Evaluation of acid-base status in patients admitted to ED—physicochemical vs traditional approaches

Approaching a phenomenal contradiction in acid-base physiology

OBJECTIVES

The study focuses exclusively on the results of an arterial blood gas report, which reveal a phenomenal contradiction if one follows the physiological and physicochemical approaches as well as the standard base excess determination to interpret an acid-base disturbance. The aim of this article is not to fully describe a clinical case and make a differential diagnosis but to analyze the blood gas report data in detail and present the conclusions that result from the application of the different approaches that exist for the interpretation of acid-base disorders.

METHODS

The results of an arterial blood gas report of a patient with severe lactic acidosis were cross-examined using the standard base excess method and the physiologic and physiochemical approaches. The causes of the contradiction are discussed with a commentary on the underlying pathophysiology.

RESULTS

The study revealed the presence of a normal anion gap (even after correction for albumin levels), a slightly increased strong ion gap and a moderately decreased standard base excess in a patient with severe lactic acidosis.

CONCLUSIONS

This real-life case provides an opportunity to give a brief overview of the current methods for investigating acid-base disturbances in a practical way, emphasizing both the common background and the conceptual differences and similarities.

Evaluation of the Acid-Base Status in Patients Admitted to the ICU Due to Severe COVID-19: Physicochemical versus Traditional Approaches

BACKGROUND

Stewart's approach is known to have better diagnostic accuracy for the identification of metabolic acid-base disturbances compared to traditional methods based either on plasma bicarbonate concentration ([HCO3-]) and anion gap (AG) or on base excess/deficit (BE). This study aimed to identify metabolic acid-base disorders using either Stewart's or traditional approaches in critically ill COVID-19 patients admitted to the ICU, to recognize potential hidden acid-base metabolic abnormalities and to assess the prognostic value of these abnormalities for patient outcome.

METHODS

This was a single-center retrospective study, in which we collected data from patients with severe COVID-19 admitted to the ICU. Electronical files were used to retrieve data for arterial blood gases, serum electrolytes, and proteins and to derive [HCO3-], BE, anion gap (AG), AG adjusted for albumin (AGadj), strong ion difference, strong ion gap (SIG), and SIG corrected for water excess/deficit (SIGcorr). The acid-base status was evaluated in each patient using the BE, [HCO3-], and physicochemical approaches.

RESULTS

We included 185 patients. The physicochemical approach detected more individuals with metabolic acid-base abnormalities than the BE and [HCO3-] approaches (p < 0.001), and at least one acid-base disorder was recognized in most patients. According to the physicochemical method, 170/185 patients (91.4%) had at least one disorder, as opposed to the number of patients identified using the BE 90/186 (48%) and HCO3 62/186 (33%) methods. Regarding the derived acid-base status variables, non-survivors had greater AGadj, (p = 0.013) and SIGcorr (p = 0.035) compared to survivors.

CONCLUSIONS

The identification of hidden acid-base disturbances may provide a detailed understanding of the underlying conditions in patients and of the possible pathophysiological mechanisms implicated. The association of these acid-base abnormalities with mortality provides the opportunity to recognize patients at increased risk of death and support them accordingly.

Comparison of a modified Story approach to traditional evaluation of acid-base disturbances in patients with shock: a cohort study

To compare whether the diagnostic evaluation of metabolic acidosis can be improved by using a modified Story method compared to the traditional evaluation in a population of critically ill patients with shock. This prospective cohort study included shock patients admitted to the ICU of a tertiary hospital in Brazil between May 2018 and November 2019. We collected laboratory data necessary for traditional evaluation and the simplified Stewart's method. During the study period, 149 patients were included in the final analysis. Of the 17 patients with a normal SBE and AG_corrected, 13 (76.5%) presented with metabolic acidosis according to the modified Story assessment. Therefore, of the 149 patients included in the study, the traditional approach failed to identify metabolic acidosis that was identified by the modified Story assessment in 13 (8.7%) patients. In addition, the determination of the severity of metabolic acidosis also differed between the two methods by a mean of - 7.8 mEq/L. We found that a modified Story method can identify and quantify metabolic acidosis in patients with disorders that were not revealed by the traditional approach.

Impact of Acid-Base Status on Mortality in Patients with Acute Pesticide Poisoning

We investigated clinical impacts of various acid-base approaches (physiologic, base excess (BE)-based, and physicochemical) on mortality in patients with acute pesticide intoxication and mutual intercorrelated effects using principal component analysis (PCA). This retrospective study included patients admitted from January 2015 to December 2019 because of pesticide intoxication. We compared parameters assessing the acid-base status between two groups, survivors and non-survivors. Associations between parameters and 30-days mortality were investigated. A total of 797 patients were analyzed. In non-survivors, pH, bicarbonate concentration (HCO₃⁻), total concentration of carbon dioxide (tCO₂), BE, and effective strong ion difference (SIDe) were lower and apparent strong ion difference (SIDa), strong ion gap (SIG), total concentration of weak acids, and corrected anion gap (corAG) were higher than in survivors. In the multivariable logistic analysis, BE, corAG, SIDa, and SIDe were associated with mortality. PCA identified four principal components related to mortality. SIDe, HCO₃⁻, tCO₂, BE, SIG, and corAG were loaded to principal component 1 (PC1), referred as total buffer bases to receive and handle generated acids. PC1 was an important factor in predicting mortality irrespective of the pesticide category. PC3, loaded mainly with pCO₂, suggested respiratory components of the acid-base system. PC3 was associated with 30-days mortality, especially in organophosphate or carbamate poisoning. Our study showed that acid-base abnormalities were associated with mortality in patients with acute pesticide poisoning. We reduced these variables into four PCs, resembling the physicochemical approach, revealed that PCs representing total buffer bases and respiratory components played an important role in acute pesticide poisoning.

A physiology-based mathematical model for the selection of appropriate ventilator controls for lung and diaphragm protection

Mechanical ventilation is used to sustain respiratory function in patients with acute respiratory failure. To aid clinicians in consistently selecting lung- and diaphragm-protective ventilation settings, a physiology-based decision support system is needed. To form the foundation of such a system, a comprehensive physiological model which captures the dynamics of ventilation has been developed. The Lung and Diaphragm Protective Ventilation (LDPV) model centers around respiratory drive and incorporates respiratory system mechanics, ventilator mechanics, and blood acid–base balance. The model uses patient-specific parameters as inputs and outputs predictions of a patient’s transpulmonary and esophageal driving pressures (outputs most clinically relevant to lung and diaphragm safety), as well as their blood pH, under various ventilator and sedation conditions. Model simulations and global optimization techniques were used to evaluate and characterize the model. The LDPV model is demonstrated to describe a CO₂ respiratory response that is comparable to what is found in literature. Sensitivity analysis of the model indicate that the ventilator and sedation settings incorporated in the model have a significant impact on the target output parameters. Finally, the model is seen to be able to provide robust predictions of esophageal pressure, transpulmonary pressure and blood pH for patient parameters with realistic variability. The LDPV model is a robust physiological model which produces outputs which directly target and reflect the risk of ventilator-induced lung and diaphragm injury. Ventilation and sedation parameters are seen to modulate the model outputs in accordance with what is currently known in literature.

Metabolic Acidosis in Critically Ill Cirrhotic Patients with Acute Kidney Injury

Background and Aims: The metabolic acid-base disorders have a high incidence of acute kidney injury (AKI) in critically ill cirrhotic patients (CICPs). The aims of our study were to ascertain the composition of metabolic acidosis of CICPs with AKI and explore its relationship with hospital mortality. Methods: Three-hundred and eighty consecutive CICPs with AKI were eligible for the cohort study. Demographic, clinical and laboratory parameters were recorded and arterial acid-base state was analyzed by the Stewart and Gilfix methodology. Results: Net metabolic acidosis, lactic acidosis, acidosis owing to unmeasured anions, acidemia, and dilutional acidosis were less frequent in the non-survival group compared to the survival group of CICPs. The presence of acidemia, acidosis owing to unmeasured anions, and lactic acidosis were independently associated with increased risk of intensive care unit 30-day mortality, with hazard ratios of 2.11 (95% confidence interval (CI): 1.43-3.12), 3.38 (95% CI: 2.36-4.84), and 2.16 (95% CI: 1.47-3.35), respectively. After full adjustment for confounders, the relationship between acidosis owing to unmeasured anions with hospital mortality was still significant, with hazard ratio of 2.29 (95% CI: 1.22-4.30). Furthermore, arterial lactate concentration in combination with chronic liver failure-sequential organ failure assessment and BEUMA had the strongest ability to differentiate 30-day mortality (area under the receiver operating characteristic curve: 0.79, 95% CI: 0.74-0.83). Conclusions: CICPs with AKI exhibit a complex metabolic acidosis during intensive care unit admission. Lactic acidosis and BEUMA, novel markers of acid-base disorders, show promise in predicting mortality rate of CICPs with AKI.

Traditional approach versus Stewart approach for acid-base disorders: Inconsistent evidence

Purpose

The traditional approach and the Stewart approach have been developed for evaluating acid-base phenomena. While some experts have suggested that the two approaches are essentially identical, clinical researches have still been conducted on the superiority of one approach over the other one. In this review, we summarize the concepts of each approach and investigate the reasons of the discrepancy, based on current evidence from the literature search.

Methods

In the literature search, we completed a database search and reviewed articles comparing the Stewart approach with the traditional, bicarbonate-centered approach to November 2016.

Results

Our literature review included 17 relevant articles, 5 of which compared their diagnostic abilities, 9 articles compared their prognostic performances, and 3 articles compared both diagnostic abilities and prognostic performances. These articles show a discrepancy over the abilities to detect acid-base disturbances and to predict patients' outcomes. There are many limitations that could yield this discrepancy, including differences in calculation of the variables, technological differences or errors in measuring variables, incongruences of reference value, normal range of the variables, differences in studied populations, and confounders of prognostic strength such as lactate.

Conclusion

In conclusion, despite the proposed equivalence between the traditional approach and the Stewart approach, our literature search shows inconsistent results on the comparison between the two approaches for diagnostic and prognostic performance. We found crucial limitations in those studies, which could lead to the reasons of the discrepancy.

Metabolic acidosis and the role of unmeasured anions in critical illness and injury

Acid-base disorders are frequently present in critically ill patients. Metabolic acidosis is associated with increased mortality, but it is unclear whether as a marker of the severity of the disease process or as a direct effector. The understanding of the metabolic component of acid-base derangements has evolved over time, and several theories and models for precise quantification and interpretation have been postulated during the last century. Unmeasured anions are the footprints of dissociated fixed acids and may be responsible for a significant component of metabolic acidosis. Their nature, origin, and prognostic value are incompletely understood. This review provides a historical overview of how the understanding of the metabolic component of acid-base disorders has evolved over time and describes the theoretical models and their corresponding tools applicable to clinical practice, with an emphasis on the role of unmeasured anions in general and several specific settings.

A comparison of prognostic significance of strong ion gap (SIG) with other acid-base markers in the critically ill: a cohort study

Background

This cohort study compared the prognostic significance of strong ion gap (SIG) with other acid-base markers in the critically ill.

Methods

The relationships between SIG, lactate, anion gap (AG), anion gap albumin-corrected (AG-corrected), base excess or strong ion difference-effective (SIDe), all obtained within the first hour of intensive care unit (ICU) admission, and the hospital mortality of 6878 patients were analysed. The prognostic significance of each acid-base marker, both alone and in combination with the Admission Mortality Prediction Model (MPM₀ III) predicted mortality, were assessed by the area under the receiver operating characteristic curve (AUROC).

Results

Of the 6878 patients included in the study, 924 patients (13.4 %) died after ICU admission. Except for plasma chloride concentrations, all acid-base markers were significantly different between the survivors and non-survivors. SIG (with lactate: AUROC 0.631, confidence interval [CI] 0.611–0.652; without lactate: AUROC 0.521, 95 % CI 0.500–0.542) only had a modest ability to predict hospital mortality, and this was no better than using lactate concentration alone (AUROC 0.701, 95 % 0.682–0.721). Adding AG-corrected or SIG to a combination of lactate and MPM₀ III predicted risks also did not substantially improve the latter’s ability to differentiate between survivors and non-survivors. Arterial lactate concentrations explained about 11 % of the variability in the observed mortality, and it was more important than SIG (0.6 %) and SIDe (0.9 %) in predicting hospital mortality after adjusting for MPM₀ III predicted risks. Lactate remained as the strongest predictor for mortality in a sensitivity multivariate analysis, allowing for non-linearity of all acid-base markers.

Conclusions

The prognostic significance of SIG was modest and inferior to arterial lactate concentration for the critically ill. Lactate concentration should always be considered regardless whether physiological, base excess or physical-chemical approach is used to interpret acid-base disturbances in critically ill patients.