Embryonic heart rate in dated human embryos

When Does the Human Embryonic Heart Start Beating? A Review of Contemporary and Historical Sources of Knowledge about the Onset of Blood Circulation in Man

The onset of embryonic heart beating may be regarded as the defining feature for the beginning of personal human life. Clarifying the timing of the first human heartbeat, therefore, has religious, philosophical, ethical, and medicolegal implications. This article reviews the historical and contemporary sources of knowledge on the beginning of human heart activity. Special attention is given to the problem of the determination of the true age of human embryos and to the problem of visualization of the human embryonic heart activity. It is shown that historical and current textbook statements about the onset of blood circulation in man do not derive from observations on living human embryos but derive from the extrapolation of observations on animal embryos to the human species. This fact does not preclude the existence of documented observations on human embryonic heart activity: Modern diagnostic (ultrasound) and therapeutic (IVF) procedures facilitate the visualization of early embryonic heart activity in precisely dated pregnancies. Such studies showed that the human heart started its pumping action during the fourth post-fertilization week. A small number of direct observations on the heart activity of aborted human embryos were reported since the 19th century, but did not receive much recognition by embryologists.

A pictorial account of the human embryonic heart between 3.5 and 8 weeks of development

Heart development is topographically complex and requires visualization to understand its progression. No comprehensive 3-dimensional primer of human cardiac development is currently available. We prepared detailed reconstructions of 12 hearts between 3.5 and 8 weeks post fertilization, using Amira® 3D-reconstruction and Cinema4D®-remodeling software. The models were visualized as calibrated interactive 3D-PDFs. We describe the developmental appearance and subsequent remodeling of 70 different structures incrementally, using sequential segmental analysis. Pictorial timelines of structures highlight age-dependent events, while graphs visualize growth and spiraling of the wall of the heart tube. The basic cardiac layout is established between 3.5 and 4.5 weeks. Septation at the venous pole is completed at 6 weeks. Between 5.5 and 6.5 weeks, as the outflow tract becomes incorporated in the ventricles, the spiraling course of its subaortic and subpulmonary channels is transferred to the intrapericardial arterial trunks. The remodeling of the interventricular foramen is complete at 7 weeks.

Menstrual irregularity as a biological limit to early pregnancy awareness

US state legislatures have proposed laws to prohibit abortion once the earliest embryonic electrical activity is detectable (fetal “heartbeat”). On average, this occurs roughly 6 wk after the last menstrual period. To be eligible for abortion, people must recognize pregnancy very early in gestation. The earliest symptom of pregnancy is a missed period, and irregular menstrual cycles—which occur frequently—can delay pregnancy detection past the point of fetal cardiac activity. In our analysis of 1.6 million prospectively recorded menstrual cycles, cycle irregularity was more common among young women, Hispanic women, and women with common health conditions, such as diabetes and polycystic ovary syndrome. These groups face physiological limitations in detecting pregnancy before fetal cardiac activity. Restriction of abortion this early in gestation differentially affects specific population subgroups, for reasons outside of individual control.

Fetal Tachycardia Is an Independent Risk Factor for Chromosomal Anomalies in First-Trimester Genetic Screening

OBJECTIVES

The association of an abnormal fetal heart rate (FHR) and chromosomal anomalies in the first trimester of pregnancy remains unclear, probably because of the lack of control for known confounding factors. This study was designed to determine whether an increased FHR is an independent risk factor for chromosomal anomalies between 11 and 14 weeks' gestation.

METHODS

This cohort study included women who underwent first-trimester genetic screening between 2011 and 2014 at a single institution. A multivariable logistic regression analysis was performed to determine whether an FHR of 170 beats per minute (bpm) or higher, derived from a receiver operating characteristic curve, is an independent risk factor for all chromosomal anomalies while controlling for known confounding factors. P < .05 was considered significant.

RESULTS

An FHR of 170 bpm or higher was observed in 7% (228 of 3254), and chromosomal anomalies were present in 1.0% (31 of 3254) of the population. A higher proportion of fetuses with an FHR of 170 bpm or higher had chromosomal anomalies compared to those with an FHR lower than 170 bpm. An FHR of 170 bpm or higher was an independent risk factor for chromosomal anomalies after controlling for known confounding factors. Of note, in the group of fetuses with a nuchal translucency above the 95th percentile, the frequency of chromosomal anomalies was significantly higher among fetuses with an FHR of 170 bpm or higher compared to those with an FHR lower than 170 bpm.

CONCLUSIONS

Fetal tachycardia is a risk factor for chromosomal anomalies during first-trimester genetic screening, independent of increased nuchal translucency, nuchal septations, and maternal age.

Kinking and Torsion Can Significantly Improve the Efficiency of Valveless Pumping in Periodically Compressed Tubular Conduits. Implications for Understanding of the Form-Function Relationship of Embryonic Heart Tubes

Valveless pumping phenomena (peristalsis, Liebau-effect) can generate unidirectional fluid flow in periodically compressed tubular conduits. Early embryonic hearts are tubular conduits acting as valveless pumps. It is unclear whether such hearts work as peristaltic or Liebau-effect pumps. During the initial phase of its pumping activity, the originally straight embryonic heart is subjected to deforming forces that produce bending, twisting, kinking, and coiling. This deformation process is called cardiac looping. Its function is traditionally seen as generating a configuration needed for establishment of correct alignments of pulmonary and systemic flow pathways in the mature heart of lung-breathing vertebrates. This idea conflicts with the fact that cardiac looping occurs in all vertebrates, including gill-breathing fishes. We speculate that looping morphogenesis may improve the efficiency of valveless pumping. To test the physical plausibility of this hypothesis, we analyzed the pumping performance of a Liebau-effect pump in straight and looped (kinked) configurations. Compared to the straight configuration, the looped configuration significantly improved the pumping performance of our pump. This shows that looping can improve the efficiency of valveless pumping driven by the Liebau-effect. Further studies are needed to clarify whether this finding may have implications for understanding of the form-function relationship of embryonic hearts.

On the form problem of embryonic heart loops, its geometrical solutions, and a new biophysical concept of cardiac looping

BACKGROUND

Cardiac looping is an essential process in the morphogenesis of embryonic hearts. Unfortunately, relatively little is known about the form and biophysics of embryonic heart loops. Thompson regarded the form of an object as "a 'diagram of forces' … from it we can … deduce the forces that are acting or have acted upon it." Therefore, the present study was conducted to uncover the best geometrical solution of the form problem of embryonic heart loops. This approach may help to identify the biophysics of cardiac looping.

RESULTS

Analysis of the tendrils of climbing plants disclosed striking resemblance between the configurations of embryonic heart loops and a form motif named helical perversion. Helical perversion occurs in helically wound objects where they connect two helical segments of opposite handedness (two-handed helix). Helical perversion evolves in living and non-living filamentary objects such as the tendrils of climbing plants and helical telephone cords.

CONCLUSIONS

Helical perversion may be the best geometrical solution of the form problem of embryonic heart loops. The dynamics and mechanics of the emergence of helical perversions are relatively well known. The behavior of looping embryonic hearts may be interpreted in light of this knowledge.

First trimester volumetric measurements: relation with hormone levels and fetal heart rate

PURPOSE

This study aimed to examine two-dimensional ultrasound (2D US) volumetric measurements of 1st trimester structures and their relationship with β-hCG, progesterone, and fetal heart rate (FHR) in 6-10 weeks healthy pregnant women.

METHODS

Using conventional 2D transvaginal ultrasound imaging, the crown rump length (CRL), yolk sac (YS) and gestational sac (GS) were measured in 80 women. Volumetric measurements were done in 32 cases that were selected among 80 women, using a simplified formula for the volume of a prolate ellipsoid: V = 0.523 × length × height × width. The β-hCG and progesterone levels were recorded. The heart rate was determined from M-mode tracings using electronic calipers.

RESULTS

Moderately positive correlation was found between FHR versus CRL, embryo volume and GS volume. FHR increased linearly with CRL value, till CRL became 15 mm, after which it formed a plateau. β-hCG increased linearly till CRL was 15 mm, and then it formed a plateau. Progesterone level was stable till CRL became 20 mm, embryo volume 2 cm(3), after which it increased linearly.

CONCLUSION

Various ranges of relations are observed between FHR, obstetric, and hormonal measurements. The relationship between these parameters might be used for determination of abnormal growth and adverse outcomes in early pregnancy.

Integration of an optical coherence tomography (OCT) system into an examination incubator to facilitate in vivo imaging of cardiovascular development in higher vertebrate embryos under stable physiological conditions

High-resolution in vivo imaging of higher vertebrate embryos over short or long time periods under constant physiological conditions is a technically challenging task for researchers working on cardiovascular development. In chick embryos, for example, various studies have shown that without appropriate maintenance of temperature, as one of the main environmental factors, the embryonic heart rate drops rapidly and often results in an increase in regurgitant flow. Hemodynamic parameters are critical stimuli for cardiovascular development that, for a correct evaluation of their developmental significance, should be documented under physiological conditions. However, previous studies were mostly carried out outside of an incubator or under suboptimal environmental conditions. Here we present, to the best of our knowledge, the first detailed description of an optical coherence tomography (OCT) system integrated into an examination incubator to facilitate real-time in vivo imaging of cardiovascular development under physiological environmental conditions. We demonstrate the suitability of this OCT examination incubator unit for use in cardiovascular development studies by examples of proof of principle experiments. We, furthermore, point out the need for use of examination incubators for physiological OCT examinations by documenting the effects of room climate (22°C) on the performance of the cardiovascular system of chick embryos (HH-stages 16/17). Upon exposure to room climate, chick embryos showed a fast drop in the heart rate and striking changes in the cardiac contraction behaviour and the blood flow through the vitelline circulation. We have documented these changes for the first time by M-mode OCT and Doppler M-mode OCT.

Ultrasonographic prediction of early miscarriage

BACKGROUND

The aim of this retrospective study was to assess the value of maternal history and ultrasound scan findings at 6-10 weeks for predicting early miscarriage.

METHODS

Embryonic crown-rump length (CRL), heart rate (HR), gestational sac diameter (GSD) and yolk sac diameter (YSD) were compared in two groups of women with singleton pregnancies attending an early pregnancy unit. In the first group the initial scan demonstrated a live embryo but in a subsequent visit the scan showed a dead embryo, complete or incomplete miscarriage. In the second group with a live embryo there was subsequent live birth of a normal neonate.

RESULTS

There were 729 pregnancies with miscarriage and 4698 with normal outcome. Logistic regression analysis demonstrated that in the prediction of miscarriage the risk was higher in women of African racial origin [odds ratio (OR) 1.62], cigarette smokers (OR 1.91) and those with vaginal bleeding (OR 2.03) and increased with maternal age (OR 1.05) and YSD (OR 1.88) and was inversely related to CRL (OR 0.79), HR (OR 0.96) and GSD (OR 0.84). At false-positive rate of 30%, the detection rate of miscarriage in screening by vaginal bleeding was 45%, 53% by the addition of maternal history factors and 85.7% by the addition of ultrasound findings.

CONCLUSIONS

In early pregnancy a prediction of miscarriage can be provided by a combination of maternal characteristics and ultrasound findings and the estimated risk can be used to rationalize follow-up. Our multivariate model requires prospective evaluation in a new sample population.

Prenatal sonographic features of fetuses in trisomy 13 pregnancies. IV

Prenatal ultrasound is a powerful tool to detect structural abnormalities associated with the fetuses in trisomy 13 pregnancies. This article provides a comprehensive review of the prenatal sonographic markers of trisomy 13 in the first trimester, including fetal nuchal translucency thickness, fetal heart rate, fetal nasal bone, fetal tricuspid regurgitation, ductus venous flow, fetal crown-rump length, fetal trunk and head volume, fetal frontomaxillary facial angle, gestational sac volume and umbilical cord diameter, along with biochemical markers such as maternal serum free beta-human chorionic gonadotropin, maternal serum pregnancy-associated plasma protein-A, maternal serum placental growth factor, and the fetal and total cell-free DNA concentration in the maternal circulation.

How does the tubular embryonic heart work? Looking for the physical mechanism generating unidirectional blood flow in the valveless embryonic heart tube

The heart is the first organ to function in vertebrate embryos. The human heart, for example, starts beating around the 21st embryonic day. During the initial phase of its pumping action, the embryonic heart is seen as a pulsating blood vessel that is built up by (1) an inner endothelial tube lacking valves, (2) a middle layer of extracellular matrix, and (3) an outer myocardial tube. Despite the absence of valves, this tubular heart generates unidirectional blood flow. This fact poses the question how it works. Visual examination of the pulsating embryonic heart tube shows that its pumping action is characterized by traveling mechanical waves sweeping from its venous to its arterial end. These traveling waves were traditionally described as myocardial peristaltic waves. It has, therefore, been speculated that the tubular embryonic heart works as a technical peristaltic pump. Recent hemodynamic data from living embryos, however, have shown that the pumping function of the embryonic heart tube differs in several respects from that of a technical peristaltic pump. Some of these data suggest that embryonic heart tubes work as valveless "Liebau pumps." In the present study, a review is given on the evolution of the two above-mentioned theories of early cardiac pumping mechanics. We discuss pros and cons for both of these theories. We show that the tubular embryonic heart works neither as a technical peristaltic pump nor as a classic Liebau pump. The question regarding how the embryonic heart tube works still awaits an answer.

In vivo imaging of the cyclic changes in cross-sectional shape of the ventricular segment of pulsating embryonic chick hearts at stages 14 to 17: a contribution to the understanding of the ontogenesis of cardiac pumping function

The cardiac cycle-related deformations of tubular embryonic hearts were traditionally described as concentric narrowing and widening of a tube of circular cross-section. Using optical coherence tomography (OCT), we have recently shown that, during the cardiac cycle, only the myocardial tube undergoes concentric narrowing and widening while the endocardial tube undergoes eccentric narrowing and widening, having an elliptic cross-section at end-diastole and a slit-shaped cross-section at end-systole. Due to technical limitations, these analyses were confined to early stages of ventricular development (chick embryos, stages 10-13). Using a modified OCT-system, we now document, for the first time, the cyclic changes in cross-sectional shape of beating embryonic ventricles at stages 14 to 17. We show that during these stages (1) a large area of diminished cardiac jelly appears at the outer curvature of the ventricular region associated with formation of endocardial pouches; (2) the ventricular endocardial lumen acquires a bell-shaped cross-section at end-diastole and becomes compressed like a fireplace bellows during systole; (3) the contracting portions of the embryonic ventricles display stretching along its baso-apical axis at end-systole. The functional significance of our data is discussed with respect to early cardiac pumping function.

Early fetal echocardiography: heart biometry and visualization of cardiac structures between 10 and 15 weeks' gestation

OBJECTIVE

The purpose of this prospective cross-sectional study was to compile normative data about biometry of the fetal heart and great vessels between 10 and 15 weeks in 123 normal singleton pregnancies. Additionally, we investigated the different methods and the optimal examination time of early fetal echocardiography.

METHODS

The interrogated parameters included total heart diameter; heart area and circumference; right and left ventricular diameter; diameter, circumference, and area of the thorax; and diameter of the aorta and pulmonary trunk. Visualization of the 4-chamber view, 3-vessel view, origin and crossover of the great arteries, aortic arch, ductus arteriosus, superior and inferior venae cavae, and pulmonary veins was analyzed, and the success rates by transvaginal sonography (TVS) and transabdominal sonography (TAS) were calculated.

RESULTS

Complete evaluation of the fetal heart was impossible at 10 weeks; the total success rate increased from 45% at 11 weeks to 90% between 12 and 14 weeks and 100% at 15 weeks. Between 10 and 13 weeks, TVS was superior to TAS. At 14 weeks, both methods were similar to each other, and at 15 weeks, TAS allowed adequate visualization of all structures. Linear regression analysis showed a significant correlation between the interrogated parameters and gestational age, crown-rump length, and biparietal diameter (P < .05). The ratio of right and left ventricular diameters and the ratio of pulmonary trunk and aortic diameters were constant.

CONCLUSIONS

Early fetal heart evaluation by TVS or TAS or both is reasonable and feasible. Our normative data could be helpful for understanding the normal development of the fetal heart and great arteries and for detection of cardiac defects in early pregnancy.

The Effect of Chorionic Villus Sampling on Fetal Heart Rate

OBJECTIVE

Fetal heart rate (FHR) variation during chorionic villus sampling (CVS) is a controversial topic. Limited studies have been published on this subject. Our study intended to evaluate the effects of CVS on the FHR.

METHOD

One hundred and sixty-five patients undergoing first-trimester elective CVS for prenatal diagnosis of beta-thalassemia were entered into a prospective study. M-mode FHR was obtained before and immediately after CVS in the patients. Potentially confounding variables also recorded included: gestational age, number of needle passes and placental location.

RESULTS

FHR values before and after CVS were compared using the paired t test and showed no statistically significant differences by 95% confidence. No differences were found in data analyzing gestational age, number of needle passes or placental location.

CONCLUSION

We were unable to detect any significant change in FHR after performing CVS. It seems that FHR is generally not altered by CVS.

Fetal heart rate in chromosomally abnormal fetuses

OBJECTIVES

To determine the effects of chromosomal defects on fetal heart rate at 10-14 weeks of gestation.

METHODS

Fetal heart rate at 10-14 weeks of gestation in 1061 chromosomally abnormal fetuses was compared to that from 25,000 normal pregnancies. The chromosomally abnormal group included 554 cases of trisomy 21, 219 cases of trisomy 18, 95 of trisomy 13, 50 of triploidy, 115 of Turner syndrome and 28 of sex chromosome abnormalities other than Turner syndrome.

RESULTS

In the normal group, fetal heart rate decreased from a mean value of 170 beats per minute (bpm) at 35 mm of crown-rump length to 155 bpm at 84 mm crown-rump length. In trisomy 21, trisomy 13 and Turner syndrome fetal heart rate was significantly higher, in trisomy 18 and triploidy the heart rate was lower and in other sex chromosome defects it was not significantly different from normal. Fetal heart rate was above the 95th centile of the normal range in 10%, 67% and 52% of fetuses with trisomy 21, trisomy 13 and Turner syndrome, respectively. The fetal heart rate was below the 5th centile in 30% of fetuses with triploidy and 19% of those with trisomy 18.

CONCLUSIONS

Trisomy 21, trisomy 13 and Turner syndrome are associated with fetal tachycardia, whereas in trisomy 18 and triploidy there is fetal bradycardia. Inclusion of fetal heart rate in a first-trimester screening program for trisomy 21 by a combination of maternal age and fetal nuchal translucency thickness is unlikely to provide useful improvement in sensitivity.

First trimester fetal heart rate measurements by transvaginal ultrasound combined with pulsed Doppler: an evaluation of 1331 cases

The aim of this study is to present the cardiac activity measurements obtained from 1331 embryos and first trimester fetuses in whom the crown-rump length (CRL) measurements were between 2 and 60 mm, and to correlate the pattern of changes according to growth in body length, with an objective and reliable technique; transvaginal ultrasound combined with pulsed Doppler. Sonographic examinations were performed using a Combison 320-Kretz scanner with a 5-7.5 MHz vaginal probe with 240 degrees scanning angle, combined with a 4.5 MHz pulsed Doppler. As the embryo grows, the mean heart rate increases sharply, from 106.8 +/- 6.4 at a CRL of 2 mm to 178.3 +/- 7.0 at a CRL of 23 mm; followed by a plateau and a slight decline thereafter. Statistical analysis of the body length and corresponding heart rate revealed a relationship with a correlation coefficient of 0.61 (P < 0.01), whereas relationship between CRL < or = 23 and corresponding heart rate was striking with a correlation coefficient of .87 (P < 0.01).