Epstein-Barr virus transformed B cell lines derived from patients with systemic lupus erythematosus produce a nephritic factor of the classical complement pathway

Defining Nephritic Factors as Diverse Drivers of Systemic Complement Dysregulation in C3 Glomerulopathy

Introduction

C3 glomerulopathy (C3G) is an ultrarare renal disease characterized by deposition of complement component C3 in the glomerular basement membrane (GBM). Rare and novel genetic variation in complement genes and autoantibodies to complement proteins are commonly identified in the C3G population and thought to drive the underlying complement dysregulation that results in renal damage. However, disease heterogeneity and rarity make accurately defining characteristics of the C3G population difficult.

Methods

Here, we present a retrospective analysis of the Molecular Otolaryngology and Renal Research Laboratories C3G cohort. This study integrated complement biomarker testing and in vitro tests of autoantibody function to achieve the following 3 primary goals: (i) define disease profiles of C3G based on disease drivers, complement biomarkers, and age; (ii) determine the relationship between in vitro autoantibody tests and in vivo complement dysregulation; and (iii) evaluate the association between autoantibody function and disease progression.

Results

The largest disease profiles of C3G included patients with autoantibodies to complement proteins (48%) and patients for whom no genetic and/or acquired drivers of disease could be identified (43%). The correlation between the stabilization of convertases by complement autoantibodies as measured by in vitro modified hemolytic assays and systemic biomarkers that reflect in vivo complement dysregulation was remarkably strong. In patients positive for autoantibodies, the degree of stabilization capacity predicted worse renal function.

Conclusion

This study implicates complement autoantibodies as robust drivers of systemic complement dysregulation in approximately 50% of C3G but also highlights the need for continued discovery-based research to identify novel drivers of disease.

Autoantibody stabilization of the classical pathway C3 convertase leading to C3 deficiency and Neisserial sepsis: C4 nephritic factor revisited

C3 deficiency is a rare disorder that leads to recurrent pyogenic infections. Here we describe a previously healthy 18 y/o Caucasian male with severe meningococcal disease. Total hemolytic activity was zero secondary to an undetectable C3. The C3 gene was normal by sequencing. Mixing the patient's serum with normal human serum led to C3 consumption. An IgG autoantibody in the patient's serum was identified that stabilized the classical pathway C3 and C5 convertases, thus preventing decay of these enzyme complexes. This autoantibody is an example of a C4 nephritic factor, with an additional feature of stabilizing the C5 convertase. Previous patients with C4 nephritic factor had membranoproliferative glomerulonephritis. Two years after presentation, this patient's C3 remains undetectable with no evidence of renal disease. We revisit the role of autoantibodies to classical pathway convertases in disease, review the literature on C4-NeF and comment on its detection in the clinical laboratory.

Control of the complement system

The complement system has developed a remarkably simple but elegant manner of regulating itself. It has faced and successfully dealt with how to facilitate activation on a microbe while preventing the same on host tissue. It solved this problem primarily by creating a series of secreted and membrane-regulatory proteins that prevent two highly undesirable events: activation in the fluid phase (no target) and on host tissue (inappropriate target). Also, if not checked, even on an appropriate target, the system would go to exhaustion and have nothing left for the next microbe. Therefore, the complement enzymes have an intrinsic instability and the fluid-phase control proteins play a major role in limiting activation in time. The symmetry of the regulatory process between fluid phase and membrane inhibitors at the C4/C3 step of amplification and convertase formation as well as at the MAC steps are particularly striking features of the self/nonself discrimination system. The use of glycolipid anchored proteins on membranes to decay enzymes and block membrane insertion events is unlikely to be by chance. Finally, it is economical for the cofactor regulatory activity to produce derivatives of C3b that now specifically engage additional receptors. Likewise, C1-Inh leads to C1q remaining on the immune complex to interact with the C1q receptor. Thus the complement system is designed to allow rapid, efficient, unimpeded activation on an appropriate foreign target while regulatory proteins intervene to prevent three undesirable consequences of complement activation: excessive activation on a single target, fluid phase activation, and activation on self.

On the origin of C3 nephritic factor (antibody to the alternative pathway C3 convertase): evidence for the Adam and Eve concept of autoantibody production

The antibody to the alternative pathway C3 convertase, designated C3 nephritic factor or C3NeF, is an autoantibody that is produced in everyone from the time of birth. The elaboration of C3NeF utilizes germline V-region genes which undergo antigen-driven affinity maturation, resulting in an autoantibody that is produced in large amounts with high affinity and narrow specificity. Our data also suggest that under normal conditions, the idiotypic network may play an important part in the control of this autoantibody. Further, a defect in the network with loss of control or inappropriate stimulation may be an underlying mechanism in the unrestricted production of C3NeF in patients with membranoproliferative glomerulonephritis.