Benefits of early anti-inflammatory medication following acute ankle injury

Naproxen versus Acetaminophen for Therapy of Soft Tissue Injuries to the Ankle in Children

Background:

Musculoskeletal (MSK) ankle injuries cause significant morbidity in ambulatory pediatric populations. No optimal pharmacotherapy is available.

Objective:

To conduct a randomized, double-blind trial to compare 2 drug therapies for soft tissue injury of the ankle.

Methods:

Patients (N = 77, aged 8–14 y, 61% male) with ankle injuries presenting to a regional pediatric emergency department were assigned to receive either acetaminophen (15 mg/kg 4 times a day) or naproxen (5 mg/kg 4 times a day) in a double-blind fashion on a routine basis for a 5 day period. On days 0 and 7, patients rated their degree of disability and pain on weight bearing using a 10 cm visual analog scale developed for this study. In addition, they were examined by a physician who rated pain, tenderness on palpation, and swelling using a 4 point scale. There were 3 follow-up telephone calls on days 3, 14, and 21. Adherence was evaluated by self-report and pill count.

Results:

Both the acetaminophen and naproxen groups had significant improvement in degree of disability and pain from day 0 to day 7. There was no statistically significant difference in outcome between the 2 groups by patient self-evaluation or physician assessment. There also was no significant difference in adverse event rates between the 2 groups, and the majority of patients in both groups felt that the medication was helpful.

Conclusions:

No significant difference in efficacy of pain control or improvement of disability between the naproxen and acetaminophen groups suggests no preferential advantage for naproxen over acetaminophen for MSK injuries when given on a regular basis, with concurrent supportive treatment. Possible differential benefit from intermittent therapy needs to be evaluated among children with ankle injury.

Management of Acute Soft Tissue Injuries

Participation in sports-related activities increases the risk for acute injury to soft tissues. In adults, the sites most often affected include the ankle, knee, and wrist joint structures, along with the muscles of the back and extremities. The subsequent inflammatory response to tissue damage results in pain and swelling, which limits mobility. A thorough patient assessment is required for accurate diagnosis and provides a guide for appropriate treatment. Initial management is based on the principles of basic first aid: rest, ice, compression, and elevation. Pharmacological therapy can also be used to achieve pain relief and improve mobility. There are few well-controlled studies addressing the pharmacotherapy of acute soft tissue injury, but clinical experience with nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs is extensive. Both traditional and nontraditional therapeutic approaches are discussed.

Cyclooxygenase-2 inhibitors and nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs in the management of arthritis

The management of arthritis pain should be individualized to the needs and characteristics of the patient. The decision to use nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs (NSAIDs), and in particular the cyclooxygenase-2 (COX-2) inhibitors, is multidimensional. The challenge is to achieve optimal pain relief at the minimum dose to minimize adverse effects. Whenever possible, NSAIDs should be given as monotherapies or in combinations at the lowest effective doses. The COX-2 inhibitors are a safe choice for most patients who are at low risk for a cardiovascular event. Individuals who are at risk for thromboses should not receive unopposed COX-2 inhibitors; COX-2 should be given in combination with low-dose aspirin which is expected to be cardioprotective in high-risk patients.