Radiation studies on multicellular tumour spheroids derived from human neuroblastoma: absence of sparing effect of dose fractionation

[131I]MIBG and topotecan: a rationale for combination therapy for neuroblastoma

MIBG is selectively concentrated in neuroblastoma cells, and radioiodinated MIBG has been used with some success for targeted radiotherapy. However, long-term cure remains elusive, and the topoisomerase I inhibitor topotecan may improve upon existing [131I]MIBG therapy. While synergistic killing by combinations of ionising radiation and topoisomerase I inhibitors has been reported, there is no consensus on optimal scheduling. Furthermore, there has been no attempt to demonstrate radio-potentiation by topoisomerase I inhibitors and targeted radiotherapy. We are investigating various scheduled combinations of topotecan and [131I]MIBG on neuroblastoma cells, and preliminary data suggests that topotecan induces increased accumulation of [131I]MIBG in vitro.

Spheroids in radiobiology and photodynamic therapy

Spheroids are tridimensional aggregates of tumor cells coming from one or several cell clones. This model, which mimics the micro-tumors structure and some of their properties, shows oxygen, pH and nutrient gradients inducing a necrotic area in the center of the spheroid. Analysis of spheroids, cultured under static or stirred conditions, can be performed on whole spheroids or dissociated spheroids. The spheroids sensitivity to ionizing radiation and photodynamic therapy can be altered by oxygen status, damage repair, intercellular commmunications and apoptosis induction, as in experimental tumor models. In radiobiology, the similarity of radiation response between spheroids and tumor xenograft bearing mice makes the spheroids to be a good alternative model to in vivo irradiation studies. In photodynamic therapy, spheroids lead to a better understanding of the own tumor response without interactions with vascular system. Finally, despite the quality of spheroid model, only the use of new technology for analysis of spheroid populations will help to increase their experimental use, particularly in preclinical oncology.

Single-dose and fractionated irradiation of four human lung cancer cell lines in vitro

Four established human lung cancer cell lines were exposed to single-dose irradiation. The survival curves of 2 small cell lung carcinomas (SCLC) were characterized by a limited capacity for repair with small and moderate shoulders with extrapolation numbers (n) of 1.05 and 1.60 respectively. Two non-small cell lung carcinoma (NSCLC) cell lines, one squamous cell (SQCLC) and one large cell (LCLC) had large shoulders with n-values of 73 and 15 respectively. The radiosensitivity when measured as D0 did not, however, differ as much from cell line to cell line, with values from 1.22 to 1.65. The surviving fraction after 2 Gy (SF2) was 0.24 and 0.42 respectively in the SCLC cell lines and 0.90 and 0.88 respectively in the NSCLC cell lines. Fractionated irradiation delivered according to 3 different schedules was also investigated. All the schedules delivered a total dose of 10 Gy in 5 days and were applied in 1, 2, and 5 Gy dose fractions respectively. Survival followed the pattern found after single-dose irradiation; it was lowest in the SCLC cell line with the lowest SF and highest in the two NSCLC cell lines. In the SCLC cell lines all schedules were approximately equally efficient. In the LCLC and in the SQCLC cell lines, the 5 Gy schedule killed more cells than the 1 and 2 Gy schedules. The results indicate that the size of the shoulder of the survival curve is essential when choosing the most tumoricidal fractionation schedule.

Radiosensitivity of different human tumor cells lines grown as multicellular spheroids determined from growth curves and survival data

Five human tumor cell lines were grown as multicellular tumor spheroids (MTS) to determine whether multicellular tumor spheroids derived from different types of tumors would show tumor-type dependent differences in response to single-dose irradiation, and whether these differences paralleled clinical behavior. Multicellular tumor spheroids of two neuroblastoma, one lung adenocarcinoma, one melanoma, and a squamous cell carcinoma of the oral tongue, were studied in terms of growth delay, calculated cell survival, and spheroid control dose50 (SCD50). Growth delay and cell survival analysis for the tumor cell lines showed sensitivities that correlated well with clinical behavior of the tumor types of origin. Similar to other studies on melanoma multicellular tumor spheroids our spheroid control dose50 results for the melanoma cell line deviated from the general pattern of sensitivity. This might be due to the location of surviving cells, which prohibits proliferation of surviving cells and hence growth of melanoma multicellular tumor spheroids. This study demonstrates that radiosensitivity of human tumor cell lines can be evaluated in terms of growth delay, calculated cell survival, and spheroid control dose50 when grown as multicellular tumor spheroids. The sensitivity established from these evaluations parallels clinical behavior, thus offering a unique tool for the in vitro analysis of human tumor radiosensitivity.

Repair of sublethal damage in two human tumor cell lines grown as multicellular spheroids

Multicellular tumor spheroids (MTS) provide a suitable in vitro model to study radiation sensitivity of tumor cells. Two cell lines of human origin, obtained from a neuroblastoma (NB-100) and a squamous cell carcinoma (HN-1), were exposed to graded doses (4-9 Gy) of radiation with 18 MV photons. Radiation was applied either as a single or as a split dose with an interval of 6 hr to determine the extent of sublethal damage repair. Treated spheroids regrew at approximately the same growth rate as control multicellular tumor spheroids, preceded by a static or regression phase. Radiation response was quantified in terms of regrowth delay, expressed as the time needed for treated spheroids to obtain an 8-fold increase of the initial volume at the time of irradiation. Data obtained from regrowth delay analysis were used to calculate the extent of sublethal damage repair, showing for the squamous cell carcinoma line a fractionally higher capacity to repair sublethal damage than the neuroblastoma line. Repair increased with larger dose fractions in both cell lines. Our results show that multicellular tumor spheroids from the two cell lines used in this study are best applicable at relatively high total radiation doses. This makes multicellular tumor spheroids a suitable model for the in vitro evaluation of clinical treatment rationales such as hyperfractionation.

Etoposide (VP-16) uptake by tumour spheroids and activity in the presence of Brij 30, formulation additives and sodium salicylate

A number of additives typically used in the formulation of poorly soluble drugs can be shown to influence drug transport across various physiological barriers. Multicellular spheroids from a human neuroblastoma cell line (NB1-G) were used to investigate the effect of etoposide in solution, as its commercial formulation, Vepesid, in the presence of a nonionic surfactant, Brij 30, and a hydrotropic agent, sodium salicylate. Enhanced growth delay, apparently related to increased drug uptake, was observed both with the Vepesid and the sodium salicylate formulations. Brij 30, however, showed no enhancement of growth delay or drug uptake at a concentration at which it was not in itself cytotoxic. Significant morphological changes in the spheroid were observed at higher concentrations of additives, particularly with Brij 30, emphasizing the fact that many formulation additives cannot be used with impunity in tissue culture systems. The enhanced uptake of drug into tumour cells and potential synergy between additive and drug is worthy of further investigation.

A tumour spheroid model for antibody-targeted therapy of micrometastases

Human neuroblastoma cells grown as tumour spheroids were briefly incubated with a conjugate of 131I and an anti-human neuroectodermal monoclonal antibody UJ13A. Unbound 131I was removed by washing and the spheroids observed in culture conditions for up to 4 weeks. Spheroid response to irradiation was evaluated as time to reach 10x treatment volume and proportion of spheroids sterilised. Spheroid growth was found to be affected by both the activity of 131I-UJ13A and the duration of the incubation. Na[131I], 131I-HSA, 131I labelled non-specific antibody and unlabelled antibody were found to be relatively ineffective compared to 131I-UJ13A. The tumour spheroid model has applications in the evaluation of antibodies or antibody fragments and different radionuclides which may be considered for radioimmunotherapy of micrometastases.

The effect on human neuroblastoma spheroids of fractionated radiation regimes calculated to be equivalent for damage to late responding normal tissues

Multicellular tumour spheroids (MTS) are a useful in vitro model of human cancer. An experiment was designed to assess the likely therapeutic advantage of hyperfractionation--a proposed strategy in radiotherapy. A cell line (NB1-G) derived from human neuroblastoma was grown as MTS. This MTS line is radiosensitive with low capacity for repair of sublethal radiation damage. These properties make NB1-G a suitable line to test the theoretical advantage of hyperfractionation. MTS were irradiated using alternative fractionated regimens, with fraction sizes varying from 0.5 to 4 Gy. In each experiment, the total dose was chosen to make the regimens theoretically isoeffective for damage to late-responding normal tissues (calculated using the linear-quadratic mathematical model with alpha/beta = 3 Gy). The radiation responses of MTS were evaluated using the end-points of regrowth delay and "proportion cured". Regimens using smaller doses per fraction were found to be markedly more effective in causing damage to neuroblastoma MTS, as assessed by either end-point. These experimental findings support the proposal that hyperfractionation should be a therapeutically advantageous strategy in the treatment of tumours whose radiobiological properties are similar to those of the MTS neuroblastoma line NB1-G.