Analysis of the role of the COL1 domain and its adjacent cysteine-containing sequence in the chain assembly of type IX collagen

The NC2 domain of collagen IX provides chain selection and heterotrimerization

The mechanism of chain selection and trimerization of fibril-associated collagens with interrupted triple helices (FACITs) differs from that of fibrillar collagens that have special C-propeptides. We recently showed that the second carboxyl-terminal non-collagenous domain (NC2) of homotrimeric collagen XIX forms a stable trimer and substantially stabilizes a collagen triple helix attached to either end. We then hypothesized a general trimerizing role for the NC2 domain in other FACITs. Here we analyzed the NC2 domain of human heterotrimeric collagen IX, the only member of FACITs with all three chains encoded by distinct genes. Upon oxidative folding of equimolar amounts of the alpha1, alpha2, and alpha3 chains of NC2, a stable heterotrimer with a disulfide bridge between alpha1 and alpha3 chains is formed. Our experiments show that this heterotrimerization domain can stabilize a short triple helix attached at the carboxyl-terminal end and allows for the proper oxidation of the cystine knot of type III collagen after the short triple helix.

Trimerization of collagen IX alpha-chains does not require the presence of the COL1 and NC1 domains

Collagen IX is a heterotrimer of three alpha-chains, which consists of three COL domains (collagenous domains) (COL1-COL3) and four NC domains (non-collagenous domains) (NC1-NC4), numbered from the C-terminus. Although collagen IX chains have been shown to associate via their C-terminal NC1 domains and form a triple helix starting from the COL1 domain, it is not known whether chain association can occur at other sites and whether other collagenous and non-collagenous regions are involved. To address this question, we prepared five constructs, two long variants (beginning at the NC4 domain) and three short variants (beginning at the COL2 domain), all ending at the NC2 domain (or NC2 replaced by NC1), to study association and selection of collagen IX alpha-chains. Both long variants were able to associate with NC1 or NC2 at the C-terminus and form various disulfide-bonded trimers, but the specificity of chain selection was diminished compared with full-length chains. Trimers of the long variant ending at NC2 were shown to be triple helical by CD. Short variants were not able to assemble into disulfide-bonded trimers even in the presence of both conserved cysteine residues from the COL1-NC1 junction. Our results demonstrate that collagen IX alpha-chains can associate in the absence of COL1 and NC1 domains to form a triple helix, but the COL2-NC2 region alone is not sufficient for trimerization. The results suggest that folding of collagen IX is a co-operative process involving multiple COL and NC domains and that the COL1-NC1 region is important for chain specificity.

Natural and artificial cystine knots for assembly of homo- and heterotrimeric collagen models

Native collagens are molecules that are difficult to handle because of their high tendency towards aggregation and denaturation. It was discovered early on that synthetic collagenous peptides are more amenable to conformational characterization and thus can serve as useful models for structural and functional studies. Single-stranded collagenous peptides of high propensity to self-associate into triple-helical trimers were used for this purpose as well as interchain-crosslinked homotrimers assembled on synthetic scaffolds. With the growing knowledge of the biosynthetic pathways of natural collagens and the importance of their interchain disulfide crosslinks, which stabilize the triple-helical structure, native as well as de novo designed cystine knots have gained increasing attention in the assembly of triple-stranded collagen peptides. In addition, natural sequences of collagens were incorporated in order to biophysically characterize their functional epitopes. This review is focused on the methods developed over the years, and future perspectives for the production of collagen-mimicking synthetic and recombinant triple-helical homo- and heterotrimers.

Stabilization of short collagen-like triple helices by protein engineering

Recombinant expression of collagens and fragments of collagens is often difficult, as their biosynthesis requires specific post-translational enzymes, in particular prolyl 4-hydroxylase. Although the use of hydroxyproline-deficient variants offers one possibility to overcome this difficulty, these proteins usually differ markedly in stability when compared with the hydroxyproline-containing analogs. Here, we report a method to stabilize collagen-like peptides by fusing them to the N terminus of the bacteriophage T4 fibritin foldon domain. The isolated foldon domain and the chimeric protein (GlyProPro)(10)foldon were expressed in a soluble form in Escherichia coli. The recombinant proteins and the synthetic (ProProGly)(10) peptide were characterized by circular dichroism (CD) spectroscopy, differential scanning calorimetry, and analytical ultracentrifugation. We show that the foldon domain, which comprises only 27 amino acid residues, forms an obligatory trimer with a high degree of thermal stability. The CD thermal unfolding profiles recorded from foldon are monophasic and completely reversible upon cooling. Similar Van't Hoff and calorimertic enthalpy values of trimer formation indicated a cooperative all-or-none transition. As reported previously, (ProProGly)(10) peptides form collagen triple helices of only moderate stability. When fused to the foldon domain, however, triple helix formation of (GlyProPro)(10) is concentration independent, and the midpoint temperature of the triple helix unfolding is significantly increased. The stabilizing function of the trimeric foldon domain is explained by the close vicinity of its N termini, which induce a high local concentration in the range of 1 M for the C termini of the collagen-like-peptide. Collagen-foldon fusion proteins should be potentially useful to study receptor-collagen interactions.

Characterization of recombinant human type IX collagen. Association of alpha chains into homotrimeric and heterotrimeric molecules

As type IX collagen is a minor cartilage component, it is difficult to purify sufficient amounts of it from tissues or cultured cells to study its structure and function. Also, the conventional pepsin digestion used for fibrillar collagens cannot be utilized for purifying type IX collagen, because it contains several interruptions in its collagenous triple helix. A baculovirus expression system was used here to produce recombinant human type IX collagen by coinfecting insect cells with three viruses containing full-length cDNAs for the alpha1(IX), alpha2(IX), and alpha3(IX) collagen chains together with a double promoter virus for the alpha and beta subunits of human prolyl 4-hydroxylase. Correctly folded recombinant type IX collagen was secreted, consisting of the three alpha chains in a 1:1:1 ratio and showing the expected biphasic thermal melting profile. When the individual alpha chains were expressed, disulfide-bonded homotrimers and homodimers of the alpha chains were observed. When the cells were coinfected with the viruses for all three alpha chains, heterotrimers of alpha1(IX), alpha2(IX), and alpha3(IX) were detected in cell culture medium, and the other possible combinations were less prominent. When any two of the alpha chains were co-expressed, in addition to the homodimers and homotrimers, only alpha1(IX) and alpha3(IX) chains were disulfide-bonded. The results thus suggest that the most favored molecular species is an alpha1(IX)alpha2(IX)alpha3(IX) heterotrimer, but the chains are also able to form disulfide-bonded heterotrimers of alpha1(IX) and alpha3(IX) chains and (alpha1(IX))(3), (alpha2(IX))(3), and (alpha3(IX))(3) homotrimers.

Absence of the alpha1(IX) chain leads to a functional knock-out of the entire collagen IX protein in mice

Cartilage fibrils contain collagen II as well as smaller amounts of collagens IX and XI. The three collagens are thought to co-assemble into cartilage-specific arrays. The precise role of collagen IX in cartilage has been addressed previously by generating mice harboring an inactivated Col9a1 gene encoding the alpha1(IX) chain, i.e. one of the three constituent chains of collagen IX (Fässler, R., Schnegelsberg, P. N. J., Dausman, J., Shinya, T., Muragaki, Y., McCarthy, M. T., Olsen, B. R., and Jaenisch, R. (1994) Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U. S. A. 91, 5070-5074). The animals did not produce alpha1(IX) mRNA or polypeptides and were born with no conspicuous skeletal abnormality but post-natally developed early onset osteoarthritis. Here we show that the deficiency in alpha1(IX) chains leads to a functional knock-out of all polypeptides of collagen IX, whereas the Col9a2 and Col9a3 genes were normally transcribed. Therefore, synthesis of alpha1(IX) polypeptides is essential for the assembly of heterotrimeric collagen IX molecules. Surprisingly, cartilage fibrils of all shapes and banding patterns found in normal newborn, adolescent, or adult mice were formed in transgenic animals, although they lacked collagen IX. Therefore, collagen IX is not essential, and may be functionally redundant, in fibrillogenesis in cartilage in vivo. The protein is required, however, for long term tissue stability, presumably by mediating interactions between fibrillar and extrafibrillar macromolecules.

Trimeric assembly and three-dimensional structure model of the FACIT collagen COL1-NC1 junction from CD and NMR analysis

The 3D structure of the COL1-NC1 junction of FACIT type XIV collagen was investigated using GYCDPSSCAG and (GPP*)3GYCDPSSCAG synthetic peptides, circular dichroism, and NMR. At -20 degrees C and under air oxidation catalyzed by Cu2+, the peptide (GPP*)3GYCDPSSCAG is able to self-associated with high yield into a stable triple disulfide bonded trimer. The presence of a triple helical conformation was confirmed by circular dichroism. The analysis of the trimer by 2D NMR provided a set of distance constraints for the noncollagenous part. Molecular models for the 3D structure of COL1-NC1 junction were calculated, using the NMR distance constraints in combination with the 3D structural data recently established by X-ray crystallography [Bella, J., Eaton, M., Brodsky, B., & Berman, H. M. (1994) Science 266, 75-81] for a collagenous triple helix. From the eight theoretically possible arrangements for the three interchain disulfide bonds, only two close disulfide conformers are compatible with the experimental data. The main feature of the trimer structure is the asymmetry of the molecule due to the disulfide bond pattern that induces a particular folding of one chain. This chain forms a turn-like structure locked by two disulfide bonds with the two other chains. The turn-like folding is close to that observed for the cyclized oxidized monomeric peptide. This is the first report of the 3D structure model for a junction between a collagenous triple helical domain and a noncollagenous domain.

Type IX collagen NC1 domain peptides can trimerize in vitro without forming a triple helix

Synthetic peptides of the three chains of type IX collagen consisting of the carboxyl-terminal end of the COL1 domain and the complete NC1 domain were characterized by circular dichroism spectroscopy and analyzed for their ability to assemble into trimers. In vitro association and oxidation result in disulfide-linked oligomers as shown by molecular sieve chromatography and SDS-polyacrylamide electrophoresis. Whereas the individual peptides show a tendency to self-associate, when an equimolar amount of the three peptides was oxidized, a heterotrimer of the three chains was observed. This heterotrimer is recognized by a monoclonal antibody against the disulfide-linked NC1 domain of chicken type IX collagen, indicating the correct formation of the disulfide bonds. Circular dichroism measurements show that under the association conditions used, a triple helix does not form between the chains. These results indicate that these peptides contain all the necessary information for chain selection and assembly.

Collagen expression in chicken tibial dyschondroplasia

Collagen expression in growth plate cartilage derived from broiler chickens with tibial dyschondroplasia was studied and compared with samples from unaffected birds. Normal growth plate contains 12% collagen (dry weight) and dyschondroplastic growth plate 19% collagen compared with articular cartilage, which contains 55%. Dyschondroplastic growth plate collagens were more resistant to extraction by pepsin treatment than were those from unaffected growth plate. Normal and dyschondroplastic growth plate cartilages contain similar amounts of type I collagen (5% of the total collagen) but dyschondroplastic growth plate cartilage contains slightly less type II and type XI collagens, and significantly more type X collagen (25% as compared to 11%) than in normal growth plate. The levels of the mature collagen cross-link, hydroxylysyl-pyridinoline, are very low in normal growth plate but are six times higher in dyschondroplastic lesions. Immunolocalisation studies show that there is little change to the normal patterns of collagen organisation in dyschondroplastic growth plate. Investigation of metalloproteinase activity showed there to be a reduction in MMP-2 levels in dyschondroplastic growth plate compared to normal growth plate. In vitro studies on articular, normal growth plate and dyschondroplastic growth plate chondrocytes cultured in alginate or on plastic revealed differences between the cell types. When plated on plastic, articular chondrocytes rapidly assume a fibroblastic morphology. In contrast, normal growth plate chondrocytes retain their polygonal morphology whereas chondrocytes derived from dyschondroplastic cartilage initially exhibit both fibroblastic and polygonal phenotypes but gradually change to totally fibroblastic. These morphological changes are reflected by the collagen synthesis in vitro. Chondrocytes derived from normal articular cartilage synthesised collagen types I, II and X when cultured in alginate but type X synthesis was lost when cultured on plastic. Chondrocytes derived from normal growth plate cartilage synthesised predominantly type X collagen when cultured in either system. Chondrocytes derived from dyschondroplastic growth plate exhibited a similar phenotype to normal growth plate chondrocytes when cultured in alginate beads, but showed signs of dedifferentiation with reduced type X collagen and increased type I collagen when plated on plastic. These results suggest that the chondrocytes in dyschondroplastic growth plate cartilage are at a different stage of maturity than normal resulting in a cartilage that is failing to turn over at a normal rate.

Trimeric assembly of collagen XII: effect of deletion of the C-terminal part of the molecule

The fibril-associated-collagens-with-interrupted-triple-helices (FACITs) are devoid of large C-propeptides like those involved in the trimeric assembly of the fibrillar collagens. Under these conditions, the C-terminal non triple-helical domain (NC1) and the adjacent triple-helical domain (COL1) are likely to be responsible for the trimeric assembly of these collagen molecules. Using a recombinant minigene of one of the FACITs, collagen XII, we show that a deletion covering most of the NC1 domain, except the first seven residues containing a cysteine and constituting the main part of the conserved junction between the COL1 and NC1 domains, does not prevent the formation of trimeric disulfide-bonded assembly of truncated alpha chains. These results suggest that if the non triple-helical NC1 domain is involved in the initial events governing the trimeric assembly, it must be through its amino acid residues participating in the junction. Our data confirm also the results obtained in a previous paper (Mazzorana et al.: J. Biol. Chem. 268:3029-3032, 1993) showing that the formation of disulfide bonds is dependent on hydroxylation and suggesting that the folding of the triple helix (or a part of it) precedes the formation of the disulfide bonds.

Caenorhabditis elegans sqt-3 mutants have mutations in the col-1 collagen gene

sqt-3 mutants of Caenorhabditis elegans form dumpy larvae and adults and display allele-specific defects in locomotion, fertility, and viability. We have determined that the sqt-3 locus encodes COL-1 collagen. We physically mapped the col-1 gene to a cosmid on chromosome V whose position is consistent with the location of the sqt-3 gene. We also observed morphological defects in sqt-3 mutants at stages that correlate with the mRNA expression patterns of col-1. Sequence analysis of the col-1 gene in the three temperature-sensitive mutants revealed that each allele of sqt-3 has a unique missense mutation causing arginine or glutamic acid to replace glycine in a Gly-X-Y triple helical domain. These glycine substitutions may result in longer non-collagenous domains, which may decrease the thermal stability or impart additional flexibility to mutant trimers. In addition, we describe four corrections to the published sequence of col-1, including one fifteen nucleotide addition that completes a conserved domain in the amino terminal coding region.

Structure and stability of the triple-helical domains of human collagen XIV

Two triple-helical domains, Col 1 and Col 2, were obtained from a pepsin digest of human placental collagen XIV and separated from each other under nondenaturing conditions. Edman degradation demonstrated 106 amino acids residues in the Col 1 and 149 residues in the Col 2 domain. All except one of the 37 prolines in the Yaa position of the Gly-Xaa-Yaa triplets were completely hydroxylated to 4-hydroxyproline, and there were three imperfections in the triplet repeat. Partial or complete hydroxylation and glycosylation were found for all seven lysines in the Yaa position. Domain Col 1 was joined by disulfide bonds into a trimer, while Col 2 appeared as a mixture of monomers and disulfide-linked dimers. Circular dichroic spectra were typical for the collagen triple helix and revealed relatively high melting temperatures for Col 1 (38 degrees C) and Col 2 (43 degrees C). An almost perfect refolding of the triple helix was observed for Col 1 but not for Col 2, emphasizing the importance of disulfide bonds for the folding kinetics and in part the stability of the triple helix. Circular dichroic spectra of the large nontriple helical domain, NC3, of collagen XIV indicated 11% alpha helix and 63% beta structure. Comparative melting profiles of NC3 and intact collagen XIV indicated that the triple helices in intact collagen XIV have a melting temperature of 44 degrees C.

A parallel three stranded alpha-helical bundle at the nucleation site of collagen triple-helix formation

A short stretch of 35 amino acids is identified as the structural motif responsible for the tight parallel association and trimerization of the three identical polypeptide chains of lung surfactant protein D, which contains both collagen regions and C-type lectin domains. This 'neck-region' is located at the nucleation site at which the collagenous sequences fold into a staggered triple-helix and is shown, by CD, NMR, and cross-linking of recombinant peptides, to consist of a triple-stranded parallel alpha-helical bundle in a non-staggered, and extremely strong, non-covalent association. This type of association between three polypeptide chains may represent a common structural feature immediately following the C-terminal end of the triple-helical region of collagenous proteins.

In vitro mutagenesis of Caenorhabditis elegans cuticle collagens identifies a potential subtilisin-like protease cleavage site and demonstrates that carboxyl domain disulfide bonding is required for normal function but not assembly

The importance of conserved amino acids in the amino and carboxyl non-Gly-X-Y domains of Caenorhabditis elegans cuticle collagens was examined by analyzing site-directed mutations of the sqt-1 and rol-6 collagen genes in transgenic animals. Altered collagen genes on transgenic arrays were shown to produce appropriate phenotypes by injecting in vivo cloned mutant alleles. Equivalent alterations in sqt-1 and rol-6 generally produced the same phenotypes, indicating that conserved amino acids in these two collagens have similar functions. Serine substitutions for either of two conserved carboxyl domain cysteines produced LRol phenotypes. Substitution for both cysteines in sqt-1 also resulted in an LRol phenotype, demonstrating that disulfide bonding is important for normal function but not required for assembly. Arg-1 or Arg-4 to Cys mutations in homology block A (HBA; consensus, 1-RXRRQ-5; in the amino non-Gly-X-Y domain) caused RRol phenotypes, while the same alteration at Arg-3 had no effect, indicating that Arg-3 is functionally different from Arg-1 and Arg-4. Substitutions of Arg-4 with Ser, Leu, or Glu also produced the RRol phenotype, while Lys substitutions for Arg-1 or Arg-4 did not generate any abnormal phenotypes. His substitutions for Arg-1 or Arg-4 caused somewhat less severe RRol phenotypes. Therefore, strong positively charged residues, Arg or Lys, are required at positions 1 and 4 for normal function. The conserved pattern of arginines in HBA matches the cleavage sites of the subtilisin-like endoproteinases. HBA may be a cleavage site for a subtilisin-like protease, and cleavage may be important for cuticle collagen processing.

In vitro mutagenesis of Caenorhabditis elegans cuticle collagens identifies a potential subtilisin-like protease cleavage site and demonstrates that carboxyl domain disulfide bonding is required for normal function but not assembly

The importance of conserved amino acids in the amino and carboxyl non-Gly-X-Y domains of Caenorhabditis elegans cuticle collagens was examined by analyzing site-directed mutations of the sqt-1 and rol-6 collagen genes in transgenic animals. Altered collagen genes on transgenic arrays were shown to produce appropriate phenotypes by injecting in vivo cloned mutant alleles. Equivalent alterations in sqt-1 and rol-6 generally produced the same phenotypes, indicating that conserved amino acids in these two collagens have similar functions. Serine substitutions for either of two conserved carboxyl domain cysteines produced LRol phenotypes. Substitution for both cysteines in sqt-1 also resulted in an LRol phenotype, demonstrating that disulfide bonding is important for normal function but not required for assembly. Arg-1 or Arg-4 to Cys mutations in homology block A (HBA; consensus, 1-RXRRQ-5; in the amino non-Gly-X-Y domain) caused RRol phenotypes, while the same alteration at Arg-3 had no effect, indicating that Arg-3 is functionally different from Arg-1 and Arg-4. Substitutions of Arg-4 with Ser, Leu, or Glu also produced the RRol phenotype, while Lys substitutions for Arg-1 or Arg-4 did not generate any abnormal phenotypes. His substitutions for Arg-1 or Arg-4 caused somewhat less severe RRol phenotypes. Therefore, strong positively charged residues, Arg or Lys, are required at positions 1 and 4 for normal function. The conserved pattern of arginines in HBA matches the cleavage sites of the subtilisin-like endoproteinases. HBA may be a cleavage site for a subtilisin-like protease, and cleavage may be important for cuticle collagen processing.