A cryoelectron microscopy study of the interaction of the Escherichia coli F1-ATPase with subunit b dimer

ATP synthase: subunit-subunit interactions in the stator stalk

In ATP synthase, proton translocation through the Fo subcomplex and ATP synthesis/hydrolysis in the F1 subcomplex are coupled by subunit rotation. The static, non-rotating portions of F1 and Fo are attached to each other via the peripheral "stator stalk", which has to withstand elastic strain during subunit rotation. In Escherichia coli, the stator stalk consists of subunits b2delta; in other organisms, it has three or four different subunits. Recent advances in this area include affinity measurements between individual components of the stator stalk as well as a detailed analysis of the interaction between subunit delta (or its mitochondrial counterpart, the oligomycin-sensitivity conferring protein, OSCP) and F1. The current status of our knowledge of the structure of the stator stalk and of the interactions between its subunits will be discussed in this review.

Mitochondrial F(0)F(1) ATP synthase. Subunit regions on the F1 motor shielded by F(0), Functional significance, and evidence for an involvement of the unique F(0) subunit F(6)

Studies reported here were undertaken to gain greater molecular insight into the complex structure of mitochondrial ATP synthase (F(0)F(1)) and its relationship to the enzyme's function and motor-related properties. Significantly, these studies, which employed N-terminal sequence, mass spectral, proteolytic, immunological, and functional analyses, led to the following novel findings. First, at the top of F(1) within F(0)F(1), all six N-terminal regions derived from alpha + beta subunits are shielded, indicating that one or more F(0) subunits forms a "cap." Second, at the bottom of F(1) within F(0)F(1), the N-terminal region of the single delta subunit and the C-terminal regions of all three alpha subunits are shielded also by F(0). Third, and in contrast, part of the gamma subunit located at the bottom of F(1) is already shielded in F(1), indicating that there is a preferential propensity for interaction with other F(1) subunits, most likely delta and epsilon. Fourth, and consistent with the first two conclusions above that specific regions at the top and bottom of F(1) are shielded by F(0), further proteolytic shaving of alpha and beta subunits at these locations eliminates the capacity of F(1) to couple a proton gradient to ATP synthesis. Finally, evidence was obtained that the F(0) subunit called "F(6)," unique to animal ATP synthases, is involved in shielding F(1). The significance of the studies reported here, in relation to current views about ATP synthase structure and function in animal mitochondria, is discussed.

The rotary binding change mechanism of ATP synthases

The F(0)F(1) ATP synthase functions as a rotary motor where subunit rotation driven by a current of protons flowing through F(0) drives the binding changes in F(1) that are required for net ATP synthesis. Recent work that has led to the identification of components of the rotor and stator is reviewed. In addition, a model is proposed to describe the transmission of energy from four proton transport steps to the synthesis of one ATP. Finally, some of the requirements for efficient energy coupling by a rotary binding change mechanism are considered.

Molecular models of the structural arrangement of subunits and the mechanism of proton translocation in the membrane domain of F(1)F(0) ATP synthase

Subunit c of the proton-transporting ATP synthase of Escherichia coli forms an oligomeric complex in the membrane domain that functions in transmembrane proton conduction. The arrangement of subunit c monomers in this oligomeric complex was studied by scanning mutagenesis. On the basis of these studies and structural information on subunit c, different molecular models for the potential arrangement of monomers in the c-oligomer are discussed. Intersubunit contacts in the F(0) domain that have been analysed in the past by chemical modification and mutagenesis studies are summarised. Transient contacts of the c-oligomer with subunit a might play a crucial role in the mechanism of proton translocation. Schematic models presented by several authors that interpret proton transport in the F(0) domain by a relative rotation of the c-subunit oligomer against subunit a are reviewed against the background of the molecular models of the oligomer.

The structure of the H(+)-ATP synthase from chloroplasts and its subcomplexes as revealed by electron microscopy

The electron microscopic data available on CF(0)F(1) and its subcomplexes, CF(0), CF(1), subunit III complex are collected and the CF(1) data are compared with the high resolution structure of MF(1). The data are based on electron microscopic investigation of negatively stained isolated CF(1), CF(0)F(1) and subunit III complex. In addition, two-dimensional crystals of CF(0)F(1) and CF(0)F(1) reconstituted liposomes were investigated by cryo-electron microscopy. Progress in the interpretation of electron microscopic data from biological samples has been made with the introduction of image analysis. Multi-reference alignment and classification of images have led to the differentiation between different conformational states and to the detection of a second stalk. Recently, the calculation of three-dimensional maps from the class averages led to the understanding of the spatial organisation of the enzyme. Such three-dimensional maps give evidence of the existence of a third connection between the F(0) part and F(1) part.

Deletions in the second stalk of F1F0-ATP synthase in Escherichia coli

In Escherichia coli F1F0-ATP synthase, the two b subunits form the second stalk spanning the distance between the membrane F0 sector and the bulk of F1. Current models predict that the stator should be relatively rigid and engaged in contact with F1 at fixed points. To test this hypothesis, we constructed a series of deletion mutations in the uncF(b) gene to remove segments from the middle of the second stalk of the subunit. Mutants with deletions of 7 amino acids were essentially normal, and those with deletions of up to 11 amino acids retained considerable activity. Membranes prepared from these strains had readily detectable levels of F1-ATPase activity and proton pumping activity. Removal of 12 or more amino acids resulted in loss of oxidative phosphorylation. Levels of membrane-associated F1-ATPase dropped precipitously for the longer deletions, and immunoblot analysis indicated that reductions in activity correlated with reduced levels of b subunit in the membranes. Assuming the likely alpha-helical conformation for this area of the b subunit, the 11-amino acid deletion would result in shortening the subunit by approximately 16 A. Since these deletions did not prevent the b subunit from participating in productive interactions with F1, we suggest that the b subunit is not a rigid rodlike structure, but has an inherent flexibility compatible with a dynamic role in coupling.

Formation of the b subunit dimer is necessary for interaction with F1-ATPase

In earlier work, we [McCormick, K. A., et al. (1993) J. Biol. Chem. 268, 24683-24691] observed that mutations at Ala-79 of the b subunit affect assembly of F1F0 ATP synthase. Polypeptides modeled on the soluble portion of the b subunit (bsol) with substitutions at the position corresponding to Ala-79 have been used to investigate secondary structure and dimerization of the b subunit. Circular dichroism spectra and chymotrypsin digestion experiments suggested that the recombinant polypeptides with Ala-79 substitutions assumed conformations similar to the bsol polypeptide. However, cross-linking studies of the Ala-79 substitution bsol polypeptides revealed defects in dimerization. The efficiency of dimer formation appeared to be related to the capacity of the altered bsol polypeptides for competing with F1-ATPase for binding to F1-depleted membrane vesicles. Ala-79 substitution polypeptides displaying limited dimerization, such as bsol Ala-79-->Leu, were shown to elute with F1-ATPase during size exclusion chromatography, suggesting a specific interaction. Sedimentation equilibrium studies indicated that 8% of the bsol Ala-79-->Leu polypeptide was in the form of a 30.6 kDa dimer and 92% a 15.3 kDa monomer. When the dimer concentration of bsol Ala-79-->Leu was normalized to the concentration of bsol, both had virtually identical capacities for competing with F1-depleted membrane vesicles for binding F1-ATPase. The result indicated that the amount of dimer formed is directly proportional to its ability to bind F1-ATPase. This suggests that formation of the b subunit dimer may be a necessary step preceding F1-ATPase binding in the assembly of the enzyme complex.

The intriguing evolution of the "b" and "G" subunits in F-type and V-type ATPases: isolation of the vma-10 gene from Neurospora crassa

We have characterized the vma-10 gene which encodes the G subunit of the vacuolar ATPase in Neurospora crassa. The gene is somewhat unusual in filamentous fungi because it contains five introns, comprising 71% of the region between the translation start and stop codons. The 5' untranslated region of the gene contains several elements that have been identified in other genes that encode subunits of the vacuolar ATPase in N. crassa. A comparison of G subunits from N. crassa, S. cerevisiae, and animal cells showed that the N-terminal half of the polypeptide shows the highest degree of sequence conservation. Most striking is the observation that this region could form an alpha helix in which all of the conserved residues are clustered on one face. Subunit G appears to be homologous to the b subunit found in F-type ATPases. The major difference between the b and G subunits is the lack of a membrane-spanning region in the G subunit. We have also identified homologous subunits in the operons which encode V-type ATPases in a eubacterium, Enterrococcus hirae, and an archaebacterium, Methanococcus jannaschii. As in eukaryotic vacuolar ATPases the G subunit homologs lack a membrane-spanning region. Although the b and G subunits appear to be derived from a common ancestor, significant changes have evolved. In F-type and V-type ATPases these subunits can have zero, one, or two membrane-spanning regions and can also differ significantly in the number of copies per enzyme.

Subunit rotation in Escherichia coli FoF1-ATP synthase during oxidative phosphorylation

We report evidence for proton-driven subunit rotation in membrane-bound FoF1-ATP synthase during oxidative phosphorylation. A betaD380C/gammaC87 crosslinked hybrid F1 having epitope-tagged betaD380C subunits (betaflag) exclusively in the two noncrosslinked positions was bound to Fo in F1-depleted membranes. After reduction of the beta-gamma crosslink, a brief exposure to conditions for ATP synthesis followed by reoxidation resulted in a significant amount of betaflag appearing in the beta-gamma crosslinked product. Such a reorientation of gammaC87 relative to the three beta subunits can only occur through subunit rotation. Rotation was inhibited when proton transport through Fo was blocked or when ADP and Pi were omitted. These results establish FoF1 as the second example in nature where proton transport is coupled to subunit rotation.

Dimerization interactions of the b subunit of the Escherichia coli F1F0-ATPase

Site-directed mutagenesis and N-terminal truncations were used to examine dimerization interactions in the b subunit of Escherichia coli F1F0-ATPase. Individual cysteine residues were incorporated into bsyn, a soluble form of the protein lacking the membrane-spanning N-terminal domain, in two main areas: the heptad repeat region and the hydrophobic region which begins at residue Val-124. The tendencies of these cysteine residues to form disulfide bonds with the corresponding cysteine in the bsyn dimer were tested using disulfide exchange by glutathione and air oxidation catalyzed by Cu2+. Within the heptad repeat region, only cysteines at residues 59 and 60, which occupy the b and c positions of the heptad repeat, showed significant tendencies to form disulfides, a result inconsistent with a coiled-coil model for bsyn. Mixed disulfide formation most readily occurred with the S60C + L65C and A61C + L65C pairs. Cysteines at positions 124, 128, 132, and 139 showed strong tendencies to form disulfides with their mates in the dimer, suggesting a parallel alpha-helical interaction between the subunits in this region. Deletion of residues N-terminal to either Glu-34 or Asp-53 had no apparent effect on dimerization as determined by sedimentation equilibrium, while deletion of all residues N-terminal to Lys-67 produced a monomeric form. These results imply that residues 53-66 but not 24-52 are essential for bsyn dimerization. Taken together the results are consistent with a model in which the two b subunits interact in more than one region, including a parallel alignment of helices containing residues 124-139.

Molecular basis for the coupling ion selectivity of F1F0 ATP synthases: probing the liganding groups for Na+ and Li+ in the c subunit of the ATP synthase from Propionigenium modestum

The conserved glutamate residue at position 65 of the Propionigenium modestum c subunit is directly involved in binding and translocation of Na+ across the membrane. The site-specific introduction of the cQ32I and cS66A substitutions in the putative vicinity to cE65 inhibited growth of the single-site mutants on succinate minimal agar, indicating that both amino acid residues are important for proper function of the oxidative phosphorylation system. This growth inhibition was abolished, however, if the cF84L/cL87V double mutation was additionally present in the P. modestum c subunit. The newly constructed Escherichia coli strain MPC848732I, harboring the cQ32I/cF84L/cL87V triple mutation, revealed a change in the coupling ion specificity from Na+ to H+. ATP hydrolysis by this enzyme was therefore not activated by NaCl, and ATP-driven H+ transport was not affected by this alkali salt. Both activities were influenced, however, by LiCl. These data demonstrate the loss of the Na+ binding site and retention of Li+ and H+ binding sites within this mutant ATPase. In the E. coli strain MPC848766A (cS66A/cF84L/cL87V), the specificity of the ATPase was further restricted to H+ as the exclusive coupling ion. Therefore, neither Na+ nor Li+ stimulated the ATPase activity, and no ATP-driven Li+ transport was observed. The ATPase of the E. coli mutant MPC32N (cQ32N) was activated by NaCl and LiCl. The mutant ATPase exhibited a 5-fold higher Km for NaCl but no change in the Km for LiCl in comparison to that of the parent strain. These results demonstrate that the binding of Na+ to the c subunit of P. modestum requires liganding groups provided by Q32, E65, and S66. For the coordination of Li+, two liganding partners, E65 and S66, are sufficient, and H+ translocation was mediated by E65 alone.

Catalytic mechanism of F1-ATPase

The structure of the core catalytic unit of ATP synthase, alpha 3 beta 3 gamma, has been determined by X-ray crystallography, revealing a roughly symmetrical arrangement of alternating alpha and beta subunits around a central cavity in which helical portions of gamma are found. A low-resolution structural model of F0, based on electron spectroscopic imaging, locates subunit a and the two copies of subunit b outside of a subunit c oligomer. The structures of individual subunits epsilon and c (largely) have been solved by NMR spectroscopy, but the oligomeric structure of c is still unknown. The structures of subunits a and delta remain undefined, that of b has not yet been defined but biochemical evidence indicates a credible model. Subunits gamma, epsilon, b, and delta are at the interface between F1 and F0; gamma epsilon complex forms one element of the stalk, interacting with c at the base and alpha and beta at the top. The locations of b and delta are less clear. Elucidation of the structure F0, of the stalk, and of the entire F1F0 remains a challenging goal.

The ATP synthase--a splendid molecular machine

An X-ray structure of the F1 portion of the mitochondrial ATP synthase shows asymmetry and differences in nucleotide binding of the catalytic beta subunits that support the binding change mechanism with an internal rotation of the gamma subunit. Other structural and mutational probes of the F1 and F0 portions of the ATP synthase are reviewed, together with kinetic and other evaluations of catalytic site occupancy and behavior during hydrolysis or synthesis of ATP. Subunit function as related to proton translocation and rotational catalysis is considered. Physical demonstrations of the gamma subunit rotation have been achieved. The findings have implications for other enzymatic catalyses.

Force effects on biochemical kinetics

Force is an important component in the proper functioning of tissues and cells. In processes ranging from the contraction of muscles to the alignment of chromosomes at the metaphase plate, forces must be adjusted to the proper levels by cells. At the molecular level, it is clear that the motor molecules and other enzymes must respond to changes in mechanical forces by altering enzymatic function. Recent technical advances, primarily the atomic force microscope and laser tweezers, enable us to measure forces at the single molecule level to test how force is transduced into a change in enzyme activity. A priori, four basic mechanisms of coupling enzyme rate and force are considered. The mechanisms extend from the cellular to the molecular level. For example, polymer assembly rates and cytoskeletal matrix concentration are potentially modified by force in ways that feed back on critical enzyme rates. In studies of the known mechanosensitive enzymes, myosin and other motors, the bacterial flagellar rotor, and the F0F1 ATPase, the molecular mechanisms used to transduce force changes into activity changes have not been clearly defined, although it is reasonable to speculate about the nature of these mechanisms from the atomic structures and nanometer measurements of movement.

The F0F1-type ATP synthases of bacteria: structure and function of the F0 complex

Membrane-bound ATP synthases (F0F1-ATPases) of bacteria serve two important physiological functions. The enzyme catalyzes the synthesis of ATP from ADP and inorganic phosphate utilizing the energy of an electrochemical ion gradient. On the other hand, under conditions of low driving force, ATP synthases function as ATPases, thereby generating a transmembrane ion gradient at the expense of ATP hydrolysis. The enzyme complex consists of two structurally and functionally distinct parts: the membrane-integrated ion-translocating F0 complex and the peripheral F1 complex, which carries the catalytic sites for ATP synthesis and hydrolysis. The ATP synthase of Escherichia coli, which has been the most intensively studied one, is composed of eight different subunits, five of which belong to F1, subunits alpha, beta, gamma, delta, and epsilon (3:3:1:1:1), and three to F0, subunits a, b, and c (1:2:10 +/- 1). The similar overall structure and the high amino acid sequence homology indicate that the mechanism of ion translocation and catalysis and their mode of coupling is the same in all organisms.

The coupling of the relative movement of the a and c subunits of the F0 to the conformational changes in the F1-ATPase

F0F1-ATPase structural information gained from X-ray crystallography and electron microscopy has activated interest in a rotational mechanism for the F0F1-ATPase. Because of the subunit stoichiometry and the involvement of both a- and c-subunits in the mechanism of proton movement, it is argued that relative movement must occur between the subunits. Various options for the arrangement and structure of the subunits involved are discussed and a mechanism proposed.

A mutation in which alanine 128 Is replaced by aspartic acid abolishes dimerization of the b-subunit of the F0F1-ATPase from Escherichia coli

Site-directed mutagenesis was used to investigate the roles of a short series of hydrophobic amino acids in the b-subunit of the Escherichia coli F0F1-ATPase. A mutation affecting one of these, G131D, had been previously characterized and was found to interrupt assembly of the F0F1-ATPase (Jans, D. A., Hatch, L., Fimmel, A. L., Gibson, D., and Cox, G. B. (1985) J. Bacteriol. 162, 420-426). To extend this work, aspartic acid was substituted for each one of the residues from positions 124 to 132. The properties of mutants in this series are consistent with the region from Val124 to Gly131 forming an alpha-helix. Two of the mutations, V124D and A128D, resulted in a similar phenotype to the G131D mutation. This suggested that Val124, Ala128, and Gly131 form a helical face which may have a role in inter- or intrasubunit interactions. This was tested by overexpressing and purifying the cytoplasmic domains of the wild type and A128D mutant b-subunits. Sedimentation equilibrium centrifugation indicated that the wild type domain formed a dimer whereas the mutant was present as a monomer.

Rotation of subunits during catalysis by Escherichia coli F1-ATPase

During oxidative and photo-phosphorylation, F0F1-ATP synthases couple the movement of protons down an electrochemical gradient to the synthesis of ATP. One proposed mechanistic feature that has remained speculative is that this coupling process requires the rotation of subunits within F0F1. Guided by a recent, high-resolution structure for bovine F1 [Abrahams, J. P., Leslie, A. G., Lutter, R. & Walker, J. E. (1994) Nature (London) 370, 621-628], we have developed a critical test for rotation of the central gamma subunit relative to the three catalytic beta subunits in soluble F1 from Escherichia coli. In the bovine F1 structure, a specific point of contact between the gamma subunit and one of the three catalytic beta subunits includes positioning of the homolog of E. coli gamma-subunit C87 (gamma C87) close to the beta-subunit 380DELSEED386 sequence. A beta D380C mutation allowed us to induce formation of a specific disulfide bond between beta and gamma C87 in soluble E. coli F1. Formation of the crosslink inactivated beta D380C-F1, and reduction restored full activity. Using a dissociation/reassembly approach with crosslinked beta D380C-F1, we incorporated radiolabeled beta subunits into the two noncrosslinked beta-subunit positions of F1. After reduction of the initial nonradioactive beta-gamma crosslink, only exposure to conditions for catalytic turnover results in similar reactivities of unlabeled and radiolabeled beta subunits with gamma C87 upon reoxidation. The results demonstrate that gamma subunit rotates relative to the beta subunits during catalysis.

Disulfide bond formation between the COOH-terminal domain of the beta subunits and the gamma and epsilon subunits of the Escherichia coli F1-ATPase. Structural implications and functional consequences

A set of mutants of the Escherichia coli F1F0-type ATPase has been generated by site-directed mutagenesis as follows: beta E381C, beta S383C, beta E381C/epsilon S108C, and beta S383C/epsilon S108C. Treatment of ECF1 isolated from any of these mutants with CuCl2 induces disulfide bond formation. For the single mutants, beta E381C and beta S383C, a disulfide bond is formed in essentially 100% yield between a beta subunit and the gamma subunit, probably at Cys87 based on the recent structure determination of F1 (Abrahams, J. P., Leslie, A. G. W., Lutter, R., and Walker, J. E. (1994) Nature 370, 621-628). In the double mutants, two disulfide bonds are formed, again in essentially full yield, one between beta and gamma, the other between a beta and the epsilon subunit via Cys108. The same two cross-links are produced with CuCl2 treatment of ECF1F0 isolated from either of the double mutants. These results show that the parts of gamma around residue 87 (a short alpha-helix) and the epsilon subunit interact with different beta subunits. The yield of covalent linkage of beta to gamma is nucleotide dependent and highest in ATP and much lower with ADP in catalytic sites. The yield of covalent linkage of beta to epsilon is also nucleotide dependent but in this case is highest in ADP and much lower in ATP. Disulfide bond formation between either beta and gamma, or beta and epsilon inhibits the ATPase activity of the enzyme in proportion to the yield of the cross-linked product. Chemical modification of the Cys at either position 381 or 383 of the beta subunit inhibits ATPase activity in a manner that appears to be dependent on the size of the modifying reagent. These results are as expected if movements of the catalytic site-containing beta subunits relative to the gamma and epsilon subunits are an essential part of the cooperativity of the enzyme.