beta-sheet in BPTI. The successive increase of pHmin along a chain of hydrogen-bonded peptides from the free amide to the free carbonyl, observed in BPTI, can be explained as an increasing contribution of the proposed mechanism in this direction of the chain. For BUSI IIA (pH 4-5) and calbindin D9K (pH 6-7) the majority of amide protons with negative pH dependence of kex are located in chains of hydrogen-bonded peptides; this situation is shown to be consistent with the proposed mechanism.

Determination of the solution structure of Apo calbindin D9k by NMR spectroscopy

The three-dimensional structure of apo calbindin D9k has been determined using constraints generated from nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy. The family of solution structures was calculated using a combination of distance geometry, restrained molecular dynamics, and hybrid relaxation matrix analysis of the nuclear Overhauser effect (NOE) cross-peak intensities. Errors and inconsistencies in the input constraints were identified using complete relaxation matrix analyses based on the results of preliminary structure calculations. The final input data consisted of 994 NOE distance constraints and 122 dihedral constraints, aided by the stereospecific assignment of the resonances from 21 beta-methylene groups and seven isopropyl groups of leucine and valine residues. The resulting family of 33 structures contain no violation of the distance constraints greater than 0.17 A or of the dihedral angle constraints greater than 10 degrees. The structures consist of a well-defined, antiparallel four-helix bundle, with a short anti-parallel beta-interaction between the two unoccupied calcium-binding loops. The root-mean-square deviation from the mean structure of the backbone heavy-atoms for the well-defined helical residues is 0.55 A. The remainder of the ion-binding loops, the linker loop connecting the two sub-domains of the protein, and the N and C termini exhibit considerable disorder between different structures in the ensemble. A comparison with the structure of the (Ca2+)2 state indicates that the largest changes associated with ion-binding occur in the middle of helix IV and in the packing of helix III onto the remainder of the protein. The change in conformation of these helices is associated with a subtle reorganization of many residues in the hydrophobic core, including some side-chains that are up to 15 A from the ion-binding site.

Signal transduction versus buffering activity in Ca(2+)-binding proteins

The three-dimensional structure of calbindin D9k in the absence of Ca2+ has been determined using NMR spectroscopy in solution, allowing the first direct analysis of the consequences of Ca2+ binding for a member of the calmodulin superfamily of proteins. The overall response in calbindin D9k is much attenuated relative to the current model for calmodulin and troponin C. These results demonstrate a novel mechanism for modulating the conformational response to Ca(2+)-binding in calmodulin superfamily proteins and provide insights into how their Ca(2+)-binding domains can be fine-tuned to remain essentially intact or respond strongly to ion binding, in relation to their functional requirements.

Effects of ion binding on the backbone dynamics of calbindin D9k determined by 15N NMR relaxation

The backbone dynamics of apo- and (Cd2+)1-calbindin D9k have been characterized by 15N nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy. Spin-lattice and spin-spin relaxation rate constants and steady-state [1H]-15N nuclear Overhauser effects were measured at a magnetic field strength of 11.74 T by two-dimensional, proton-detected heteronuclear NMR experiments using 15N-enriched samples. The relaxation parameters were analyzed using a model-free formalism that characterizes the dynamics of the N-H bond vectors in terms of generalized order parameters and effective correlation times. The data for the apo and (Cd2+)1 states were compared to those for the (Ca2+)2 state [Kördel, J., Skelton, N. J., Akke, M., Palmer, A. G., & Chazin, W. J. (1992) Biochemistry 31, 4856-4866] to ascertain the effects on ion ligation on the backbone dynamics of calbindin D9k. The two binding loops respond differently to ligation by metal ions: high-frequency (10(9)-10(12) s-1) fluctuations of the N-terminal ion-binding loop are not affected by ion binding, whereas residues G57, D58, G59, and E60 in the C-terminal ion-binding loop have significantly lower order parameters in the apo state than in the metal-bound states. The dynamical responses of the four helices to binding of ions are much smaller than that for the C-terminal binding loop, with the strongest effect on helix III, which is located between the linker loop and binding site II. Significant fluctuations on slower time scales also were detected in the unoccupied N-terminal ion-binding loop of the apo and (Cd2+)1 states; the apparent rates were greater for the (Cd2+)1 state. These results on the dynamical response to ion binding in calbindin D9k provide insights into the molecular details of the binding process and qualitative evidence for entropic contributions to the cooperative phenomenon of calcium binding for the pathway in which the ion binds first in the C-terminal site.

Nuclear magnetic resonance studies of the internal dynamics in Apo, (Cd2+)1 and (Ca2+)2 calbindin D9k. The rates of amide proton exchange with solvent

The backbone dynamics of the EF-hand Ca(2+)-binding protein, calbindin D9k, has been investigated in the apo, (Cd2+)1 and (Ca2+)2 states by measuring the rate constants for amide proton exchange with solvent. 15N-1H correlation spectroscopy was utilized to follow direct 1H-->2H exchange of the slowly exchanging amide protons and to follow indirect proton exchange via saturation transfer from water to the rapidly exchanging amide protons. Plots of experimental rate constants versus intrinsic rate constants have been analyzed to give qualitative insight into the opening modes of the protein that lead to exchange. These results have been interpreted within the context of a progressive unfolding model, wherein hydrophobic interactions and metal chelation serve to anchor portions of the protein, thereby damping fluctuations and retarding amide proton exchange. The addition of Ca2+ or Cd2+ was found to retard the exchange of many amide protons observed to be in hydrogen-bonding environments in the crystal structure of the (Ca2+)2 state, but not of those amide protons that were not involved in hydrogen bonds. The largest changes in rate constant occur for residues in the ion-binding loops, with substantial effects also found for the adjacent residues in helices I, II and III, but not helix IV. The results are consistent with a reorganization of the hydrogen-bonding networks in the metal ion-binding loops, accompanied by a change in the conformation of helix IV, as metal ions are chelated. Further analysis of the results obtained for the three states of metal occupancy provides insight into the nature of the changes in conformational fluctuations induced by ion binding.