Flunarizine of limited value in children with intractable epilepsy

Classification of drugs based on properties of sodium channel inhibition: a comparative automated patch-clamp study

Background

There is only one established drug binding site on sodium channels. However, drug binding of sodium channels shows extreme promiscuity: ∼25% of investigated drugs have been found to potently inhibit sodium channels. The structural diversity of these molecules suggests that they may not share the binding site, and/or the mode of action. Our goal was to attempt classification of sodium channel inhibitors by measuring multiple properties of inhibition in electrophysiology experiments. We also aimed to investigate if different properties of inhibition correlate with specific chemical properties of the compounds.

Methodology/Principal Findings

A comparative electrophysiological study of 35 compounds, including classic sodium channel inhibitors (anticonvulsants, antiarrhythmics and local anesthetics), as well as antidepressants, antipsychotics and neuroprotective agents, was carried out using rNav1.2 expressing HEK-293 cells and the QPatch automatic patch-clamp instrument. In the multi-dimensional space defined by the eight properties of inhibition (resting and inactivated affinity, potency, reversibility, time constants of onset and offset, use-dependence and state-dependence), at least three distinct types of inhibition could be identified; these probably reflect distinct modes of action. The compounds were clustered similarly in the multi-dimensional space defined by relevant chemical properties, including measures of lipophilicity, aromaticity, molecular size, polarity and electric charge. Drugs of the same therapeutic indication typically belonged to the same type. We identified chemical properties, which were important in determining specific properties of inhibition. State-dependence correlated with lipophilicity, the ratio of the neutral form of molecules, and aromaticity: We noticed that the highly state dependent inhibitors had at least two aromatic rings, logP>4.0, and pKa<8.0.

Conclusions/Significance

The correlations of inhibition properties both with chemical properties and therapeutic profiles would not have been evident through the sole determination of IC₅₀; therefore, recording multiple properties of inhibition may allow improved prediction of therapeutic usefulness.

Anticonvulsant profile of flunarizine and relation to Na(+) channel blocking effects

The present study will summarize our findings concerning the anticonvulsant properties of the Ca2+ channel blocker flunarizine in a variety of experimental models of epilepsy. Flunarizine exhibits anticonvulsant effects against tonic seizures induced by electroshock or various chemoconvulsants in mice, however, did not protect against pentylenetetrazol-induced clonic seizures. In the MES test, the efficacy of clinically established antiepileptics was increased by co-medication. In the rotarod test, a minimal "neurotoxic" dose (TD50) of 18.0 mg/kg intraperitoneally was determined. In models of complex partial seizures like the hippocampal stimulation and the amygdala kindling in rats, flunarizine showed only a moderate activity. Thus, it can be suggested that the anticonvulsant potency of flunarizine in various screening tests is lower than that of standard antiepileptics such as carbamazepine and phenytoin. Concerning the possible mode of action, whole-cell patch-clamp experiments with cultured neonatal rat cardiomyocytes showed that flunarizine depressed the fast inward Na+ current in a concentration- and frequency-dependent manner well comparable with the action of phenytoin. It is concluded that the use-dependent inhibition of voltage-dependent Na+ channels may essentially contribute to the anticonvulsant activity of flunarizine in models for generalized tonic-clonic seizures. The clinical efficacy as add-on therapy is critically discussed in view of the present data.

Pharmacokinetic-pharmacodynamic correlation of lamotrigine, flunarizine, loreclezole, CGP40116 and CGP39551 in the cortical stimulation model

The purpose of this study was to assess the concentration-anti-convulsant effect relationships of a number of anti-convulsant drugs in the direct cortical stimulation model, to obtain more insight in the properties and predictive value of this model. The time course of the effect of lamotrigine, loreclezole, flunarizine, CGP40116 and CGP39551 was determined after iv. administration in conjunction with their pharmacokinetics. Convulsive activity was induced by stimulation of the motor cortex with a ramp-shaped pulse train. This technique allows consecutive measurements of the treshold for localized (TLS) and for generalized (TGS) seizure activity. Increase in threshold was used as measure of the anti-convulsant effect. After administration of lamotrigine, pronounced elevation of the TGS, with little change in the TLS, was observed. Flunarizine caused a similar effect, but much less intense. Loreclezole strongly elevated the TGS and to a lesser extent the TLS, also. The concentration-anti-convulsant effect relationship of the three compounds could be fitted by an exponential model. The NMDA antagonists, CGP40116 and CGP39551, induced minor changes in the TLS and a slight increase in the TGS. The onset of this effect was marked by a delay relative to blood concentrations. The biophase equilibration kinetics was estimated and a linear model was applied to describe the concentration-effect relationship of both NMDA antagonists. The present results show that the cortical stimulation model is a suitable technique for integrated pharmacokinetic-pharmacodynamic modelling and for assessing anti-convulsant efficacy. The results show that the model is rather insensitive to calcium channel blockers and NMDA antagonists.