Loss of tRNA 5-methyluridine methyltransferase and pseudouridine synthetase activities in 5-fluorouracil and 1-(tetrahydro-2-furanyl)-5-fluorouracil (ftorafur)-treated Escherichia coli

Schizosaccharomyces pombe pus1 mutants are temperature sensitive due to decay of tRNAIle(UAU) by the 5'-3' exonuclease Dhp1, primarily targeting the unspliced pre-tRNA

The pseudouridylase Pus1 catalyzes pseudouridine (Ψ) formation at multiple uridine residues in tRNAs, and in some snRNAs and mRNAs. Although Pus1 is highly conserved, and mutations are associated with human disease, little is known about eukaryotic Pus1 biology. Here, we show that Schizosaccharomyces pombe pus1Δ mutants are temperature sensitive due to decay of tRNAIle(UAU), as tRNAIle(UAU) levels are reduced, and its overexpression suppresses the defect. We show that tRNAIle(UAU) is degraded by the 5'-3' exonuclease Dhp1 (ortholog of Saccharomyces cerevisiae Rat1), as each of four spontaneous pus1Δ suppressors had dhp1 mutations and restored tRNAIle(UAU) levels, and two suppressors that also restored tRNAIle(UAU) levels had mutations in tol1 (S. cerevisiae MET22 ortholog), predicted to inhibit Dhp1. We show that Pus1 modifies U27, U34, and U36 of tRNAIle(UAU), raising the question about how these modifications prevent decay. Our results suggest that Dhp1 targets unspliced pre-tRNAIle(UAU), as a pus1Δ strain in which the only copy of tRNAIle(UAU) has no intron [tI(UAU)-iΔ] is temperature resistant and undergoes no detectable decay, and the corresponding pus1Δ tI(UAU)-WT strain accumulates unspliced pre-tRNAIle(UAU) Moreover, the predicted exon-intron structure of pre-tRNAIle(UAU) differs from the canonical bulge-helix-loop structure compatible with tRNA splicing, and a pus1Δ tI(UAU)i-var strain with intron mutations predicted to improve exon-intron structure is temperature resistant and undergoes little decay. These results suggest that decay of tRNAIle(UAU) by Dhp1 in pus1Δ strains occurs at the level of unspliced pre-tRNAIle(UAU), implying a substantial role for one or more of the Ψ residues in stabilizing the pre-tRNA structure for splicing.

Fluoropyrimidines trigger decay of hypomodified tRNA in yeast

Therapeutic fluoropyrimidines 5-fluorouracil (5-FU) and 5-fluorocytosine (5-FC) are in long use for treatment of human cancers and severe invasive fungal infections, respectively. 5-Fluorouridine triphosphate represents a bioactive metabolite of both drugs and is incorporated into target cells' RNA. Here we use the model fungus Saccharomyces cerevisiae to define fluorinated tRNA as a key mediator of 5-FU and 5-FC cytotoxicity when specific tRNA methylations are absent. tRNA methylation deficiency caused by loss of Trm4 and Trm8 was previously shown to trigger an RNA quality control mechanism resulting in partial destabilization of hypomodified tRNAValAAC. We demonstrate that, following incorporation into tRNA, fluoropyrimidines strongly enhance degradation of yeast tRNAValAAC lacking Trm4 and Trm8 dependent methylations. At elevated temperature, such effect occurs already in absence of Trm8 alone. Genetic approaches and quantification of tRNA modification levels reveal that enhanced fluoropyrimidine cytotoxicity results from additional, drug induced uridine modification loss and activation of tRNAValAAC decay involving the exonuclease Xrn1. These results suggest that inhibition of tRNA methylation may be exploited to boost therapeutic efficiency of 5-FU and 5-FC.

A connection between the ribosome and two S. pombe tRNA modification mutants subject to rapid tRNA decay

tRNA modifications are crucial in all organisms to ensure tRNA folding and stability, and accurate translation. In both the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae and the evolutionarily distant yeast Schizosaccharomyces pombe, mutants lacking certain tRNA body modifications (outside the anticodon loop) are temperature sensitive due to rapid tRNA decay (RTD) of a subset of hypomodified tRNAs. Here we show that for each of two S. pombe mutants subject to RTD, mutations in ribosomal protein genes suppress the temperature sensitivity without altering tRNA levels. Prior work showed that S. pombe trm8Δ mutants, lacking 7-methylguanosine, were temperature sensitive due to RTD, and that one class of suppressors had mutations in the general amino acid control (GAAC) pathway, which was activated concomitant with RTD, resulting in further tRNA loss. We now find that another class of S. pombe trm8Δ suppressors have mutations in rpl genes, encoding 60S subunit proteins, and that suppression occurs with minimal restoration of tRNA levels and reduced GAAC activation. Furthermore, trm8Δ suppression extends to other mutations in the large or small ribosomal subunit. We also find that S. pombe tan1Δ mutants, lacking 4-acetylcytidine, are temperature sensitive due to RTD, that one class of suppressors have rpl mutations, associated with minimal restoration of tRNA levels, and that suppression extends to other rpl and rps mutations. However, although S. pombe tan1Δ temperature sensitivity is associated with some GAAC activation, suppression by an rpl mutation only modestly inhibits GAAC activation. We propose a model in which ribosomal protein mutations result in reduced ribosome concentrations, leading to both reduced ribosome collisions and a reduced requirement for tRNA, with these effects having different relative importance in trm8Δ and tan1Δ mutants. This model is consistent with our results in S. cerevisiae trm8Δ trm4Δ mutants, known to undergo RTD, fueling speculation that this model applies across eukaryotes.

A connection between the ribosome and two S. pombe tRNA modification mutants subject to rapid tRNA decay

tRNA modifications are crucial in all organisms to ensure tRNA folding and stability, and accurate translation in the ribosome. In both the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae and the evolutionarily distant yeast Schizosaccharomyces pombe, mutants lacking certain tRNA body modifications (outside the anticodon loop) are temperature sensitive due to rapid tRNA decay (RTD) of a subset of hypomodified tRNAs. Here we show that for each of two S. pombe mutants subject to RTD, mutations in ribosomal protein genes suppress the temperature sensitivity without altering tRNA levels. Prior work showed that S. pombe trm8Δ mutants, lacking 7-methylguanosine, were temperature sensitive due to RTD and that one class of suppressors had mutations in the general amino acid control (GAAC) pathway, which was activated concomitant with RTD, resulting in further tRNA loss. We now find that another class of S. pombe trm8Δ suppressors have mutations in rpl genes, encoding 60S subunit proteins, and that suppression occurs with minimal restoration of tRNA levels and reduced GAAC activation. Furthermore, trm8Δ suppression extends to other mutations in the large or small ribosomal subunit. We also find that S. pombe tan1Δ mutants, lacking 4-acetylcytidine, are temperature sensitive due to RTD, that one class of suppressors have rpl mutations, associated with minimal restoration of tRNA levels, and that suppression extends to other rpl and rps mutations. However, although S. pombe tan1Δ temperature sensitivity is associated with some GAAC activation, suppression by an rpl mutation does not significantly inhibit GAAC activation. These results suggest that ribosomal protein mutations suppress the temperature sensitivity of S. pombe trm8Δ and tan1Δ mutants due to reduced ribosome concentrations, leading to both a reduced requirement for tRNA, and reduced ribosome collisions and GAAC activation. Results with S. cerevisiae trm8Δ trm4Δ mutants are consistent with this model, and fuel speculation that similar results will apply across eukaryotes.

Hypomodified tRNA in evolutionarily distant yeasts can trigger rapid tRNA decay to activate the general amino acid control response, but with different consequences

All tRNAs are extensively modified, and modification deficiency often results in growth defects in the budding yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae and neurological or other disorders in humans. In S. cerevisiae, lack of any of several tRNA body modifications results in rapid tRNA decay (RTD) of certain mature tRNAs by the 5'-3' exonucleases Rat1 and Xrn1. As tRNA quality control decay mechanisms are not extensively studied in other eukaryotes, we studied trm8Δ mutants in the evolutionarily distant fission yeast Schizosaccharomyces pombe, which lack 7-methylguanosine at G46 (m7G46) of their tRNAs. We report here that S. pombe trm8Δ mutants are temperature sensitive primarily due to decay of tRNATyr(GUA) and that spontaneous mutations in the RAT1 ortholog dhp1+ restored temperature resistance and prevented tRNA decay, demonstrating conservation of the RTD pathway. We also report for the first time evidence linking the RTD and the general amino acid control (GAAC) pathways, which we show in both S. pombe and S. cerevisiae. In S. pombe trm8Δ mutants, spontaneous GAAC mutations restored temperature resistance and tRNA levels, and the trm8Δ temperature sensitivity was precisely linked to GAAC activation due to tRNATyr(GUA) decay. Similarly, in the well-studied S. cerevisiae trm8Δ trm4Δ RTD mutant, temperature sensitivity was closely linked to GAAC activation due to tRNAVal(AAC) decay; however, in S. cerevisiae, GAAC mutations increased tRNA loss and exacerbated temperature sensitivity. A similar exacerbated growth defect occurred upon GAAC mutation in S. cerevisiae trm8Δ and other single modification mutants that triggered RTD. Thus, these results demonstrate a conserved GAAC activation coincident with RTD in S. pombe and S. cerevisiae, but an opposite impact of the GAAC response in the two organisms. We speculate that the RTD pathway and its regulation of the GAAC pathway is widely conserved in eukaryotes, extending to other mutants affecting tRNA body modifications.

Unexpected functions of tRNA and tRNA processing enzymes

tRNA and tRNA processing enzymes impact more than protein production. Studies have uncovered roles for tRNA in the regulation of transcription, translation and protein turnover. Induced by stress or as a programmed part of development, nonrandom tRNA fragments can guide mRNA cleavage, inhibit translation and promote morphological changes. Similarly, tRNA processing enzymes, such as RNaseP and tRNA aminoacyl-synthetases participate in tasks affecting more than tRNA function (i.e., mRNA function and cellular signaling). Unraveling the complexities of their functions will increase our understanding of how mutations associated with disease impact these functions and the downstream consequences. This chapter focuses on how tRNA and tRNA processing enzymes influence cellular function and RNA-infrastructure via pathways beyond the decoding activities that tRNA are known for.

Evidence that tRNA modifying enzymes are important in vivo targets for 5-fluorouracil in yeast

We have screened a collection of haploid yeast knockout strains for increased sensitivity to 5-fluorouracil (5-FU). A total of 138 5-FU sensitive strains were found. Mutants affecting rRNA and tRNA maturation were particularly sensitive to 5-FU, with the tRNA methylation mutant trm10 being the most sensitive mutant. This is intriguing since trm10, like many other tRNA modification mutants, lacks a phenotype under normal conditions. However, double mutants for nonessential tRNA modification enzymes are frequently temperature sensitive, due to destabilization of hypomodified tRNAs. We therefore tested if the sensitivity of our mutants to 5-FU is affected by the temperature. We found that the cytotoxic effect of 5-FU is strongly enhanced at 38 degrees C for tRNA modification mutants. Furthermore, tRNA modification mutants show similar synthetic interactions for temperature sensitivity and sensitivity to 5-FU. A model is proposed for how 5-FU kills these mutants by reducing the number of tRNA modifications, thus destabilizing tRNA. Finally, we found that also wild-type cells are temperature sensitive at higher concentrations of 5-FU. This suggests that tRNA destabilization contributes to 5-FU cytotoxicity in wild-type cells and provides a possible explanation why hyperthermia can enhance the effect of 5-FU in cancer therapy.

Transglycosylation: a mechanism for RNA modification (and editing?)

The vast majority of the ca. 100 chemically distinct modified nucleosides in RNA appear to arise via the chemical transformation of a genetically encoded nucleoside. Two notable exceptions are queuosine and pseudouridine, which are incorporated into tRNA via transglycosylation. Transglycosylation is an extremely efficient process for incorporating highly modified bases such as queuine into RNA. Transglycosylation is also a requisite process for "isomerizing" an N-nucleoside into a C-nucleoside as is the case for pseudouridine formation. Finally, transglycosylation is an attractive possibility for certain RNA editing events (e.g., pyrimidine to purine conversions) that cannot occur via the known, more straightforward enzymatic reactions (e.g., deaminations). This review discusses what is known about the mechanisms of transglycosylation for the queuine and pseudouridine RNA modifications and will speculate about a potential role for transglycosylation in certain RNA editing events.

Ribonucleoprotein particle assembly and modification of U2 small nuclear RNA containing 5-fluorouridine

An in vitro assembly/modification system was used to study the effect of 5-fluorouridine (5-FU) incorporation on the biosynthesis of the U2 small nuclear ribonucleoprotein particle (U2 snRNP). Labeled U2 RNAs were transcribed in vitro with 5-fluoro-UTP either partially supplementing or completely replacing UTP during synthesis. The resulting U2 RNAs have levels of 5-fluorouridine that range from 0 to 100% of the uridine content. When incubated in reactions containing extracts from HeLa cells, these 5-FU U2 RNAs are assembled into RNPs that are recognized by anti-Sm monoclonal antibody even when there is a complete replacement of uridine with 5-FU. However, when the in vitro assembled U2 snRNPs are subjected to buoyant density gradient centrifugation, the particles that contain 100% 5-FU are not resistant to salt dissociation. When the in vitro assembled U2 snRNPs were analyzed by velocity sedimentation gradient centrifugation, 5-FU incorporation correlated with a shift in the sedimentation rate of the particles. With 100% 5-FU incorporation, the peak of radioactivity shifted to approximately 15 S (control U2 RNA was at approximately 12 S). This peak from 5-FU U2 snRNPs was not resistant to dissociation on cesium sulfate gradients. The amount of pseudouridine (psi) found in the RNA from snRNP assembled in vitro on control and 5-FU-containing U2 RNAs was determined, and even at very low levels of 5-FU incorporation (5% replacement), the formation of psi was severely inhibited (36% of control). At higher levels of 5-FU incorporation, there was essentially no psi formed.

Multiple pseudouridine synthase activities for small nuclear RNAs

The formation of pseudouridine (psi) in human U1, U2 and U5 small nuclear RNAs (snRNAs) was investigated using HeLa cell extracts. Unmodified snRNAs were synthesized in vitro and the extent of psi formation was determined after incubation in cell extracts. The formation of psi on labelled substrates was monitored in the presence of 5-fluorouracil (5-FU)-containing snRNAs as inhibitors of psi formation. The conversion of uridine to psi was inhibited only when the cognate 5-FU-containing inhibitor snRNA was included in the reaction. For example, 5-FU-containing U1 RNA inhibited psi formation in unmodified U1 RNA, but not in (unmodified) U2 or U5 RNAs. The results suggest that there are at least three activities that form psi in these snRNAs. The 5-FU-containing RNAs were stable during incubation in the cell extracts. A 12-fold molar excess of unlabelled U1 RNA did not inhibit psi formation on a labelled U1 RNA substrate, whereas a 3-fold molar excess of 5-FU-containing U1 RNA nearly abolished psi formation on the U1 substrate. The fact that 5-FU-containing snRNAs are potent inhibitors of psi formation in these pre-mRNA splicing cofactors raises the possibility that this is related to the cytotoxicity of fluoropyrimidines in cancer chemotherapy.

Interactions of transfer RNA pseudouridine synthases with RNAs substituted with fluorouracil

We have previously purified and characterized two different S. cerevisiae enzymes that produce pseudouridine specifically in nucleotide positions 13 and 55, respectively, in their tRNA substrates. The interactions of these enzymes with fluorinated tRNAs have now been studied. Such RNAs were produced by in vitro transcription using as templates synthetic genes that encode variants of a yeast glycine tRNA. RNAs substituted with fluorouracil were found to markedly inhibit pseudouridine synthase activity and the inhibitory effect of a tRNA was to a large extent dependent on the presence of fluorouracil in the nucleotide position where normally pseudouridylation occurs. Pseudouridine synthases were shown to form highly stable, non-covalent complexes with fluorinated tRNAs and we demonstrate that this interaction may be used to further characterize and purify these enzymes. The use of 5-fluorouracil as a cancer therapeutic agent is discussed in relation to our results.

Specific incorporation of 5-fluorocytidine into Escherichia coli RNA

RNAs isolated from Escherichia coli B grown in the presence of 5-fluorouracil have high levels of the analog replacing uridine and uridine-derived modified nucleosides. Cytidine has also been shown to be replaced in these RNAs by 5-fluorocytidine, a metabolic product of 5-fluorouracil, but to a considerably lesser extent. When 5-fluorocytidine is added to cultured of E. coli B little 5-fluorocytidine (0.20 mol%) is incorporated into cellular RNAs because of the active cytosine/cytidine deaminase activities. Addition of the cytidine deaminase inhibitor tetrahydrouridine (70 micrograms/ml) increases 5-fluorocytidine incorporation to about 3 mol% in tRNAs, but does not eliminate 5-fluorouridine incorporation. E. coli mutants lacking cytosine/cytidine deaminase activities are able to more than double the extent of 5-fluorocytidine incorporation into their transfer and ribosomal RNAs, replacing cytidine with no detectable 5-fluorouridine incorporation. Levels of 5-methyluridine, pseudouridine and dihydrouridine in tRNAs are not affected. These fluorocytidine-containing tRNAs show amino acid-accepting activities similar to control tRNAs. Fluorocytidine was found to be quite susceptible to deamination under alkaline conditions. Its conversion to primarily 5-fluorouridine follows pseudo-first-order reaction kinetics with a half-life of 10 h in 0.3 M KOH at 37 degrees C. This instability in alkali probably explains why 5-fluorocytidine was not found earlier in RNAs isolated from cells treated with 5-fluorouridine, since most early RNA hydrolyses were carried out in alkali. It may also explain the mild mutagenic properties observed in some systems following 5-fluorouridine treatment. Initial 19F-NMR measurements in fluorocytidine-containing tRNAs indicate that this modified tRNA may be useful in future structural studies of tRNAs and in probing tRNA-protein complexes.