Increased 3H-clonidine binding in the platelets of patients with depressive and schizophrenic disorders

Is there a relationship between morphological and functional platelet changes and depressive disorder?

BACKGROUND

Blood platelets, due to shared biochemical and functional properties with presynaptic serotonergic neurons, constituted, over the years, an attractive peripheral biomarker of neuronal activity. Therefore, the literature strongly focused on the investigation of eventual structural and functional platelet abnormalities in neuropsychiatric disorders, particularly in depressive disorder. Given their impact in biological psychiatry, the goal of the present paper was to review and critically analyze studies exploring platelet activity, functionality, and morpho-structure in subjects with depressive disorder.

METHODS

According to the PRISMA guidelines, we performed a systematic review through the PubMed database up to March 2020 with the search terms: (1) platelets in depression [Title/Abstract]"; (2) "(platelets[Title]) AND depressive disorder[Title/Abstract]"; (3) "(Platelet[Title]) AND major depressive disorder[Title]"; (4) (platelets[Title]) AND depressed[Title]"; (5) (platelets[Title]) AND depressive episode[Title]"; (6) (platelets[Title]) AND major depression[Title]"; (7) platelet activation in depression[All fields]"; and (8) platelet reactivity in depression[All fields]."

RESULTS

After a detailed screening analysis and the application of specific selection criteria, we included in our review a total of 106 for qualitative synthesis. The studies were classified into various subparagraphs according to platelet characteristics analyzed: serotonergic system (5-HT2A receptors, SERT activity, and 5-HT content), adrenergic system, MAO activity, biomarkers of activation, responsivity, morphological changes, and other molecular pathways.

CONCLUSIONS

Despite the large amount of the literature examined, nonunivocal and, occasionally, conflicting results emerged. However, the findings on structural and metabolic alterations, modifications in the expression of specific proteins, changes in the aggregability, or in the responsivity to different pro-activating stimuli, may be suggestive of potential platelet dysfunctions in depressed subjects, which would result in a kind of hyperreactive state. This condition could potentially lead to an increased cardiovascular risk. In line with this hypothesis, we speculated that antidepressant treatments would seem to reduce this hyperreactivity while representing a potential tool for reducing cardiovascular risk in depressed patients and, maybe, in other neuropsychiatric conditions. However, the problem of the specificity of platelet biomarkers is still at issue and would deserve to be deepened in future studies.

α2 adrenergic receptor dysregulation in depressive disorders: implications for the neurobiology of depression and antidepressant therapy

Dysfunction in noradrenergic neurotransmission has long been theorized to occur in depressive disorders. The α2 adrenergic receptor (AR) family, as a group of key players in regulating the noradrenergic system, has been investigated for involvement in the neurobiology of depression and mechanisms of antidepressant therapies. However, a clear picture of the α2ARs in depressive disorders has not been established due to the existence of apparently conflicting findings in the literature. In this article, we report that a careful accounting of methodological differences within the literature can resolve the present lack of consensus on involvement of α2ARs in depression. In particular, the pharmacological properties of the radioligand (e.g. agonist versus antagonist) utilized for determining receptor density are crucial in determining study outcome. Upregulation of α2AR density detected by radiolabeled agonists but not by antagonists in patients with depressive disorders suggests a selective increase in the density of high-affinity conformational state α2ARs, which is indicative of enhanced G protein coupling to the receptor. Importantly, this high-affinity state α2AR upregulation can be normalized with antidepressant treatments. Thus, depressive disorders appear to be associated with increased α2AR sensitivity and responsiveness, which may represent a physiological basis for the putative noradrenergic dysfunction in depressive disorders. In addition, we review changes in some key α2AR accessory proteins in depressive disorders and discuss their potential contribution to α2AR dysfunction.

Noradrenergic function in suicide

Although abnormalities in serotonergic function have been the major focus of studies on suicidal behavior, several studies indicate that abnormalities of noradrenergic function may also be involved in the pathophysiology of suicide. In this paper, we have reviewed some of the noradrenergic studies in suicide, including studies of the biosynthetic enzyme for norepinephrine, tyrosine hydroxylase (TH), the receptors for norepinephrine, alpha- and beta-adrenergic receptors, as well as the signaling cascades linked to beta-adrenergic receptors. In general, these studies indicate that the protein expression of TH, as well as alpha2- and beta2-adrenergic receptors, is increased in the postmortem brain of suicide victims. More studies are needed in order to examine extensively the role of noradrenergic function in suicidal behavior.

Hyperactive phosphoinositide signaling pathway in platelets of depressed patients: effect of desipramine treatment

There is some evidence to suggest that certain neurotransmitter receptors, such as adrenergic and serotonergic receptors and receptor-linked signaling systems, may be altered in depression. Serotonin(2A) and alpha(2)-adrenergic receptors are linked to the phosphoinositide (PI) signaling system in platelets and brain. To examine if the PI signaling system is altered in depression, we studied thrombin- and sodium fluoride-stimulated inositol phosphate(1) (IP(1)) formation before and during desipramine (DMI) treatment in platelets of depressed patients and normal control subjects. We determined thrombin- and sodium fluoride-stimulated IP(1) formation in platelets obtained from hospitalized depressed patients during a drug-free baseline period and after 6 weeks of DMI treatment, and drug-free non-hospitalized normal control subjects. Depressed subjects were diagnosed according to DSM-IV criteria, and severity of illness was assessed with the Hamilton Depression Rating Scale. We observed that thrombin-stimulated IP(1) formation in platelets of depressed patients was significantly higher compared with that of normal control subjects. There were no significant differences in sodium fluoride-stimulated IP(1) formation between depressed patients and normal control subjects. We also did not find any significant effect of treatment with DMI on either thrombin- or sodium fluoride-stimulated IP(1) formation in platelets of depressed patients, which continued to be significantly higher after 6 weeks of treatment with DMI, compared with normal control values. Our studies found a hyperactive PI signaling system in platelets of depressed patients. This hyperactive system may be related either to an increased number of thrombin receptors or to a generalized overstimulation of this pathway; however, since we did not observe any differences in sodium fluoride-stimulated IP(1) formation, it appears that, although the sites distal to the receptors may be altered, this abnormality is probably not related to the abnormalities in G proteins.

Platelet alpha2A-adrenoceptor function in major depression: Gi coupling, effects of imipramine and relationship to treatment outcome

Studies suggest alpha2A-adrenoceptors (alpha(2A)AR) dysregulation in major depressive disorder (MDD). Platelet alpha(2A)ARs exist in high- and low-conformational states that are regulated by Gi protein. Although alpha(2A)AR coupling to Gi protein plays an important role in signal transduction and is modulated by antidepressants, it has not been previously investigated. Alpha2AR density in the high- and low-conformational states, agonist affinity and coupling efficiency were investigated in 27 healthy control subjects, 23 drug-free MDD patients and 16 patients after imipramine treatment using [3H]yohimbine saturation and norepinephrine displacement of [3H]yohimbine binding experiments. Coupling measures were derived from NE-displacement experiments. Patients had significantly higher alpha(2A)AR density, particularly in the high-conformational state, than control subjects. Coupling indices were normal in patients. High pre-treatment agonist affinity to the receptor in the high-conformational state and normal coupling predicted positive treatment outcome. Decreased coupling to Gi predicted a negative treatment outcome. Imipramine induced uncoupling (-11%) and redistribution of receptor density in treatment responders only, but had no effect on alpha(2A)AR coupling or density in treatment non-responders. Increased alpha(2A)AR density may represent a trait marker in MDD. The results provide indirect evidence for abnormal protein kinase A (PKA) and protein kinase C (PKC) in MDD which may be pursued in future investigations.

Characteristics of norepinephrine and clonidine displacement of [3H]yohimbine binding to platelet alpha2-adrenoreceptors in healthy volunteers

Clonidine's estimates of platelet alpha2-adrenoreceptor (alpha2AR) density are substantially lower than yohimbine's. This discrepancy could have contributed to inconsistent results from studies on the role of alpha2AR in depression. Furthermore, few studies have investigated the relative distribution of alpha2AR between the high- and low-affinity states or their Gi protein coupling. [3H]yohimbine saturable binding to platelet alpha2AR, its displacement by norepinephrine and clonidine, and the effects of Gpp(NH)p on agonist displacement curves were investigated in 11 healthy volunteers. Clonidine estimates of alpha2AR density were close to norepinephrine estimates, and both were strongly correlated. Clonidine's K(L)/K(H) ratio was lower than norepinephrine's, consistent with its partial agonist nature. Norepinephrine and clonidine displacement curves revealed two affinity states. Gpp(NH)p induced a significant rightward shift to a single low-affinity state. When used in combination with a specific antagonist, clonidine's estimates of alpha2AR density were similar to those of norepinephrine's, and both were higher than previously reported, when clonidine was used alone. Re-evaluation of previous studies on alpha2AR in depression using clonidine is needed. The combined use of antagonist-saturation and agonist-displacement experiments to examine possible dysregulation in alpha2AR coupling to Gi protein in psychiatric disorders is recommended.

Differences and variability in plasma noradrenaline between depressive and anxiety disorders

Plasma noradrenaline (NA) levels were compared between two groups of patients with major depressive disorder (melancholic/psychotic and non-melancholic), patients with general anxiety disorders and healthy controls. The melancholic/psychotic depressed group had the highest plasma NA levels. This only reached statistical significance with respect to the control group. Within the depressed group, there was no association between plasma NA levels and age, weight loss, ratings of depression, anxiety or plasma cortisol levels. Variance of plasma NA was greatest in the melancholic/psychotic depressed group. A review of previous studies shows an association between raised plasma NA, depressive illness and alterations in NA variance. This association may be limited to melancholic/psychotic depressed patients. The above findings support a dysregulated noradrenergic system in depressive illness.

Effects of electroconvulsive therapy on peripheral adrenoceptors, plasma, noradrenaline, MHPG and cortisol in depressed patients

BACKGROUND

The mechanism of the antidepressant action of electroconvulsive therapy (ECT) remains unknown. Based on previous work with antidepressant drugs and their effects on the noradrenergic system, we undertook this study to further determine the effects of ECT on selected indices of peripheral adrenoceptor function in depressed patients.

METHODS

Binding parameters (Bmax and Kd) of platelet alpha 2- and leukocyte beta 2-adrenoceptors, plasma noradrenaline (NA), 3-methoxy-4-hydroxy-phenylglycol (MHPG) and cortisol levels were determined in 18 patients, prior to treatment and 14 days after the last of a series of ECTs, and compared with samples obtained from 18 matched control subjects.

RESULTS

Platelet alpha 2-adrenoceptor sites were significantly elevated in untreated patients compared with controls (P < 0.03), but leukocyte beta 2-adrenoceptor numbers did not differ. Treatment with ECT led to a significant reduction in platelet alpha 2-adrenoceptor numbers, whereas leukocyte beta 2-adrenoceptor densities increased. Pre-ECT plasma NA, MHPG, and cortisol levels were elevated in patients, compared with controls, and decreased following ECT, but these differences were not statistically significant. Post-ECT plasma NA and beta 2-adrenoceptor numbers were significantly, negatively correlated (P < 0.05).

CONCLUSIONS

These results suggest that platelet alpha 2-adrenoceptors are supersensitive in depressed patients and treatment with ECT results in down-regulation of these receptors, which may be interpreted as a primary therapeutic, "normalising' effect. The post-ECT changes in leukocyte beta 2-adrenoceptors are probably only secondary to the lower circulating plasma NA levels.

Predicting haloperidol treatment response in chronic schizophrenia

The study attempted to identify pretreatment characteristics of chronic schizophrenic patients that would predict remission in psychosis and amount of clinical improvement after treatment with haloperidol. Thirty-five acutely relapsed schizophrenic patients were entered into a blind 6-week treatment protocol. Pretreatment measures were assessed for prediction of both remission status (dichotomous) and for correlations with change in psychopathology (continuous). Later age of onset and higher plasma homovanillic acid values were significant predictors of remission status (model 1). However, higher cerebrospinal fluid levels of 3-methoxy-4-hydroxyphenylglycol, as well as indices of normal neurodevelopment, predicted larger changes in psychopathology. The results indicate that the definition of drug response determines the predictive variables. Dopaminergic activity seems to relate to the ability to reach remission, while noradrenergic activity relates to symptom intensity and reduction. In addition to catecholamine activity, neurodevelopmental changes determine response to haloperidol.

Platelet I1-imidazoline binding sites are elevated in depression but not generalized anxiety disorder

Depressed patients have been reported to have a higher than normal density of platelet binding sites for 3H-clonidine, an alpha 2-adrenoceptor agonist. Paradoxically, other studies using 3H-alpha 2, antagonists have found no differences from controls. Because 3H-clonidine interacts with platelet alpha 2-adrenoceptors to form G-protein complexes, whereas 3H-alpha 2-antagonists bind with uncoupled receptors, an elevation in G-protein coupling might explain this paradox. Another possibility is that depression might be associated with increased non-adrenergic I1-imidazoline binding sites, which are also clonidine sensitive. To distinguish these possibilities, we utilized p125I-clonidine to measure density (Bmax) and affinity (KD) of platelet G-protein coupled alpha 2-adrenoceptors as well as platelet I1 binding sites, and compared diagnostic groups of major depressive disorder (MDD), generalized anxiety disorder (GAD) and healthy subjects. Specific inhibition of binding by norepinephrine (NE = 10 microM) was used to selectively quantify alpha 2-adrenoceptors, whereas inhibition by 10 microM moxonidine (a > 100-fold selective I1 ligand) quantified I1 binding sites under a NE mask. I1 sites were found to be markedly elevated by, on average, +136% in MDD patients (p = .0007), whereas there was only a marginal increase in alpha 2-adrenoceptor Bmax values in MDD patients (p = .08; GAD and healthy subjects did not differ). Treatment of MDD patients for 6-8 weeks with desipramine downregulated I1 sites as well as alpha 2-adrenoceptors. Positive correlations were also noted for both sites: (a) between Bmax values and the severity of depression (using the Hamilton Depression Rating Scale); and (b) between end-of-treatment plasma desipramine concentrations and the extent of downregulation in Bmax values when subject groups were pooled. None of the binding parameters was associated with plasma catecholamine concentrations. The results suggest that an increased density of platelet I1 binding sites may partially explain the utility of radiolabeled clonidine as a potential biological marker for depressive illness, although an additional increase in G-protein coupling cannot be excluded.

Increased imidazoline and alpha 2 adrenergic binding in platelets of women with dysphoric premenstrual syndromes

An association between dysphoric premenstrual syndromes (PMS) and a lifetime history of major depressive disorders has previously been documented. Other studies have demonstrated an increase in the binding of radiolabeled imidazoline compounds to platelets of depressed patients. Clonidine and related imidazoline compounds interact with alpha 2 adrenoceptors to inhibit neuronal noradrenergic activity and in higher concentrations, they stimulate noradrenergic activity through their interaction with imidazoline receptors. Here we report increased 3H para-aminoclonidine binding to high affinity alpha 2 adrenoceptor sites as well as to nonadrenergic imidazoline binding sites in platelets of women with dysphoric PMS. This higher binding was most pronounced during the late-luteal-symptomatic phase of the menstrual cycle and, to a lesser degree, during the non-symptomatic mid-follicular phase. Binding to the imidazoline site distinguished women with dysphoric PMS from women with no such symptoms, was highly positively correlated with the severity of symptoms, and was negatively correlated with plasma levels of progesterone. These findings suggest that platelet imidazoline binding sites might be a biological marker for dysphoric states in PMS or for the vulnerability to develop them. These findings also point to a possible biological link between dysphoric PMS and major depressive disorders.

Alpha 2- and beta-adrenergic stimulation of corticosterone secretion in rats

Bilateral injection of 6-hydroxydopamine into the medial forebrain bundle (MFB) significantly decreased monoamine concentrations in the hypothalamus. The noradrenaline and serotonin content of the paraventricular nucleus (PVN) was also significantly reduced. These drastic decreases in neurotransmitter concentration did not alter basal secretion of corticosterone. Isoproterenol, a beta-adrenoceptor agonist (1 mg/kg, i.p.), significantly stimulated corticosterone release in saline and MFB lesioned rats. This stimulation did not differ significantly between the two groups. Clonidine, an alpha 2-adrenoceptor agonist, injected either intraperitoneally or intracerebrally just dorsal to the PVN, caused a dose-dependent increase in corticosterone secretion. The stimulation of corticosterone release by clonidine (250 micrograms/kg, i.p.) was antagonised by the selective alpha 2-adrenoceptor antagonist, yohimbine (1 mg/kg, i.p.) and significantly reduced by the MFB lesion. These results suggest that corticosterone secretion is stimulated by activation of alpha 2-adrenoceptors which occur on noradrenergic nerve terminals in the PVN.

Platelet α2-adrenoreceptors in depression: a critical examination

During the past decade, results from radioligand studies comparing platelet α(2)-adrenoreceptors in depressed patients and healthy volunteers have been inconsistent, especially when related to the known functional characteristics of these receptors. Despite the availability of radioligands for α(2)-adrenoreceptors, inherent methodological problems exist which make data from these studies difficult to interpret. The authors review the overall data from radioligand studies using [(3)H] clonidine and [(3)H] yohimbine of platelet α(2)-adrenoreceptors in depressed patients and healthy volunteers. Theoretical and methodological issues are critically examined in the light of recent findings. Finally, alternative strategies for studying α( 2)-adrenoreceptors in clinical populations are considered.

Paroxetine binding in the blood platelets of post-traumatic stress disorder patients

Platelet serotonin (5-HT) uptake, as determined by 3H-paroxetine (PA) binding, was studied in 20 Post-traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD) patients and 20 normal controls. Kd (an inverse measure of affinity of 3H-PA binding to uptake sites) and Bmax (maximum number of 3H-PA binding sites) of 3H-PA binding were significantly decreased in PTSD patients as compared to normal controls. However, there was no difference in Kd or Bmax between PTSD patients with and without a diagnosis of major depression. The Bmax of 3H-PA binding was negatively correlated with state dependent anxiety score whereas Kd was positively correlated with the Mississippi Scale for Combat-Related PTSD score. The role of serotonergic processes in the psychobiology of PTSD is discussed.

The biochemical basis of relapse and drug response in schizophrenia: review and hypothesis

This review of the literature suggests that antipsychotic drug response is determined by dopamine (DA) turnover and norepinephrine (NE) activity prior to treatment. The data suggest that NE modulates the DA system. Drug-free psychotic patients with relatively increased DA and NE activity, including release, are more likely to be treatment responsive, while patients who show evidence of enhanced DA and NE activity during treatment with antipsychotic drugs are likely to relapse soon after neuroleptic withdrawal. Basal release of DA and NE is decreased and associated with residual positive and negative symptoms. Improvement during neuroleptic treatment is associated with decreases in DA and NE phasic or stimulus induced release. The variable response to antipsychotic drugs is most likely to be a result of dysregulated DA and NE release, i.e. under state-dependent control, rather than evidence of a heterogeneous aetiology. Because catecholamines regulate gain, signal-to-noise ratio and gating in the brain, this model allows for environmental factors to interact with biochemical state and drug treatment. The author proposes that impaired homeostasis of NE and DA in schizophrenia causes instability in NE and DA neuronal firing and release, presumably related to mechanisms down-stream from the receptors, such as G proteins. This instability of catecholamine release may explain the observed variability in clinical states and drug response in schizophrenia.

Binding of [3H]-p-aminoclonidine to alpha 2-adrenoceptor states plus a non-adrenergic site on human platelet plasma membranes

Characterization of the binding of [3H]p-aminoclonidine ([3H]PAC) to purified plasma membranes from human platelets has revealed multiple binding sites. [3H]PAC identified site-1 in the picomolar affinity range (site-1 KD estimates ranged from 13 to 94 pM). Site-1 displayed a rank order of competition by various compounds for [3H]PAC, indicative of an alpha 2-adrenoceptor, and was sensitive to 0.1 mM GTP. [3H]PAC also identified a second site with nanomolar affinity (site-2 KD estimates ranged from 0.7 to 1.7 nM). In the presence of 0.1 mM GTP, site-2 was not diminished significantly. Also in contrast to site-1, site-2 displayed low affinity for yohimbine (YOH), (-)-epinephrine and (-)-norepinephrine (NE). Therefore, site-2 could not be an active alpha 2-adrenoceptor; instead it had properties similar to a previously reported imidazoline-preferring binding site. A third site (site-3) bound [3H]PAC with a KD for site-3 of 26.6 +/- 10.0 nM (SD). Site-3 had a rank order of competition by various compounds for 5 nM [3H]yohimbine ([3H]YOH) binding which was indicative of an alpha 2-adrenoceptor. (-)-NE competed for 5 nM [3H]YOH binding at two sites: site-1 Ki = 32 pM, site-3 Ki = 239 nM. Treatment with 0.1 mM GTP completely removed site-1 and transferred the competitive binding of (-)-NE to low affinity (Ki = 437 nM). Thus, site-3 appears to be a free alpha 2-adrenoceptor. Bmax estimates for untreated membranes, derived from simultaneous multi-experiment curve-fitting analyses, were site-1 = 36 +/- 29 fmol/mg plasma membrane protein, site-2 = 95 +/- 34 fmol/mg and site-3 = 154 +/- 35 fmol/mg. We are the first to report a site for [3H]PAC binding on platelets (site-2) with properties uncharacteristic of an adrenoceptor. This observation appears to be due to our use of purified plasma membrane and low ionic strength buffer. These studies relate to reports of increased binding of [3H]PAC to platelets from depressed patients.

Relationship between membrane fluidity and adrenoceptor binding in depression

Membrane fluidity and adrenergic receptor binding were studied in platelets of depressed patients before and during treatment with desmethylimipramine to investigate the relationship between the alpha 2-adrenergic receptor and its membrane environment in depression. Most samples came from a previous study in which we observed higher 3H-para-aminoclonidine (3H-PAC) binding in platelets from depressed patients compared to healthy subjects. Fluidity was measured by steady state diphenylhexatriene (DPH) anisotropy in both purified plasma membranes and in intracellular membrane preparations from platelets. No differences were observed in DPH membrane fluidity, per se, indicating that fluidity changes probably do not underlie either the increased alpha 2-adrenergic receptor binding in depression or the normalization of binding during treatment. However, lower intracellular membrane fluidity was correlated with higher binding to 3H-PAC site-1 in healthy subjects, but not in depressed patients. Thus, during depression there may be a disruption in the normal relationship between the adrenergic receptor and its membrane environment.

Dopamine and norepinephrine activity in schizophrenia. An integrative perspective

The dopamine (DA) hypothesis of schizophrenia stated that increased DA activity is the primary cause of schizophrenia. Recently, even though increased DA activity is in fact involved in psychotic symptoms and antipsychotic drug response, it has become clear that decreased DA activity is present in remitted and chronic states and may relate to deficit symptoms and cortical lesions. In addition, the norepinephrine (NE) system seems to be involved in symptomatology, antipsychotic drug response, course, and outcome in schizophrenia. This review supports the hypothesis that a disturbance in DA and NE activity regulates schizophrenic behavior. A plethora of DA- and NE-related findings in schizophrenic patients are reviewed in relationship to each other according to basic science data and to presently entertained hypotheses, with emphasis on a neural developmental disturbance interacting with a genetic predisposition shaped by environmental factors.

Platelet alpha 2-adrenergic receptor binding sites in major depressive disorder and borderline personality disorder

Platelet alpha 2-adrenergic receptor binding sites were measured in a group of patients with major depressive disorder (MDD) (n = 23) and in normal controls (n = 25). When all depressed subjects were compared to controls, there were no differences in either Kd (affinity of the ligand) or total binding site (number/platelet), although a significant change in the ratio of high to low affinity states was observed in the depressed group. When the depressed patients were subdivided into those with and without a co-occurring borderline personality disorder (BPD), the BPD group had significantly fewer alpha 2 high affinity binding sites, while the group with depression alone had significantly more binding sites (both low and high affinity) than the control group. The results support the concept that assessment of comorbid diagnoses may be essential to biological studies of depression.

Platelet adrenoceptors and prostaglandin responses in depressed patients

Platelet alpha 2-adrenergic receptor binding and prostaglandin responsivity were measured in depressed patients. Depressed patients had significantly higher platelet 3H-dihydroergocryptine (3H-DHE) binding values than controls. Depressed patients also showed significantly reduced prostaglandin E1-stimulated cyclic adenosine 3',5'-monophosphate (cAMP) production and significantly decreased % inhibition of cAMP production by norepinephrine. These results support the suggestion that there may be a dissociation between alpha 2-adrenergic receptor binding and responsivity in depression. There were no significant correlations between platelet adrenergic variables and other indices of noradrenergic function. However, there was a significant correlation between 3H-DHE binding values and basal plasma levels of cortisol.