Evaluation of diallate and triallate herbicides for genotoxic effects in a battery of in vitro and short-term in vivo tests

The genotoxicity of ambient outdoor air, a review: Salmonella mutagenicity

Mutagens in urban air pollution come from anthropogenic sources (especially combustion sources) and are products of airborne chemical reactions. Bacterial mutation tests have been used for large, multi-site, and/or time series studies, for bioassay-directed fractionation studies, for identifying the presence of specific classes of mutagens, and for doing site- or source-comparisons for relative levels of airborne mutagens. Early research recognized that although carcinogenic PAHs were present in air samples they could not account for the majority of the mutagenic activity detected. The mutagenicity of airborne particulate organics is due to at least 500 identified compounds from varying chemical classes. Bioassay-directed fractionation studies for identifying toxicants are difficult to compare because they do not identify all of the mutagens present, and both the analytical and bioassay protocols vary from study to study. However, these studies show that the majority of mutagenicity is usually associated with moderately polar/highly polar classes of compounds that tend to contain nitroaromatic compounds, aromatic amines, and aromatic ketones. Smog chamber studies have shown that mutagenic aliphatic and aromatic nitrogen-containing compounds are produced in the atmosphere when organic compounds (even non-mutagenic compounds) are exposed to nitrogen oxides and sunlight. Reactions that occur in the atmosphere, therefore, can have a profound effect on the genotoxic burden of ambient air. This review illustrates that the mutagenesis protocol and tester strains should be selected based on the design and purpose of the study and that the correlation with animal cancer bioassay results depends upon chemical class. Future emphasis needs to be placed on volatile and semi-volatile genotoxicants, and on multi-national studies that identify, quantify, and apportion mutagenicity. Initial efforts at replacing the Salmonella assay for ambient air studies with some emerging technology should be initiated.

A review of the genotoxicity of triallate

Triallate is a selective herbicidal chemical used for control of wild oats in wheat. It has an extensive genotoxicity database that includes a variety of in vitro and in vivo studies. The chemical has produced mixed results in in vitro assay systems. It was genotoxic in bacterial mutation Ames assays, predominantly in Salmonella typhimurium strains TA100 and TA1535 in the presence of S9. Weaker responses have been observed in TA100 and TA1535 in the absence of S9. Mixed results have been observed in strain TA98, whereas no genotoxicity has been observed in strains TA1537 and TA1538. The presence and absence of S9 and its source seem to play a role in the bacterial response to the chemical. There have also been conflicting results in other test systems using other bacterial genera, yeast, and mammalian cells. Chromosome effects assays (sister-chromatid exchange and cytogenetics assays) have produced mixed results with S9 but no genotoxicity without S9. Triallate has not produced any genotoxicity in in vitro DNA damage or unscheduled DNA synthesis assays using EUE cells, human lymphocytes, and rat and mouse hepatocytes. In a series of in vivo genotoxicity assays (cytogenetics, micronucleus, dominant lethal, and unscheduled DNA synthesis), there has been no indication of any adverse genotoxic effect. Metabolism data indicate that the probable explanation for the differences observed between the in vitro studies with S9 and without S9 and between the in vitro and the in vivo studies is the production of a mutagenic intermediate in vitro at high doses of triallate is expected to be at most only transiently present in in vivo studies. The weight of evidence strongly suggests that triallate is not likely to exert mutagenic activity in vivo due to toxicokinetics and metabolic processes leading to detoxification.

Genotoxicity of contaminated soil and shallow well water detected by plant bioassays

Three major plant bioassays, i.e., the Allium root anaphase aberration (Allium-AA), the Tradescantia-micronucleus (Trad-MCN) and the Tradescantia stamen hair mutation (Trad-SHM) tests, were utilized in soil solutions or shallow well water samples to determine the degree of their genotoxicity. Shallow well water samples were collected from five different farms, and soil solutions were extracted with distilled water or dimethyl sulfoxide (DMSO) from pesticide-contaminated (metolachlor, atrazine, extrazine, and 2, 4-D) and pesticide-free soil samples. Genotoxicity was expressed in terms of anaphase aberration (AA) frequencies in the Allium-AA test, in terms of micronuclei frequencies in the Trad-MCN test, and in terms of pink mutation events in the Trad-SHM test. On average, results of Allium-AA tests showed a 2.78-3.01 fold increase in anaphase aberration frequencies in contaminated soil solution samples and well water samples as compared with the negative control. Results of Trad-MCN tests showed a 1.66-4.75 fold increase of MCN frequencies in contaminated soil solution samples and shallow well water samples as compared with the frequencies of the controls. Results of Trad-SHM tests showed a 2.7-2.86 fold increase of pink mutation events in the contaminated soil solution samples over that of the controls. Control groups of the Allium-AA tests had an average of 0.75/1000 anaphase figures, and control groups of the Trad-MCN tests had an average of 3.2 MCN/100 tetrads, while control groups of the Trad-SHM tests had an average of 1.4 mutation events/1000 hairs. In general, soil solutions of DMSO extracts showed higher genotoxicity than that of distilled water extracts. Among these three plant bioassays, the Trad-MCN test has the highest efficiency. The highest toxicity, based upon the Trad-MCN test results, was found in the pesticide contaminated soil samples from Monroe's farm. Water samples from the Fountain Green/Bushnell area ranked second in genotoxicity.

The L5178Y/tk+/- mouse lymphoma specific gene and chromosomal mutation assay a phase III report of the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency Gene-Tox Program

The L5178Y/tk+/- (-)3.7.2C mouse lymphoma assay (MLA) which detects mutations affecting the heterozygous thymidine kinase (tk) locus is capable of responding to chemicals acting as clastogens as well as point mutagens. Improvements in the assay to enhance detection of this spectrum of genetic events are summarized, and criteria for evaluating the data are defined. Using these criteria, the Phase III Work Group reviewed and evaluated literature containing MLA results published from 1976 through 1993. The data base included 602 chemicals of which 343 were evaluated as positive, 44 negative, 18 equivocal, 54 apparently inappropriate for evaluation in this test system with the published protocols, and 142 that were inadequately tested, and thus a definitive call could not be made. The overall performance of the assay is summarized by chemical class, and the outcome of testing 260 chemicals in the MLA is compared with Gene-Tox and National Toxicology Program evaluations of rodent carcinogenesis bioassay results for the same chemicals. Based on the Work Group's evaluation of published MLA data for chemicals that were considered adequately tested, it is concluded that for most chemicals the L5178Y/tk+/- mouse lymphoma assay is eminently well suited for genotoxicity testing and for predicting the potential for carcinogenicity.

Cytogenetic effect of the thiocarbamate herbicides butylate, molinate and vernolate in the mouse bone marrow micronucleus test

Three thiocarbamate herbicides, butylate (S-ethyl-diisobutylthiocarbamate), vernolate (S-propyl dipropylthiocarbamate) and molinate (S-ethyl-N,N-hexamethylenethiocarbamate) were assayed for cytogenetic effect in the mouse bone marrow micronucleus test. Butylate was inactive in bone marrow, vernolate caused a marginal increase in the incidence of micronucleated polychromatic erythrocytes only at a high toxic dose level. Molinate, the N,N-hexamethylene derivative was, however, strongly active in the bone marrow, causing a high frequency of micronucleated erythrocytes, even at subtoxic concentrations.