Diagnostic Capability of Peripapillary Three-dimensional Retinal Nerve Fiber Layer Volume for Glaucoma Using Optical Coherence Tomography Volume Scans

Frequency of Agreement Between Structural and Functional Glaucoma Testing: A Longitudinal Study of 3D OCT and Current Clinical Tests

PURPOSE

To evaluate how often tests of structure and function detect glaucoma progression at the same study visit. Tests include current glaucoma clinical tests and a new 3-dimensional (3D) optical coherence tomography (OCT) rim measurement.

DESIGN

Prospective cohort study.

METHODS

For 124 open-angle glaucoma patients at a single institution, one eye was randomly selected for each patient. Patients were included if they had open-angle glaucoma and if they had at least 4 yearly study visits. Study visits included a full dilated eye exam, disc photography (DP), Humphrey visual field (HVF 24-2) testing, 2D OCT retinal nerve fibre layer (RNFL) thickness measurements, and 3D OCT neuroretinal rim measurements (i.e., minimum distance band or MDB). For each test at each study visit, eyes were classified as progressors or non-progressors using event-based analysis. Agreement occurred if tests progressed in the same eye at the same study visit. Agreements between all compared tests were calculated as percentages of agreement.

RESULTS

The study included 124 open-angle glaucoma eyes, which had an average follow-up period of 66.9 ± 16.4 months. Structural tests (i.e., DP, global RNFL thickness, and global MDB rim thickness) progressed at the same visit as the functional test (i.e., HVF testing) in only 5.0% (3/60) to 16.0% (13/81) of eyes. Global MDB thickness and global RNFL thickness showed similar agreement with functional HVF testing (i.e., 16.0% [13/81] and 8.3% [7/84], respectively), and global MDB thickness showed better structure-function agreement with HVF testing than between DP and HVF testing (i.e., 5.0% [3/60], P = 0.04). For all paired comparisons between testing methods, eyes with moderate glaucoma showed similar or better agreement than eyes with mild or severe glaucoma.

CONCLUSIONS

Clinical tests of structure and function do not usually progress at the same clinic visit. Most of the time, glaucoma progression is only detected by one or two tests.

Diagnostic Accuracy of Imaging Devices in Glaucoma: An Updated Meta-Analysis

Background

Different devices have diverse accuracy in diagnosing glaucoma, and therefore choosing the best device is challenging. Thereby, this study was conducted to evaluate the diagnostic sensitivity and specificity of imaging devices in glaucoma and explore the need for an updated meta-analysis on this issue.

Methods

In this systematic review and meta-analysis, PubMed, Scopus, and Web of Science databases were searched for articles published between January 2004 and 2022. Cross-sectional or diagnostic studies were selected, and sensitivity, specificity, positive predictive value, and negative predictive value were measured.

Results

A total of 28 cross-sectional studies were included for meta-analysis. Devices were divided into 2 groups, based on the optic nerve area and the macular area. For the nerve area, the pooled sensitivity was 77% (CI 95%, 70-83; I2, 90.01%) and the pooled specificity was 89% (CI 95%, 84-92, I2, 93.22%), and for the macular area, the pooled sensitivity was 87% (CI 95%, 80-92, I2, 91.79%), and the pooled specificity was 90% (CI 95%, 84-94; I2, 86.30%). We analyzed each device separately. For optical coherence tomography(OCT), the pooled sensitivity was 85% (CI 95%, 81-89; I2, 87.82%) and the pooled specificity was 89% (CI 95%, 85-92; I2, 84.39%); for Heidelberg retinal tomography (HRT), the pooled sensitivity was 72% (CI 95%, 57-83; I2, 88.94%) and the pooled specificity was 79% (CI 95%, 62-90; I2, 98.61%), and for optical coherence tomography angiography (OCTA), the pooled sensitivity was 82% (CI 95%, 66-91; I2, 93.71%) and the pooled specificity was 93% (CI 95%, 87-96; I2, 64.72%).

Conclusion

The macular area was more sensitive and specific than the optic nerve head. Furthermore, OCT had higher sensitivity, and OCTA had higher specificity when compared with other imaging devices.

New views on three-dimensional imaging technologies for glaucoma: an overview

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

To summarize the literature on three-dimensional (3D) technological advances in ophthalmology, the quantitative methods associated with this, and their improved ability to help detect glaucoma disease progression.

RECENT FINDINGS

Improvements in measuring glaucomatous structural changes are the result of dual innovations in optical coherence tomography (OCT) imaging technology and in associated quantitative software.

SUMMARY

Compared with two-dimensional (2D) OCT parameters, newer 3D parameters provide more data and fewer artifacts.

Hemiretinal Asymmetry in Peripapillary Vessel Density in Healthy, Glaucoma Suspect, and Glaucoma Eyes

PURPOSE

To investigate hemiretinal asymmetry in radial peripapillary capillary vessel area density (VAD) of healthy, glaucoma suspect, and glaucoma eyes of varying severity and its diagnostic utility for glaucoma.

DESIGN

Population-based, cross-sectional study.

METHODS

Optic disc scans (6 × 6 mm) were collected on optical coherence tomography angiography (OCTA) to obtain VAD and on optical coherence tomography (OCT) to measure circumpapillary retinal nerve fiber layer (RNFL) thickness. Hemiretinal difference in VAD (hdVAD) was defined as the absolute difference between superior and inferior hemiretinal VAD. Age-adjusted multivariable linear regression of hdVAD on glaucoma severity was performed. Areas under curves (AUCs) were calculated from predicted probabilities generated by multiple logistic regression of glaucoma severity on age-adjusted single and combined parameters.

RESULTS

A total of 1,043 eyes of 1,043 participants (587 healthy, 270 suspect, 67 mild, 54 moderate, 65 severe glaucoma) were included. After age adjustment, mean hdVAD was similar between healthy and suspect (P = .225), higher in mild vs suspect (P < .001), and higher in moderate vs mild (P = .018), but lower in severe vs moderate (P = .001). AUCs of hdVAD were highest for discriminating mild (0.685) and moderate (0.681) glaucoma from healthy. Combining hdVAD and global RNFL (gRNFL) yielded the highest AUCs of all parameters for mild (0.818) and any POAG (0.859) and resulted in significantly better diagnostic accuracy than either hdVAD or gRNFL alone (P < .05 for all comparisons).

CONCLUSIONS

hdVAD is higher in early glaucoma and may help with early detection when damage is focal, but its diagnostic ability appears less robust in advanced glaucoma when damage is diffuse.

Macular pigment optical density change analysis in primary open-angle glaucoma and pseudoexfoliation glaucoma

PURPOSE

We aimed to investigate whether macular pigment optical density (MPOD) has a diagnostic value by comparing MPOD and retinal nerve fiber layer (RNFL), ganglion cell layer++ (GCL++) of patients with primary open-angle glaucoma (POAG) and pseudoexfoliation (PEX) glaucoma and normal individuals.

METHODS

We included in the study 54 eyes of 34 patients with diagnosis POAG, 40 eyes of 25 patients with PEX glaucoma and 40 eyes of 20 normal individuals. The MPOD measurements of the cases were performed in the MPOD mode of the fundus fluorescein angiography (Carl Zeiss Visucam Meditec, Germany) device while the pupils were in dilated status. RNFL and GCL++ measurements of all individuals included in the study were done by swept source optical coherence tomography (DRI Triton swept source optical coherence tomography; Topcon, Tokyo, Japan). Intraocular pressures of all three groups were measured by Applanation tonometer. The relationship between MPOD, RNFL and GCL++ values were examined. Patients with additional ophthalmic disease, intraocular surgery, history of chronic drug use, and smokers were excluded in the study.

RESULTS

MPOD mean and MPOD max values were significantly higher in patients with PEX glaucoma than POAG and control group (p < 0.05). MPOD mean and MPOD max measurements were not different when compared to POAG patients and control group (p > 0.05). RNFL and GCL++ measurements were found significantly thinner in patients with POAG and PEX glaucoma compared to the control group (p < 0.001). There was no correlation between MPOD values and RNFL or GCL++. MPOD max values show a very high correlation with age in a statistically significant positive direction (r = 0.90, p < 0.001). The average age of PEX glaucoma group was higher than the control group (p = 0.006). There was no age difference between the PEX glaucoma group and the POAG group (p > 0.05). Also, there was no difference in age between POAG and control groups. In POAG and PEX glaucoma groups, mean intraocular pressure values are significantly higher than the control group.

CONCLUSIONS

In our study, no MPOD change was observed in the POAG group, while a statistically significant increase in MPOD was found in the PEX glaucoma group. As a result of these findings, we think that PEX syndrome also affects the posterior segment. Well-organized, large, prospective, and randomized studies should be developed for preventive treatment to the negative effects of PEX syndrome on all eye tissues.

Three-dimensional Neuroretinal Rim Thickness and Visual Fields in Glaucoma: A Broken-stick Model

Supplemental Digital Content is available in the text.

Precis:

In open-angle glaucoma, when neuroretinal rim tissue measured by volumetric optical coherence tomography (OCT) scans is below a third of the normal value, visual field (VF) damage becomes detectable.

Purpose:

To determine the amount of neuroretinal rim tissue thickness below which VF damage becomes detectable.

Methods:

In a retrospective cross-sectional study, 1 eye per subject (of 57 healthy and 100 open-angle glaucoma patients) at an academic institution had eye examinations, VF testing, spectral-domain OCT retinal nerve fiber layer (RNFL) thickness measurements, and optic nerve volumetric scans. Using custom algorithms, the minimum distance band (MDB) neuroretinal rim thickness was calculated from optic nerve scans. “Broken-stick” regression was performed for estimating both the MDB and RNFL thickness tipping-point thresholds, below which were associated with initial VF defects in the decibel scale. The slopes for the structure-function relationship above and below the thresholds were computed. Smoothing curves of the MDB and RNFL thickness covariates were evaluated to examine the consistency of the independently identified tipping-point pairs.

Results:

Plots of VF total deviation against MDB thickness revealed plateaus of VF total deviation unrelated to MDB thickness. Below the thresholds, VF total deviation decreased with MDB thickness, with the associated slopes significantly greater than those above the thresholds (P<0.014). Below 31% of global MDB thickness, and 36.8% and 43.6% of superior and inferior MDB thickness, VF damage becomes detectable. The MDB and RNFL tipping points were in good accordance with the correlation of the MDB and RNFL thickness covariates.

Conclusions:

When neuroretinal rim tissue, characterized by MDB thickness in OCT, is below a third of the normal value, VF damage in the decibel scale becomes detectable.

Analysis of retinal nerve fiber layer birefringence in patients with glaucoma and diabetic retinopathy by polarization sensitive OCT

The retinal nerve fiber layer (RNFL) is a fibrous tissue that shows form birefringence. This optical tissue property is related to the microstructure of the nerve fiber axons that carry electrical signals from the retina to the brain. Ocular diseases that are known to cause neurologic changes, like glaucoma or diabetic retinopathy (DR), might alter the birefringence of the RNFL, which could be used for diagnostic purposes. In this pilot study, we used a state-of-the-art polarization sensitive optical coherence tomography (PS-OCT) system with an integrated retinal tracker to analyze the RNFL birefringence in patients with glaucoma, DR, and in age-matched healthy controls. We recorded 3D PS-OCT raster scans of the optic nerve head area and high-quality averaged circumpapillary PS-OCT scans, from which RNFL thickness, retardation and birefringence were derived. The precision of birefringence measurements was 0.005°/µm. As compared to healthy controls, glaucoma patients showed a slightly reduced birefringence (0.129 vs. 0.135°/µm), although not statistically significant. The DR patients, however, showed a stronger reduction of RNFL birefringence (0.103 vs. 0.135°/µm) which was highly significant. This result might open new avenues into early diagnosis of DR and related neurologic changes.

Artifact Rates for 2D Retinal Nerve Fiber Layer Thickness Versus 3D Retinal Nerve Fiber Layer Volume

Purpose

To compare artifact rates in two-dimensional (2D) versus three-dimensional (3D) retinal nerve fiber layer (RNFL) scans using Spectralis optical coherence tomography (OCT)

Methods

Thirteen artifact types in 2D and 3D RNFL scans were identified in 106 glaucomatous eyes and 95 normal eyes. Artifact rates were calculated per B-scan and per eye. In 3D volume scans, artifacts were counted only for the 97 B-scans used to calculate RNFL parameters for the 2.5–3.5-mm annulus. 3D RNFL measurements were calculated twice, once before and again after deletion of B-scans with artifacts and subsequent automated interpolation.

Results

For 2D scans, artifacts were present in 58.5% of B-scans (62 of 106) in glaucomatous eyes. For 3D scans, a mean of 35.4% of B-scans (34.3 of 97 B-scans per volume scan) contained an artifact in 106 glaucomatous eyes. For 3D data of glaucoma patients, mean global RNFL thickness values were similar before and after interpolation (77.0 ± 11.6 µm vs. 75.1 ± 11.2 µm, respectively; P = 0.23). Fewer clinically significant artifacts were noted in 3D RNFL scans, where only 7.5% of glaucomatous eyes (8 of 106) and 0% of normal eyes (0 of 95) had artifacts, compared to 2D RNFL scans, where 58.5% of glaucomatous eyes (62 of 106) and 14.7% of normal eyes (14 of 95) had artifacts.

Conclusions

Compared to 2D RNFL scans, 3D RNFL volume scans less often require manual correction to obtain accurate measurements.

Translational Relevance

3D RNFL volume scans have fewer clinically significant artifacts compared to 2D RNFL thickness scans.

Three-Dimensional Optical Coherence Tomography Imaging For Glaucoma Associated With Boston Keratoprosthesis Type I and II

PRECIS

Three-dimensional (3D) spectral domain optical coherence tomography (OCT) volume scans of the optic nerve head (ONH) and the peripapillary area are useful in the management of glaucoma in patients with a type I or II Boston Keratoprosthesis (KPro).

PURPOSE

The purpose of this study was to report the use of spectral domain OCT in the management of glaucoma in patients with a type I or II Boston KPro.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

This study is an observational case series. Four consecutive patients with KPro implants were referred for glaucoma evaluation. A comprehensive eye examination was performed which included disc photography, visual field testing, and high-density spectral domain OCT volume scans of the ONH and the peripapillary area. 2D and 3D parameters were calculated using custom-designed segmentation algorithms developed for glaucoma management.

RESULTS

Spectral domain OCT parameters provided useful information in the diagnosis and management of 4 KPro patients. OCT parameters which can be used in KPro patients included 2D retinal nerve fiber layer (RNFL) thickness, 3D peripapillary RNFL volume, 3D peripapillary retinal thickness and volume, 3D cup volume, and 3D neuroretinal rim thickness and volume. In 3 of 4 cases where the traditional 2D RNFL thickness scan was limited by artifacts, 3D spectral domain OCT volume scans provided useful quantitative objective measurements of the ONH and peripapillary region. Therefore, 3D parameters derived from high-density volume scans as well as radial scans of the ONH can be used to overcome the limitations and artifacts associated with 2D RNFL thickness scans.

CONCLUSIONS

Spectral domain OCT volume scans offer the possibility to enhance the evaluation of KPro patients with glaucoma by using both 2D and 3D diagnostic parameters that are easily obtained in a clinic setting.

Peripapillary microvasculature in the retinal nerve fiber layer in glaucoma by optical coherence tomography angiography: focal structural and functional correlations and diagnostic performance

Purpose

To quantify peripapillary microvasculature within the retinal nerve fiber layer (RNFL) in primary open-angle glaucoma (POAG) and normal eyes, determine association of perfusion parameters with structural and functional measures, and report diagnostic accuracy of perfusion parameters.

Patients and methods

POAG and normal patients underwent 6×6 mm² optic nerve head scans (Angioplex optical coherence tomography angiography [OCTA]; Cirrus HD-OCT 5000) and Humphrey Field Analyzer II-i 24-2 visual field (VF) testing. Prototype software performed semiautomatic segmentation to create RNFL en face images and quantified vessel area density (VAD), vessel skeleton density (VSD), and vessel complexity index (VCI) in the optic nerve head globally and focally. Generalized estimating equations models assessed association of OCTA parameters with VF mean deviation (MD) and RNFL thickness.

Results

Thirty-eight POAG and 17 normal eyes were studied. Global VAD, VSD, and VCI were reduced in mild POAG vs normal (P<0.02) and moderate-severe vs mild POAG (P<0.04). Stepwise focal reductions across disease stage were demonstrated for OCTA parameters in the inferior hemisphere (P<0.05); reduction in OCTA parameters in mild POAG vs normal was demonstrated in inferior and superior quadrants (P<0.05). Reduced global VF MD was associated with reduced VAD, VSD, and VCI (P=0.0007, 0.0013, <0.0001; R²=0.449, 0.312, 0.399, respectively), and global RNFL thickness was associated with VAD, VSD, and VCI (P<0.0001; R²=0.499, 0.524, 0.542), superior and inferior hemifield MD were associated with corresponding VAD, VSD, and VCI (P≤0.001; R² from 0.208 to 0.513). RNFL thickness in all quadrants was associated with corresponding OCTA parameters (P<0.05; R² from 0.213 to 0.394), except temporal VAD and VCI. Area under curves for VAD, VSD, and VCI demonstrated good diagnostic ability (0.868, 0.855, 0.868; P<0.0001).

Conclusion

Glaucomatous eyes showed stepwise reductions in RNFL microcirculation across severity; focal reductions in the inferior hemisphere and inferior and superior quadrants were most significant. OCTA parameters had stronger associations with structural rather than functional measures of glaucoma.

The ISNT Rule: How Often Does It Apply to Disc Photographs and Retinal Nerve Fiber Layer Measurements in the Normal Population?

PURPOSE

To determine what percentage of normal eyes follow the ISNT rule, and whether ISNT rule variants may be more generalizable to the normal population.

DESIGN

Cross-sectional study.

METHODS

Setting: Institutional setting.

STUDY POPULATION

Total of 110 normal subjects.

OBSERVATION PROCEDURES

Neuroretinal rim assessments from disc photographs and retinal nerve fiber layer (RNFL) thickness measurements from spectral-domain optical coherence tomography.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES

The percentages of subjects that obeyed the ISNT rule and its variants.

RESULTS

The ISNT rule is only valid for 37.0% of disc photograph rim assessments and 43.8% of RNFL measurements. Deviation of the nasal sector from the expected ISNT pattern was a major cause for the ISNT rule not being obeyed for both rim and RNFL assessments. Specifically, 10.9% of subjects had wider nasal rims than the inferior rims, 29.4% had wider nasal rims than the superior rims, 14.7% had narrower nasal rims than the temporal rims, and 42.9% had thinner nasal RNFLs compared to the temporal quadrant. Exclusion of the nasal quadrant from the ISNT rule significantly increased the validity of ISNT variant rules, with 70.9% and 76.4% of disc photographs following the IST rule and the IS rule, respectively. Similarly, for RNFL thickness, 70.9% and 71.8% of patients followed the IST and IS rule, respectively.

CONCLUSIONS

The ISNT rule is only valid for about a third of disc photographs and less than half of RNFL measurements in normal patients. ISNT rule variants, such as the IST and IS rule, may be considered, as they are valid in more than 70% of patients.