Three-dimensional crystal structure of recombinant erabutoxin a at 2.0 A resolution

Mimicking the nicotinic receptor binding site by a single chain Fv selected by competitive panning from a synthetic phage library

We have developed a novel competitive method to select from a phage display library a single chain Fv which is able to mimic the alpha-bungarotoxin binding site of the muscle nicotinic receptor. The single chain Fv was selected from a large synthetic library using alpha-bungarotoxin-coated magnetic beads. Toxin-bound phages were then eluted by competition with affinity purified nicotinic receptor. Recognition of the toxin by the anti-alpha-bungarotoxin single chain Fv was very similar to that of the receptor, such as indicated by the epitope mapping of alpha-bungarotoxin through overlapping synthetic peptides. Moreover, several positively charged residues located in the toxin second loop and in the C-terminal region were found to be critical, to a similar extent, for toxin recognition by the single chain Fv and the receptor. However, although the anti-alpha-bungarotoxin single chain Fv seems to mimic the toxin binding site of the nicotinic receptor, it does not bind other nicotinic agonists or antagonists. Our results suggest that competitive selection of anti-ligand antibody phages can allow the production of receptor-mimicking molecules directly and exclusively targeted at one specific ligand. Since physiologically and pharmacologically different ligands can produce opposite effects on receptor functions, such selective ligand decoys can have important therapeutic applications.

High resolution x-ray analysis of two mutants of a curaremimetic snake toxin

A previous mutational analysis of erabutoxin a (Ea), a curaremimetic toxin from sea snake venom, showed that the substitutions S8G and S8T caused, respectively, 176-fold and 780-fold affinity decreases for the nicotinic acetylcholine receptor (AchR). In view of the fact that the side-chain of Ser8 is buried in the wild-type toxin, we wondered whether these affinity changes reflect a direct binding contribution of S8 to the receptor and/or conformational changes that could have occurred in Ea as a result of the introduced mutations. To approach this question, we solved X-ray structures of the two mutants S8G and S8T at high resolution (0.18 nm and 0.17 nm, with R factors of 18.0% and 17.9%, respectively). The data show that none of the mutations significantly modified the toxin structure. Even within the site where the toxin binds to the receptor the backbone conformation remained unchanged. Therefore, the low affinities of the mutants S8T and S8G cannot be explained by a large conformational change of the toxin structure. Although we cannot exclude the possibility that undetectable structural changes have occurred in the toxin mutants, our data support the view that, although buried between loop I and II, S8 is part of the functional epitope of the toxin.

Identification of pairwise interactions in the alpha-neurotoxin-nicotinic acetylcholine receptor complex through double mutant cycles

alpha-Neurotoxins are potent inhibitors of the nicotinic acetylcholine receptor (nAChR), binding with high affinity to the two agonist sites located on the extracellular domain. Previous site-directed mutagenesis had identified three residues on the alpha-neurotoxin from Naja mossambica mossambica (Lys27, Arg33, and Lys47) and four residues on the mouse muscle nAChR alpha-subunit (Val188, Tyr190, Pro197, and Asp200) as contributing to binding. In this study, thermodynamic mutant cycle analysis was applied to these sets of residues to identify specific pairwise interactions. Amino acid variants of alpha-neurotoxin from N. mossambica mossambica at position 33 and of the nAChR at position 188 showed strong energetic couplings of 2-3 kcal/mol at both binding sites. Consistently smaller yet significant linkages of 1.6-2.1 kcal/mol were also observed between variants at position 27 on the toxin and position 188 on the receptor. Additionally, toxin residue 27 coupled to the receptor residues 190, 197, and 200 at the alphadelta binding site with observed coupling energies of 1.5-1.9 kcal/mol. No linkages were found between toxin residue Lys47 and the receptor residues studied here. These results provide direct evidence that the two conserved cationic residues Arg33 and Lys27, located on loop II of the toxin structure, are binding in close proximity to the alpha-subunit region between residues 188-200. The toxin residue Arg33 is closer to Val188, where it is likely stabilized by adjacent negative or aromatic residues on the receptor structure. Lys27 is positioned closer to Tyr190, Pro197, and Asp200, where it is likely stabilized through electrostatic interaction with Asp200 and/or cation/pi interactions with Tyr190.

Nonidentity of the alpha-neurotoxin binding sites on the nicotinic acetylcholine receptor revealed by modification in alpha-neurotoxin and receptor structures

alpha-Neurotoxins constitute a large family of polypeptides that bind with high affinity to the nicotinic acetylcholine receptor (nAChR). Using a recombinant DNA-derived alpha-neurotoxin (Naja mossambica mossambica, NmmI) and mouse muscle nAChR expressed transiently on the surface of HEK 293 cells, we have delineated residues involved in the binding interaction on both the alpha-neurotoxin and the receptor interface. Several of the studied NmmI mutations, including two residues conserved throughout the alpha-neurotoxin family (K27 and R33), resulted in substantial decreases in the binding affinity. We have also examined 23 mutations located on the receptor alpha subunit and have identified 4 positions that appear to be important to NmmI recognition. These determinants represent a conserved aromatic residue (Y190), two positions where neuronal and muscle receptors differ (V188 and P197), and a negatively charged residue (D200). Unlike many of the nAChR agonists and antagonists which bind to the alphadelta and alphagamma binding sites on the receptor with different affinities, the wild-type NmmI-wild-type nAChR interaction showed a single affinity. However, by mutating critical toxin or receptor residues, we were able to produce site-selectivity between the alphagamma and alphadelta interfaces. These results suggest a nonequivalence in the binding interaction at the two sites, sensitive to discrete structural changes at key contact points on either the toxin or the receptor protein, and underscore the importance of delta and gamma receptor subunits in governing binding affinity.

High-level production and isotope labeling of snake neurotoxins, disulfide-rich proteins

The aim of this work was to produce and to label snake neurotoxins, disulfide-rich proteins. A mutant of a snake toxin, erabutoxin a, was used as a model. Its N-terminal part was fused to ZZ, a synthetic IgG-binding domain of protein A (B. Nilsson et al., 1987, Protein Eng. 1, 107-113), thus preventing degradation in the bacterial cytoplasm and providing a simple affinity-purification method on IgG Sepharose. A soluble fusion protein was obtained with a yield of 60 mg/L, corresponding to 20 mg/L toxin. The toxin moiety was folded on the column while the hybrid was still bound. The oxidoreducing conditions for the refolding were optimized and were found to be oxidative but with a need for reducing molecules. The concentration of the hybrid bound to the column could be increased up to 3.3 mg/ml without significantly altering the folding process. CNBr cleavage of the fusion protein followed by a purification step yielded about 2 mg of biologically active toxin mutant per gram of dry cell weight. This procedure was applied to produce 55 mg of a toxin uniformly labeled with 15N.

Mimicry between receptors and antibodies. Identification of snake toxin determinants recognized by the acetylcholine receptor and an acetylcholine receptor-mimicking monoclonal antibody

In several instances, a monoclonal antibody raised against a receptor ligand has been claimed to mimic the ligand receptor. Thus, a specific monoclonal antibody (Malpha2-3) raised against a short-chain toxin from snake was proposed to mimic the nicotinic acetylcholine receptor (AChR) (). Further confirming this mimicry, we show that (i) like AChR, Malpha2-3 elicits anti-AChR antibodies, which in turn elicit anti-toxin antibodies; and (ii) the region 106-122 of the alpha-chain of AChR shares 66% primary structure identity with complementarity-determining regions of Malpha2-3. Also, a mutational analysis of erabutoxin a reveals that the epitope recognized by Malpha2-3 consists of 10 residues, distributed within the three toxin loops. Eight of these residues also belong to the 10-residue epitope recognized by AChR, a result that offers an explanation as to the functional similarities between the receptor and the antibody. Strikingly, however, most of the residues common to the two epitopes contribute differentially to the energetic formation of the antibody-toxin and the receptor-toxin complexes. Together, the data suggest that the mimicry between AChR and Malpha2-3 is partial only.

Genetic engineering of snake toxins. The functional site of Erabutoxin a, as delineated by site-directed mutagenesis, includes variant residues

Using site-directed mutagenesis, we previously identified some residues that probably belong to the site by which Erabutoxin a (Ea), a sea snake toxin, recognizes the nicotinic acetylcholine receptor (AcChoR) (Pillet, L., Trémeau, O., Ducancel, F. Drevet, P., Zinn-Justin, S., Pinkasfeld, S., Boulain, J.-C., and Ménez, A. (1993) J. Biol. Chem. 268, 909-916). We have now studied the effect of mutating 26 new positions on the affinity of Ea for AcChoR. The mutations are F4A, N5V, H6A, Q7L, S9G, Q10A, P11N, Q12A, T13V, T14A, K15A, T16A, delta S18, E21A, Y25F, Q28A, S30A, T35A, I36R, P44V, T45A, V46A, K47A, P48Q, I50Q, and S53A. Binding affinity decreases upon mutation at Gln-7, Gln-10 and to a lesser extent at His-6, Ser-9 and Tyr-25 whereas it increases upon mutation at Ile-36. Other mutations have no effect on Ea affinity. In addition, new mutations of the previously explored Ser-8, Asp-31, Arg-33, and Glu-38 better explain the functional role of these residues in Ea. The previous and present mutational analysis suggest that the "functional" site of Ea covers a homogeneous surface of at least 680 A2, encompassing the three toxin loops, and includes both conserved and variant residues. The variable residues might contribute to the selectivity of Ea for some AcChoRs, including those from fish, the prey of sea snakes.