Nonresectable recurrent pelvic neoplasm. Outcome in patients explored for pelvic exenteration

Pain, pain management and related outcomes following pelvic exenteration surgery: a systematic review

AIM

Pelvic exenteration surgery can improve survival in people with advanced colorectal cancer. This systematic review aimed to review pain intensity and other outcomes, for example the management of pain, the relationship between pain and the extent of surgery and the impact of pain on short-term outcomes.

METHOD

Electronic databases were searched from inception to 1 May 2021. We included interventional studies of adults with any indication for pelvic exenteration surgery that also reported pain outcomes. Risk of bias was assessed using ROBINS-1.

RESULTS

The search found 21 studies that reported pain following pelvic exenteration [n = 1317 patients, mean age 58.4 years (SD 4.8)]. Ten studies were judged to be at moderate risk of bias. Before pelvic exenteration, pain was reported by 19%-100% of patients. Five studies used validated measures of pain intensity. No study measured pain at all three time points in the surgical journey. The presence of pain before surgery predicted postoperative adverse pain outcomes, and pain is more likely to be experienced in those who require wider resections, including bone resection.

CONCLUSION

Considering that pain following pelvic exenteration is commonly described by patients, the literature suggests that this symptom is not being measured and therefore addressed.

Implementation of a peri-operative pain-management algorithm reduces the use of opioid analgesia following pelvic exenteration surgery

AIM

This study aimed to investigate the implementation and pain-related outcomes of a peri-operative pain-management regimen for patients undergoing pelvic exenteration surgery at a university teaching hospital.

METHOD

This is a single-site prospective observational cohort study involving 100 patients who underwent pelvic exenteration surgery between January 2017 and December 2018. A pain-management algorithm regarding the use of opioid-sparing multimodal analgesia was developed between the departments of anaesthesia, pain management and intensive care. The primary outcomes were: compliance with a pain-treatment algorithm compared with a similar retrospective surgical patient cohort in 2013-2014; and requirements for regular doses of opioid analgesia at discharge, measured in oral morphine equivalent daily dose (oMEDD).

RESULTS

Following the introduction of a pain-management algorithm, regional anaesthesia techniques (spinal anaesthesia, transversus abdominus plane block, preperitoneal catheters or epidural analgesia) were used in 83/98 (84.7%) of the 2017-2018 cohort compared with 13/73 (17.8%) of the 2013-2014 cohort (p < 0.001). There was a reduction in the median dose of opioid analgesics (oMEDD) at time of discharge, from 150 mg (interquartile range [IQR]: 75.0-235.0 mg) in the 2013-2014 cohort to 10 mg (IQR: 0.00-45.0 mg) in the 2017-2018 cohort (p < 0.001). There was no change in pain intensity (assessed using the Verbal Numerical Rating Score) or oMEDD in the first 7 days following surgery.

CONCLUSION

Since implementation of a novel peri-operative pain-treatment algorithm, the use of opioid-sparing regional techniques and preperitoneal catheters has increased. Additionally, the dose of opioids required at the time of discharge has reduced significantly.

Pre-exenterative chemotherapy, a novel therapeutic approach for patients with persistent or recurrent cervical cancer

Background

Most cervical cancer patients with pelvic recurrent or persistent disease are not candidates for exenteration, therefore, they only receive palliative chemotherapy. Here we report the results of a novel treatment modality for these patients pre-exenterative chemotherapy- under the rational that the shrinking of the pelvic tumor would allow its resection.

Methods

Patients with recurrent or persistent disease and no evidence of systemic disease, considered not be candidates for pelvic exenteration because of the extent of pelvic tumor, received 3-courses of platinum-based chemotherapy. Response was evaluated by CT scan and bimanual pelvic examination; however the decision to perform exenteration relied on the physical findings. Toxicity to chemotherapy was evaluated with standard criteria. Survival was analyzed with the Kaplan-Meier method.

Results

Seventeen patients were studied. The median number of chemotherapy courses was 4. There were 9 patients who responded to chemotherapy, evaluated by bimanual examination and underwent pelvic exenteration. Four of them had pathological complete response. Eight patients did not respond and were not subjected to surgery. One patient died due to exenteration complications. At a median follow-up of 11 months, the median survival for the whole group was 11 months, 3 months in the non-operated and 32 months in those subjected to exenteration.

Conclusion

Pre-exenterative chemotherapy is an alternative for cervical cancer patients that are no candidates for exenteration because of the extent of the pelvic disease. Its place in the management of recurrent disease needs to be investigated in randomized studies, however, its value for offering long-term survival in some of these patients with no other option than palliative care must be stressed.

Braquiterapia intersticial para recidivas de câncer de colo uterino pós-radioterapia

OBJETIVO: Analisar a resposta e toxicidade da braquiterapia de alta taxa de dose (BATD) intersticial para carcinoma do colo do útero com recidiva pélvica pós-radioterapia. MATERIAIS E MÉTODOS: Entre 1998 e 2001, 11 pacientes com carcinoma de colo de útero e que tiveram recidiva pélvica pós-radioterapia receberam BATD intersticial. Idade: 41 a 71 anos (média: 56,5 anos); estádios (FIGO): IIA, IIB, IIIB e IVA. Nove (82%) pacientes tinham carcinoma de células escamosas e duas (18%), adenocarcinoma. Dose total de BATD: 20-30 Gy, em frações de 4-5 Gy. O seguimento variou de dois a 54 meses (média: 22,5 meses), através de exame físico periódico (três meses). Uma paciente faleceu sem avaliação de resposta. RESULTADOS: Dez pacientes (91%) tiveram resposta clínica completa, com duração de três a 46 meses (média: 18,9 meses). Três pacientes estão livres de doença (27%), duas estão vivas com doença (18%), três morreram (27%) e de três se perdeu o seguimento após nova recidiva (27%). A toxicidade para o trato urinário foi de 9% (uma paciente - grau III). CONCLUSÃO: A BATD intersticial é uma abordagem alternativa e viável para pacientes selecionadas que tiveram recidiva pós-radioterapia. Foi possível obter altas taxas de resposta com baixa toxicidade, considerando-se o grupo estudado, o tempo de seguimento e a re-irradiação.

Radical surgical resection and high-dose intraoperative radiation therapy (HDR-IORT) in patients with recurrent gynecologic cancers

OBJECTIVE

To determine the outcome for patients with recurrent gynecologic tumors treated with radical resection and combined high-dose intraoperative radiation therapy (HDR-IORT).

METHODS AND MATERIALS

Between November 1993 and June 1998, 17 patients with recurrent gynecologic malignancies underwent radical surgical resection and high-dose-rate brachytherapy. The mean age of the study group was 49 years (range 28-72 years). The site of the primary tumor was the cervix in 9 (53%) patients, the uterus in 7 (41%) patients, and the vagina in 1 (6%) patient. The treatment for the primary disease was surgery with or without adjuvant radiation in 14 (82%) patients and definitive radiation in 3 (18%) patients. The current surgery consisted of exenterative surgery in 10 (59%) patients and tumor resection in 7 (41%) patients. Complete gross resection was achieved in 13 (76%) patients. The mean HDR-IORT dose was 14 Gy (range 12-15). Additional radiation in the form of permanent Iodine-125 implant was given to 3 of 4 patients with gross residual disease. The median peripheral dose was 140 Gy.

RESULTS

With a median follow-up of 20 months (range 3-65 months), the 3-year actuarial local control (LC) rate was 67%. In patients with complete gross resection, the 3-year LC rate was 83%, compared to 25% in patients with gross residual disease, p < 0.01. The 3-year distant metastasis disease-free and overall survival rates were 54% and 54%, respectively. The complications were as follows: gastrointestinal obstruction, 4 (24%); wound complications, 4 (24%); abscesses, 3 (18%); peripheral neuropathy, 3 (18%); rectovaginal fistula, 2 (12%); and ureteral obstruction, 2 (12%).

CONCLUSION

Radical surgical resection and combined IORT for patients with recurrent gynecologic tumors seems to provide a reasonable local-control rate in patients who have failed prior surgery and/or definitive radiation. Patient selection is very important, however, as only those patients with complete gross resection at completion of surgery appear to benefit most from this radical approach in the salvage setting.

[Pelvic wall recurrence of cervix carcinomas. Combined surgical-radio-chemotherapeutic procedure (CORCT)]

PURPOSE

The prognosis of patients with pelvic wall recurrences after primary therapy of cervical cancer is bad. In selected patients treated exclusively by surgery as primary therapy the 5-year survival rate was between 5 and 25%. Additionally the combination of operation and radiotherapy (CORT) improved the survival so far. We developed a new concept for the treatment of pelvic wall recurrences. This concept includes the combination of radical surgery, interstitial radiation and chemotheray--CORCT (combined operative- and radiochemotherapy).

PATIENTS AND METHODS

After radical surgery, interstitial HDR (Ir-192) brachytherapy in afterloading technique (2.5 Gy, 2 fractions/day in 5 days) was performed. Additionally a chemotherapy with cisplatin 25 mg/m2/day in 5 days and 5-fluorouracil 1000 mg/day in 5 days was applicated.

RESULTS

After combined operative- and radiotherapy 3 of 3 patients died after treatment within 8 months (median) because of distant metastases. After additive radiochemotherapy 3 of 4 patients had no evidence of disease (NED) after a follow-up period of 14 (12 to 30) months.

CONCLUSION

The first treatment results of the new designed combined operative- and radiochemotherapy concept (CORCT) led us to expect an improvement of the prognosis of patients with recurrences of cervical cancer at the pelvic wall.

Operative laparoscopy prior to a pelvic exenteration in patients with recurrent cervical cancer

INTRODUCTION

Selecting out the true candidates for a pelvic exenteration frequently poses a difficult clinical dilemma in patients with recurrent cervical cancer after radiation therapy. Despite very thorough preoperative investigation, inoperable disease is discovered at the time of laparotomy in up to 60% of cases.

SUBJECTS AND METHODS

In this retrospective analysis, we report the use of operative laparoscopy in 13 patients with either biopsy proven locally recurrent cervical cancer (N = 9) or with clinically suspected tumor recurrence (N = 4). All have previously received radical radiation therapy.

RESULTS

Patients' ages ranged from 36 to 79 years (median, 43). The median duration of the procedure was 150 min (range,50-200) and median blood loss was 50 cc (range, 50-200). The procedure was well tolerated in all patients. There was no intraoperative complication. One deep thrombophlebitis occurred postoperatively. The laparoscopic evaluation could not be completed in one case because of a large nonmobile uterine fibroid filling the whole pelvis. At laparoscopy, metastatic tumor was identified in 9 of 12 patients (75%). An unnecessary laparotomy was avoided in 8 of those 9 cases (one had a palliative exenteration). The most common site of metastasis was in the previously radiated pelvis (7/9). Three patients had a negative laparoscopy. Two had an exenteration and one had a transureteroureterostomy. At the time of laparotomy, none were found to have disease that would have been missed at laparoscopy.

CONCLUSION

We conclude that operative laparoscopy may be a valuable additional step in the work-up and management of patients with locally recurrent cervical cancer. With experience in retroperitoneal surgery, the procedure can be carried out safely in previously radiated patients. We believe this approach can lower the number of unnecessary laparotomies, reduce the morbidity, and shorten the length of the postoperative recovery.

Five-year experience with combined operative and radiotherapeutic treatment of recurrent gynecologic tumors infiltrating the pelvic wall

BACKGROUND

Whereas 25 to 50% of selected patients with gynecologic tumors who relapse centrally in an irradiated pelvis can be salvaged by exenteration, postirradiation recurrence infiltrating the pelvic side wall generally has been fatal. We have designed the combined operative and radiotherapeutic treatment (CORT) procedure for the treatment of postirradiation recurrence infiltrating the pelvic wall and developed several new techniques for its realization. The aim of the surgery is as follows: (1) total resection of the tumor with only a microscopic margin (R1) at the pelvic wall, preserving the bony pelvis and the neurovascular support of the leg; (2) modulation of the therapeutic index for a second high-dose irradiation of the pelvic wall by transferring autologous tissue from the abdomen or the thigh, and (3) reconstruction of pelvic organ functions lost due to tumor resection. The tumor bed is irradiated postoperatively with brachytherapy through transcutaneous guide tubes implanted at the pelvic wall.

METHODS

Between April 1989 and December 1994, we treated 48 patients with postirradiation recurrent or persistent gynecologic malignancies infiltrating the pelvic wall with CORT and followed them prospectively with the following endpoints: tumor control, survival, complications, and quality of life.

RESULTS

At a median follow-up of 33 months (range, 3-71 months), the 5-year survival probability calculated with the Kaplan-Meier method was 44%. The overall local control rate was 68%, and 85% in the last 25 patients in the series. The censored severe complication rate at 5 years was 33%. No patient died as a consequence of the treatment. Quality of life was self-assessed with a validated questionnaire by 15 patients without evidence of disease, and was rated with a total of 74% of the maximum score points. Age of the patient, state of resection at the pelvic wall (R1 vs. R2), and recurrent tumor size independently influenced tumor progression after CORT in this series.

CONCLUSIONS

CORT appears to be a feasible, innovative treatment with long term survival potential and acceptable quality of life for selected patients with postirradiation gynecologic tumor recurrence infiltrating the pelvic wall. R1 resection of the tumor at the pelvic wall is mandatory; however, the reconstruction options within the pelvis are limited.

The combined operative and radiotherapeutic treatment (CORT) of recurrent tumors infiltrating the pelvic wall: first experience with 18 patients

CORT is a new radiosurgical treatment concept for patients with recurrent gynecologic malignancies infiltrating the pelvic wall. The operative part consists of (i) staging laparotomy; (ii) maximum debulking of the tumor from the pelvic wall and exenteration of infiltrated central pelvic organs; (iii) implantation of brachytherapy guiding tubes on the residual tumor/tumor bed at the pelvic wall; (iv) pelvic wall plasty with muscle and omentum flaps to create a protective distance between the tubes and the pelvic hollow organs and to induce therapeutic angiogenesis; and (v) surgical reconstruction of bowel, bladder, and vulvoperineovaginal functions. Radiation is given postoperatively as fractionated HDR brachytherapy via the implanted tubes. Patients without prior pelvic radiation also receive preoperative whole pelvis teletherapy. Eighteen patients with recurrent malignancies infiltrating one pelvic wall have been treated with CORT in a prospective phase I/II trial at the University of Mainz. Fourteen patients had a history of radiation therapy with midpelvic doses of 40-100 Gy (median, 65 Gy) as primary treatment. Eleven patients (61%) are without evidence of disease at 6-32 months (median, 15 months) follow-up. Four patients have died from pelvic progression and distant metastases, and two patients are alive with disease after 12 months. There was no operative mortality; however, one patient succumbed from fatal thromboembolism 6 months after therapy. Three patients with prior radiation of greater than 75 Gy had to be treated for intestinal fistulas. We conclude that CORT is feasible with encouraging preliminary results.

Iodine-125 interstitial implants as salvage therapy for recurrent gynecologic malignancies

Twenty-one patients with the diagnosis of recurrent gynecologic pelvic malignancy from various primary sites were treated with iodine-125 (I-125) interstitial implants. Eighteen of these patients had been treated with a combination of surgery and radiation therapy for their primary malignancies and 90% had responded. Seventy-five percent had complete local responses. The overall survival time, volume-response relationship, and complications are discussed and the radioresponse of various histologic types is presented.

Intra-operative radiation therapy in the treatment of pelvic malignancies: a preliminary report

Local control of advanced pelvic malignancies, particularly when complete surgical resection is not feasible, is often impeded by dosage limitations in radiation therapy and the intolerance to radiation of normal tissues. This is a preliminary report on the feasibility of improved local control in pelvic malignancies treated by intra-operative radiation therapy, as a radiation boost, in addition to conventional surgical resection and external beam radiation therapy. Fifteen gynaecological malignancies (five cervix, five uterus, four ovary, and one vulva) from Rush Medical College and the University of Navarre, as well as 36 other pelvic malignancies (32 colorectal, 4 genito-urinary) from Rush Medical College were reviewed. All tumours were advanced or recurrent, and all patients were felt to be at high risk of local failure. IORT was administered at a dose range of 10-26 Gy. Our data suggest that the probability of local control improves when IORT is used for primary and for microscopic disease, when the tumour is at least partially resectable, and when the total dose given in IORT and external beam radiation exceeds 70 Gy.

High dose irradiation for recurrent carcinoma of the cervix following radical hysterectomy

A patient with recurrent carcinoma, after radical hysterectomy for Stage 1B carcinoma of the cervix, is presented to illustrate a technique for excluding the small bowel from high dose irradiation. With a barium meal and follow through examination, and fluoroscopy using the simulator, the ideal treatment position for the boost to high dose was determined. Consequently the patient received high dose irradiation with minimal complications and has survived for 42 months after treatment. Since a significant proportion of patients with recurrent carcinoma of the cervix have disease limited to the pelvis, many are potentially curable with high dose irradiation. Small bowel tolerance is a major dose limiting factor: the use of special techniques that limit the volume of small bowel receiving a high dose may enable these patients to have curative irradiation with minimal morbidity.

Late recurrent carcinoma of the cervix: a report of an unusual case and course

A patient with late recurrence of squamous cell carcinoma of the cervix after full course irradiation is presented. The recurrence was extensive and not amenable to surgery. She was reirradiated utilizing special treatment techniques and fields which resulted in long-term survival with acceptable morbidity. The need for case selection and individualization of treatment for patients with late recurrence is discussed.

Carcinoma of the cervix--a review

Carcinoma of the cervix is the fourth most common neoplasm in women. The mortality from this tumor has dropped with the advent of Papanicolaou smears and routine periodic screening, particularly in high risk populations. Diagnosis and staging includes a careful physical examination, the use of colposcopy, directed biopsy, intravenous urogram and cystoscopy. Computed tomography and lymph-angiography may be helpful for detection of iliac or paraaortic lymph nodes. Early, noninvasive stages of this disease (CIN) may be treated with cryosurgery or laser vaporization. Carcinoma in situ (CIS) and microinvasive carcinoma is usually treated with simple hysterectomy for cure. More advanced invasion localized to the cervix may be treated with radical hysterectomy or radiation therapy with 90% of patients surviving 5 years. More advanced tumors are treated with external and intracavitary radiation therapy. For patients with paraaortic lymph node involvement or recurrent tumor, 5-year survival is less than 10%. Chemotherapy may provide some palliation to patients with recurrent tumors but does not increase long term survivorship.