Analysis of site-specific interaction parameters in protein-DNA complexes

DNase I footprinting

DNase I footprinting has found a wide following for both identifying and characterizing DNA-protein interactions, particularly because of its simplicity. The concept is that a partial digestion by DNase I of a uniquely (32)P-end-labeled fragment will generate a ladder of fragments, whose mobilities on a denaturing acrylamide gel and whose positions in a subsequent autoradiograph will represent the distance from the end label to the points of cleavage. Bound protein prevents binding of DNase I in and around its binding site and thus generates a "footprint" in the cleavage ladder. The distance from the end label to the edges of the footprint represents the position of the protein-binding site on the DNA fragment. The position of the binding site can be determined by electrophoresing a DNA sequencing ladder alongside the footprint. DNase I cannot bind directly adjacent to a DNA-bound protein because of steric hindrance. Hence, the footprint gives a broad indication of the binding site, generally 8-10 base pairs (bp) larger than the site itself.

Quantitative DNase footprint titration: a tool for analyzing the energetics of protein-DNA interactions

A major goal in biomedical research is to determine the mechanisms responsible for gene regulation. However, the promoters and operators that control transcription are often complex in nature, containing multiple-binding sites with which DNA-binding proteins can interact cooperatively. Quantitative DNase footprint titration is one of the few techniques capable of resolving the microscopic binding affinities responsible for the macroscopic assembly process. Here, we present a step-by-step protocol for carrying out a footprint titration experiment. We then describe how to quantify the resultant images to generate individual-site binding curves. Finally, we derive basic equations for binding at each site and present an overview of the fitting process, applying it to the anticipated results. Users should anticipate that the footprinting experiment will take 3-5 d starting from DNA template isolation to image acquisition and quantitation.

Determination of macromolecular folding and structure by synchrotron x-ray radiolysis techniques

Radiolysis of water by synchrotron X-rays generates oxygen-containing radicals that undergo reactions with solvent accessible sites of macromolecules inducing stable covalent modifications or cleavage on millisecond time scales. The extent and site of these reactions are determined by gel electrophoresis and mass spectrometry analysis. These data are used to construct a high-resolution map of solvent accessibility at individual reactive sites. The experiments can be performed in a time-resolved manner to provide kinetic rate constants for dynamic events occurring at individual sites within macromolecules or can provide equilibrium parameters of binding and thermodynamics of folding processes. The application of this synchrotron radiolysis technique to the study of lysozyme protein structure and the equilibrium urea induced unfolding of apomyoglobin are described. The Mg2+-induced folding of Tetrahymena thermophila group I ribozyme shows the capability of the method to study kinetics of folding.

Coupled energetics of lambda cro repressor self-assembly and site-specific DNA operator binding II: cooperative interactions of cro dimers

The bacteriophage lambda relies on interactions of the cI and cro repressors which self assemble and bind the two operators (O(R) and O(L)) of the phage genome to control the lysogenic to lytic switch. While the self assembly and O(R) binding of cI have been investigated in detail, a more complete understanding of gene regulation by phage lambda also requires detailed knowledge of the role of cro repressor as it dimerizes and binds at O(R) sites. Since dimerization and operator binding are coupled processes, a full elucidation of the regulatory energetics in this system requires that the equilibrium constants for dimerization and cooperative binding be determined. The dimerization constant for cro has been measured as a prelude to these binding studies. Here, the energetics of cro binding to O(R) are evaluated using quantitative DNaseI footprint titration techniques. Binding data for wild-type and modified O(R) site combinations have been simultaneously analyzed in concert with the dimerization energetics to obtain both the intrinsic and cooperative DNA binding energies for cro with the three O(R) sites. Binding of cro dimers is strongest to O(R)3, then O(R)1 and lastly, O(R)2. Adjacently bound repressors exhibit positive cooperativity ranging from -0.6 to -1.0 kcal/mol. Implications of these, newly resolved, energetics are discussed in the framework of a dynamic model for gene regulation. This characterization of the DNA-binding properties of cro repressor establishes the foundation on which the system can be explored for other, more complex, regulatory elements such as cI-cro cooperativity.

A mathematical model for synergistic eukaryotic gene activation

The precise biochemical mechanism underlying the synergistic action of gene activators on eukaryotic transcription has eluded a solution, largely because of the technical difficulties inherent in analyzing the mechanics of a 2.5 MDa complex comprising greater than 50 polypeptide components. To complement the biochemical approach we have employed mathematical modeling as a means to understand the mechanism of synergy. Parameters relevant to activated transcription were varied in a simple biochemical system and the data were compared to the transcriptional response predicted by a multi-component statistical model. We found that the model achieved a consistent, semi-quantitative description of the measured transcriptional response, and enabled the characterization and measurement of thermodynamic parameters in the in vitro system. The results provide evidence for the existence of cooperativity in the activation process beyond what would be predicted from one current model suggesting that activators function solely by simple recruitment of the general transcription machinery to the promoter.

Cooperative non-specific DNA binding by octamerizing lambda cI repressors: a site-specific thermodynamic analysis

Relationships between dimerization and site-specific binding have been characterized previously for wild-type and mutant cI repressors at the right operator (OR) of bacteriophage lambda DNA. However, the roles of higher-order oligomers (tetramers and octamers) that are also formed from these cI molecules have remained elusive. In this study, a clear correlation has been established between repressor oligomerization and non-specific DNA-binding activity. A modification of the quantitative DNase I footprint titration technique has been used to evaluate the degree of saturation of non-specific, OR-flanking lambda DNA by cI repressor oligomers. With the exception of one mutant, only those repressors capable of octamerizing were found to exhibit non-specific DNA-binding activity. The non-specific interaction was accurately modeled using either a one-dimensional, univalent, site-specific Ising lattice approximation, or a more traditional, multivalent lattice approach. It was found that non-specific DNA-binding by repressor oligomers is highly cooperative and energetically independent from site-specific binding at OR. Furthermore, the coupling free energy resolved for non-specific binding was similar to that of site-specific binding for each repressor, suggesting that similar structural elements may mediate the cooperative component of both binding processes. It is proposed that the state of assembly of the repressor molecule modulates its relative affinity for specific and non-specific DNA sequences. These specificities are allosterically regulated by the transmission of assembly-state information from the C-terminal domain, which mediates self-association and cooperativity, to the N-terminal domain, which primarily mediates DNA-binding. While dimers have a high affinity for their cognate sites within OR, tetramers and octamers may preferentially recognize non-specific DNA sequences. The concepts and findings developed in this study may facilitate quantitative characterization of the relationships between specific, and non-specific binding in other systems that utilize multiple modes of DNA-binding cooperativity.

Following the folding of RNA with time-resolved synchrotron X-ray footprinting

The rapid mixing synchrotron X-ray footprinting technique described in this article allows nucleic acid folding and ligand binding reactions to be followed on a millisecond time resolution with single nucleotide resolution. In principle, the change in .OH protection of every nucleotide in a nucleic acid hundreds of nucleotides long can be monitored separately. In addition, a wide range of solution conditions are compatible with the radiolytic generation of .OH. These characteristics of synchrotron X-ray footprinting create opportunities for conducting thermodynamic and kinetic studies of nucleic acids that are both comprehensive and detailed. Kinetic footprinting studies of a number of systems have been initiated by the Center for Synchrotron Biosciences using this technique.

Time-resolved synchrotron X-ray "footprinting", a new approach to the study of nucleic acid structure and function: application to protein-DNA interactions and RNA folding

Hydroxyl radicals (.OH) can cleave the phosphodiester backbone of nucleic acids and are valuable reagents in the study of nucleic acid structure and protein-nucleic acid interactions. Irradiation of solutions by high flux "white light" X-ray beams based on bending magnet beamlines at the National Synchrotron Light Source (NSLS) yields sufficient concentrations of .OH so that quantitative nuclease protection ("footprinting") studies of DNA and RNA can be conducted with a duration of exposure in the range of 50 to 100 ms. The sensitivity of DNA and RNA to X-ray mediated .OH cleavage is equivalent. Both nucleic acids are completely protected from synchrotron X-ray induced cleavage by the presence of thiourea in the sample solution, demonstrating that cleavage is suppressed by a free radical scavenger. The utility of this time-dependent approach to footprinting is demonstrated with a synchrotron X-ray footprint of a protein-DNA complex and by a time-resolved footprinting analysis of the Mg(2+)-dependent folding of the Tetrahymena thermophilia L-21 ScaI ribozyme RNA. Equilibrium titrations reveal differences among the ribozyme domains in the cooperativity of Mg(2+)-dependent .OH protection. RNA .OH protection progress curves were obtained for several regions of the ribozyme over timescales of 30 seconds to several minutes. Progress curves ranging from > or = 3.5 to 0.4 min-1 were obtained for the P4-P6 and P5 sub-domains and the P3-P7 domain, respectively. The .OH protection progress curves have been correlated with the available biochemical, structural and modeling data to generate a model of the ribozyme folding pathway. Rate differences observed for specific regions within domains provide evidence for steps in the folding pathway not previously observed. Synchrotron X-ray footprinting is a new approach of general applicability for the study of time-resolved structural changes of nucleic acid conformation and protein-nucleic acid complexes.

Quantitative nucleic acids footprinting: thermodynamic and kinetic approaches

Quantitative footprinting techniques allow a detailed analysis of the thermodynamic forces that characterize nucleic acid-ligand interactions and ligand-induced changes in nucleic acid structure by separately resolving the intrinsic and cooperative Gibbs free energy changes describing the reactions being investigated. A new implementation of the quantitative footprinting technique is the application of stopped-flow techniques to the study of kinetic reactions.

Cooperative binding of DctD to the dctA upstream activation sequence of Rhizobium meliloti is enhanced in a constitutively active truncated mutant

DctD, a sigma54-dependent, two-component regulator, binds to promoter distal (A) and promoter proximal (B) sites in an activation sequence located upstream of the dctA promoter. We report gel filtration and quantitative DNase I footprint experiments supporting a model in which DctD2 binds to these sites cooperatively. The global analysis of upstream activation sequences containing sites A and B, A and B one-half helical turn out of phase, and only B yielded values for the intrinsic and cooperative binding free energies of DeltaG0A = -9.5 +/- 0.3, DeltaG0B = -11.2 +/- 0.2, and DeltaG0AB = -2.5 +/- 0.5. A separate analysis of data from upstream activation sequences containing site A and a point mutant of site B, and site A and mutant site B one-half helical turn out of phase confirmed the estimate of cooperativity, yielding free energy values of DeltaG0A = -9.4 +/- 0.2, DeltaG0B(G-->C) = -10.0 +/- 0.2, and DeltaG0AB(G-->C) = -2.2 +/- 0.4. We previously showed that removing the two-component receiver domain from DctD, making DctDDelta(1-142), yields a constitutively active truncated protein. Global analysis of binding data for DctDDelta(1-142) showed that this constitutively active mutant has intrinsic binding energies equal to that of the inactive DctD protein, but that it displays significantly higher cooperativity (DeltaG0A = -9.4 +/- 0.6, DeltaG0B = -11.1 +/- 0.3, and DeltaG0AB = -3.8 +/- 0.6.).

Thermodynamic and kinetic characterization of the binding of the TATA binding protein to the adenovirus E4 promoter

A thermodynamic analysis of the binding of the TATA binding protein (TBP) from Saccharomyces cerevisiae to the adenovirus E4 promoter was conducted using quantitative DNase I "footprint" titration techniques. These studies were conducted to provide a foundation for studies of TBP structure-function relations and its assembly into transcription preinitiation complexes. The binding of TBP to the E4 promoter is well described by the Langmuir binding polynomial, suggesting that no linked equilibria contribute to the binding reaction under the conditions examined. Van't Hoff analysis yielded a nonlinear dependence on temperature with the TBP-E4 promoter interaction displaying maximal affinity at 30 degrees C. An unusually negative value of the apparent standard heat capacity change, delta Cp degrees = -3.5 +/- 0.5 kcal/mol.K, was determined from these data. The dependence of the TBP-E4 promoter interaction on [KCl] indicates that 3.6 +/- 0.3 K+ ions are displaced upon complex formation. Within experimental error, no linkage of proton binding with the TBP-E4 promoter interaction is detectable between pH 5.9 and 8.7. Rates of association of TBP for the E4 promoter were obtained using a novel implementation of a quench-flow device and DNase I "footprinting" techniques. The value determined for the second-order rate constant at pH 7.4, 100 mM KCl, 5 mM MgCl2, 1 mM CaCl2, 30 degrees C (ka = 5.2 +/- 0.5) x 10(5) M-1 s-1) confirms the results obtained by Hawley and co-workers [Hoopes, B.C., LeBlanc, J.F., & Hawley, D.K. (1992) J. Biol. Chem. 267, 11539-11547] and extends them through TBP concentrations of 636 nM.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)