Radiation therapy in primary carcinoma of the vagina

Prognostic factors for outcomes and complications for primary squamous cell carcinoma of the vagina treated with radiation

PURPOSE

To analyze the results of treatment and identify prognostic factors for primary squamous cell carcinoma (SCCA) of the vagina managed with radiotherapy at a single institution.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Seventy-eight patients were analyzed in this retrospective series. Mean characteristics: follow-up 89 months; age 65 years (range 33-99); tumor size 3.8 cm (0.3-10); treatment hemoglobin 12.4 g/dl (range 8.7-14.4); and tumor dose 72 Gy (range 6-127). In addition, 49% of our cohort had a prior hysterectomy. The FIGO stage distribution: I (42%); II (29%); III (17%); and IVA/B (11%). Sixty-two percent of patients were treated with a combination of external beam radiation (EBRT) and brachytherapy, 22% with EBRT alone and 13% with brachytherapy alone.

RESULTS

Kaplan-Meier (KM) 5-year pelvic control, distant metastasis free survival and disease specific survival probabilities: stage I, 83%, 100%, and 92%; stage II, 76%, 95%, and 68%; stage III, 62%, 65%, and 44%; and stage IV, 30%, 18%, and 13%. On multivariate analysis: stage; treatment hemoglobin; and prior hysterectomy were prognostic for DSS (p<0.05). The KM 5-year grade 3/4 (G3/4) complication free estimate of our cohort was 84%. G3/4 complications: tumor size and tumor dose were independently predictive (p<0.05).

CONCLUSIONS

Radiotherapy as a single modality for early stage primary vaginal SCCA produces good results. Advanced stage disease necessitates a combined modality approach and/or new methods. Treatment Hg levels appear to be clinically significant and studies on correction of anemia during treatment are warranted.

Primary carcinoma of the vagina: Tata Memorial Hospital experience

PURPOSE

Carcinoma of the vagina is a rare gynecological malignancy comprising approximately 2% of all the gynecological malignancies. We have analyzed the treatment outcome of the patients treated at the Tata Memorial Hospital from January 1984 to December 1993.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

In this 10-year period, 134 patients of primary vaginal cancers were registered at our hospital. Of these, 75 patients received complete treatment and are analyzed.

RESULTS

Disease-free survival (DFS) for the whole group is 50%, and overall survival (OAS) is 60%. Most locoregional recurrences and distant failures are noted in the 2 years following treatment. DFS at 5 years is as follows: Stage I (5 patients), Stage IIA (37 patients), Stage IIB (15 patients), Stage III (14 patients), and Stage IV (4 patients); are 40%, 55%, 60%, 50%, and 25%, respectively. The DFS for patients with complete response (42 patients) to external radiation at 5 years is 68%, with partial response (25 patients) is 35%, and with poor or no response (6 patients) is 18% (p = 0.0000). We observed that brachytherapy was an important part of the treatment, and patients who received brachytherapy (59 patients), either with a vaginal intracavitary applicator (30 patients) or interstitial implant (29 patients) had a DFS of 53% and 56%, respectively, while 15 patients who received external radiation alone had a DFS of 30%. Patients receiving brachytherapy within 4 weeks of external radiation had a DFS of 60% as compared to 30% when the interval was more than 4 weeks.

CONCLUSION

The factors indicating prognosis are: site and extent of involvement, presence of lymph nodes at presentation, technique of brachytherapy, and interval between external radiation and brachytherapy.

Radiotherapy alone for carcinoma of the vagina: the importance of overall treatment time

PURPOSE

Review treatment results, complications, and the importance of overall treatment time for carcinoma of the vagina treated with radiotherapy alone.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

Between October 1964 and October 1990, 65 patients with histologically confirmed carcinoma of the vagina received definitive radiotherapy at the University of Florida. All patients had a minimum 2-year follow-up. Most patients were treated with a combination of external-beam radiotherapy and brachytherapy. The probability of pelvic control, cause-specific survival, and complications was calculated and multivariate analyses were performed. The log-rank test was used to determine significance levels between the curves.

RESULTS

The 5-year cause-specific survival rates were, Stage 0 (six patients), 100%; Stage I (17 patients), 94%; Stage IIA (six patients), 80%; Stage IIB (ten patients), 39%; Stage III (twn patients), 79%; and Stage IVA (six patients), 62%. The pelvic control rates at 5 years were: Stage 0, 100%; Stage I, 87%; Stage IIA, 88%; Stage IIB, 68%; Stage III, 80%; and Stage IVA, 67%. The parameters of stage, patient age, total dose to primary site, and overall treatment time were evaluated in a multivariate analysis. The single most important predictor of pelvic control was overall treatment time. If the entire course of radiotherapy (external beam + implant) was completed within 9 weeks (63 days), the pelvic control rate was 97%. The pelvic control rate was only 54% if treatment time extended beyond 9 weeks (p = .0003). The rate of severe complications was 12%, and the incidence increased with increasing total primary dose.

CONCLUSION

Radiotherapy alone can cure a significant proportion of patients with carcinoma of the vagina. Treatment should be completed without significant interruption, preferably within 9 weeks.

Radical radiation therapy for carcinoma of the vagina--impact of treatment modalities on outcome: Peter MacCallum Cancer Institute experience 1970-1990

To determine the outcome of radical radiation therapy for carcinoma of the vagina, a retrospective analysis has been made of 103 patients referred with this diagnosis to the Peter MacCallum Cancer Institute from 1970 to 1989. Eighty-four patients were treated for cure, seventy-four patients with definitive radical radiotherapy and 10 patients with adjuvant post-operative radiotherapy. Results were analyzed from two eras--before and after 1985--reflecting changes in referral pattern, treatment policy, and outcome. Forty-eight patients were treated before 1985 (Stage I--24, Stage II--6, Stage III--15, Stage IV--3) and 36 patients after 1985 (Stage I--20, Stage II--3, Stage III--6, Stage IV--7). After 1985 more patients were treated with combined beam radiation and brachytherapy (23/36 vs. 16/48 prior to 1985). More extensive tumors were systematically implanted (Ir 192). (No implants before 1985; 15 implants and 8 intracavitary applications post 1985). Fewer were treated with external beam alone after 1985; 11/36 (31%) vs. 27/48 (55%) before 1985. A small number (7/84-8%) were treated with brachytherapy alone. Survival results were markedly improved after 1985 (22/36-61% vs 16/48-33%) due partly to the shorter period of follow-up, but due also to marked improvement in local control particularly in early stage disease. (1/23 vs. 12/30 recurrences in Stage I, II disease). Results indicate optimal results with radical radiation therapy occur only with adequate dose delivery best achieved with a judicious combination of external beam radiotherapy and brachytherapy. Interstitial implantation plays a crucial role.

Results of radiotherapeutic management of primary carcinoma of the vagina

Forty-five previously untreated patients with primary carcinoma of the vagina were treated with curative radiotherapy from 1965 through 1985. All patients were staged according to the FIGO system. One patient was classified as Stage 0, 15 as Stage I, 22 as Stage II, 6 as Stage III, and 1 as Stage IV. Treatment consisted of intracavitary irradiation alone in Stage 0 patients. Stage I patients received intracavitary/interstitial irradiation alone or in combination with external irradiation and an implant when feasible. When treated with an implant only, the total tumor dose delivered was between 65-70 Gy. External irradiation consisted of delivering a dose of 45-50 Gy over a period of 4 1/2-5 weeks to the whole pelvis to treat the regional lymph nodes. An additional dose of 20-25 Gy was delivered to the site of original involvement using an implant when feasible. If not technically feasible, as in advanced stages, the patient was treated with additional external irradiation to a total dose of 65-70 Gy by a shrinking field technique. All patients except one were followed either until death or for a minimum of 2 years. The actuarial 5-year survival rates were 100% for Stage 0, 78% for Stage I, and 71% for Stage II patients. None of the patients with Stage III or IV disease survived. Of the patients who recurred, all but two did so within 16 months after diagnosis. Pelvic recurrence as the first site of recurrence occurred in 86% of the patients who recurred. Distant recurrence as a component occurred in 20% of all failures. Complications as a consequence of therapy occurred in 18% of the patients. Vaginal necrosis that healed with conservative treatment was seen in four patients and the other four patients had rectal complications of varying severity. Thus, curative radiotherapy is an effective method of treatment, with acceptable morbidity, in patients with early stage primary carcinoma of the vagina.

Invasive vaginal carcinoma: analysis of early-stage disease

From 1960 through 1987, 89 patients with stage I (44 patients) or II (45 patients) vaginal carcinoma (excluding melanomas) were treated primarily at the Mayo Clinic. Treatment consisted of surgery alone in 52 patients, surgery plus radiation in 14, and radiation alone in 23. The median duration of follow-up was 4.4 years. The 5-year survival (Kaplan-Meier method) was 82% for patients with stage I disease and 53% for those with stage II disease (p = 0.009). Analysis of survival according to treatment did not show statistically significant differences. This report is consistent with previous studies showing that stage is an important prognostic factor and that treatment can be individualized, including surgical treatment for primary early-stage vaginal cancer.

Primary vaginal squamous cell carcinoma in the young patient

This report, prompted by the recent observation of three cases of primary squamous cell carcinoma in relatively young patients, reviews the English-language literature in search of information on age-related incidence for this tumor in the below-40 age group. From those series providing data, it was found that only 10% of these tumors occur in patients less than 40 years old. No authentic squamous cell vaginal cancer could be found in patients less than 10 years of age, and only five such well-documented cases were found in the age group 11-20. The incidence of this tumor then rises abruptly to 60 patients in the age group 21-30 and to 160 patients in the age group 31-40. The rarity of the tumor, particularly with regard to the anatomical location, is impressive as well as enigmatic.