Stage III Hodgkin's disease--long-term results following chemotherapy, radiotherapy and combined modality therapy

Hodgkin's disease

This synthesis of the literature on radiotherapy for Hodgkin's Disease is based on 104 scientific articles, including 2 meta-analyses, 22 randomized studies, 5 prospective studies, and 58 retrospective studies. These studies involve 38,362 patients. The literature review clearly shows that radiotherapy is a cornerstone of treatment for localized Hodgkin's disease. At early stages, long-term survival is 80% to 90% when treatment is tailored to known prognostic factors. There is a tendency toward increased use of chemotherapy as additional treatment, however no evidence shows that it increases survival. To further improve survival following radiotherapy an attempt is being made to reduce long-term toxicity by better defining the patient groups who require lower radiation volumes, and delivering a dose that is as low as possible to avoid secondary solid tumors or delayed cardiopulmonary or gastrointestinal effects, while not jeopardizing therapeutic results. In advanced disease, radiotherapy may be needed as a complement to chemotherapy to effectively control bulky disease. For recurrent disease, radiotherapy may be considered as relapse treatment or additional therapy in conjunction with high-dose chemotherapy.

Haematological toxicity of radiotherapy following high-dose chemotherapy and autologous bone marrow transplantation in patients with recurrent Hodgkin's disease

17 patients with recurrent Hodgkin's disease received 21 courses of radiotherapy (RT) 1-23 months after high-dose chemotherapy and autologous bone marrow transplantation. WHO grade III-IV haematological toxicity, of median duration 38 days (range 4-236), was observed following 10 courses of radiotherapy in 9 patients. This haematological morbidity could be predicted with an 80.0% sensitivity when the pre-RT white cell count was < 5 x 10(9)/l or the platelet count < 100 x 10(9)/l. It occurred in 9/11 patients with initial stage III-IV disease, including all 6 given extended radiotherapy fields, but in no patients with initial stage II disease (chi 2 = 9.35, P < 0.005). Age, histology, the presence of B symptoms, performance status, previous radiotherapy or chemotherapy, the interval between autologous bone marrow transplantation and radiotherapy, the high-dose regimen used, and the radiotherapy dose or field size, did not appear to affect haematological toxicity. The median survival was 18 months from the date of starting radiotherapy. 7 patients remain alive and progression-free 8-51 months (median 21 months) after radiotherapy. Radiotherapy may contribute to durable remissions in patients with relapsed or residual Hodgkin's disease after autologous bone marrow transplantation, but significant haematological toxicity may be expected in those with mild pancytopaenia prior to radiotherapy, particularly with initial stage III or IV disease.

The role of radiation therapy in Hodgkin disease: experience and controversy. The 54th annual Janeway Lecture: 1989

BACKGROUND

Beginning in 1970, a series of patients with Hodgkin disease were treated at the University of Minnesota, after staging laparotomy, with radiation therapy (RT) for Stage I, II, and IIIA Hodgkin disease. This report is an analysis of the results of the treatment and of treatment modifications.

METHODS

From 1970 to 1974, all patients were treated with standard RT. In 1975, an analysis of these patients indicated that patients with large mediastinal mass (LMM) and patients with Stage IIIA spleen-positive (IIIAS+) disease had a higher recurrence rates than patients without these factors. Subsequently, a schema of radical radiation therapy (RRT) was devised, which included low-dose lung RT for patients with LMM and low-dose liver RT for patients with IIIAS+ disease.

RESULTS

Analysis of the results of the two treatments indicates that the use of low-dose lung RT in patients with LMM and low-dose liver RT in patients with IIIAS+ Hodgkin disease produced survival and recurrence-free survival results equivalent to those achieved by use of combined modality treatment (CMT) or chemotherapy (CT) alone.

CONCLUSIONS

The use of RT with whole lung and liver irradiation for patients with LMM and IIIAS+ Hodgkin disease, respectively, produces results that are equivalent to those of CMT or CT alone with the advantage of a decreased incidence of second malignant neoplasms. In addition, patients who do not respond to initial RT have a greater chance of being saved with chemotherapy than do patients initially treated with CMT of being saved with RT. The authors suggest that radical RT is the treatment of choice for patients with LMM and/or IIIAS+ Hodgkin disease.

Randomized trial of chemotherapy versus chemotherapy plus radiotherapy for stage III-IV A & B Hodgkin's disease

A total of 151 patients with previously untreated Hodgkin's disease, clinical stages III-IV A & B, were randomized to receive CVPP for 6 cycles, or CVPP plus RT 3000 cGy to previously involved areas between the 3rd and 4th cycles. CVPP consists of cyclophosphamide 600 mg/m2/i.v., vinblastine 6 mg/m2/i.v. on day 1, procarbazine 100 mg/m2/p.o. and prednisone 40 mg/m2/p.o. on days 1 to 14. Both groups displayed similar clinical characteristics at diagnosis. Sixty-six were treated with CVPP + RT (52 St III and 14 St IV) and 85 with CVPP alone (68 St III and 17 St IV). Complete remission was obtained in 57 (86%) of 66 patients who received CVPP plus RT, and in 62 (73%) of 85 patients treated with CVPP. Five and sixteen patients, respectively, achieved partial responses, while 2 in each group died during treatment. At 7 years, duration of complete remission and failure-free survival were: 51% and 45% for those treated with CVPP plus RT, and 23% and 21% with CVPP alone (p = 0.0150 and P = 0.0016, respectively). Overall survival at 7 years was 71% and 58%, respectively (p = 0.1488). A dose analysis performed in 84 pts showed that 91% and 88% received full protocol doses of CPM and PCZ, respectively, in the CVPP + RT group, and 95% and 94% for CVPP. The WBC nadir was 3.5 and 3.7 x mm3, respectively. Of 25 pts on CVPP + RT who relapsed, 9 are now disease-free, 5 are alive with disease and 11 have died, and with CVPP, of 37 relapsing pts, 18 are disease-free, 5 are alive with disease and 14 are dead.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Salvage radiotherapy in recurrent Hodgkin's disease

Forty-four patients with Hodgkin's disease (HD) which relapsed after chemotherapy were treated with salvage radiotherapy (S-RT) with curative intent. Patients were aged 7 to 80 years (median 32 years) at the time of S-RT and the median follow-up from S-RT was 5 years (1-15). Nine patients had recurrent HD following first-line chemotherapy and thirty five patients had refractory HD. Salvage therapy consisted of radiotherapy alone in 25 and combined chemotherapy and radiotherapy in 19 patients. The overall CR rate of salvage therapy was 66%. The overall median survival of 44 patients was 4.6 years from S-RT with 46% 5 year and 40% 10 year survivals. Age (greater than 40 years) and progression free interval (less than or equal to 1 year) were adverse independent prognostic factors for survival on multivariate analysis. The 5 and 10 year progression free survivals were 38% and 23% respectively. Adverse independent prognostic factors for progression-free survival were extranodal site of recurrence and short progression free interval (less than or equal to 1 year). We conclude that radiotherapy with or without chemotherapy has a role in the salvage of patients failing chemotherapy, particularly in those with nodal disease and progression-free interval greater than 1 year.

Curative radiotherapy for laparotomy-staged IA, IIA, IIIA Hodgkin's disease: an evaluation of the gains achieved with radical radiotherapy

Between 1970 and 1983, 179 patients with pathologically staged IA, IIA, and IIIA Hodgkin's disease were treated with curative radiotherapy. From 1970 to 1974, patients were treated with standard extended or total nodal field irradiation (Treatment Group 1). Since 1975, because of the high prevalence of recurrences in patients with large mediastinal mass and/or hilar disease and/or splenic involvement (LMM &/or H+ &/or S+), treatment was modified to include low-dose lung irradiation within the mantle field for those patients with LMM &/or H+ and low-dose liver irradiation within the infradiaphragmatic field for patients with S+ (radical XRT). Patients who did not have those characteristics were treated with standard radiotherapy (standard XRT). A total of 122 patients were treated from 1975 to 1983 (Treatment Group 2), of whom 61 received radical XRT and 61 received standard XRT. An analysis was done to evaluate whether the progressive-improvement in outcome since 1970 at the University of Minnesota Hospital resulted from the contribution of modified treatment or from progressive improvement in treatment overall. There was a statistical improvement in recurrence-free survival (RFS) in Treatment Group 2 (Tr Gr 2) compared to Treatment Group 1 (Tr Gr 1), with 10-year RFS of 80% versus 57% (p less than 0.001 for time to event). The improvement in RFS was attributed to treatment modification consisting of radical XRT for those patients with LMM &/or S+. There was no change in RFS for those patients without LMM &/or H+ &/or S+ who were treated in Tr Gr 1 and Tr Gr 2, with 10-year RFS of 78% versus 86% (p = 0.29), respectively. However, treatment results for patients with LMM &/or H+ &/or S+ improved considerably in the radical XRT group. Comparing standard versus radical XRT, 10-year RFS was 36% versus 78% (p = 0.001), and 10-year OS was 72% versus 92% (p = 0.034). Patterns of relapse also changed for patients with LMM &/or H+ &/or S+ who were treated with radical XRT. Rather than showing a high frequency of intrathoracic recurrence as was seen in those patients with LMM &/or H+ &/or S+ after standard XRT, the relapse pattern was similar to patients without LMM &/or H+ &/or S+. Salvage treatment was well tolerated for patients who failed after radical XRT. Delayed, life-threatening effects, such as pulmonary and cardiovascular complications and SMN, were equivalent for patients in Tr Gr 1 versus 2, and for those who received standard and radical XRT.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)

The management of early Hodgkin's disease

Hodgkin's disease has provided a focus of academic attention for haematologists, radiotherapists and oncologists over the last 20 years but nevertheless there is considerable controversy over the management especially of early presentations. Options include performing a staging laparotomy and splenectomy with radiotherapy for pathological stage I and II disease, clinical staging with combined chemotherapy and radiotherapy, clinical staging with either extensive radiotherapy or with limited radiotherapy and close surveillance, or finally, clinical staging and treatment with chemotherapy alone. An appropriate management decision depends upon an assessment of the disease and also on the impact of treatment side-effects on the individual patient.