Surgical management of pulsatile tinnitus secondary to jugular bulb or sigmoid sinus diverticulum with review of literature

Causes and outcomes of revision surgery in subjects with pulsatile tinnitus

INTRODUCTION

Once the underlying pathology has been identified, pulsatile tinnitus (PT) can be treated successfully with surgical or interventional management. However, some patients experience residual or recurrent symptoms following initially successful surgical treatment, and require revision surgery or additional procedures. Here, we report a case series of patients who had undergone revision surgery or interventional treatment, and suggest possible ways of minimizing the need for revision.

METHODS

Between January 2014 and March 2023, a total of seven subjects underwent revision surgery or interventional treatment for persistent or recurrent PT after initial surgical treatment. Demographic data, reasons for revision, and changes in symptoms before and after revision were analyzed retrospectively. Temporal bone computed tomographic angiography images were reviewed to identify the causes and reasons for revision.

RESULTS

Of the seven subjects, six underwent sigmoid sinus (SS) resurfacing/reshaping due to ipsilateral diverticulum (Div) or dehiscence (Deh), and one underwent jugular bulb (JB) resurfacing due to a high-riding JB with bony Deh. Of the five subjects who underwent revision SS surgery due to recurrent SS-Div or SS-Deh, three showed marked resolution of PT, while the other two showed partial improvement of the symptoms. One subject who underwent revision JB resurfacing, and another who underwent additional transarterial embolization for a concurrent ipsilateral dural arteriovenous fistula, reported marked improvement of PT.

DISCUSSION

The possibility of recurrence should be taken into account when performing surgical intervention in patients with PT. The likelihood of recurrence can be minimized through a comprehensive evaluation to identify possible multiple etiologies, and through the use of durable materials and appropriate surgical methods.

Outcomes in Managing Vascular Tinnitus: Institutional Experience and Review of 6-Year Literature

To evaluate the outcomes in patients of vascular tinnitus managed at our institute. The clinical data of all patients diagnosed with pulsatile tinnitus from January 2014 to April 2022 and managed at AIIMS, Bhubaneswar, was retrospectively reviewed. The diagnosis, treatment and outcomes were analyzed. A 6-year literature review was performed from March 2015 to April 2021. Our series discusses managing eleven cases of vascular tinnitus with varied aetiology and their outcomes. Out of the eleven cases, eight patients underwent surgical or radiological intervention, and seven had complete resolution of symptoms. Of the eleven patients, three had partial resolution. The 6-year literature review revealed sigmoid and transverse sinus as the most common causative anatomical sites for pulsatile tinnitus. Amongst those who received an intervention, 83.56% of the patients had complete resolution of symptoms. Vascular tinnitus can be cured if the exact vessel causing it is localized. Clinical suspicion is based on the character of tinnitus and patient history. A careful evaluation of the head and neck sites for any vascular anomaly that can cause pulsatile tinnitus must be done. Radiology demonstrates treatable causes of it. It delineates the aberrant anatomical variations that can lead to this disturbing aetiology. Treatable causes are best addressed, and pathology should be taken care of. A multidisciplinary team comprising ENT surgeons, audiologists and interventional radiologists must identify and treat the pathology.

Analysis of Etiology, Diagnosis, and Treatment Strategy and Efficacy of Pulsatile Tinnitus Caused by Abnormal Vascular Anatomy

OBJECTIVE

To investigate the etiology, clinical characteristics, diagnosis, and treatment strategies and efficacy of pulsatile tinnitus (PT) caused by vascular anatomy abnormality.

METHODS

The clinical data of 45 patients with PT in our hospital from 2012 to 2019 were collected and retrospectively analyzed.

RESULTS

All 45 patients had vascular anatomical abnormalities. The patients were divided into 10 categories according to the different locations of vascular abnormalities: sigmoid sinus diverticulum (SSD), sigmoid sinus wall dehiscence (SSWD), SSWD with high jugular bulb, pure dilated mastoid emissary vein, aberrant internal carotid artery (ICA) in the middle ear, transverse-sigmoid sinus (TSS) transition stenosis, TSS transition stenosis with SSD, persistent occipital sinus stenosis, petrous segment stenosis of ICA, and dural arteriovenous fistula. All patients complained of PT synchronous with heartbeat rhythm. Endovascular interventional therapy and extravascular open surgery were used according to the location of the vascular lesions. Tinnitus disappeared in 41 patients, was significantly relieved in 3 patients, and was unchanged in 1 patient postoperatively. Except for one patient with transient headache postoperatively, no obvious complications occurred.

CONCLUSION

PT caused by vascular anatomy abnormalities can be identified by detailed medical history and physical and imaging examination. PT can be relieved or even completely alleviated after appropriate surgical treatments.

CT evaluation of unilateral pulsatile tinnitus with jugular bulb wall dehiscence

OBJECTIVES

To investigate the imaging features of unilateral pulsatile tinnitus (PT) with jugular bulb wall dehiscence (JBWD).

METHODS

Computerized tomography angiography images of unilateral PT patients were reviewed between 2019 and 2021. Thirty-one symptomatic JBWD patients without sigmoid sinus wall dehiscence (SSWD) were included. Thirty-eight patients with SSWD were used as the control group. The prevalence of JBWD was calculated. The area and height of the jugular bulb, the extent of dehiscence, the presence of jugular bulb diverticulum, posterior condylar emissary vein (PCEV), oblique occipital sinus (OOS), venous outflow laterality (VOL), the degree of transverse sinus stenosis (TSS), and the pituitary height to sella turcica ratio were compared between the two groups.

RESULTS

The prevalence of JBWD was 12.1%, and JBWD was established as a causative diagnosis in 5.0% of unilateral PT patients. There were no statistical differences in the gender, symptomatic side, or VOL between the two groups. The area of the jugular bulb was larger and the height was higher (p_area < 0.001, p_height = 0.005). The prevalence of jugular bulb diverticulum was higher in the JBWD group (p = 0.002). The degree of symptomatic TSS was less severe (p < 0.001), and the prevalence of bilateral TSS was lower in the JBWD group (p < 0.001). The pituitary height to sella turcica ratio was greater (p = 0.004), the prevalence of PCEV (p = 0.014) was lower, and OOS (p = 0.015) was greater in the JBWD group.

CONCLUSIONS

The correlating factors of PT with JBWD and PT with SSWD are significantly different. These findings can further facilitate early and efficient PT treatment.

KEY POINTS

• The incidence of jugular bulb dehiscence (JBWD) accounted for approximately 12.1% in pulsatile tinnitus (PT) patients, and JBWD was established as a causative diagnosis in 5.0% of PT patients. • PT required large blood flows and abnormal flow patterns, whether in JBWD or sigmoid sinus wall dehiscence groups. • JBWD causing PT has some unique characteristic findings on CT.

Evaluation and Management of Tinnitus: Are There Opportunities for Improvement?

OBJECTIVE

To review current information about diagnosis and management of tinnitus aiming to identify opportunities for achieving a cost-effective, efficient, evidence-based approach that meets the needs of tinnitus sufferers.

DATA SOURCES

PubMed/MEDLINE.

REVIEW METHODS

In total, 249 relevant published reports were reviewed. Pertinent keywords and MeSH terms identified reports via PubMed and EMBASE. Acknowledged experts were consulted on ways to improve tinnitus management.

CONCLUSIONS

There may be opportunities to improve evaluation and management of patients with tinnitus using modern modes of communication and a multidisciplinary therapeutic approach.

IMPLICATIONS FOR PRACTICE

Tinnitus can adversely affect quality of life while being time-consuming and costly to evaluate and manage. Based on both personal experience and the reports of others, patients with tinnitus who choose to see a physician primarily want to know two things: (1) that the tinnitus that is so distressing will not remain at the same level of severity forever and (2) that something can be done to help cope with the tinnitus that is so annoying. Recent advancements in internet communications, social media, information technology, artificial intelligence, machine learning, holistic medical care, mind-body integrative health care, and multidisciplinary approaches in medical therapeutics may be possibly making new ways of meeting the needs of patients with tinnitus.

Surgical treatment of pulsatile tinnitus related to the sigmoid sinus

Objective

Tinnitus-a common clinical symptom-can be categorized into pulsatile tinnitus (PT) and non-PT. Among these, PT is usually associated with sigmoid sinus symptoms, such as sigmoid sinus wall defect or diverticulum, for which various surgical treatments are available. We have discussed the clinical efficacy of surgery for sigmoid sinus-associated PT via the transmastoid approach in this study.

Methods

We conducted a retrospective review of 4 patients who underwent surgery for sigmoid sinus-associated PT via the transmastoid approach at Nanjing Drum Tower Hospital from January to December 2020. Of these, 2 patients had sigmoid sinus wall defect and 2 had sigmoid sinus diverticulum. Post-operative tinnitus grading and surgical efficacy were determined.

Results

After surgery, PT dissolved in 3 patients, while tinnitus significantly decreased in 1 patient. During the follow-up period of 12-18 months, none of the 4 patients showed complications related to increased intracranial pressure or venous sinus thrombosis, and tinnitus symptoms disappeared in 3 patients without recurrence, although 1 patient occasionally developed tinnitus. Postoperative thin-slice CTA of the temporal bone indicated that the sigmoid sinus bone wall defect or diverticulum was completely repaired with a thick soft tissue coverage.

Conclusion

Surgical repair of sigmoid sinus-associated PT via the transmastoid approach deserves clinical promotion as it exhibited better efficiency while being relatively less invasive.

Surgical Fixation of Jugular Bulb Abnormalities Associated With Phelebectasia in Patients With Vascular Tinnitus

Internal jugular phlebectasia is a rare entity in which there is a fusiform dilatation of the internal jugular vein (IJV), usually presenting as a neck mass or tinnitus. The jugular bulb (JB) is an enlarged confluence connecting the sigmoid sinus and the IJV. It has been suggested that JB abnormality might also cause vertigo and pulsatile tinnitus. This prospective interventional study involved 15 patients with pulsatile tinnitus associated with internal jugular phlebectasia. Four patients presented with recurrent vertigo attacks. IJV diameter at rest ranged from 11 to 18 mm. Eight patients have had inner ear bone dehiscence, and 40% had high JB. All cases were treated by surgical fixation using a ringed polytetrafluoroethylene graft extending from the costoclavicular joint to the sigmoid sinus under fluoroscopic guidance. Tinnitus disappeared immediately postoperatively in all cases, followed by the disappearance of vertigo on the fourth day. Two cases reported thrombosis of the graft in the sixth and seventh months but maintained symptomatic improvement. Recurrence was reported in 2 cases while the grafts were patent. Surgical fixation by replacing the jugular vein and bulb with a synthetic graft may offer an excellent surgical option for relieving vascular tinnitus, especially in these young patients in whom endovascular therapy may not be a durable treatment.

Sigmoid Sinus Diverticulum-A Unique Case of Pulsatile Tinnitus

Sigmoid sinus diverticula are relatively rare but typically cause pulsatile tinnitus (PT) in the involved ear. Occasionally, symptoms produced by blood flowing through the diverticulum are severe enough to necessitate recontouring the sigmoid sinus. Recently, a 59-year-old female was evaluated after years of worsening unilateral PT. CT angiography identified a 5 mm sigmoid sinus diverticulum near the sinodural angle. Given the severity of symptoms, the patient's diverticulum was surgically decompressed and recontoured using hydroxyapatite bone cement.

The efficacy of acoustic therapy versus oral medication for chronic tinnitus: A meta-analysis

PURPOSE

To compare the efficacy of acoustic therapy (AT) and drug therapy (DT) for chronic tinnitus.

METHODS

We searched Pubmed, ScienceDirect, Chinese Journal Full-text Database (CNKI), Wanfang Database, Chinese Biomedical Literature Database (CBM), Embase, and Cochrane Library from the establishment of the database to December 2019. Meta-analysis was performed on the Tinnitus Handicap Inventory (THI) score and Visual Analogue Scale (VAS) with included literature using Revman 5.3 software.

RESULTS

A total of 18 documents were included, including 16 Chinese documents and 2 English documents, with 1774 patients (including 962 patients treated with AT and 812 patients treated with DT). The effect of AT (by the number of cases or ears) is better than that of DT (P < 0.05). After treatment, the THI value of AT was more evident than that of DT (WMD = -4.25, (-13.24, -5.29)). And the VAS value of AT was significantly lower than that of DT (WMD = -0.73, (-1.31, -0.15)).

CONCLUSION

Compared with DT, AT can significantly improve the efficacy of tinnitus and reduce the symptoms of tinnitus patients. Clinically, it can vigorously promote the application value of treating tinnitus by sound.

Prevalence, Surgical Management, and Audiologic Impact of Sigmoid Sinus Dehiscence Causing Pulsatile Tinnitus

OBJECTIVE

To evaluate the prevalence, surgical management, and audiologic impact of pulsatile tinnitus caused by sigmoid sinus dehiscence.

STUDY DESIGN AND SETTING

Retrospective chart review at a tertiary care hospital.

PATIENTS

Adults with unilateral pulsatile tinnitus attributable to sigmoid sinus dehiscence who underwent resurfacing between January 2010 and January 2020.

INTERVENTIONS

Transmastoid sigmoid resurfacing.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES

Resolution of pulsatile tinnitus; audiologic outcomes; complications; tinnitus etiologies.

RESULTS

Nineteen patients (89.4% women) had surgery for suspected sigmoid sinus dehiscence. The mean dehiscence size was 6.1 mm (range, 1-10.7 mm). Eight patients had concurrent sigmoid sinus diverticulum and one patient also had jugular bulb dehiscence. Only two patients (10.5%) had the defect identified by radiology. Low-frequency pure-tone average, measured at frequencies of 250 and 500 Hz, showed a significant median improvement of 8.8 dB following resurfacing (18.8 dB versus 10.0 dB, p = 0.02). The majority of patients had complete resolution of pulsatile tinnitus (16/19, 84.2%). Of those without complete resolution, two patients had partial response and one patient had no improvement. There were no significant complications. Of 41 consecutively tracked patients with a pulsatile tinnitus chief complaint, sigmoid pathology represented 32% of cases.

CONCLUSIONS

Sigmoid sinus dehiscence represents a common vascular cause of pulsatile tinnitus that, if properly assessed, may be amenable to surgical intervention. Sigmoid sinus resurfacing is safe, does not require decompression, and may improve low-frequency hearing. Radiographic findings of dehiscence are often overlooked without a high index of clinical suspicion. Its relationship with transverse sinus pathology and idiopathic intracranial hypertension remain unclear.

Association Between Sigmoid Sinusoidal Tinnitus and Low-Frequency Sensorineural Hearing Loss: A Retrospective Study at a Single Center

BACKGROUND We aimed to explore the correlation between patients' sigmoid sinusoidal tinnitus (SST) and low-frequency sensorineural hearing loss (LFSHL) and illustrate the underlying mechanism. MATERIAL AND METHODS Seven healthy volunteers with normal hearing were subjected to 125-, 250-, and 500-Hz pure sound and different white noise-masking intensities. A retrospective analysis was made on the clinical data and postoperative follow-up data of 59 patients with SST in the First Affiliated Hospital of Chongqing Medical University. The patients' sex, age, chief complaints, affected site, concomitant symptoms, course of disease, pure-tone audiometry (PTA) results, tinnitus discomfort loudness scale results, imaging examination, and complications were collected. RESULTS The results of the simulation experiment showed that the threshold of each frequency segment was higher after noise masking than before masking; the intensity of noise masking was positively correlated with hearing loss, and the changes of the hearing threshold of the 3 frequencies before and after masking were statistically significant (P<0.05). Fifty-nine patients with SST were documented between January 2015 and January 2020. After the operation, their low-frequency hearing was recovered to normal; 11 cases had significantly alleviated tinnitus and 9 cases were cured. CONCLUSIONS SST often causes corresponding pseudo-low-frequency hearing loss due to the noise-masking effect. The center frequency of tinnitus appears not to be 250-Hz or 500-Hz octave frequency of PTA, barring the detection of the pseudo-hearing loss in the audiometry chart of most patients. Surgery positively affects patients with SST, and the pseudo-LFSHL can be completely recovered after the operation as a result of tinnitus elimination.

Transmastoid Hydroxyapatite Resurfacing for Sigmoid Sinus Wall Anomalies Causing Pulsatile Tinnitus

OBJECTIVE

Comprising 4% of tinnitus, pulsatile tinnitus (PT) can be particularly difficult for affected patients as well as surgeons looking to address their symptoms. Often the cause is not identified but can be secondary to turbulent flow in or near the sigmoid sinus, particularly if there is an identifiable sigmoid sinus dehiscence (SSDe) and/or diverticulum (SSDi). These sigmoid sinus wall anomalies (SSWA) may be treated with transmastoid sigmoid sinus resurfacing; however, this intervention remains relatively novel and its technique, materials used, resolution success, and complications need to be continuously reviewed.

METHODS

A retrospective case series of patients with PT due to SSWA at a tertiary referral center was reviewed. A total of 6 patients (7 ears) treated by transmastoid resurfacing using hydroxyapatite (HA) were retrospectively assessed. Pre-operative demographics and symptoms, pre- and post-operative hearing results, and post-operative outcomes were reviewed.

RESULTS

All patients were female with an average BMI of 32.9 (±5.4) and a mean age of 45.5 years (±15.3). Mean follow-up was 648 days. Objective tinnitus was noted in all ears with SSDi (100%); however, no objective tinnitus was noted with purely SSDe. In 100% of ears, PT was diminished with ipsilateral jugular compression and was amplified with contralateral head turn. Pre-operative symptoms of PT resolved in all patients, but delayed recurrence (>1 year) occurred in 1 ear (14%). No patient had pre- or post-operative hearing loss. No major complications were encountered.

CONCLUSIONS

Transmastoid resurfacing for SSWA with HA bone cement is a safe, reliable intervention in properly identified PT patients.

Treatment of pulsatile tinnitus caused by anomalies of the sigmoid sinus wall via combined internal and external sigmoid sinus wall reconstruction with 3D temporal bone CT guidance

PURPOSE

The present analysis aims to describe a surgical approach wherein pulsatile tinnitus (PT) arising due to sigmoid sinus wall anomalies (SSWA) can be treated via combination internal and external sigmoid sinus wall reconstruction. We further evaluated the utility of temporal bone 3D-CT imaging during both the pre- and post-operative assessments of all treated patients.

METHODS

Data pertaining to 11 patients that had undergone sigmoid sinus wall reconstruction were retrospectively analyzed. All of these patients underwent preoperative 3D-CT imaging assessment. These patients were additionally subjected to sigmoid sinus wall reconstruction via a combined internal and external layer approach. Postoperatively, all patients underwent a radiological assessment of auricular cartilage and autologous bone powered displacement. Patients were additionally asked about any subjective changes in PT or associated symptoms at follow-up time points.

RESULTS

SSWA in the 3D-CT imaging from these patients were all distinct. In 10/11 patients, PT fully resolved following reconstruction of the sinus wall. The remaining patients exhibited significant improvements in symptoms postoperatively, with PT fully resolving within a 1-month follow-up period. No patients suffered any major complications.

CONCLUSIONS

Temporal bone 3D-CT imaging allow for effective visualization of SSWA, enabling effective pre- and post-operative assessments of treated patients. A combined internal and external layer approach to sigmoid sinus wall reconstruction can be implemented safely and effectively, yielding high rates of satisfactory outcomes and achieving rigid reconstruction of this surface. As such, there is clear value in the consideration of this approach when treating individuals suffering from PT as a result of SSWA.

The styloid process and the formation of sigmoid sinus diverticulum: is there a link?

INTRODUCTION

Sigmoid sinus diverticulum has been considered the most common cause of pulsatile tinnitus; the mechanism underlying sigmoid sinus diverticulum formation is unclear. To the best of our knowledge, no previous studies have assessed whether the formation of sigmoid sinus diverticulum is related to compression of the internal jugular vein by the styloid process.

OBJECTIVE

To discuss the relationship between the styloid process and the formation of sigmoid sinus diverticulum.

METHODS

The medical records of nine patients diagnosed with venous pulsatile tinnitus caused by sigmoid sinus diverticulum were reviewed between April 2009 and May 2019. All patients underwent high-resolution computed tomography of the temporal bones, computed tomography venogram of the head and neck, magnetic resonance venography, and brain magnetic resonance imaging. The length and medial angulation of the styloid process were measured, and compression of the internal jugular vein was recorded.

RESULTS

The study population consisted of nine female right-sided pulsatile tinnitus patients with a mean age of 53.8±4.6 years. The mean lengths of the styloid process were 3.9±0.6cm on the right side and 4.1±0.7cm on the left side. The mean medial angulation of the styloid process was significantly smaller on the right side than the left side (65.3°±1.2° vs. 67.8°±1.7°, p<0.05). In addition, computed tomography venogram of the head and neck demonstrated the left internal jugular vein was compressed by the styloid process in eight of the nine patients.

CONCLUSION

The formation of sigmoid sinus diverticulum with venous pulsatile tinnitus may be related to compression of the contralateral internal jugular vein by the styloid process. However, accumulation of data in additional cases is required to verify this suggestion.

Systematic Review of Temporal Bone-Resurfacing Techniques for Pulsatile Tinnitus Associated with Vascular Wall Anomalies

OBJECTIVE

To systematically review literature evidence on temporal bone-resurfacing techniques for pulsatile tinnitus (PT) associated with vascular wall anomalies.

DATA SOURCES

We searched PubMed, Embase, and the Cochrane Database. The period covered was from 1962 to 2018.

REVIEW METHODS

We included studies in all languages that reported resurfacing outcomes for patients with PT and radiographic evidence or direct visualization of sigmoid sinus wall anomaly, jugular bulb wall anomaly, or dehiscent or aberrant internal carotid artery.

RESULTS

Of 954 citations retrieved in database searches and 5 citations retrieved from reference lists, 20 studies with a total of 141 resurfacing cases involving 138 patients were included. Resurfacing outcomes for arterial sources of PT showed 3 of 5 cases (60%) with complete resolution and 2 (40%) with partial resolution. Jugular bulb sources of PT showed 11 of 14 cases (79%) with complete resolution and 1 (7%) with partial resolution. Sigmoid sinus sources of PT showed 91 of 121 cases (75%) with complete resolution and 12 (10%) with partial resolution. Symptoms occurred more in females and on the right side. Most cases (94%) used hard-density materials for resurfacing. Material density did not appear to be associated with resurfacing outcomes. Use of autologous materials was associated with improved outcomes for arterial sources resurfacing. Major complications involving sigmoid sinus thrombosis or compression were reported in 4% of cases without long-term morbidity or mortality.

CONCLUSIONS

Resurfacing surgery is likely effective and well tolerated for select patients with PT associated with various vascular wall anomalies.

Jugular bulb and skull base pathologies: proposal for a novel classification system for jugular bulb positions and microsurgical implications

OBJECTIVE

There is no definitive or consensus classification system for the jugular bulb position that can be uniformly communicated between a radiologist, neurootologist, and neurosurgeon. A high-riding jugular bulb (HRJB) has been variably defined as a jugular bulb that rises to or above the level of the basal turn of the cochlea, within 2 mm of the internal auditory canal (IAC), or to the level of the superior tympanic annulus. Overall, there is a seeming lack of consensus, especially when MRI and/or CT are used for jugular bulb evaluation without a dedicated imaging study of the venous anatomy such as digital subtraction angiography or CT or MR venography.

METHODS

A PubMed analysis of “jugular bulb” comprised of 1264 relevant articles were selected and analyzed specifically for an HRJB. A novel classification system based on preliminary skull base imaging using CT is proposed by the authors for conveying the anatomical location of the jugular bulb. This new classification includes the following types: type 1, no bulb; type 2, below the inferior margin of the posterior semicircular canal (SCC), subclassified as type 2a (without dehiscence into the middle ear) or type 2b (with dehiscence into the middle ear); type 3, between the inferior margin of the posterior SCC and the inferior margin of the IAC, subclassified as type 3a (without dehiscence into the middle ear) and type 3b (with dehiscence into the middle ear); type 4, above the inferior margin of the IAC, subclassified as type 4a (without dehiscence into the IAC) and type 4b (with dehiscence into the IAC); and type 5, combination of dehiscences. Appropriate CT and MR images of the skull base were selected to validate the criteria and further demonstrated using 3D reconstruction of DICOM files. The microsurgical significance of the proposed classification is evaluated with reference to specific skull base/posterior fossa pathologies.

RESULTS

The authors validated the role of a novel classification of jugular bulb location that can help effective communication between providers treating skull base lesions. Effective utilization of the above grading system can help plan surgical procedures and anticipate complications.

CONCLUSIONS

The authors have proposed a novel anatomical/radiological classification system for jugular bulb location with respect to surgical implications. This classification can help surgeons in complication avoidance and management when addressing HRJBs.