Is callus calcium content an indicator of the mechanical strength of healing fractures? An experimental study in rat metatarsals

Evaluating the Utility of the Pixel Value Ratio in the Determination of Time to Full Weight-bearing in Patients Undergoing Intramedullary Limb Lengthening

Introduction

Limb lengthening using intramedullary nails is an increasingly popular method of achieving limb length equalisation. Currently, the decision regarding when to commence full weight-bearing (FWB) remains largely subjective. Objective criteria for determining the proper timing of FWB would be helpful to limb lengthening surgeons. This study examines using the pixel value ratio (PVR) as an objective method to determine the time to FWB for patients being lengthened with an intramedullary nail.

Materials and methods

A retrospective chart review of 42 patients who underwent unilateral lengthening of the femur was undertaken. The PVR of all four cortices of the regenerate bone was monitored throughout the distraction and consolidation stages to determine the ratio at the time of FWB.

Results

Clinically and radiologically determined FWB was achieved at a mean time of 125.7 ± 30.1 days from surgery. The mean PVR at the time of FWB was 0.94. The medial cortex healed fastest with a mean PVR of 0.96, while the posterior cortex healed slowest with a mean PVR of 0.92.

Conclusion

The PVR is a quick and reliable method to objectively assess the state of healing of the regenerate bone during distraction osteogenesis. We observed that there were no adverse effects when subjects commenced FWB when three out of the four cortices had a PVR of at least 0.93.

How to cite this article

Bafor A, Duncan ME, Iobst CA. Evaluating the Utility of the Pixel Value Ratio in the Determination of Time to Full Weight-bearing in Patients Undergoing Intramedullary Limb Lengthening. Strategies Trauma Limb Reconstr 2020;15(2):74-78.

Serial bone mineral density ratio measurement for fixator removal in tibia distraction osteogenesis and need of a supportive method using the pixel value ratio

Distraction osteogenesis is one of the common procedures for limb lengthening. However, attempts are being made constantly to establish objective guidelines for early and safe removal of a fixator using a sensitive and quantitative measurement technique. Dual-energy X-ray absorptiometry (DEXA) has been evaluated in the past for understanding callus stiffness, and the present study is a step further in this direction. The purpose of this study was to evaluate the correlation between bone mineral density ratio (BMDR) obtained by a DEXA scan and the pixel value ratio (PVR) on plain digital radiographs at each cortex and various callus pathways and callus shapes as described by Ru-Li's classification. A retrospective analysis of 40 tibial segments in 23 patients operated upon for various indications for limb lengthening was carried out. There were 11 male and 12 female patients with a mean age of 18 years. The Ilizarov method was applied after monofocal osteotomy, and distraction and consolidation were monitored using digital radiographs and DEXA scanning. BMDR was positively correlated with PVR, and the optimal BMDR for removal of the fixator was found to be 0.511. PVR of all cortices, except the anterior cortex, showed significant positive correlation with BMDR of the regenerate. There was good correlation between BMDR and PVR in the homogenous or heterogenous pathway according to callus shape and pathway. Thus, this study shows that BMD measurement can provide an objective and noninvasive method for assessing the rate of new bone formation during tibial distraction osteogenesis. It can thus function as an effective adjunct to measure callus stiffness, along with PVR, using digital radiographs, especially in cases in which callus maturation and stiffness is doubtful. Further studies especially dealing with callus progression through the lucent pathway as well as those dealing with regenerate fractures may be needed to conclusively prove the efficacy of this method for measurement of callus maturation.

Correlations between strength and quantitative computed tomography measurement of callus mineralization in experimental tibial fractures

BACKGROUND

the evaluation of fracture healing in the clinic has not changed significantly during the past few decades, despite the development of modern tissue-imaging tools. Recent publications have reported significant and interesting associations between biomechanical properties and quantitative computed tomography data of fractures and grafts. We therefore studied the correlations between the strength and segmented quantitative computed tomography data of tibial diaphyseal fractures.

METHODS

forty male rats received a tibial-shaft osteotomy that was initially stabilized with either intramedullary nailing or external fixation. Evaluation at 30 and 60 days post-osteotomy included X-ray, quantitative computed tomography and bending testing. Quantitative computed tomography data were segmented by voxel density into soft callus (171-539 mg/cm(3)), hard callus (540-1199 mg/cm(3)) and cortical bone (≥ 1200mg/cm(3)), and volumetric bone mineral density was calculated.

FINDINGS

all fractures demonstrated pronounced formation of soft and hard callus tissues at 30 days post-osteotomy, and at 60 days the cortical bone volume was significantly increased with callus resorption. Bending strength correlated significantly and positively with fracture-site cortical bone volume and volumetric bone mineral density in the intramedullary nailed group in the early phase of healing.

INTERPRETATION

quantitative computed tomography was used to quantify characteristic secondary healing. The observed correlations indicate that biomechanically important mineralization can be measured by quantitative computed tomography in the early phase of healing in flexibly fixed fractures.

Effects of calcium supplements on fracture healing in a rat osteoporotic model

Fracture healing is a complex process, which is further complicated if the bone is osteoporotic. Calcium is one of the important minerals in bone and has been found to prevent osteoporosis but its role in fracture healing of osteoporotic bone is still unclear. We carried out a study on the effects of calcium supplementation on the late phase healing of fractured osteoporotic bone using an ovariectomized rat model. Twenty-four female Sprague-Dawley rats were divided into three groups: sham-operated (SO), ovariectomized-control (OVXC), and ovariectomized + calcium supplements (Ca). The right femurs of all the rats were fractured at mid-epiphysis and a K-wire was inserted for internal fixation. After 2 months of treatment, the rats were sacrificed and the femora were dissected out for radiological and biomechanical assessment. As expected, osteoporosis resulted in impaired healing as shown by the poor radiological and biomechanical properties of the OVXC group. CT scans showed significantly lower callus volumes in the SO and Ca groups compared to the OVXC group. Radiological scoring of fracture healing and callus staging of the SO and Ca groups were better than the OVXC group. However, the biomechanical parameters of the Ca group were significantly lower than the SO group and similar to the OVXC group. Therefore, calcium supplements may appear to improve fracture healing of osteoporotic bone but failed to improve strength.

Objective guidelines for removing an external fixator after tibial lengthening using pixel value ratio: a pilot study

During limb lengthening over an intramedullary nail, decisions regarding external fixator removal and weightbearing depend on the amount of callus seen at the lengthening area on radiographs. However, this method is subjective and objective evaluation of the amount of callus likely would minimize nail or interlocking screw breakage and refracture after fixator removal. We asked how many cortices with full corticalization of the newly formed bone at the lengthening area are needed to allow fixator removal and full weightbearing and how to radiographically determine the stage of corticalization. We retrospectively reviewed 17 patients (34 lengthenings) who underwent bilateral tibial lengthenings over an intramedullary nail. The average gain in length was 7.2 +/- 3.4 cm. We determined the pixel value ratio (ratio of pixel value of regenerate versus the mean pixel value of adjacent bone) of the lengthened area on radiographs. There were no nail or screw breakage and refracture. Partial weightbearing with crutches was permitted when the pixel value ratio was 1 in two cortices and full weightbearing without crutches was permitted when the pixel value ratio was 1 in three cortices. The pixel value ratio on radiographs can be an objective parameter for callus measurement and may provide guidelines for the timing of external fixator removal. We cannot determine from our limited data the minimum pixel value in how many cortices would suggest safe removal, but we can say our criteria were not associated with subsequent refracture.

Assessment of mineral density and atomic content of fracture callus by quantitative computerized tomography

The mineral density and atomic numbers of elements in the periosteal callus and the cortex area of a healing fracture were measured by quantitative computerized tomography (QCT) to obtain accurate information on the mineralization process in rabbit tibia. The mineral density of the periosteal callus was highest on day 15 and decreased gradually throughout the experiment. This was initially detected by QCT, but not with conventional radiography. An apparent decrease in cortical bone density on days 28 and 42 after fracture was observed. Atomic numbers of elements in the cortex remained stable, indicating a possible homeostatic mechanism of mineral preservation at the fracture callus and involved cortical area. QCT may predict density alterations in the fracture callus more accurately than conventional X-ray. Further studies are essential to predict a relationship between mineral density, atomic numbers, and mechanical stability.

Temporal changes in dynamic inter fragmentary motion and callus formation in fractures

This study examined whether callus proliferation at long bone fractures is triggered by cyclical inter-fragmentary displacement which arises from routine activity. It also examined whether a growing callus increases the stability of a fracture, thereby reducing displacement amplitude during relative motion. Seven tibial fractures stabilised with external fixators were monitored up to and beyond fixator removal. An instrumented spatial linkage was developed which was attached to the bone screws to measure inter-fragmentary displacement at the fracture in all six degrees of freedom during routine walking. Callus index (final bone width/initial bone width) was measured at the posterior and lateral cortical surfaces from orthogonal radiographs. In all seven subjects, callus growth was initiated subsequent to a peak in displacement which occurred within the first 42 days; at nine of the 14 surfaces occurred callus initiation occurred within 14 days of the peak displacement. With the exception of two lateral surfaces, maximum callus size, subsequent to fixator removal (at up to 119 days after removal). Displacement reduced during callus growth in five out of six subjects. Since the reduction in displacement did not arise from reduced weight-bearing, increasing callus size must correlate with progressive mechanical union. This was confirmed by end point stiffness tests. Therefore, peak cyclical displacement appears to be the stimulus for callus growth, the effect of which is to reduce displacement and strain which allows the following stages of bone formation and remodelling to unite the fracture.

Effect of decalcification on bone mineral content and bending strength of feline femur

The relationships between bone mineral content (BMC), bone calcium, and bone strength were studied in fractionally demineralized feline femurs. In 44 pairs of cat femurs, the right bones were decalcified in ethylene diaminetetra acetic acid (EDTA) to 20%, 40%, 60%, 80%, and 100% of the mineral content of the intact left bone (= control). The bones were then loaded to failure, and maximum strength values were recorded. The data were then used to calculate the percentage strength of the right relative to the left femurs. A correlation coefficient (r) of 0.970 was found between the percentage decalcification and percentage bending strength. A direct relationship (r = 0.876) was also observed between the total calcium extracted and total loss in BMC. The EDTA solutions were spot checked for protein content to determine if the organic matrices had been altered by demineralization. Protein was never detected. Nor did the demineralized tissues display histologic evidence of gross microscopic damage. This study has shown that in cat femurs, 20% decalcification led to about 35% loss in bending strength, and 60% decalcification caused 75% loss in strength. These values are significant as they highlight the importance of calcium to the strength of osteopenic bone.