Detection of misfolded rhodopsin aggregates in cells by Förster resonance energy transfer

Aggregation of the constitutively active K296E rhodopsin mutant contributes to retinal degeneration

A K296E mutation in rhodopsin causes autosomal dominant retinitis pigmentosa, a progressive retinal degenerative disease. Early in vitro characterizations of this mutation studied on a bovine rhodopsin background indicated that the mutation causes the receptor to be constitutively active. This molecular defect has been the primary focus when considering the pathogenic mechanism of the mutation. Knockin mice expressing the K296E rhodopsin mutant were generated and characterized to better understand the pathogenic mechanism of the mutation. Knockin mice exhibited progressive retinal degeneration characteristic of retinitis pigmentosa. The K296E rhodopsin mutant mislocalized in photoreceptor cells and, surprisingly, appeared to aggregate, as indicated by the dye PROTEOSTAT, which binds protein aggregates. The propensity of the K296E rhodopsin mutant to aggregate was tested and confirmed in vitro but was dependent on the species background of rhodopsin. The K296E mutation on either murine or human rhodopsin backgrounds exhibited similar propensities to aggregate. The same mutation on a bovine rhodopsin background, however, exhibited a lower propensity to aggregate, indicating this species background does not adequately model the effects of the K296E mutation. In contrast to previous expectations, we demonstrate here that aggregation of the K296E rhodopsin mutant can promote photoreceptor cell loss.

A Y178C rhodopsin mutation causes aggregation and comparatively severe retinal degeneration

Rhodopsin is the light-activated G protein-coupled receptor that initiates vision in photoreceptor cells of the retina. Numerous mutations in rhodopsin promote receptor misfolding and aggregation, causing autosomal dominant retinitis pigmentosa, a progressive retinal degenerative disease. The mechanism by which these mutations cause photoreceptor cell death, and the role aggregation plays in this process is still unclear. We recently demonstrated with the P23H and G188R rhodopsin mutants that the severity of aggregation observed in vitro is also reflected in vivo and impacts the rate of retinal degeneration. A Y178C rhodopsin mutant was investigated here to determine if this relationship applies broadly among mutations that cause misfolding and aggregation of the receptor. In vitro characterization indicated the Y178C rhodopsin mutant exhibits similar properties to the more severely aggregating G188R rhodopsin mutant, where the mutant is mislocalized to the endoplasmic reticulum in HEK293 cells and form aggregates that cannot be rescued by treatment with the retinoid 9-cis retinal. Despite these similarities in vitro, the Y178C rhodopsin mutant promoted a more severe retinal degeneration compared to the G188R mutant in vivo in mice. Aggregates of the Y178C rhodopsin mutant labeled by the dye PROTEOSTAT were morphologically similar to those formed by both the P23H and G188R rhodopsin mutants. There was, however, significantly greater photoreceptor cell death occurring independently of PROTEOSTAT-labeled aggregates in mice expressing the Y178C rhodopsin mutant compared to those expressing either the P23H or G188R rhodopsin mutants. Here, we demonstrate that PROTEOSTAT-labeled aggregates are not the sole cause of photoreceptor cell death promoted by the Y178C rhodopsin mutation in vivo, and there may be alternate aggregate forms contributing to cell death in these mice.

Aggregation of rhodopsin mutants in mouse models of autosomal dominant retinitis pigmentosa

Mutations in rhodopsin can cause it to misfold and lead to retinal degeneration. A distinguishing feature of these mutants in vitro is that they mislocalize and aggregate. It is unclear whether or not these features contribute to retinal degeneration observed in vivo. The effect of P23H and G188R misfolding mutations were examined in a heterologous expression system and knockin mouse models, including a mouse model generated here expressing the G188R rhodopsin mutant. In vitro characterizations demonstrate that both mutants aggregate, with the G188R mutant exhibiting a more severe aggregation profile compared to the P23H mutant. The potential for rhodopsin mutants to aggregate in vivo was assessed by PROTEOSTAT, a dye that labels aggregated proteins. Both mutants mislocalize in photoreceptor cells and PROTEOSTAT staining was detected surrounding the nuclei of photoreceptor cells. The G188R mutant promotes a more severe retinal degeneration phenotype and greater PROTEOSTAT staining compared to that promoted by the P23H mutant. Here, we show that the level of PROTEOSTAT positive cells mirrors the progression and level of photoreceptor cell death, which suggests a potential role for rhodopsin aggregation in retinal degeneration.

Toward the Treatment of Inherited Diseases of the Retina Using CRISPR-Based Gene Editing

Inherited retinal dystrophies [IRDs] are a common cause of severe vision loss resulting from pathogenic genetic variants. The eye is an attractive target organ for testing clinical translational approaches in inherited diseases. This has been demonstrated by the approval of the first gene supplementation therapy to treat an autosomal recessive IRD, RPE65-linked Leber congenital amaurosis (type 2), 4 years ago. However, not all diseases are amenable for treatment using gene supplementation therapy, highlighting the need for alternative strategies to overcome the limitations of this supplementation therapeutic modality. Gene editing has become of increasing interest with the discovery of the CRISPR-Cas9 platform. CRISPR-Cas9 offers several advantages over previous gene editing technologies as it facilitates targeted gene editing in an efficient, specific, and modifiable manner. Progress with CRISPR-Cas9 research now means that gene editing is a feasible strategy for the treatment of IRDs. This review will focus on the background of CRISPR-Cas9 and will stress the differences between gene editing using CRISPR-Cas9 and traditional gene supplementation therapy. Additionally, we will review research that has led to the first CRISPR-Cas9 trial for the treatment of CEP290-linked Leber congenital amaurosis (type 10), as well as outline future directions for CRISPR-Cas9 technology in the treatment of IRDs.

Pharmacological Inhibition of the VCP/Proteasome Axis Rescues Photoreceptor Degeneration in RHOP23H Rat Retinal Explants

Rhodopsin (RHO) misfolding mutations are a common cause of the blinding disease autosomal dominant retinitis pigmentosa (adRP). The most prevalent mutation, RHO^P23H, results in its misfolding and retention in the endoplasmic reticulum (ER). Under homeostatic conditions, misfolded proteins are selectively identified, retained at the ER, and cleared via ER-associated degradation (ERAD). Overload of these degradation processes for a prolonged period leads to imbalanced proteostasis and may eventually result in cell death. ERAD of misfolded proteins, such as RHO^P23H, includes the subsequent steps of protein recognition, targeting for ERAD, retrotranslocation, and proteasomal degradation. In the present study, we investigated and compared pharmacological modulation of ERAD at these four different major steps. We show that inhibition of the VCP/proteasome activity favors cell survival and suppresses P23H-mediated retinal degeneration in RHO^P23H rat retinal explants. We suggest targeting this activity as a therapeutic approach for patients with currently untreatable adRP.

Structural aspects of rod opsin and their implication in genetic diseases

Vision in dim-light conditions is triggered by photoactivation of rhodopsin, the visual pigment of rod photoreceptor cells. Rhodopsin is made of a protein, the G protein coupled receptor (GPCR) opsin, and the chromophore 11-cis-retinal. Vertebrate rod opsin is the GPCR best characterized at the atomic level of detail. Since the release of the first crystal structure 20 years ago, a huge number of structures have been released that, in combination with valuable spectroscopic determinations, unveiled most aspects of the photobleaching process. A number of spontaneous mutations of rod opsin have been found linked to vision-impairing diseases like autosomal dominant or autosomal recessive retinitis pigmentosa (adRP or arRP, respectively) and autosomal congenital stationary night blindness (adCSNB). While adCSNB is mainly caused by constitutive activation of rod opsin, RP shows more variegate determinants affecting different aspects of rod opsin function. The vast majority of missense rod opsin mutations affects folding and trafficking and is linked to adRP, an incurable disease that awaits light on its molecular structure determinants. This review article summarizes all major structural information available on vertebrate rod opsin conformational states and the insights gained so far into the structural determinants of adCSNB and adRP linked to rod opsin mutations. Strategies to design small chaperones with therapeutic potential for selected adRP rod opsin mutants will be discussed as well.

Supramolecular organization of rhodopsin in rod photoreceptor cell membranes

Rhodopsin is the light receptor in rod photoreceptor cells that initiates scotopic vision. Studies on the light receptor span well over a century, yet questions about the organization of rhodopsin within the photoreceptor cell membrane still persist and a consensus view on the topic is still elusive. Rhodopsin has been intensely studied for quite some time, and there is a wealth of information to draw from to formulate an organizational picture of the receptor in native membranes. Early experimental evidence in apparent support for a monomeric arrangement of rhodopsin in rod photoreceptor cell membranes is contrasted and reconciled with more recent visual evidence in support of a supramolecular organization of rhodopsin. What is known so far about the determinants of forming a supramolecular structure and possible functional roles for such an organization are also discussed. Many details are still missing on the structural and functional properties of the supramolecular organization of rhodopsin in rod photoreceptor cell membranes. The emerging picture presented here can serve as a springboard towards a more in-depth understanding of the topic.

Differential Aggregation Properties of Mutant Human and Bovine Rhodopsin

Rhodopsin is the light receptor required for the function and health of photoreceptor cells. Mutations in rhodopsin can cause misfolding and aggregation of the receptor, which leads to retinal degeneration. Bovine rhodopsin is often used as a model to understand the effect of pathogenic mutations in rhodopsin due to the abundance of structural information on the bovine form of the receptor. It is unclear whether or not the bovine rhodopsin template is adequate in predicting the effect of these mutations occurring in human retinal disease or in predicting the efficacy of therapeutic strategies. To better understand the extent to which bovine rhodopsin can serve as a model, human and bovine P23H rhodopsin mutants expressed heterologously in cells were examined. The aggregation properties and cellular localization of the mutant receptors were determined by Förster resonance energy transfer and confocal microscopy. The potential therapeutic effects of the pharmacological compounds 9-cis retinal and metformin were also examined. Human and bovine P23H rhodopsin mutants exhibited different aggregation properties and responses to the pharmacological compounds tested. These observations would lead to different predictions on the severity of the phenotype and divergent predictions on the benefit of the therapeutic compounds tested. The bovine rhodopsin template does not appear to adequately model the effects of the P23H mutation in the human form of the receptor.

Rhodopsin Oligomerization and Aggregation

Rhodopsin is the light receptor in photoreceptor cells of the retina and a prototypical G protein-coupled receptor. Two types of quaternary structures can be adopted by rhodopsin. If rhodopsin folds and attains a proper tertiary structure, it can then form oligomers and nanodomains within the photoreceptor cell membrane. In contrast, if rhodopsin misfolds, it cannot progress through the biosynthetic pathway and instead will form aggregates that can cause retinal degenerative disease. In this review, emerging views are highlighted on the supramolecular organization of rhodopsin within the membrane of photoreceptor cells and the aggregation of rhodopsin that can lead to retinal degeneration.