Radiation and transposon-induced genetic damage in Drosophila melanogaster: X-ray dose-response and synergism with DNA-repair deficiency

Effects of genomic instability in populations of Drosophila melanogaster from regions of Ukraine with different impact of radiation factors

PURPOSE

To investigate differences in the gonadal dysgenesis frequency as one of the indicators of genome instability through natural populations of Drosophіla melanogaster, selected from Ukrainian regions with different radiation impacts. Follow-up study of the dynamics of this indicator under chronic exposure in laboratory conditions for 10 generations.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

The study was conducted in two stages. The first one included trapping of insects in regions with different radiation loads with subsequent assessment of both the time of maturation and the index of the gonadal dysgenesis through the first (F1) generation, obtained in laboratory conditions. At the second stage, the dynamics of this indicator were investigated for the F1-descendants of each ten consequent generations, which were developed under laboratory conditions both with and without additional gamma-exposure with different characteristics of the dose rate 1.2 × 10^-8, 0.3 × 10^-8 and 0.12 × 10^-8Gy/sec.

RESULTS

Differences in the gonadal dysgenesis frequency as one of the indicators of genome instability were revealed in F1-descendants of natural populations of Drosophіla melanogaster, selected from regions of different radiation impact. Under conditions of additional low rate chronic irradiation in laboratory conditions for 10 generations, significant differences in changes in the level and dynamics of this indicator were established depending on the accumulated dose of Drosophila populations from the city of Netishyn (Khmelnytskyi NPP) and Magarach city. There were no signs of adaptation.

CONCLUSIONS

The discrepancy between the real and expected biological effects has reflected the difference in the intensity of the radiation background, which was traditionally determined by the gamma-emitters and did not take into account the wide range of other genotoxic elements from nuclear power emissions. A complex, non-monotonic type of frequency dynamics of gonadal dysgenesis could be determined by the interaction of radiation damage, protection and recovery.

Frequencies of chromosomal inversions in Drosophila melanogaster in Fukushima after the nuclear power plant accident

In order to investigate genetic impact of a large amount of radionuclides released by the Fukushima Dai-ichi Nuclear Power Plant accident in 2011, we surveyed 2,304 haploid genomes of Drosophila melanogaster collected in three localities in Fukushima in 2012 and 2013 for chromosomal inversions. No unique inversion was found in 298 genomes in 2012 and only two in 2,006 genomes in 2013. The observed frequencies were even lower than the long-term average frequency of unique inversions in Japan. The common cosmopolitan inversions were also examined in Fukushima, Kyoto, and Iriomote (Okinawa) in 2012. Among three samples in Fukushima, the flies in Iizaka, where environmental radiation level was the highest, showed the lowest frequency of In(2L)t, but the highest frequency of In(3R)P, contrary to the expectation of decreasing of their frequencies in higher polluted areas. These results suggest that, at this level of genetic analysis, Fukushima populations of D. melanogaster would not have been negatively impacted following the release of radionuclides. Transposable P-element mobility was not likely to induce DNA damage solely or synergistically with radioactivity, because their transposition activity was totally repressed in the Fukushima strains. However, it should be noted that, because of limitations in access to the exclusion zone, we could only sample the populations in areas of relatively low radioactive contamination (0.39-0.63 μSv/h). Therefore, the present study is likely to be underpowered to detect any effects that might be expected in heavily contaminated areas.

Flaws in the LNT single-hit model for cancer risk: An historical assessment

The LNT single-hit model was derived from the Nobel Prize-winning research of Herman J. Muller who showed that x-rays could induce gene mutations in Drosophila and that the dose response for these so-called mutational events was linear. Lewis J. Stadler, another well-known and respected geneticist at the time, strongly disagreed with and challenged Muller's claims. Detailed evaluations by Stadler over a prolonged series of investigations revealed that Muller's experiments had induced gross heritable chromosomal damage instead of specific gene mutations as had been claimed by Muller at his Nobel Lecture. These X-ray-induced alterations became progressively more frequent and were of larger magnitude (more destructive) with increasing doses. Thus, Muller's claim of having induced discrete gene mutations represented a substantial speculative overreach and was, in fact, without proof. The post hoc arguments of Muller to support his gene mutation hypothesis were significantly challenged and weakened by a series of new findings in the areas of cytogenetics, reverse mutation, adaptive and repair processes, and modern molecular methods for estimating induced genetic damage. These findings represented critical and substantial limitations to Muller's hypothesis of X-ray-induced gene mutations. Furthermore, they challenged the scientific foundations used in support of the LNT single-hit model by severing the logical nexus between Muller's data on radiation-induced inheritable alterations and the LNT single-hit model. These findings exposed fundamental scientific flaws that undermined not only the seminal recommendation of the 1956 BEAR I Genetics Panel to adopt the LNT single-hit Model for risk assessment but also any rationale for its continued use in the present day.

Mutability, sterility and suppression in P-M hybrid dysgenesis: the influence of P subline, cross, chromosome, sex and P-element structure

Three Harwich P sublines with different P-element activity potential were used to investigate the influence of P-derived chromosomes on snw mutability and vg suppression and to relate the induction of these dysgenic traits to the number and structure of P elements. Destabilization of the snw allele, a measure of P transposase activity, was differentially influenced by the major autosomes. Chromosome 2 of the standard Harwich subline, Hw, induced only 60% of the level of mutability relative to chromosome 3, whereas chromosome 3 of the weakest Harwich subline, Hf, induced only 50% of the mutability relative to chromosome 2. In somatic suppression of the vg21-3 allele, chromosome 3 of the Hf subline produced a lower level of complete suppression as compared to chromosome 3 of the Hw or the Hs subline (the high hybrid-dysgenesis-inducing subline). The level of these dysgenic traits and GD sterility, was not correlated with the number of P elements per individual (67-68) or per chromosome arm which was very similar among the sublines. The number of complete P elements per genome, based on Southern blot analysis of the X and major autosomes, ranged from 15 to 19. Destabilization of the snw allele and vg suppression by chromosome 3 was correlated with a greater number of complete P elements. Two novel unexpected observations emerged from these studies: both snw mutability and vg suppression data demonstrated high P-element activity in hybrids derived from non-dysgenic crosses irrespective of Harwich subline, indicating a lack of P-cytotype regulation. Mutability in non-dysgenic males ranged from 40 to 60% of the level found in dysgenic males. The high snw mutability and low GD sterility in non-dysgenic hybrids suggests that these traits may arise by a different mechanism.