Major interactions between radiation therapy and systemic sclerosis: is there an optimal treatment?

Current and emerging treatment options for lung cancer in patients with pre-existing connective tissue disease

An association between connective tissue disease (CTD) and lung cancer has been claimed in accumulating studies. However, the management of lung cancer with CTD is challenging because the pre-existing CTDs have proved to be significant risk factors for treatment-related toxicity, resulting in poor survival. In this review, we summarize the available information related to the treatment for lung cancer with CTD, discuss risk factors for treatment-related toxicities and management recommendations, which attempts to approach lung cancer with comorbid CTD systematically. Preliminary data show that: i) limited studies have focused on the effect of traditional therapeutic modalities, such as surgical treatment and chemotherapy; ii) with the development of the modern radiation techniques, radiotherapy would be well tolerated in this challenging clinical situation, but a cautious decision should be made for patients with CTD associated interstitial lung disease (ILD); iii) for patients with inactive CTD, immunotherapy was shown to have excellent local control with acceptable toxicity; iv) little information is available on the effects of tyrosine kinase inhibitors because of acute exacerbation (AE) of ILD risks; v) antiangiogenic therapy might be useful in preventing the progression in both lung cancer and CTD without increasing the AE-ILD risk; vi) Nintedanib would be a potentially promising novel therapy since it has recently been developed with promising results for both lung cancer and CTD-ILD. Further large-scale, randomized, controlled studies are still required to develop better therapeutic management for patients with lung cancer and pre-existing CTD.

[Radiotherapy and immune suppression: A short review]

The management of patients undergoing immunosuppressive agents is really challenging. Based on precaution principle, it seems mandatory to stop immunosuppressive (or immunomodulating) agents during radiation. Yet, it is impossible in grafted patients. It is possible in patients with autoimmune disease, but in this case, the autoimmune disease might modify patient's radio-sensitivity. We provide a short review about the safety of radiotherapy in grafted/auto-immune patients. The literature is limited with data coming from outdated case-report or case-control studies. It seems that radiotherapy is feasible in grafted patients, but special dose-constraints limitations must probably be considered for the transplant and the other organs at risk. There is very little data about the safety of radiotherapy, when associated with immunomodulating agents. The most studied drug is the methotrexate but only its prescription as a chemotherapy (high doses for a short period of time) was reported. When used as an immunomodulator, it should probably be stopped 4 months before and after radiation. Apart from rheumatoid arthritis, it seems that collagen vascular diseases and especially systemic scleroderma and systemic lupus erythematous feature increased radio-sensitivity with increased severe late toxicities. Transplanted patients and collagen vascular disease patients should be informed that there is very little data about safety of radiation in their case.

Pelvic radiotherapy in the setting of rheumatoid arthritis: Refining the paradigm

PURPOSE

Conflicting results concerning the toxicity of radiotherapy in the setting of rheumatoid arthritis were reported in literature. This work describes the toxicity profiles of patients with rheumatoid arthritis undergoing pelvic radiotherapy for gynecologic malignancies at our institution.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

Charts of patients with rheumatoid arthritis who underwent pelvic radiotherapy for cervical or endometrial cancer in a curative intent at the Gustave-Roussy Cancer Campus between 1990 and 2015 were reviewed for treatment-related toxicities. Acute and late effects were graded as per the Common Terminology Criteria for Adverse Events version 4.0 scoring system.

RESULTS

Eight patients with cervical cancer and three with endometrial cancer were identified. Median follow-up was 56 months. Median external beam radiotherapy dose was 45Gy. All patients received a brachytherapy boost using either pulse- or low-dose rate technique. Concomitant chemotherapy was used in seven cases. Median time from rheumatoid arthritis diagnosis to external beam radiation therapy was 5 years. No severe acute gastrointestinal or genitourinary toxicity was reported. One patient had grade 3 dermatitis. Any late toxicity occurred in 7 /11 patients, and one patient experienced severe late toxicities. One patient with overt systemic rheumatoid arthritis symptoms at the time of external beam radiation therapy experienced late grade 3 ureteral stenosis, enterocolitis and lumbar myelitis.

CONCLUSION

Pelvic radiotherapy, in the setting of rheumatoid arthritis, appears to be feasible, with potentially slight increase in low grade late events compared to other anatomic sites. Patients with overt systemic rheumatoid arthritis manifestation at the time of radiotherapy might be at risk of potential severe toxicities.

Use of pentoxifylline and tocopherol in radiation-induced fibrosis and fibroatrophy

Radiation-induced fibrosis in the head and neck is a well-established pathophysiological process after radiotherapy. Recently pentoxifylline and tocopherol have been proposed as treatments to combat the late complications of radiation-induced fibrosis and a way of dealing with osteoradionecrosis. They both have a long history in the management of radiation-induced fibrosis at other anatomical sites. In this paper we review their use in sites other than the head and neck to illustrate the potential benefit that they offer to our patients.

Complications of Postoperative Radiation Therapy after Partial Laryngectomy in Supraglottic Cancer: A Long-Term Evaluation

This retrospective study, based on a series of 90 patients with invasive squamous cell carcinoma of the supraglottis, was designed to document the functional outcome and complications after postoperative radiation therapy following partial laryngeal surgery. The surgical procedure was a standard supraglottic laryngectomy in 62 patients and a supracricoid partial laryngectomy in 28 patients. All of the patients had an unremarkable postoperative course and achieved locoregional control. The average dose delivered to the remaining larynx was 51.2 Gy (range 25–71 Gy). The average dose delivered to the neck was 50.6 Gy (range 2270 Gy). The patients were treated at 180-cGy per fractions in a continuous course technique with a cobalt 60 beam. In 5 patients (5.5%) complications led to cessation of postoperative radiation therapy, and the total dose delivered to the remaining larynx and neck was less than 40 Gy. All patients were followed up for a minimum of 10 years or until death. The 5-, 10-, and 15-year actuarial survival estimates were 71.5%, 44.3%, and 36.3%, respectively. The 5-, 10-, and 15-year actuarial severe complication estimates were all 11.2%. Overall, severe complications occurred in 15 patients. Severe complications led to death in 3 patients (3.3%), permanent gastrostomy in 3 (3.3%), and permanent tracheostomy in 1 (1.1%). A severe complication never resulted in completion of total laryngectomy. In univariate analysis, the mean dose delivered to the larynx was the only variable statistically related to the incidence of a severe complication. The mean dose delivered to the larynx was statistically higher (P = 0.014) in patients who had severe complications (60 Gy) than in patients who did not (50 Gy).

Severe Acute Radiodermatitis in a Keloid Patient with Takayasu's Arteritis

SUMMARY

Although combination therapy for keloid including postoperative radiation therapy (RT) is common, the radiation toxicity of RT in a patient with a history of collagen vascular disease has not been fully recognized. We experienced a case of an acute radiodermatitis in a patient with keloid. This patient had a chest keloid because of the bypass surgery for Takayasu's arteritis. After we performed an excision and postoperative RT, severe radiodermatitis occurred. We speculate that the higher single dose and the use of electron beams may be related to the onset of severe acute radiodermatitis in this case. It should be kept in mind that there is a risk of exacerbation of radiation toxicity in patients with collagen vascular disease.

Radiotherapy of early breast cancer in scleroderma patients: our experience with four cases and a short review of the literature

PURPOSE

Connective vascular diseases (CVD), including scleroderma, are reported to represent for some researchers a relative contraindication and for others absolute contraindication for radiotherapy. The purpose of our study is to add four new cases to the existing body of international literature and to determine whether women with pre-existing scleroderma who have been surgically treated for early breast cancer could undergo postsurgical radiotherapy without serious early and late complications.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

From May 1998 to November 2010, we irradiated for early breast cancer four patients suffering from pre-existing scleroderma; after conservative surgery, we performed whole breast postoperative radiotherapy of 50.4 Gy total dose to the whole breast plus a 9 Gy boost to the tumor bed. We reviewed the records of all four patients and evaluated the early and late reactions using acute radiation morbidity scoring criteria (Radiation Therapy Oncology Group [RTOG], American College of Radiology, Philadelphia, PA) and late radiation morbidity scoring scheme (European Organisation for Research and Treatment of Cancer [EORTC], Brussels, Belgium and RTOG).

RESULTS

After a median follow-up of 105 months (range 12-155 months) the early and late toxicity concerning the skin, the subcutaneous tissues, the lungs, and the heart have been acceptable and are in full accordance with what have been reported in international literature.

CONCLUSION

This study matches global experience, which shows that patients with scleroderma and breast cancer must be discussed by the multidisciplinary tumor board in order for a personalized treatment strategy to be formulated. Radiation therapy can be proposed as a postsurgical therapeutic option in selected cases.

Scleroderma and radiotherapy as part of the treatment of breast carcinoma: Six cases and a short critical review of the literature

Purpose: To add six new cases to the literature and to determine whether women with pre-existing scleroderma have an increased incidence of complications after breast-conserving therapy.

Methods and Materials: From 1995 to 2005, nine patients with pre-existing scleroderma were treated for their breast cancer at the Institute Curie. Six of them underwent radiotherapy. The patients who underwent radiotherapy were irradiated using high-energy photons of a cobalt unit and/or linear accelerator, either before or after surgery, or were exclusively treated using radiation therapy. The early and late skin reactions have been evaluated using the Acute Radiation Morbidity Scoring Criteria (RTOG) and Late Radiation Morbidity Scoring Scheme (RTOG, EORTC).

Results: Median follow-up of the six irradiated patients was 34 months (range from 10 to 120 months). Early reactions were as follows: grade 1 in two cases, grade 2 in two cases, and grade 3 in two cases. Late toxicity was as follows: grade 0 in three patients, currently at 56, 48, and 12 months of follow-up; grade 1, slight atrophy, in two patients; grade 3 reaction with marked atrophy in one patient, followed up for 120 months now. There was no toxicity worse than grade 3 in these series.

Conclusions: This small study cannot provide evidence that scleroderma increases the risk of developing early and late toxicity. Patients with scleroderma must be discussed in multidisciplinary meetings to adapt their treatment to their rheumatologic history. When radiotherapy is considered, more attention must be paid to the protection of normal tissues. Careful follow-up during and after the radiation therapy remains of paramount importance in this specific population of patients.

Radiotherapy for malignancy in patients with scleroderma: The Mayo Clinic experience

PURPOSE

To determine the frequency of acute and chronic adverse effects in patients with scleroderma who receive radiotherapy for treatment of cancer.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

Records were reviewed of 20 patients with scleroderma who received radiotherapy. Acute and chronic toxic effects attributable to radiotherapy were analyzed, and freedom from radiation-related toxicity was calculated.

RESULTS

Of the 20 patients, 15 had acute toxic effects, with Grade 3 or higher toxicity for 3 patients. Seven patients had self-limited Grade 1 or 2 radiation dermatitis, and no patient had Grade 3 or higher radiation dermatitis. Thirteen patients had chronic toxic effects, with Grade 3 or higher chronic toxicity for 3 patients. The median estimated time to any grade chronic toxicity was 0.4 years, and the median estimated time to Grade 3 or higher chronic toxicity has not been reached.

CONCLUSIONS

The results suggest that although some patients with scleroderma treated with radiation experience considerable toxic effects, the occurrence of Grade 3 or higher toxicity may be less than previously anticipated.

The radiation-induced fibroatrophic process: therapeutic perspective via the antioxidant pathway

The radiation-induced fibroatrophic process (RIF) constitutes a late, local and unavoidable sequela to high-dose radiotherapy, traditionally considered irreversible. Today, this process is partly reversible, thanks to recent progress in understanding the physiopathology of the lesions it causes and the results of recent clinical trials using antioxidant therapy. This review includes a synthetic description of the static and dynamic features of the RIF process, as reflected by its clinical, instrumental and histopathological characteristics, and by its cellular and molecular regulation. Schematically, three successive clinical and histopathological phases can be distinguished: a pre-fibrotic aspecific inflammatory phase, a constitutive fibrotic cellular phase, and a matrix densification and remodelling phase, possibly ending in terminal tissular necrosis. The respective roles of the chief actors in the RIF process are defined, as well as their development with time. A fibroblastic stromal hypothesis is suggested revolving around a 'gravitational effect' exerted by the couple ROS (reactive oxygen species)--fibroblasts, and partly mediated by TGF-beta1. A variety of strategies have been tested for the management of RIF. In the light of the mechanisms described, a curative procedure has been proposed via the antioxidant pathway. In particular, it was showed that superoxide dismutase and combined pentoxifylline-tocopherol treatment enables the process of established radiation-induced fibroatrophy to be greatly reduced or even reversed, both in clinical practice and animal experiments. The efficacy of combined pentoxifylline-tocopherol treatment in superficial RIF was confirmed in a randomised clinical trial, and then in successful phase II trials especially in uterine fibroatrophy and osteoradionecrosis. It is of critical importance to evaluate these new management approaches in larger clinical trials and to improve the recording of results for better outcome analysis. Mechanistic studies are always necessary to improve understanding of the RIF process and the antifibrotic drug action.

The rationale behind autologous autoimmune hematopoietic stem cell transplant conditioning regimens: concerns over the use of total-body irradiation in systemic sclerosis

Hematopoietic stem cell transplantation (HSCT) is becoming an increasingly recognized indication for treatment of autoimmune diseases and severe immune-mediated disorders. However, multicenter registry data have demonstrated higher than anticipated early toxicity, approximately 10% for autoimmune diseases in general, and 20-27% for diffuse systemic sclerosis (scleroderma). If uncorrected, this high treatment-related mortality will hinder development of stem cell therapy for immune-mediated diseases. In order to develop safer regimens, we address some pitfalls and concepts involved in design and selection of conditioning regimens for autoimmune diseases in general, and because it is associated with the highest regimen-related toxicity, scleroderma in specific.

The effect of nonmalignant systemic disease on tolerance to radiation therapy

PURPOSE

Some patients with nonmalignant systemic diseases, like collagen vascular disease (CVD), hypertension, diabetes mellitus, and inflammatory bowel disease (IBD), tolerate radiation therapy poorly. Although the mechanisms of each of these disease processes are different, they share a common microvessel pathology that is potentially exacerbated by radiotherapy. This article reviews and evaluates available data examining the effects of these benign disease processes on radiation tolerance.

METHODS

We conducted a thorough review of the Anglo-American medical literature from 1960 to 2001 on the effects of radiotherapy on CVD, hypertension, diabetes mellitus, and IBD.

RESULTS

Fifteen studies were identified that examined the effects of radiation therapy for cancer in patients with CVDs. Thirteen of 15 studies documented greater occurrences of acute and late toxicities (range 7%-100%). Higher rates of complications were noted especially for nonrheumatoid arthritis CVDs. Nine studies evaluated the effects of hypertension and diabetes on radiation tolerance. All nine studies documented higher rates of late toxicities than in a "control" group (range 34%-100%). When patients had both diabetes and hypertension, the risk of late toxicities was even higher. Six studies examined radiation tolerance of patients with IBD irradiated to the abdomen and pelvis. Five of these six studies showed greater occurrences of acute and late toxicities for patients with IBD, even with precautionary measures like reduced fraction size and volume and patient immobilization (13%-29%).

CONCLUSION

The majority of published studies documented lower radiation tolerance for patients who have CVD, diabetes mellitus, hypertension, and IBD. This may reflect a publication bias, as the majority of these studies are retrospective with small numbers of patients and use different scoring scales for complications. These factors may contribute to an overestimation of true radiation-induced morbidity. Although the paucity of data makes precise estimates difficult, a subset of patients, in particular, those with active CVD, IBD, or a combination of uncontrolled hypertension with type I diabetes, is likely to be at higher risk. Future prospective trials need to document these disease entities when reporting treatment-related complications and also must monitor toxicities associated with quiescent versus active IBD and CVD, type I versus type II diabetes, and levels of hypertension (controlled versus uncontrolled) matched for radiation-specific treatment sites, field size, fractionation, and total dose.

The radiotherapeutic injury--a complex 'wound'

Radiotherapeutic normal tissue injury can be viewed as two simultaneously ongoing and interacting processes. The first has many features in common with the healing of traumatic wounds. The second is a set of transient or permanent alterations of cellular and extracellular components within the irradiated volume. In contrast to physical trauma, fractionated radiation therapy produces a series of repeated insults to tissues that undergo significant changes during the course of radiotherapy. Normal tissue responses are also influenced by rate of dose accumulation and other factors that relate to the radiation therapy schedule. This article reviews the principles of organised normal tissue responses during and after radiation therapy, the effect of radiation therapy on these responses, as well as some of the mechanisms underlying the development of recognisable injury. Important clinical implications relevant to these processes are also discussed.

[Reversibility of radiation-induced fibroatrophy]

PURPOSE

The radiation-induced fibro-atrophic process described in numerous tissues and organs is a localized and irreversible late effect of high-dose radiation therapy. Our purpose is to show that this process is today reversible.

CURRENT KNOWLEDGE AND KEY POINTS

This review describes a synthesis of various clinical, paraclinical and histopathological aspects of radiation-induced fibro-atrophic process, and of cellular and molecular process regulation. Schematically, there exists a prefibrotic aspecific inflammatory phase, then a constituted and cellular phase, then a matricial densification and remodeling phase, associated in some cases with a tissular terminal necrosis. The respective parts and their evolution during time of the main protagonists as myofibroblast, extracellular matrix and growth factor TGF beta 1 are clarified. From the pathophysiological mechanisms described, curative therapeutic attitudes are proposed for the different progressive phases. Especially, superoxide dismutase (not available) and the pentoxifylline-tocopherol combination seem to allow reduction and reversibility of the fibro-atrophic radiation-induced established process, in clinics as in animal experiments.

FUTURE PROSPECTS AND PROJECTS

Some phase II trials try to assess the therapeutic interest of combined pentoxifylline-tocopherol in various radiation-induced sequelae, as in osteo-radionecrosis. A clinical randomized trial phase III has just been achieved and could support the results of these experimental and retrospective clinical trials.

Complications of postoperative radiation therapy after partial laryngectomy in supraglottic cancer: A long-term evaluation

This retrospective study, based on a series of 90 patients with invasive squamous cell carcinoma of the supraglottis, was designed to document the functional outcome and complications after postoperative radiation therapy following partial laryngeal surgery. The surgical procedure was a standard supraglottic laryngectomy in 62 patients and a supracricoid partial laryngectomy in 28 patients. All of the patients had an unremarkable postoperative course and achieved locoregional control. The average dose delivered to the remaining larynx was 51.2 Gy (range 25-71 Gy). The average dose delivered to the neck was 50.6 Gy (range 22-70 Gy). The patients were treated at 180-cGy per fractions in a continuous course technique with a cobalt 60 beam. In 5 patients (5.5%) complications led to cessation of postoperative radiation therapy, and the total dose delivered to the remaining larynx and neck was less than 40 Gy. All patients were followed up for a minimum of 10 years or until death. The 5-, 10-, and 15-year actuarial survival estimates were 71. 5%, 44.3%, and 36.3%, respectively. The 5-, 10-, and 15-year actuarial severe complication estimates were all 11.2%. Overall, severe complications occurred in 15 patients. Severe complications led to death in 3 patients (3.3%), permanent gastrostomy in 3 (3.3%), and permanent tracheostomy in 1 (1.1%). A severe complication never resulted in completion of total laryngectomy. In univariate analysis, the mean dose delivered to the larynx was the only variable statistically related to the incidence of a severe complication. The mean dose delivered to the larynx was statistically higher (P = 0.014) in patients who had severe complications (60 Gy) than in patients who did not (50 Gy).

Collagen vascular diseases and radiation therapy: a critical review

PURPOSE

Although many oncologists have the impression that patients with collagen vascular disease tolerate radiotherapy less well than other patients, until now this was never described in a review article.

METHODS AND RESULTS

The principal objective was to determine whether patients with collagen vascular diseases have a greater risk of severe radiation therapy complications, than those without a collagen vascular disease. However, most of the publications found on this topic are short anecdotal case reports of patients with increased toxicity after radiation. Consequently, the true incidence of these side effects is unknown.

CONCLUSIONS

Unless further studies on this subject are reported, each radiation oncologist should be cautious in treating these patients.

[Tumor and individual radiosensitivity. An introduction]

This text is intended to introduce the following articles, which correspond to the lectures given at the "Radiosensitivity" session of the 1998 SFRO Meeting. We first underline the somewhat disappointing results obtained so far for evaluating tumoral radiosensitivity. However, a few new tests could bring some hope in a not-too distant future. We then focus on individual radiosensitivity. We first list the syndromes or diseases associated with a known hyperradiosensitivity. We then concentrate on the radiosensitivity tests that are available in 1998, some of them being already used in a few centers in specific situations. However, the "optimal" test is still to be identified. After a brief chapter on the possible modulations of radiosensitivity, we conclude with a few recommendations to the clinician.

[Late effects of mammary radiotherapy on skin and subcutaneous tissues]

Late damages to the skin and subcutaneous tissues are almost inescapable because of the high skin doses required in the irradiation of breast tumours. While the clinical and histological descriptions date back to the first decades of the therapeutic use of ionising radiation, the recent advances in cellular and molecular biology have significantly contributed to the increased understanding of late skin injury mechanisms. In particular, sub-cutaneous fibrosis appears to be the partly reversible results of a continuous and self-maintained local process, possibly sensitive to therapeutic intervention. A second very active research avenue is the development of biologic assays potentially able to predict the probability of increased normal tissue injury after irradiation in individual patients. Such a test would allow the adaptation of the treatment modalities to the radiobiological behaviour of normal tissues. To date, these expectations have not been met. The quality of the irradiation and its modalities (total dose, fractionation, inter fraction interval) remain the main ways to achieve an optimal functional and cosmetic outcome.

Abnormal phenotype of cultured fibroblasts in human skin with chronic radiotherapy damage

PURPOSE

The pathophysiological aspects of radiation-induced fibrosis (RIF) have not been well characterized. We therefore cultured human fibroblasts from samples of skin with RIF to investigate the long-term effects of therapeutic irradiation.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Biopsies of normal and RIF skin were obtained from patients previously irradiated for cancer, without recurrence. Cells were extracted from dermis samples by the outgrowth technique, seeded as monolayers and cultured at confluence. Enzyme activities and proteins were assayed, RNA was isolated and Northern blot analysis was performed on surviving cells between passages 2 and 5.

RESULTS

RIF cell cultures displayed heterogeneous fibroblasts populations. The initial outgrowth consisted of one-third small cells that floated rapidly, one-third spindle-shaped cells migrating far from the explant to form islets and one-third large pleiomorphic cells. In subsequent subcultures, surviving cells exhibited either myofibroblastic characteristics with a normal proliferative capacity or senescent morphology with a reduced proliferative capacity. These RIF cells had a brief finite lifespan, with dramatically reduced growth rate during their initial outgrowth and the following passages. Study of the antioxidant metabolism showed that Mn superoxide dismutase and catalase activities were significantly weaker in surviving RIF cells than healthy fibroblasts. These exhausted RIF cells exhibited no overexpression of transforming growth factor beta or tissue inhibitor of metalloproteinase.

CONCLUSION

Irradiation may lead to apparently contradictory effects such as fibrosis and necrosis in clinical practice. In cell culture, we observed two main cellular phenotypes which may be related to both processes, i.e. myofibroblast-like cells and fibrocyte-like cells. These two phenotypes may represent two steps in the differentiation induced as a long-term effect of therapeutic irradiation of the skin. Cell culture probably accelerates the induction of the terminal differentiation in RIF fibroblasts.